High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24763/2023dismissed

S.N. Sidheshwar Sr. Sec. Public School v. The Appellate Authority Under Payment Of Gratuity Act And ORS.

2023-11-03Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger7 pages

"#$ '$()*)%+

,, -,, -)'.$*./"0 -0, -$(, 123)( -(.%%3

,,,,,, $#)#)%+$0

* 4$0*1* .$

55$33"#$

1#.%0)#6

"67$+# 0"#1)#6

(#8 %#.$0*

,,,,,, $*5%+'$+#* 9: ,

- - 0$*$+# 0, -17$$#

")+8

';%("#$ 5$#)#)%+$0,

, , - 8

, .$ )+*#"+# /0)# 5$#)#)%+ &)3$'

5$#)#)%+$0

-,, -)'.$*./"0 -0, -$(, 123)( -(.%%3

0#)(3$* %+*#)#1#)%+ +')"

*$$<)+= /0)# +"#10$ ($0#)%0"0) >1"*.)+= %0'$0

8 5"**$'

1#.%0)#6 "67$+# 0"#1)#6

(#8

@ /.$0$26 (3")7 "553)("#)%+ &)3$'

0(."+"

$/"0)8 *$$<)+= 5$#)#)%+$0-(.%%38 "33%/$',

$#)#)%+$0 *$$<* *$##)+= "*)'$ %0'$0

A, ,

8 5"**$'

55$33"#$

1#.%0)#6 "67$+# 0"#1)#6

(#8

.$0$)+8 /.$0$26 *#"#1#%06 "55$"3 &)3$'

-$(#)%+

"67$+# 0"#1)#6

(#8

.$0$)+"&#$0 0$&$00$'

(#98 ')*7)**$', , 0)$&368

0(."+"

$/"0) &)3$'

"553)("#)%+

(# 2$&%0$

1#.%0)#6 53$"

*.$ /"* $753%6$'

, , *.$ 0$#)0$'

, , .$0 3"*# '0"/+ /"=$* /$0$ *, B8 B,

$*5%+'$+#

(3")7$'

*.$ %&&$0$'

*, 8BB8 =0"#1)#68 /.)(.

/"* 3$** #."+ .$0 '1$ "7%1+#,

$*5%+'$+#

(3")7$'

*.$ /%0<$'

A 6$"0*8 7%+#.* '"6*

6$"0* "+'8 #.$0$&%0$8 *.$ $+#)#3$'

"7%1+#, .$ "&%0$*")'

(3")7

/"* (%+#$*#$'

53$"

*.$ /"* $753%6$'

#$"(.$0

, , #)33 , , ."'

5")'

"33 .$0 '1$* 5$0 50%;)*)%+*

(# +%#.)+= /"* '1$ 2$ 5")'

.$0, $#)#)%+$0-(.%%3 7")+#")+$'

"# #)7$ 0$#)0$7$+#8 "7%1+# *, 8BB8 /"* 5")'

=0"#1)#68 /.)(.

/"* '136 0$($);$'

.$0,

# /"* *#"#$'

)+&"(# "7%1+# *, 8

8 /"* 5"6"23$ $?($** *, BB8

/"* 5")'8 /.)(.

/"* 0$(%;$0"23$

((%0')+=368 50"6$0 ')*7)**"3 (3")7 /"* 7"'$,

, .$

1#.%0)#68 2"*)* 53$"')+=* 5"0#)$*8 &0"7$'

&%33%/)+= )**1$*

B, .$ 5"0#)$* 3$'

#.$)0 0$*5$(#);$ $;)'$+($ *155%0# #.$)0 (3")7*,

, .$

1#.%0)#68 ;)'$ %0'$0

8 "33%/$'

"553)("#)%+

.$3'

! " #

$ %&&%'() $ "

# * %''+'() * $ &&''() ,

* # * -

.) /

! #* 0 1 2 3 '4 5 1 4167 && 8167

9 # # :

9 6

5 0 "

" * ;

* < * "

4= #

6 86

''4 55 &+= 8/ *7 > "

3 444 ' ? * % * # * 4 * 4&''&=()

* %&&%'()

4++ =()

3 444 '

? * % *

4 * / * :"

&+% &() # *

4+'?%() " *

%&&%'() &?+%%()

! "

# $ "

# *

$ $

# $ * "

'@ , $ + '

% 4=4() /

* $

$ * $ # * * A * $

* &?+%%()

# * ?=='()

4= %() 8 ! 5 3 * 1$ !

! * 1 , > *7

* " * ' *

* '@

" 6 :

. 4'4' 6

# " * B ;

* < * "

)& <#

, $)+= ')**"#)*&)$'

"&%0$*")'

%0'$0

8 50$&$00$'

*#"#1#%06 "55$"3 -$(#)%+

(#8 .%/$;$08 *"7$ /"* ')*7)**$'

55$33"#$

1#.%0)#68 ;)'$ %0'$0 A, ,

, A, # 0$>1)0$'

2$ +%#)($'

.$0$ 5"0"

/0)# 5$#)#)%+8 )# *#"#$'

'$5%*)#$'

"7%1+# *, 88

,, 50%#$*#8 ;)'$ (.$>1$

,, 8 2$&%0$

1#.%0)#6,

, + "&%0$7$+#)%+$'

()0(17*#"+($*8 &)3$'

)+*#"+# /0)# 5$#)#)%+ 2$&%0$ #.)* %10#,

10)+= (%10*$ "0=17$+#*8 3$"0+$'

(%1+*$3 5$#)#)%+$0 -(.%%3 +%# ')*51#$'

&"(#

/%13'

2$ $+#)#3$'

#$07*

C1'=7$+# 0$+'$0$'

%+923$ -150$7$ %10# 1 C D

#7 0 B

' 8+7 16! 48 .%/$;$08 )# *127)##$'

"1#.%0)#)$* 2$3%/ .";$ /0%+=36 ("3(13"#$'

5$0)%'

50)%0

(# /"* 7"'$ "553)("23$ $'1("#)%+"3 )+*#)#1#)%+* $&&$(#

, )#*$3& "+'8 #.$0$&%0$8 5$0)%'

50)%0

, /"* +%# 2$ (%+*)'$0$',

:$"0+$'

(%1+*$3 *127)#* "1#.%0)#)$* 2$3%/ .";$ /0%+=36 =0"+#$'

)+#$0$*# '$3"6$'

=0"#1)#68 /.)(.

/"* +%# 5"6"23$

)#.

*")'

*127)**)%+*8 3$"0+$'

(%1+*$3 50"6$'

*$##)+= "*)'$ )751=+$'

%0'$0,

, .";$ .$"0'

3$"0+$'

(%1+*$3 .";$ "3*%

5$01*$'

5"5$02%%< .)* "23$ "**)*#"+($,

, +

/ 3 $ "

/ 3 E "8

- B 8 )# /"* .$3'

50%;)*)%+*

(# .";$ %;$00)')+= $&&$(# *"7$ "0$ "553)("23$ $753%6$$ #$07* 50%;)*)%+*

(# $?$75#)%+ 7"6 2$ =0"+#$'

%+36 "550%50)"#$ %;$0+7$+# -$(#)%+

(# 1+3$** )# $*#"23)*.$'

$753%6$$* "0$ 0$($)5# 5$+*)%+ 2$+$&)#*8 /.)(.

"0$ 7%0$ &";%10"23$ #."+ 2$+$&)#*

(#, ,

* &"0 "553)("2)3)#6 50%;)*)%+*

(# %0 7"##$0 (3")7

(%+($0+$'8 *")'

)**1$ "30$"'6 *#"+'* '$()'$'

%+923$ -150$7$ %10# ("*$ 1 C D

*150" /.$0$)+ )# /"* "3*% .$3'

$+#)0$ 3$+=#.

*$0;)($ )+(31')+= *$0;)($ 5$0)%'

50)%0

, 2$ (%1+#$'

5105%*$ (%751#)+= $+#)#3$7$+# $753%6$$ '$#$07)+)+= "7%1+# =0"#1)#6,

10#.$07%0$8 )**1$ 0$="0')+= $+#)#3$7$+# )+#$0$*# '$3"6$'

"7%1+# "3*% +% 7%0$ 0$* )+#$=0"

*"7$ '$()'$'

%+923$ -150$7$ %10# ("*$ - < < 0 "# 6 5 ''

87 16! 4 = , D$$5)+= ;)$/ "&%0$*")'

3$="3 5%*)#)%+8 %+($

$+#)#3$'

#$07*

510*1"+($ "7$+'7$+# ("00)$'

%1#

, (%+*)'$0)+= C1')()"3 )+#$0')(# $+#)0$ 3$+=#.

*$0;)($ 2$ (%1+#$'

'$#$07)+)+= $+#)#3$7$+# ),$, $;$+ *$0;)($

0$+'$0$'

50)%0

,8 '% +%# &)+'

"+6 )33$="3)#6 %0 5$0;$0*)#6 0$3)$& =0"+#$'

1#.%0)#6

.$0$)+

.$0$)+,

10#.$07%0$8 ("*$ - < <

*150"8 %+923$ -150$7$ %10# (3$"036 .$3'

$+#)#3$7$+# $753%6$$ )+#$0$*# '$3"6$'

%2*$0;"#)%+ #.$0$ +% *(%5$ "+6 )+#$0&$0$+($ )+#$0$*# (%75%+$+#, .$0$&%0$8 )# .$3'

1#.%0)#6 0)=.#36 =0"+#$'

*#"#1#%06 )+#$0$*# '$3"6$'

B, %+*)'$0)+= #%#"3)#6 ()0(17*#"+($*8 #.$0$ +% *(%5$ "+6 )+#$0&$0$+($ )751=+$'

%0'$0*

A, ,

8 5"**$'

"1#.%0)#)$* 2$3%/,

$*13#"+#368 )+*#"+# /0)# 5$#)#)%+ &")3* *"7$ "((%0')+=36 ')*7)**$', ,

5$+')+= "553)("#)%+ *8 )& "+68 *."33 *#"+'

(3%*$',

*C<* .$#.$0 *5$"<)+=0$"*%+$'

!$*

% .$#.$0 0$5%0#"23$ !$*