Pranav Gupta v. Union Of India And Another
!!
"#"$ %&'"
! $( &#)# )* # "
"#
"#)'+, -
$#,,'
%&'"
! $( &#)# )* # "
"#
"#)'+, -
. / !0 / "
0
. " 2!33 0 / "
0
. /(4
(0 "
0 . (3!
$6 !0 "
0 . /2!7 / !0 "
0 . / 8
'2 7(0 "
0 . $ /!920 "
0 . /!2 $6 "
. "9 :0 "
0
! ! . (
:!0 / "
0
. $!-(:
;2!0 "
0 . /(4
(0 "
0 . $ /!920 "
0 . / 8
'2 7(0 "
0 . 2
< -!:
"
0 . /!2 $6 "
0
. "9 :0 "
0
! !
. / $ 4(0 ": /:! !
% !
. "! .(9!:0 /! (:
&! !
. =23 +( !0 /- !
(:
,
. / 6
%1 6!0 "
0 .
- 2( %(-
"
0 . $!7 %( !0 "
0 . < !7 / 21 :0 "
0 . .
2(6!
<2 0 "
0 . .
!2
(380 "
0 . ;8 !7
0 "
0 . #!2
"
0
. 1
% 2!0 "
0 >9 (:
,
- #
. 7
0 )?"
. !
!7
.2 > ,
@@@@
/! 3
1!
!
! 6
66 *0 3! 3
1!
!
::9
6
!
;(9 .0 3
1!
!
66 :! -( A(
! : 6 4(! !
( 80
2 0 3
1!
!
6 3: !
2(92
66 !
'2 ! 6
6 6
4(! !
( 8
2(92
6
'2 0
6! 12
!
6
:
-!! 63! / ! "0 0
/ ! B
! .8 > (!9 "
2!
"
D
9 0
8
2!
E
-!! 0 12! 2 3 6 E
2!
"
#
$
%
&
% !
"
' '
' %
'
#
$
%
!
5
9 :9 A( ! 12! 2
!
4(!
!
20
( !
2
6
!0
6 0
( 2
9(
3:!0
0
6 (--:!
260
7
:
!! .0
7
( ::8
0
2(92
6
66 10
--!
6-:!
0
E
( 8 -!!0 12 8
0
-
!0
69!9 6
2!0 !:8 :90
--!
!F
0
?0
2! :
, 6
!
0
6( 0
2!
( ::8
2 ! .0
( 2
6!0 12
(0
!0
238 7
( 3:
2!
2
!
!0
9(
2!
2!
0 6 (--:!
260
12
60
!
+G3: "-E
!
"#$$ #
:
C % & '
( )*
D0
8 - ! 3 6 2
8
( 8 -!! .0 12
6 (630
:!
3:
-(
6-: :8
!::9 : (:
:80 12
::9 6
:
- ( 8
6 2 !
::8 0 3! 12
$
!
:
2! : 6 4(! !
( 8
!9
1
30
/! (:
-- !9
! !
2!
(36!!
'2
!1
!
238 !- !
2! 6 ::8
2(92
1!9
660 8
(
2!
/!
9(
3 6 (--:!
260
2
9(
238 3
( 8 -!! 3 7!9
(36!!0
/! (:
! 7 :!
0 (-0
4(96
+G3: 563 +!92
:
C! %+ !
,
- .!
( !
/01 ' 2 3 .
!
D0 12!0
3 E- (:
0
-G
2 ::
6
66 !66!
:8 2! -:
(
?0 2! 6 4- !F
'2
--( !1 (--
4(96
!!! 5 2
+G3: <
+!92
:
C4 &5 (
*
.6
D .0
7 !1
(--
4(96
+G3: "2
2 +!92
:
C8 *-2
4
(9 ,
:
1;
&
1< .6
D '28 ( -
7
9(6
!
7
-( 6
0
+G3: "-E
:
C % &'
=
03!
:!92
E- (:
!
0
+G3: "-E
:
C; '
()* .!
- > ? ,6 *,@ 7$0
! - 7!9
2!0
2 3:
3
8 -!! (:
:80
:
!::9
!
:
3 6 : 6 4(! !
( 8 H
!" !#$%&'&()"&***'!' + $!)&"&)('!# "* (()&( "*&)
'2 ": /:! !
% !
12!: ( !9
(36!!0
3
2!
/! (:0
! !0 6-2 !F - 9 -2 #H0
!
1 +G3: "-E
:
C,
A
(, %8
& 1/ 0
# /0D0 - 9 -2 12 3 6 E
2! 30
(36!
!0 1
!( (660
-((
(660
28 1 :9
! 2! : '2 0
28 1
3(
1
2 6:8
!
2! 9
!
A( ,
:2! A( 0 (36!
2
6 (630
-
!0
2 (36!
0
7!9
6
-
!0
2(92
66 1
3 6
:
0 - !
::8 7!9
4(!
!0 12
0
2 1
8 3
8 -!! 3 + ( (36!
0
( 20
6 ::8
! 3
26 6 (--:!
66
3:!0
28 66!
63!
"
'2 0 (36!
2 9
3
8 -!! 0
!
:
8 :!
26 ()* +
+
,
+%
+
- -
.
+
+
/
01
2
3
3 4#
5 1 6
3
0
$
*78
+
+
9 6
4 +.
%'
.
.6# & 6 + .
'
: 2 /
;
-<*= +
+
+
* >
:
*
&
!
'2 ": /:! !
% !
(-- !9
(36!!0
- 9 -2
!
1 0 . 2:
2 9 9
!
6!:8 %(-
- 9 -2 12 3 6 E
2!
0 12!0
2 0
- 7!9 (0 3(
:!9
! !
: E %(-
6- 8
26 !66!
:8 '2 0
"/% 0
0 1!::!9:8
6- !
! !
:
,
2!
!F
(:
:80
2
8
(
!0
2
8 !
(--:!
9(
3:!
238
2
8 3
8
( 8 -!!
( % ?8;@ 25 " /
5 2
$
65:#
1
7
;#4???(5 2
$ /
0
/
9
'
A8?A?AB5 2
$
/
0
4
/
5 2
$
!
'2
! -!
2 (660
6
6 !(
(0
2 0 (::8
6- 8!9
0 !:8 2! :0 12! 2 1 !
!F 1
, 0 1 :8 6
-(- 9
!0
( 3:
#
(!9
2!
!:80
!6-
2 0
1 -((
2
7
, A(
2! 9
2 '2 0
9(
6 ::8
2(92
66
3 6
:
0
4(9!9 12
2
8 3
8 -!! + 6-2 !F
0
28 1 (--:!
9(
3:! 0
28 66!
(:
:80 (::8
9(
3:
- ( ! !
8
( 8 -!! '2
!
(-- 1!
(36!! -:
3
2!
"/% "(', !#$%&
!" (**)& &*- .)(/ &#!)& $% !
)$ ("* $%& )&( !" #!) )&0&+$ "1 $%& ()1
&"$ !# $%& '&()"&*("*(++&.$ "1$%&()1
&"$ (**)& &* &#!)&$% !
)$ ,$%&'&()"&*&" !)+!
" &' #!)$%&)& .&+$ 2&.&$ $ !"&) '2
!
9(6 3
2!
(: 0 3 (!:8 :(
2! B )
(!
:8!
9(6 0
-- 0
"/% 0 !!3:8 ( 1!9
6 ! !
( 80
2(92 2! 7!9 :!
4(96 .0
6-2 !F0
6- 8!9
! 2! :0 12! 2 1
!:8 !F0
?0 3:9
, ! !
: 0 1 :8 -((
(660
6 !(
26
!
!0
2(92
6-
238 7
(36!!0
-(-
1!9
6
660
7 3:
::
:
-(- # 2:0
(36!!
3
2!
3 60 2!9
!
-:
3
2!
"/% 0
6 3:
-
2! '2 7!9
:(!0 -( 6
4(96
0
3
2!
/! (: 12!0
3 6
!:8 E-0
(!9 (:
1 (:
!0
7 3:
0
7!9
6
(
(0
2(92
1!9
66 #1
--:8!9
!
0
3(
:8 69
6
!
A(
(0
!:8
6- 8!9
! !
:
, 0 !:8
!F
3:9!9
26 '2 0
6- 8!9
, ! !
:0
6(
2!
2 (:
1 (::8 !0
( 20
6- 8!9
2! :0
3(
3 6
(
2! 3!90
2 +10
1
(--:!
9(
3:!0
28 66!
-(!2 3: (
"
A( :80
238 - ! 3
8 -!! '2
9(6
80
3
2!
"/% 0
6- 8!9
2! : 0 :8 -((
(660 !(
260 (!9
2380
28
9
, A( :
:2!0 3(
:!
3:
4 '2 4 !9
9(6 3(
-:
70
!
!
(:
1!::!9:8
6- !
, ! !
: 0
2! -!
2! :
2! :
2! :
!0
2(-
2!
6
2!
6- 8!9
, ! !
:
, A( 0 :
:2!0 1(: (
2!
238
20
(:
1 (::8 ! +10
!
9 9:8
6!0
!
690
6- !0
, ! !
:0
!:8 !F 2! :
2! : 3:9!9
, ! !
: '2 0
6
6- 8!9
, ! !
:0
(
2! !
:(
!:8 1!::!9:8
6- 8!9
260
, A( 0
238
6- 8!9
, ! !
:0
6
-((
2! (660
2! 9
! 0
, A( :
:2!
--
3
(66
, ! !
:
6-
9!
21! (:
1 (:
( 3: :(
:(
!:8
6- 8!90
, ! !
:
, A( 0 :
:2! H , 21!0
!
3 6 :!0
"/% 0 !!9! !
(
(36!!0
E
- 9 -2 0
6-:! 80
, ! !
:
E
(0
6- 8
26 '2 0
6 !9
!6-
1 I EG
2 6
::(6
-(8
, ! !
:
6- 8
260
! 2! :0 12! 2 1 !
!:8 !F0
?0 3:9
26 A( :80
238
"/%0
1
::(
6- 8
, A(
:2!0 3!
6- 8!9
, ! !
:0
-((
8 -(- (660
6 !(
260 12! 2 21! :( 3:8 !( 6:8
(-0
(:
1 (:
6 0
(63 (-0
! '2(920 "/% 0 6-2 !F
(60
!
.
9!
0 6 ! !
(0
2
6
( 3:
!9
-
+10
9(6
3 6
-
2! !1
+G3: "-E
:
C(
'
&(
; 23, ,%
6
D - #
6 12!0
3 E- (:
0
!
:0 69
(99 !
- 6
2!0 :
!9
--:!
! 4(! !
6!
!
;(9 0
7!9
:
( 8 3 2 3(
3 6 ! !90
2! 7!9
!6-(9 6
( 20 (-0
! --:!
! 6!
69!90
-:
70 3
/ ! B
"
0
238
6
!::9 : B A( 0
3
--(
2!0
238
! !9 !!9
6
238
!6-(9 6
A( 20
!0
2! (
!90
-
- !
8
( 8 -0
6
! !
:
, !1
30
2!
A( 2
6
E ! 1!
4(!!
!0
6
!
-( % &'
=
0
;'
=
0 :
!
!
A( 0
::1!9
!
!0
2!
A( 2
!6-(9 6 "E( 3 !0
! : 6 4(! !
( 80 3(
(34
2! (!2!9 - :0
( 3
(6 0 0 ? 3
!
?2! ;(! !
.
9!
?
( .
9!
0
2!
!0
(34
2!
6-!9 - ( ! ! 0
2!
! :( !9 - ( ! .0
! 2 ::
(
2! ! - - 3
$
!
0
2 ::
9!
(
7!9 3
!
;(9 0
(3A(
!90
!9
!
;(9 0
28 2 ::
!
2(
-! -6!!
!
;(9 -
/ 3455657 - / $%'& % %&$%&) .&(8 "19)&( !"&*: & 9!
%&$%&))&.!)$( '& & 9!