Lovleen Sethi v. State Bank Of India And Others
!
"#$%%&
#$#'$( "#$%%&
) *+, % - ,- ,, + ****
!"
! # !"
# $ !"
-.$"
/ #'"0123 % %&'
( )#
*# + #!
",,-
*
# .
"
/#
&, &, ,0&1 %!2# 3' &4 &, ,0&1 %!2# -' &1 &, ,0&1 %!2# 4' 05 &, ,0&1 %!2# 4!' .
6
6 + +.
.+ "$ /#
." 7 "
6 "
"$ "
# $ # $
! "
#
6
6
"$ 05 ,0&5 %!2# &' 6
+
"
"
$
# + 6 "
$+6 #"
%,'
"
"
. "
+
$ "
80 ,0&, 9 #""# "6
. $
. " 6 :# 6 ; "< %:
; <' 80 ,0&5
- 2 -
.
+ # 6
"$ 05 ,0&5 %!2# &'
(
/#
! < # "6
26
. 6 #
6 ; "< %
; <' ,, ,0&5 #+/# $ ,1 ,0&3
. = " ( 6 + "
7 #
6 $#
/# 6 #
6
!
# "
"
. 6
; < &0 &0 ,0&4 .
"
6 8& ,0&4 """.
#&4
"> "# &8 0- ,0&1
7 "
++$
#
6
+# 6
"
7. .
.
+"
&4 &, ,0&1
"6 " 6 +$ ? 3 "$<6 ? 5 " 6 "6 "
&, &, ,0&1
.
.
@ 6
.
"
6 8& ,0&4 (
. . +$
6 &1 &, ,0&1 6
"
#"
"$ 6# 6
@ ""# "/#"
.
.6
" ,5 &, ,0&1
05 &, ,0&16 ,
"6 #
"
.
.
6
; <
#
".
6
; <
"6
6 $ #
6 +
+
6
#"
2"$6#
, 03 -855 + +" 7"
.
- 3 - %8'
# $ !" + < "6 .
# 6
500 "
6
6
6 ; "%
; <' +$6
"$ 05 ,0&5 .
2$/# $" "6 . $ " # 6 <#+ +"
"
$
6
#
. #
6 ++"
"%!2#&' .
"
# 7 .
#+
#
#
"
#
" + 6 $ #
6 .
. <
+ "
+
+" 6
; < %5'
"6 . "
#.
<"#"
. #
6 $
+
$ "
+ 6 #"
6
. .
. "$ 26
.
+$
"6 #
$ #
#+6
6
.
6
A
"
$ $"
#
"$ !.
6
6
6 .# #6
"
" "$ "6
%3'
"#
"
+ 6 #
6 ; "<%
; < ',, ,0&5
.
#
+$.$
6 = " ( 6 + "
7 +$
- 4 - ,1 ,0&3 %!2# 8' "6
6 $
6 #
6
7 #
. 6$
6+$
" 6$
. 7 .
. "
#$ +
" #
"
#+"
$$ +# +$
6
6
"
.
"
%-'
"# " $ "
6 &8 0- ,0&1%!2#8!'+$
.
"$ .
. +#"
.+#
#
" 6
" #"
#
#+6
"6# $ 6 .$ " +"
6 + 6 "
" 6$ %4'
#
..!!! #
#+"
+
6
$". 6$$.
.
"#+"
+ "
"
" .
2" 6"
# +"
#
.
"
#+6
."
66 34B" .
.#
C"
#
"
"&0 &0 ,0&4.
8& ,0&4 "6 ".
#&4
"@ "# %1'
7"#
- 5 - %B'
.6 "
"6 0,$#"
" .
# "
. #
. "
#$ .
# " %' 7 .
#
+ "+ $
"%!2#&'.
.
. 7 #
6 ,1 ,0&3 ,4 0, ,0&4 %&0'
(
. 6
; <
# " """.
6
"$ 05 ,0&5%!2# <&'
7
"$ .
.
+"
#
6 %!2#<8'
#
#
" "#"
$ 7 "
# $ " 6
6" "
#+"
? $.
"#
+
$ "
+# #""#$ #
"
.
"6
#
7 6 "
"66
$
@
+
$#
"$#
6
6
; < .
" 6$ + $ 6
6
" ++
$"
6$ . 2" +$.
#". $ !+
$ .
# .
"#
# .<"#
" #
$ " $ . "
#)#
"
- 6 - %&&'
=#
6
6# &, &, ,0&1 .
.
@ 6
. # +$
; "
#"
"
D"6 #
$ E !6
$
#
2 .
.$ /# $"#"
( 6# 6
$"
" "
" # 6 "#"
#
$ #
"@ " # .
#"
# 6
"
6
"$ %!2# <&' $ . "# .
. 6
$
# " .
.
6 . .
$. 6
"
#
%!2# <3' .
#
$6
.
. %&,'
7 $ "#6 #6# #%!2#1B'6
$
#+"
+# "
$#"
.
""
$ 7 " " %!2# 4' "66# "
"# #+
# . @ .
.
.$ .
6 6"
"
##
%&8'
""+"
!" #$%% # &'.
+ .
6
#"
#"
"
- 7 - +$.$# 6 #
#"
$"/#" 2 "
# <
!
" #$% #&%
!
'
!
($$
- 8 -
%&5'
" (%) * + ,-
' ." .
+ . +
" +$
6 *F
" 6 6&B-5 &B4,
. "# .
$
.
+
."
.
.
6
6 < =
=
( " +$
6 6 &B-5 &B4, . .
. 6
. ""
+""# 6 #6*#
#
#
$
"# + $ . +.+#
+"
F
# + 6
" +$
66&B-5 &B4,"# +"# .
6
.#+"" %&3'
! "6
$
.
* "
"
" 6
+
"
"
"#6 " ( #6 *# .
$"
#"
6$ .
.
+
$ " "
$ .
#"
#"
" "
"/#"#"
# $
$ "$+
# #
6# .
"# #
"# .<"#
/# $ #
( *# #
+ . #
6
)# 6
- 9 - #
"
/# +# "6 " .
"
#)#
" "# %&-'
* $
"
.6
#
6
"#
$
"
+$ "/#
6
< .
#
" /# $ #66 $ .
.
6
$
6"
$
@" +# "# "
#
6
"
66
)# 6 +# #
6#/# #+ " .#
"
"
"# "
"# +$
!2 *#
( @ # . # " "#
+" .<"#
" /# $
"
+
$ $ ## + )#
" "6+$
#6*#
%&4'
( "
#)#
"
#"6 +" C +
# " !
"&5+"#
. $6 "
+$
*#
"" /#
$.
#+)"
<6
" $#
$
6#
#
# # )#
" # +
.
6 "
A .
"
# "
!
"&5
"
#)#
"+$ "
!
"&5 !
"&5 .
$
"
#)#
" G
#
$. "
6.
+ #". "
#)#
. $ $
"
+# .
$ +# #
$+$6 "6
- 10 - !
" &, "
.
# $ "
6
" 2 " .
6 $ ;6 6$ + #
$ + +
.
+$
"
#6 *# .# " % ,- &
& %&1'
(
< "
$ # "#
@ "#6
.$ 6
$
6
"$.
#
C #"
"
"
6
#
+
+
$ "
" 6
! 6
""
# +
"
$ " #""#$ "
C"
.
."
; < %&B'
/
% / , 001-
11
#6 *# "
.
!"
# 6
# "
# )#
" 6# + +
.
*# < $)* +
+ +
#,, "- . #$/0$%$,""112%
+ + 3 +
- 11 - %,0'
#"6 +
"
#)#
" #6 " .
6$# "
"/#"$ #+
.
"
.
# + + #
$
( "
#)#
"+"6#6
#2
$2"# +$ "$ 6 "
!$
"
"
@"
.
.
>6
+"
" #
+ "
# )#
+$
6# $ ## + ( /# 6 # )#
" "#"
"
$.
#+
"# $ $ "
"6 #6
6# + %,&'
!
"#
" " $ % 2 0 ,&-
" 1
2
# 6 "
6# # #"
+"66
+$
6
+$ #
6"+"
66
"6
"
6" +. + # %,,'
*# 6 #
"
6
""
6
"#
+
$
#"
2"
.
$ "+
"
"" $ )"
@"
? +$
< #" $ " " + " +$ 6 #6 # <
- 12 - #+
"66
$# "# 6
6
" # #
.6 $
#
6
+
$ #
+
$ 6 6 &04B " .
H *
+ #+)"
"
#$ "6
"
" %,8'
=#
6
6
"
< $ $ "
$
6"$ ""# $ +
"+"
"#
"
$ .
$ $6 +"
" #
" 6 6 " #
"
#
7 6
"
# .
$ 6
+#"
#
6! ,0&3
6+ ,0&4 !
$
< . $
2
+"6# $
#"
$
""#
I# 6@+".#+
66#
6
%,5'
"
6 J
+"
= " #$
" +". +$
7 6 &8 0- ,0&1 %!2# 8!' .
+ 6
) + "
8& ,0&3 "6
#
6 # 2
"
.# +$
* "$ #"
"
"#6 "
$
+ ""#
"6
#
6
- 13 -
"
$+"6#$
++ " 6
; <
+$
"
< ""
6
$ +
$
%,3'
.
+ "#
.
.
&, &, ,0&1 %!2# 3' &4 &, ,0&1 %!2# -' &1 &, ,0&1 %!2# 4' 05 &, ,0&1 %!2# 4!' .
6
6 + +.
.+ "$ /#
." +$/# %,-'
(
6
; <.
"/#
+
KBL 6
6# . ( "/#
+
"# $ + J +#
.
&6
%,4'
"" $ %%& -.$"
/ #'"012
'"0
1. Whether speaking/reasoned?
:
Yes/No
2. Whether reportable?
:
Yes/No