High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/49574/2019disposed of

Harpreet Kaur And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others

2020-05-08Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill10 pages

!"#!$%&%"'()** +,+!! -.+'/" 0!+& 11* ! % %"'!+& 2!+&.& 3 !"# .'45'/" 0!+& 1** !&,"'/!' &

+!&!' ( +* *-*3%'678/9"$ !8#"+ 0!,! % %"'!+&* +*0+.9:783+*8 .'45* +*-+'9%+3%'60-0!0+8/9"$ !8 #"++!&,"'/!' "&*'/*

+:!+%' 0!,+!&!' ,! % %"'.'/!+3!$ %"')+* ** %&#"+;.&0%'6"#/ !/**8.'/!+3!$ %"' +* **8 "7%$!3 %"'%768%& +%$ 7'/0+

.+7 8+!& +%'%'6 0!,! % %"'!+&#+"<$. %'6 0!,//:$+",'/,,"%' <!' "# 0! %5!0&%7/+ & +!$!%9!+ =% 0". %&&.%'6 '" %$!& '/ =% 0". %'9% %'6"54!$ %"'&*

! % %"'!++,+!! -.+7"'6=% 00!+<%'"+$0%7/+!' 0&,,+"$0!/ 0%&".+ #"+;.&0%'6"# 0!,+"$!!/%'6&.'/!+ 3!$ %"'+* **"' 0!6+".'/ 0 "'!3' ">03%'60&"'"# 6 3%'600/9%/!7!&!/!!// !/?**)7!&!/". 0%&7'/ '/7'/"#0%&!@ !'/!/#<%7:<!&.+%'6>'7?<+7 &+&%#"+:!+&8=*!*#**) "A*)*AB &*C ,!+$+!*0!6+!!<!' =&/.7:=% '!&&!/'/ 0!<".' "#

&*A88?C=&7&"+!$!%9!/*3%'$! 0!+!=&#!+%' 0!<%'/ "#,! % %"'!++,+!! -.+ 0 &0!<%60 5!.,+"" !/<%/=:8 &.% #"+ ,!+<'!' %'4.'$ %"' +!& +%'%'6 0! /!#!'/' & #+"< /%&,"&&!&&%'6 0! ,7%' %## ,! % %"'!+ "* 0!+!%'

%77!677: '/ #"+$%57:=&#%7!/*' 0!&%/&.% 8 0".60 0!%' !+%<%'4.'$ %"' 0/ 5!!' /!$7%'!/ 5: 0! 7!+'!/ +%7 ".+ 8 :! ,! % %"'!+ +,+!! -.+0&#%7!/',,!76%'& 0!&%/"+/!+8=0%$0%& ,!'/%'6* D0!' 0!7!&&"+ & +%!/ " >!#"+$%57!,"&&!&&%"'"# 0! 7!&!/ ". 7'/ '/ 0! 0".&!8 ,! % %"'!+ "* </! $"<,7%' "' 0!5&%&=0!+!"#8 "*/ !/**.'/!+ 3!$ %"'&AA8A8)8'/ =&+!6%& !+!/ "7%$!

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

%&&.%'6'" %$!'/=% 0". %'% % %'6"54!$ %"'&* ' 0!$"<,7%' "#,! % %"'!+"*%*!*E!&&!!8 "*/ !/**0/

5!!'+!6%& !+!/'/'%' !+%<%'4.'$ %"'0/7&"5!!'6+' !/5: 0! %9%7 ".+ %' 0! &.% #"+ ,!+<'!' %'4.'$ %"' #%7!/ 5: ,! % %"'!+"*8 0".60&.$0%'4.'$ %"'=&7 !+"'9$ !/'/ ',,!76%'& 0!&%/"+/!+%&& !/ "5!,!'/%'6* E!+'!/$".'&!7#"+ 0!,! % %"'!+&0&7&"/+=' 0! !' %"'"# 0%&".+ " 0!#$ 0 &%'$! 0!,7!/%'6&'/ ##%/9% "# -.7=%'/!+ 3%'608 +!&,"'/!' "* /" '" $7!+7: !@,+!&&& "0"=<.$0%&& !<!' "# 0!>'"=7!/6!"# 0! /!,"'!' '/ 0"= <.$0 ,+ 0!+!"# %& 5&!/ "' 0%& 5!7%!#8 0!+!#"+!8 0!+!%&9%"7 %"'"# +/!+ .7!A '/&&.$0 0!

,7!/%'6&$''" 5! >!'%' "$"'&%/!+ %"'*!0&+!7%!/.,"' "' 0! .77!'$04./6<!' +!'/!+!/5: 0!"'F57! '%60 ".+ %'%,!'/+ 03+>+2&*3 !"#%0+'/" 0!+&

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

5:+!&,"'/!' "*8$''" 5! >!'%' "$"'&%/!+ %"'&'" ,+",!+,!+<%&&%"'#+"< 0!".+ 0/5!!' >!'5!#"+! >%'6 0! ",%'%"' "# 0! !@,!+ * "+!"9!+8 =0!' 0! +!9!'.! . 0"+% %!& #%7!/ "$"<,7:=% 0 0!"+/!+/ !/**,&&!/5: 0%& ".+ 8 0!,! % %"'!+#%7!/ "*?)6%'& 9%"7 %"'"# & :"+/!+%'=0%$0'" %$!0/5!!'%&&.!/#"+**'/ 0! 77!6!/ .$ %"' </! 5: 0! %5 !0&%7/+8 %& %' 0! '<! "# -.7=%'/!+3%'608=0"%&$7"&!7:+!7 !/ " 0!7!&&"+*

!+$"' +87!+'!/$".'&!7#"++!&,"'/!' "&*'/ 0&+6.!/ 0 "='!+& +! %' ,"&&!&&%"'"# 0! ,+",!+ : %' /%&,. !!9!'&,!++!9!'.!+!$"+/&'/ 0!,! % %"'!+&0/'" %<,7!/!/ 0!'!$!&&+:,+ %!&&&0!=' !/ "6+5 0!,+",!+ : "# "' !&%/!' '/%'& '/ "7/ 6!/ ,!+&"'&* %& #.+ 0!+ &.5<% !/ 0 %' 0!!' %+!+!9!'.!+!$"+/8=0%$0%&5+".60 "' +!$"+/5:+!&,"'/!' "&*'/&''!@.+! C8'"=0!+!

0&% 5!!'+!#7!$ !/ 0 0!,! % %"'!+&+!%',"&&!&&%"'"# 0! 7'/ & 7!&&!!&* "+!"9!+8 "0%'/!+ -.+ 0& #%7!/ $%9%7 &.% 6%'& ,! % %"'!+"*'/3' ">03%'600&7&"#%7!/$%9%7&.% '/& .&;.""+/!+=&,&&!/"'?**5:%9%7./6!8

0%77.+* 3' ">0 3%'60 7&" #%7!/ ) "# #"+ ,+" !$ %"'"#7%#!'/7%5!+ :'/#"+0%&,+",!+ :*0.&8 0!3.5 %9%&%"'76%& + !0&+%60 7:,&&!/ 0!"+/!+.'/!+3!$ %"' +* **&%' !+%<"+/!+&,&&!/5: 0!%9%7".+ &8&77!6!/ 5: 0!,! % %"'!+&80/'" 5!!',7$!/5!#"+! 0!3.5%9%&%"'7 6%& + !'/ 0!+!9!'.!+!$"+/&7%>!<5'/%&"+%+/=+%& /"'" &.,,"+ 0!$&!"#,! % %"'!+&*

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

4 "'/'" 0!+2&*%+4&0!!+%6'/" 0!+&8 ?

) 3* 09!0!+/7!+'!/$".'&!7#"+ 0!,+ %!&'/09! 6"'! 0+".60 0!$&!#%7!/* 3.% #"+,!+<'!' %'4.'$ %"'=&#%7!/5:,! % %"'!+ "*+,+!! -.+6%'& 3' ">03%'60'/" 0!+&"'?*** ' 0!&%/$%9%7&.% 89%/! "+/!+/ !/**8',,7%$ %"' .'/!+ +/!+A .7!&'/ #%7!/5:0!+=&/%&<%&&!/*0!

+!7!9' ,+ "# 0!"+/!+=".7/+!/&.'/!+( I1**' 0!+!9!'.!+!$"+/8/!#!'/' "* %&&0"='& "='!+ '/ ,7%' %## %& '"=0!+! &0"=' %' 0! +!9!'.! +!$"+/* 7%' %##J&$7%<"' 0!&.% ,+",!+ :%&5&!/"' 7!&!/ !/?**)*"=!9!+85:,+"/.$%'6#"+!'&%$

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

'/ " 0!+&"'***' 0!&%/&.% 89%/!"+/!+/ !/**8 0! 7!+'!/ +%7".+ 80//%+!$ !/ 0!,+ %!& "<%' %'& .&;. 0!&.% ,+",!+ :* 3 %77 #.+ 0!+ :! '" 0!+ $%9%7 &.% #"+ ,!+<'!' %'4.'$ %"' =& #%7!/ 5: 3' ">0 3%'60 6%'& +,+!! -.+

,! % %"'!+"*0!+!%'

'/" 0!+&*' 0!&%/&.% 0!7!+'!/ +%7 ".+ 9%/!"+/!+/ !/?**/%+!$ !/ 0!,+ %!& "<%' %' 0!& .&;."+!6+/%'6,"&&!&&%"'* <:5!'" %$!/ 0 %' 0!$%9%7&.% #%7!/5:,! % %"'!+ +,+!! -.+6%'& 3' ">03%'60'/" 0!+&8+!&,"'/!' "* 0&'" 5!!'%<,7!/!/&/!#!'/' *0!$.&! % 7!"# 0!&.%

=".7/&0"= 0 0!+,+:!+%' 0!&%/&.% "6+' 0!+,!+<'!' %'4.'$ %"';. 0!7'/<!&.+%'6$+!>'7%*!* 0!&0+!"# 3' ">03%'60 /!#!'/' "* 0!+!%'

*0.&8% %&,,+!' 0 &0!0&'" $7%<!/':+!7%!#;. 0!7'/"#+!&,"'/!' "* &5%+3%'60%' 0!&%/$%9%7&.% *7&"8%' 0!&%/&.% 8&0!$7%<& "5!%',"&&!&&%"'"# 0!7'//! %7!/ 0!+!%'"' 0!5&%&"#7!&! 6+!!<!' / !/ ?**)8 =0!+!& %' "* / !/ **86" +!6%& !+!/5:0!+8&0!77!6!& 0 &0!0/5!!'%' ,"&&!&&%"'"# 0!7'/%';.!& %"'#"+ 0!7& :!+&* 3 %77#.+ 0!+8 0! " 77'/+!6+/%'6=0%$0 0!$%9%7&.% 0&5!!'#%7!/5:,! % %"'!+"*%&$+!>'7&% . !/%' 0! +!"#9%776! ,,70.,8!0&%7 0%77.+8%& +%$ 7'/0+'/ 9%776!3%<57,.+8!0&%7 0%77.+8%& +%$ 7'/0+8=0!+!& 0!

&.54!$ < !+"# 0!,+"$!!/%'6&.'/!+3!$ %"'+* **%& 0!

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

)

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

&.$0,+"$!!/%'6&09!5!!'%'% % !/5:+!&,"'/!' "*&5%+ 3%'60* %&'" /%&,. !/ 0 3' ">03%'60'/+'%73%'60 %*!*# 0!+"#+!&,"'/!' "*+!$"&0+!+&%'+!&,!$ "# 0!7'/ %';.!& %"'8=0%$0%&+!#7!$ !/%'4<'5/%&#"+ 0!:!+)* 0!,! % %"'!+&09!'" 5!!'+!#7!$ !/%' 0!&%/+!9!'.!+!$"+/ &7!&&!!

& "+%'':" 0!+$,$% :*0.&8'"+%60 8 % 7!"+%' !+!& 0&5!!'&0"=' "09!5!!'7!677:7!&!/". " 0!,! % %"'!+& 9%/! 0! 77!6!/ 7!&! /!!/ / !/ ?**) ;. 0! &0+! "# +!&,"'/!' "*&5%+3%'60*!'$!8% /"!&'" 7%!%' 0!<". 0 "# 0!,! % %"'!+& 0 0!+%60 &%' 0!7'/&.54!$ < !+"# 0! ,+"$!!/%'6&.'/!+3!$ %"'+* **=!+! +'&#!++!/ "0!+9%/!

0!77!6!/7!&!/!!/+!6+/%'6=0%$0 0!$%9%7&.% 0&5!!'#%7!/ 5:,! % %"'!+"*6%'& 3' ">03%'60'/" 0!+&*

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

$7!+& "0"=/!&,% ! 0!+!5!%'6& .&;.""+/!+#+"< 0!%9%7

".+ 8 0!,"&&!&&%"'"# 0!7'/=& >!'5: 0!38 0%77.+8 '/+!$!%9!+,,"%' !/* 0.&8 0!%<,.6'!/"+/!+%&&! &%/!* 0!< !+%& +!<'/!/ " 0!3.5%9%&%"'76%& + !8 0%77.+8 "$"'&%/!+ 0! < !+ #+!&0 '/ /!$%/! 0! &<! # !+ >%'6 %' " $"'&%/!+ %"' 0! 9+%".& "+/!+& ,&&!/ 5: 0! %9%7 ".+ & & +!6+/& 0!,"&&!&&%"'C& .&;.""# 0!7'/%'/%&,. !'/7&" # !+ >%'6%' "$"'&%/!+ %"'9+%".&4./6<!' &,&&!/5: 0%& ".+ &7&"5: 0!"'J57!3.,+!<!".+ +!6+/%'6%'% % %"'"# 0!,+"$!!/%'6&.'/!+3!$ %"'+* ** %&,"&!/"#%' 0!5"9! !+<&* )**

/& !

D0! 0!+3,!>%'6C !&"'!/( !&C"

D0! 0!+ !,"+ 57!( !&C"