High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/48774/2025allowed

Harveer Singh Alias Harbir Singh v. State Of Punjab

2025-09-25Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel7 pages

: :

0 >

&'8 7+& * &'8 7+& * &'8 7+& * &'8 7+& *

6% <$ >

6% <$ >/ 0 > / 0 > / 0 > / 0 > > > % & % & % & % &

!"#$ !" @9

+(+ $

&'( ) @9 +6& 8 * * * * %* %* %* %* 3,9

3,9

, , , , 9 (5% !"55/8 &7%

'&%"

9 95) 8 !" /88%& & 5( )$9 ?????

?????

????? , , , ,/91,4 /91,4 /91,4 /91,4

% 6 %%& "+ $

8 ( 8

7%& &' %"

"%- !. (.+" "%/ 0 1'&+"&%2

34'&! %&'

' !(5$5 %&%"

7+ $ !

! &9AA8% 8::90;9 0 / / !+% 8 '& & %"

&''

+ 6( +"$5 ( 8

7%& + :B AB;:B> &' %"

7&%7 ( (!+ 8 +-7"&%&67 ($+% 7

+ 7%/ :A> 1'& +"&% 2

7%34/%&5 %%& " 8/+%7%< <%+1(549

! < &'%"

55 !%& + +! +%%"

+%"%& ::90;9 0 / 6 +& 5 % 7 6% 8%"

8& <

" & +(+67& &'%"

% '&( (+7% +/="

$&%"&'%"

< = +8 !% + %"

58+ $ $&8 '

7 !9 <

" +&< "&=< !

8%&'5

/$(%%"

=+66 896& + 7"/ /

.! 0!<+&' & /=66 8 %=&65+%7$!+/"+$

55 !

85-

7% 8'&<%"

58+9

, 87&( + 5'&%"

"+% % 8%"%%"

+ 7(+%&8-+ 7 ::90;9 0 9, 87&( + 5"+'(%"

+($<%% 8%"% < 8%&- 6& +& + &' %"

7% "

&% +7(6(5&(+5- $

7&<65 8=%"/ 8%"(+/%"

7(%& 7+ +(''

+'&< "

%8 '

7%+9 , 87&( + 5"+% % 8%"%%"

%5+8 5- 8 8%"

5$5%-%"

&' 7 &%$ '+%

8(6& %"

9, 87&( + 5"+'(%"

% % %"%%"

"++(''

8 77 %& '&<& %" 0 - +9 "(+/ !(5$5+6- 8'&9 9 , 7&( + 5 +

.+ %& 657 & 7&8 %"

7(+%&8- %'7% 8% 8 >90A9 0 > + = 55 + +"&% 65- $- =- &' ''8 8% 8 90A9 0 > &' ,."= 8 !"/ / 6(%- (6 % % &' &57 / ($ +& %%/<%+1(54 %"

&(%%&8-/="7" %.

& 7&89 + ! +($<++& + % 8 < =%" %"

'& +8 65-/ 7&( + 5"+&66&+ 8%"

6 %6 %%& $-!( !%"%%"

55 !%& ++ 8! +%%"

+ &(+ %( 8/%"(+/"

8& + &%8

7& 7 ++& &'%"

!(5$59, 7&( + 5 "+ '(%"

+($<%% 8 %"% %"

+% % $5 65 + $ 8 $- %"

!&+ &'

&'%"

7%/ 8%"(+/%"

+< &(!"%%&$ 8+<++ 89 >9

87&( + 5'&%"

56% + 8"

!& %"&(!" 5$5 7&8+&'%"

=+ +% 8 & ::90;9 0 ="

+%!%& =+7 8&(% 87"55 =+6 8& 09: 9 0 &%5 :6&+ 7(%& =% ++ +"

7% 8/&(%&'="7"& 5-0 "

C< 8%558% 57& % %& ++ 8%!

+ %&8 $%$5 ++( +/="7"+"55$ %&7 % 8(6& 8( !%"

7&(+ &'%59 "+&(% 8& + &%8

<%66&6% %&8

6 %&%"

57& % %& +/% %"++%!

/5 +%%<-6 )(87 %59 &%" !% !$5 "+$

$&(!"% '&=8 %& 87% %"

5"&&8 &' %"

$+7& 8 ! '&< %"

6&7 ++&')(+%7 & % '

!=%"%"

7(%&

;9:9 6 (+5&'%"

D< &8 +6++ 8$-%"

%5&(%/$&(!"% '&%"$-%"

/ 87% +%"%%"

%5+ 8

86&7+% % ! 8 '&55- %"

&' 7 &% $ +885 8 (6& %"

9 + 6 7(+%&8- %'7% 8% 8 >90A9 0 >'5 8$-%"

5 7&( + 5/%"

"+ 5 8- +(''

8 77 %& '& 6 &8 &' <& %" 0 - +/ 0 <& %"+ 8 : 8-+9 %"+

= &' %"

<%% / %"

!& <6&+ 8 ( 8

&'%"

7%+% 8+85(% 8 5!"%&'%"

%75 :&'%"

& +%%(%& &' 89 ;9 9

"+ &(% )(8!< % %%5 8 + E(5= 8

+(+ &' E(5= 8

+(+ &' ( )$ ( )$ ( )$ ( )$6++ 8 ;0 ;0 ;0 ;0 0 0 0 0 1 0 >**00 ;A>4F'% 5- ! (6& %"

%&8 8&'%"

)(8!< %+&'%"

& 3$5 (6 &(% (++ E"%&& +9&<

7-9/ &'"1:A04: :F$8(5 "< %(5- + 9 -. 1:AA 4 : >F

8 (5< $

"." +9 &'"+"% 8 &%"

/ 0 1 41< 54AF &"8(+5<#(++ +9 1 &' 5"4 6&% 8+ 0

::F < 5 66 5 &9 >B 0 0 8% 8 090 9 0 0 %%5 8 + G"%% +=+5+ ($"+ +9 &'H +% !5IFG %+"8".-# 6 +9 &' H +% !5I/ 75 ,

%& 66 5 1594

&9>> 0 0 8% 8 909 0 %%5 8+G&"<<8 5< ' "."

+9 &' ()%IF < 5 66 5 &9::;A &' 0 8% 0>909 0 %%5 8+&65E+" %#&65(+< +9 & &' 8/ 8 .( "(8"- +9 &' 8"- 8 +"/ 0 14 1< 54: F"+"

58/%"(+* G99

!"% %& +6

8- 8 C6 8%&(+ %5 + &% & 5-

%5+'

!(8%&6

%( 8( 8&66 ++

77 %& F%&<%!% C %- 87& 7 77&<6 - !%"

77(+%& += 55+%&7(%5 - <6< % %"

$5%-&' 77(+ 8%&8 '

8"<+ 5'/$(%%"

+ &

7" !+&7 %5 % +%6 !=-'&+6

8-%59 "+!"%"+ $

% 85-7%(% 8 %"

%6+% 8%"

%&8 8&'%"

8%& (6 &(%3+)(8!< %+"

588&= + +&' 7+& +&6 !(6 = +%+&''( 8< %5!"%+9 7& 7 6%&' +6

8-%5+<5!<% 8 %&%"

%75 :+ ++ %56%&'%"

'( 8< %5!"%%&5'

85$ %-/!( %

8 86

8( 8 &( & +%%(%& 9 !"% %& +6

8- %5 $ ! + =%" %"

7%(5 +% % <6&+ 8 % %"

%< &' %"

+% &' %"

77(+ 8 8 7& + J( 77 %& ="7" 7& % ( + % 55 +%!

+/ < 5-/ %"

+%!

+%!%& / J(-/ %5/ 66 5 8

+& +& %"% - 6&++$5 6 )(87 %"%<- +(5%8( %&<6 <++$5 8 &8$5 5-+ 7 %< &' %"

7&<<++& &' %"

&''

%55 %"

7< 5 6&7

8 !+ 7& +(<<% %& ' 5%-/ 7&(58 $

% 89 +6

8- %5/ 5- ! 8J(7.8+6&+5 + J( & &'7< 5)(+6(8 &

7&=8 8&(%8&7.

%+/%"

- &5(< &'=&. 8%"

+(5% % 6 ++( & %"

7(%& 8%"

&57 / 8($%$5-.

6+%"

% 7< 5)(+6(8 %5< 7" +<( 8 +% ++ 8+% 9&=

/%"+ 7 &%$ C7(+ '&.

6 !%"

+=&8&'<&75 +" ! !& %"

77(+ 8'& 8 ' % &8&'%< %8& + &%+

-7 8%%&%"

7< 5 )(+%7 +-+% </ %"

% <.

+ '& +8 +%% &' ''+9 !( %

&' +6

8- %5 + % 8 %& &8 &66 ++& 8 6

5- $- <6&+ ! & %"

&(% 8 %"

6&+ 7(%& &$5!%& %& 6&7

8=%"%"

%5=%" +& $5 8+6%7"9 !( %

+ %"

'&586(6&+ 9+%5-/%6&% 7%+%"

77(+ 8! +%&66 ++

6 %5 <6+& < %F + 7& 85-/ %

+ %"

77(+ 8 &' %"

C %- 8 6($57+(+67& 8( %&( +&5

87< 57"!

+ 85+%5-/%6&% 7%+ ! +% %"

+. %"%

=55 $ 5&+% & < <& + 8<< 8 $- %"

6++!

&' %< / %"(+/ <6 ! %"

$5%- &' %"

77(+ 8 %& 8 '

"<+ 5'9 %!& +=%"&(%+- !%"%%"

7& + J( +&'6 %58 %& !

9 77(+ 8/ 6 +(< 8 &7 %/ %55 6&

&%"

=+ / +($) 7% 8 %& 6+-7"&5&!75 8 6"-+75 8 6 %& + &' )55'

/ (+(55- ( 8 & &(+7& 8%& +9J(55-<6&% %/%"

$(8 &'8 %& &' +(7" 77(+ 8' J( %5-'55+"

5-& %"

&7 %< <$ +&'"+ '<5-9

+ - % &%"

+6 7% &' %"

<%% ="7" 8

+ 7& +8 %& % %"+ +%!

55 !%& + %"

6 % 7+ 5% %& 77(+ 8 $ !

8 5% ! %& 7&<< 75 J( %%- &' 7& %$ 8( 8 %"

7%/:A>9H"5 7& +8 !$56 %%& 7+ !7&<< 75J( %%-/%"

&(%"+%&.

6 < 8%"

!&(+ (< % 8( 8

&' 7%/:A>="7"< 8% + %"% &(%+ 7 ! % $5 %& 77(+ 8 & 5- '% "

! %"

6($57 6&+ 7(%& 8'% " !+%+'

8%+ 5'&'%= 7& 8%& +="7" +& $5 !&( 8+ '& $

! %"% %"

77(+ 8 + &% !(5%- &' %"

> &''

7"!

8B55 !

8 8%"%/"

+ &%5.

5-%&7&<<% -&''

="5 & $59 +% !

%!&(+&'

&'%"

7%/:A> <(+% $ < %7(5&(+5- +7(% D 8 ! +% %"

$7.8&6 &' 77(+ 83+ '( 8< %5!"%%&+6

8-%59 !"%%&5'

86 +& 55$ %- 7 &%$ 8 (!%&-$-( = % 88 5-+ %"

)(8756&7 ++/ 6%7(55-="

+(7"8 5-1+4+ %%$(%$5 %&%"

77(+ 8 & )(+%'

8%%"

8&'%"

7(%& $- 7&!

% +& +9 8 8(5 7 &% $ .

6% $ " 8 $+ '& &8 % &8 &' %< $- %. ! '(!

!&(+588&=

&'%"

7%/:A>9 !+5%( %+=+8&</ &8 %& +( +6

8- 8%< 5-8+6&+5&' +( 8 %"

7%/"+6& 8'&%"

7& +%%(%& &'+6 75&(%+ ( 8

;&'%"

7%9&=

/%"+&(%7 &%%(

5+& 3+

- %&%"

6&%7% 88 5-+ 8+-+% <%7 ''7 7-%"%'(+%% %"+ !+5%

6(6&+ 9&(%&'5=+8(%-$&( 8%& +( %"%%8& + &%$ 7&< 7&<657% &5%& &' 8 8(53+'( 8< %5!"%+/ &%=%"+% 8 ! -%" !7& % 8 +%%(% 9H"5 5 !=%"$5 %%& 7+ !&

8$-%"

!&(+&'

&'%"

7%/ :A>/ %"

&(% <(+% +%.

)(87&(+ $5 7 $ %=

5 !+5%

%%&7($%"

< 7 &'8(!+ 8%"

+7&+ 7%!"%&'%"

77(+ %&' 8 C6 8%&(+%59&5& !

8 77 %& /=%"&(%)(+%'$5 7(+ / +.+ % +'&< ! 6 %5 8 %& %& 6( %

<6+& < %/ &(%7&< %%"

%75%&%"

6 765 &')(+%7 8 J(%-9 !&/%"

( J( &75 '

+%"%="

%5"+ '5 8 %& 7& 75(8 =%" +& $5 %< / +(5% ! 6&5& !

77 %& / % <5%% + ! +% %"

6 7&(+ '( 8< %5 !"%+ &' 5'

8 5$ %- ! % 8 ( 8 %"

5= 8/ + +(7"/ 7& 8%& 5 5$ %- &

8 !%"

+%%(%&- <$!&7 % 8( 8

&'%"

7%/:A>&(!"%%&$ 7& +8 8+6 '7%+&'!

&%"

=&8+/! %&'$5 7+ % !%&7&<< 75J( %%-/& %"

!&( 8&'( 8( 5- %5/7 &%$ +8%&$ '

%% 8$-

&'%"

7%/:A>9I ;9 (%"

/ + 6 %"

+8 7(+%&8- 7 %'7% / %"

+ +%% 8 %& $

8 &%"

1+49 &=

/ %"+ '7%(< 7 &% $ !&( 8+(''7 %$-%+ 5'/%&8 7& 7 ++& &' !(5$5%&%"

J( +%& ="

7+ +<8 &(%'&! %&' !(5 $5J(%"

J( +%& $-%&7 % !(6& %"

'7%+B77(<+% 7 +&' +8 9 5 7 %"+ !87 $ 657 8(6& %"

)(8!< %&'%"

& 3$5 (6 &(% (5 &"89<+"8 &'99 (5 &"89<+"8 &'99 (5 &"89<+"8 &'99 (5 &"89<+"8 &'99 8 &%"

/ 0: 1:41< 54>;

8 &%"

/ 0: 1:41< 54>;

8 &%"

/ 0: 1:41< 54>;

8 &%"

/ 0: 1:41< 54>;F +& 7")(8!< %&' & 3$5 57(%%!"&(% 7+ &' 8"+ /:AA1 4

8"+ /:AA1 4

8"+ /:AA1 4 1< 54 1< 54 1< 54 1< 54K)(8!< %+&'%"+&(% &9 0

; %%5 8 + ."5 +" !" &' - ."5 +" !" &' - ."5 +" !" &' - ."5 +" !" &' - / 8 8 & A9::9 0 :/ 8 5) &'- /:AA1 41< 54:A:9 5) &'- /:AA1 41< 54:A:9 5) &'- /:AA1 41< 54:A:9 5) &'- /:AA1 41< 54:A:9

(''7 %& +-/ '(%"

8 %& &' %"

+ ( 8 %5+ &%= % 8 %"

'7%+ 877(<+% 7 +&'%"

=&'$&

/%"

6 %6 %%& +55&= 89 + &8 8%&$ + 8& !(5$5& "+'( +" !$5B+( %-$& 8+%& +%+'7%& &'%"

,897& 7 8%5&(%B(%-!+%% 9&=

/ 88%& %& 7& 8%& + %"% <- $ <6&+ 8 $- %"

7& 7 8 %5 &(%B(%-!+%% /%"

+"55 < $&( 8$-%"

'&55&= ! 7& 8%& +* 14

+"55 &%<+(+ 5$ %-! % 89 14

+"55 &%%<6 =%" -

/&5& 8&7(< %-/8( !%"

%59 14 +"55 &%$+ %"<+ 5'& -8% $ '& %59 4 +"55 &% 7&<<% - &''

="5 & $59 4

+"558 6&+%"+6++6&%/' -/=%"%"

%5&(%9 4

+"55 !

"+ 7 556"& (<$ %& %"

+%!% ! ''7 B &' 7& 7 8 &57 %%& 8+"55 &%7" !

"+7 556"& (<$ =%"&(%6& <++& &'%"

%5&(%B 55J!+%% 4 +"55 &% - < %- %& 8 5- %"

%59 4 +"55+($<%/& %"

'+%=&. !8-&'

- <& %"/ ''8 %/ $ '& %"

7& 7 8 %5 &(%/ %& %"

7% %"% "

"+ &% $

8 7&<<++& &' -&''

'% $ ! + 8& $59

7+ %"

+ '&( 8 %& $

8 - &''

'% "+ $ ! 5!

8 & $5 %"

6 /& %"

$++&'"+''8 %&&%"

=+ /%"

+ < 8% 8%&<&

/'&%"=%"/'&7 7 55%& &'"+$5 ="7" 65 / $(% &' 7&(+ / +"55 $ %&7 % 8 (6& %+%"

&'9 9

&'$ 7"&' -&'%"

'& +87& 8%& + 8%"&+ ="7"<-$ <6&+ 8$-7& 7 8%5&(%B(%-!+%% +8 7%

& (6& +"&= ! - &%"

+(''7 7(+ /

B7&<65 % +"55 $ % 5$ %- %& <&

7 7 55%& &' $5 &' %"

9 A9 8 877&8 !5-9 :09

&%" !+8"

+"55$ 7& +%( 8+ C6 ++& &' &6 & & %"

< %+&'%"

::9

< 7+ "+$

8/6 8 !<+7 55 &(+ 6657%& /' -/+"555+&+% 8+8+6&+ 8&''9 1 ,

6% <$ >

6% <$ >/ 0 > / 0 > / 0 > / 0 > <" H"

+6 . !B +& 8* +B & H"

6&%$5 * +B &