High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28287/2022disposed of

Ashok Kumar v. State Of Punjab And Others

2024-04-19Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary5 pages

!"#"$"

%"" ""$"

'()*+,'*-./.+0122 3/4+5678(9 222*).).+0*9 :*9/7/ ;4*<)()*+,70=(>(0?+)4*9/ 222@*/A+0?*0)/

"BC D#EB F!

G"B""

% HHHH 9*/*0)

/2@.).3II(9J(KL3?M+-()* ,+9)4*A*).).+0*92

92 (0.A(K<.0I43)J(KL'3NL70=(> HHHH "B""

%O!F 2 ;4* A9(P*9 .0 )4* A9*/*0) A*).).+0 ./ ,+9 ?.9*-).+0/ )+ )4* 9*/A+0?*0)/ )+ A*98.) )4* A*).).+0*9/ )+ -+0).07* J.)4 )4* N*0*9(K 9+M.?*0) Q70? <-4*8* (/ (K/+ >* *0).)K*? )+ >*0*,.)/ 70?*9 )4*

K? *0/.+0 <-4*8*L >P -+70).0I )4* J4+K* A*9.+? +, ?(.KP J(I*/&-+0)9(-)7(K /*9M.-* +, )4* A*).).+0*9/ (/ R7(K.,P.0I ,+9 )4* /(8*2 2 S*(90*? -+70/*K /7>8.)/ )4() )4* A*).).+0*9 J(/ (AA+.0)*? (/ A(9) ).8* /J**A*9 .0 1L J4*9*(,)*9 4./ /*9M.-*/ J*9* 9*I7K(9.T*? .0 2 +J*M*9 4* J(/ ?*0.*? >*0*,.)/ 70?*9 )4*

K? *0/.+0 <-4*8* +0 (--+70) +, )4* U*J +0)9.>7)+9P *0/.+0 <-4*8* 4(M.0I -+8* .0)+ +A*9().+0 A+/) 222 ;4* .//7* ./ 0+ K+0I*9 9*/ .0)*I9(L 4(M.0I >**0 ?*-.?*? >P )4* '.M./.+0 V*0-4 +, )4./ +79) .0 WXYWZ[ EW\ ][F G^W^_ `a bZcWY WZd `^e_X[ L L ?*-.?*? +0 22L (I(.0/) J4.-4 )4* <S (/ J*KK (/ )4* @*M.*J 3AAK.-().+0 J*9* ?./8.//*? +0 22 (0? 22 9*/A*-).M*KP2 Q+KK+J.0I )4* (>+M* (0? -+0/.?*9.0I @7K* 2 +, 70=(> .M.K <*9M.-*/ @7K*/ (/ J*KKL )4./ +79) (KK+J*?

!"#

$ % &

'()

*& &+

. !"

,&$+0(1 23 44 5 26 78 9:2; <=2 <2>? 6>29

; @@ 2 A; B 22? CD < BE3 6>= ::2393 23 44 =D = F< A63 23>CD2>; 323 GD3 H5=9 < 9 ::5C = =9 2 C B2E>3 D3> =

323 ID C3B 3 >E5 :>2> 2 444 J?< 3

K++L

M &

'()

*& &+

. !"

,&$+0(

5 23 44@ :> 9 <:> < B>3 = C36 C3B 59C;=:23>=>3 >E3:><=>26 >=D NO= PD23 26 < 2 <==> 3 9:2; <=2 >E5 <> >BD> 6> < C B2E>3 C; = F< 323 H5=9 2> =

323 H5=9 < 3 = >; 3 63; D: 2 = 23Q C HD:>9 2D> 26 734 O= AE23 R35= 26 = 2D> <= 53B F24 26

S !(

M T

U0()

*& &+

. !"

W0() 5 23 = = = 3 9:2; <=2 < 3 >E5 23 =2DB= = >E5 9B= =E C3 >BD> 6> = 2 C B2E>3 D3> =

323 H5=94O= >E3 :2>2326=XDB93D3> NG>29 = C2E 5D23 < =E 529 2 = 5235D23 = = 3> ; <B >E5 26 = :23> 6>29 @ = 26 = >BD>Y23 2 C 52D3 PD6;3B >E5 62> = :D>:2 26 :3234 < C 9 2 C 3 B2E4 H>E5 :>2> 2 444 O= 3< I>D5D> A63 23>CD23 323 H5=9 Z33[D> = C3 3>2D5 62> = 3< 3>3 3 = D3XC \2E>393 H>E5 <4464 44 < 32 C ::5C 2 = :23>4 O= 9393 9 E Z33[D> 933B = D3XC E H>E5 ID 5332 C 6D>=> 93 C; D3B 5>6523]3>D523 44 Z33[D> O= :23> < 5233D 2 C B2E>3 C; = \G H5=9 3 = 3 2 >5E :323>; C36 ::5C 2 = 9:2; >5>D 3 = D3XC\2E4H>E5:>2>2444 73 E< 26 = C2E = <> :23 2<4 Z552>3B; >:233 > >5 2 > = <=2 :>2 26 <2>?

5=>B >E5 PD6 >E5 62> :323 C5D 552>3B; 2 5>6523 D 23 44 Z33[D> = 3< 63 23>CD2>; 323 H5=9 <2D C ::5C 2 =2 9:2; <=2 =E C3 <2>?

! ! "# $! %& ' % (!" ' !"

#!" '

#!"!' !' %'!" ) * ! !)+ ," - . /#! " % !! '!% ! !" 0

1 # ! ' 2 !" 1 3- !! ' /! !" . /#!

% !" 1!! ' . " %

#) ," ' & !" ' ! . ! (" " !"

! "- !4 ! % !" !! !"

'! ' !" / !"! !" !! (

% !" *( !

! % -! 5 "# "/ ! . !) ," . ! (" " "

% !"

! !"! - ' !"

"# !" !! & 4/ -( - ' !" 6 ) 7& !" -

% !" !! ! !#

! 8 '%/ - ' !" / ! ' %

'!) ," 6 " %

! !

% !" ! (" / *) 99 ' !! : 1/" ;) 1!! ' % !" )) (" # 8 ! ' ( ) 2 !"

!" #% ( 4/ ! !#

& ( 4/ !"

'! ' !" ! !# - !

! 8 '%/ - ' !" / ! ' %

'!) 7'!

%/ !" . /#! < " ;) 1!! ' . !" & !" ! (" / *) 99 ' & ))& " !"! #% " ( 4 (!" !"

! !" /" ! !#

& !" ! !# - "

!4 !

! '

/ ! ' - ' #%& !"

'! ' - &

! 8 '%/ - ' !" / ! ' %

'!)," -! !'!". /#! $$ $$ $$ 7/! !" 37 *) 9 ' 9 ( '

% !" =- #! ' % - ! ))9& '! ! / !" - ' 6 )7& !" >- ? " " !"! % " ! ! # ! !# #%#! !"! ! '

!/ %& " !

/ ("

# !/ !" %

'!) ," >- ? " " !"! (" #% " ( 4 ' / !#

! %& (" " # !" & !" #

! ! !# //#!&

/ ("

# !/ !" %

'!) ,"

-! ! ' !" . /#! ' !">-? " $$ $$ $$ ," 8 ! ' ( ! ("!" & !" ! !# - !

! '

# !/ !" %

'! /

# '

' !" ! *) ' 9 !! @ ?"/( ;

) 1!! ' %

!" & ))A) 2 !"

& 4/ -( !" ' !" ! ? " : 1/"0 1 ( !" 37 *) 9 ' 9& !"

! "#$% !&

& & #!

" !

$% " ! %!

!$$ & "#'& ! ('!$%)

* +

$ ! # ,'&)" !

'& -. !

& ' $ #!

!& !

) ') & !$!

!* ' $ # & ! # !&

& &

" !

) " /**00 $$ **1

!" $!$ '& ! ('!$%)

) ! # !

% * ' $ # '

& ! ') # 2) #!

" !

1 ' 2& !' %!

1 !

!& ! & !

)& &' #!

" !

* 3'

1 # 2) !

$1 !

!& ! & !

)) &' #!

" !&

!" !

& & !

)'$!

"#$%" !$$ !&#'

# * !&1 ' $

! ! !##" "!& #!

" !

!" ! & & ! ('!$%)

# 4 * 46 7$..1 ! &) 1 #!

! !&!

!('!$%)

* . ! "! ! ! # 2& #!

" !

$% %!

* 5 #

)!)& #!

" $% !

# , !&

#& # &* . !

!& ! ! "#$%1 2) ''

$% %!

$1 ! #!

" ,* +

!& ! $) ""#$%" !$$ !&#'

# * 5 3'$$ 8 '

9 !&:

'# !

$& ! &!$% !)

1 $$ & %

)'$!

1 '& ! ('!$%)

) ! # !

% *

1 &!$% !)

'& ! ('!$%)

1 !

!& ! ''

!##"

& & % # %!

') #!

" !

1 $

! &!$% !)

& & % ! "#$%* + ,'

! ) %

#& &%

!& 1 <# 6'$ * * +

!& 6'$ !

!$ !&% & & 9 !&:

'# !& !

$& ! &!$% !)

$$ & %

)'$!

)& ') !& ('!$%)

"#') # !

% * + 1

# !

& & %!

! " /**00 $$ ** ! ) & "#') # !

% # *=

! " #$

#! " %&"'( ) * " + &,- # #,

(

%&"'( . ! #

" #!

( !

/&, $ ' !

. '&, 0") 1 .

#!-

" #%

. # " #$

( !

" " #$

( 2

,, )) # & " /&, $ ' !

, #,

# % ") 3

" #$

, ,. " ! , "$ # % "-

$ #

, ,'

," +()

,,.") " "

," +(

$ #

" . , " '

$ #

," +(-

" " #$

( 2

,, ,, , #

" /&, $ ' !

( &

$ #

) *

,&,

$ #

# " #$

" .

. ( (

" $

" " . ! (&

,&,

,, # ,"

"4 .( )5 ) * " + &, "

# # &#,

" " . & $ "

(

"%&"'(

$ $,.) ) 1 .6

(

%&"'(

7 899:;<77 =;>;7 -7 ?;@A;<B77 =;C7 "7 D;AE<FG77 DH;I;>7 & ) J7 KLKM7N?KOP?KQR7 S7

,2- 8OPTU7 "

6 ' VWX #, VWX