← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaARB/527/2025dismissed

Rayat Educational And Research Trust Regd v. Punjab Skill Development Mission

2026-03-11Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri15 pages

              



 ! "#$%$ &' ()(*    +  , , ( (((--.$# &

% /,,  ,0++ /+  ,, (((%- &"&

%  '

1+ ( , , ,  

   

       



     

, , 2 (





!  "



!

#  $$% &   

' () *

+

 ! 

,"  "

 - 



 !- 

.

/  "

 * 



 "!+

+ "+ 0 * & 10)  .3.3 &4" 2) - 4" !- 

 

 "

# " 5 - 



"

*   -

10 - 

 

+ !6

  7+- #++ 

089  6 :" 

+ 8+ ; -  

  

!* 

 

" 

  "!+

*

 # "  <!

 ! / -=

* 

 "  

"

 !- 

 



 " !6 "*

  > .3.?

&4" 3) * +

!  !"   -  + 

 



!  *

+

 ! 

1  



    "   "!+



   ! +  *"

 + "+ 0 * & 10)    

6

 "

@  *

 # "

"!+

+ 

* # "  <!

 ! / -= -"  +

 -

6 +* +     + 

 

"

 !-  ! " 



 # "

6 "

* !-    -

10 - 

 

+ !6   7+- #++ 

089  6 :" 

+ 8+ ;

# "      

! 

A "  "!+



+  * B  



     





    !  "

# $   %#  &

!$%&"

   '()(

 "*

  

 6

!" # "  C" - +  



 - + 

 ) *"

 "*

* # " - <!

 ! / -= !" " -  7+- #++

 #"  



6 ! 

 

  C"

6  !6

 ,"*+  !6  #"

  ! +

?

/  "

 * 



 -  *

*"+  !6   "   "!+

 ,"*+  3?

.

.3.>  *"

! +   ! " 

  "      

* - 

 " -" * 

 "

"!  



*"+ "!+

 "*

# " 

"   7+- #++ !"

* # "  <!

 ! / -=



 

 "

 $ 

*    4"  !    

 "* #

*

* !  B 2?$ .3.?

 *

B

   -  6   !6



 - # " <!

 ! / -= "  C"

," 

  

 

 +

  - + 



! 

"!+

-   

6  "

 $   4" 2  -

+ !6 

 4

 "  6  + 6 "!+ !"

  6  +

 *

B 

 

+ 4

 3

 "   - + 

 



 " 4

"  "!+

* "  - !6 

! +   !6 

 4

 "   + 

 !, !  #"

>

;  *    "

 * 



  

 D&?)&)  - 



*+  +  -*      

4

*  +  +

  - 

4

*+ 

* !6  6

  !6  

"!+

  - 6 

  *"

! +



 - 

-  !6   "   ! "    "  -

 "

!

+  6   "

 $ 

 "!+

!6 *

 6  - 



+

 " 

-   *  "

!,

%

;



   "  

 * "  # "  !

 - 





!  *

B   !6

 "

 $ 

 * 6  !6   "

 $ 

 C" " !-

  *+( ,



,  %-  

     



 

 

 





                   

   

  

  !"#     

  

$   !   %  



 

     

& '

     ! 

%      %   ( %       )          

  

$  

*

       

 +  %  )  

*

 

,

,-  

      

      

  

    ,

. /

0 . 

/()0  



 

 

  2

12      3'

               

          



    

   



      

  

       /   -

    

  

/

     )    

   

  

  



  4

       ,

 "

)  ,  5' 6        '

 )

  

  



      

    

    78(&8&9        

  

    78(&8&9 

  :

 &     '

   

' ;;<

 = 

 

3  .10  #

        ,  

 



 

  2 .   , 16   

      

     

.>

   





 .> 

'    

  

 

'

  

?        

 

  

       1 



 



 

  

  



                      

   

 *

  

  !"#     

  

$   !   %  



 

     

0% 

   4



  

 ,

&

 '

 @ 

'  ;;<    

 !"#

 $    !   % +  A  

   

. 





   

0 ===3===3===3===

 ===3===3===3=== 126  

 4 +2 

 

  = 

  





 

     ,B4  

 

       

 

 0

" 

 # "

-" -

 "*

* # "   

<!

 ! / -= !" "!  # " 

6 "

*   -

10 - 

 

+ !6

  7+- #++ 

089  6 :" 

+ 8+ ;

  # "     "

 + 

 -

6



+ 

* # "   <!

 ! / -= -"  +

+ * + *

 "

 #" 

 ,"*+  

     





   5  !

"

"  "   



 ,"*+

- # " -    "

 

 ,"*+  !6  #"  3?

.

.3.>  "

"

  17  A      

  

   + 

    

 



/

   C3 *+( ,



,  %- 

     



 



 

 





B                   

   

 

 ' ) - ,-   

$   !   %  



 

     

0 <  '       

         

      +

1,



,  %-67  

 



   

   - 

 

  

 

         

  

 



%





     

 

       

 

 

 ' ) - ,-   

 $      !     %     

 

      

%

               

     

1,



,  %-67  



   

=



 



  

  

 2.>, 

8(8( & #( 8(/( & !)11+"

 09         

  =

  

   

   

    

  )

    C3 2' 

  

        

     

  C 56

   

  



 

     

    5&6 )



 

   



 







  





    





      -

  

 

D

 4 5(6    

   





 

     

 > 596 

    



 

  

 )   



   / 





   

 576     





     

    

   

 

      

D 5<6    

   

    - 

 

  

   

  

  

  

 0   

 .>  ,   

 :  

 #(  

 ;

4(6 !0"

  0)1   

  



 

 

  



   



 

   

 



  

   ""    "+   E5;;6 (, 72(F  A

A  A   4, %

 ?

 E5;;;6  &  ,  <<F    A  ,

       A 

5%6546?

 E5&88(62,9F%,

 B

 

E5;;<6&,&<F



   

 

 

  1

  0

     

 



  

 

 =

    

 

   G 

) 

   3

  

         



 

   6

 

  

       



          %          

 





    



  



   )

    

 

 

   

 

   G  





   

       

  

 



 5

 

      

  

G  

    

     

    

   



 



 

 

 

     

  

6   

     1

0   1'



 5

60   

   



  

 

 



    ) 

  

          

   

  



 

  

     

   

   

  



  

    C5 6     

56

      

 5 

6           

     

   56    

 

           )       

   



           



    





  

56

    

 

     

    



6G         





  

 

    

   

 

  

   G    

  

    



=

   







 

   

  

    -

 

  A      

 





 

    

 =  

   

   



   

 

  

   

   * =      /

 

  

        

  



   /

   

      

  

    

   

  

      













  

 

   

 

 

-     

         

   6 A              1

0  

0               - 

 

   

/

  



  



 *  =            1

 

 







0    1           

   

               

0 1

 



  

      



  

0         

   

  



      

   

   ,     

1



  

   

 

0 1 

   

 

           

 

0

  

    ,       

    



   

    



   =  

      



  

 

, 

/

 



  

    

   



'          /



 

 

    

   

 

    

               

    0 ;  *

   .>  ,   

 &   % (

 ( #( &<

=% & : = 6 !"

  9       



 *   >

<, 67 





  

 

   



     

 =

   

  

 

          C3

  7,

 

 :'

C 7%

  

  

   

  

   

  

=

  .  

  

 -         

     

   

       

 

    

  

 - /



     3 

 



 : 

(85

6  

        

 :  

      

 :  

 

    7&% 





 

 



 

      



  !  

 



*  !   % 

 %  

          



 

     



 0 .>, 

      1'

0  

   

    

   

  



 

        

       

   ,

2 '@' 8.>, 

   )  &<   $   % ( =( &<



$ 

    #

 .#( % ( !%.

!# "

/4()1'0'"

 8<&8&7 

   

 )

     







    

  

    

         

 

   /   

 



 



 '    3

)



.>  ,   

    )      A



 &<  ? .#( % ( !

"

 -

          / 

   

   



    1

0      



      

 

        

    

 

  

      

   

 



 ' 

  

                   

 *,



,  %-67



  

       

   

   

   ' ) -  ,-     



        

    

  

    

  &'



   

      .>, 

  

    

 

     

   

    

   

         

   

  

 

    

    

 

  

  

    

      

     

 

     *,



,  %-7



 



 

         

        



( / 

 

     

 

0 $

 # "     -"  6  !6

 ,"*+  !6  #"  # "  +  "

A-   "

 * 









  

 *"

! +

   *"

 

 "

 $  !    

 "* #

* - 

-  !6   4" 2  - 

 " -

+

 !6 " 

!6 "

 D&?)&) 

 # "

 +

 "



*"+  !6   "

 )

 * 



  C"   !

  *"

* " 

   !6

 "

 $ 

"  *

B   "

 $  !6

 -" -



!    !6



"  C"

," 

  

 

 +

!  - 

"  + 6 "!+ B

"

! -" -

  !6  *

 "*

 

 !

 ! / -

 # " + "+ 0 * * !-  !"

 # " 5 "   7+- #++

;  - 6 



+

 # " - 

 "

  -     + 6 "!+ 6

"

 4

 - "   

"   7+- #++

;   - 

    6

+    !  !"   

+    7+- #++ 

089  6 :" 

+ 8+ ;

;   

 6 

  

 "

 .

  * 7+- #++ 

089  6 :" 

+ 8+ ;

A

 

 

  *

 #++



6 ! 

+   -  

 3 

 *

B 

"

!  *

   4

 

# "

;  - 6 

+ 4 # " !" 

+

  -  + 

; 6 - 

-  !6  "

 $ 

+   6 4 # " !"    "

+

  -  + 

#C"6 C" +  -   # " 

 "  

 # "

 6 !  !6  #" 

 ,"*+  

     





   5  !

"

 !

  -  - !6 A(!

"+ #"

  



+





*  + 

.



*"+ - 

-  !6   " 

 -

* 

 !6

 D&?)&)    + -

  "  !  - 

 * "

 $    6

 # " - 

!

+

    + 

1 # "      +  

  + 

* # "  <!

 ! / -= -"  +

 -    + 

 

; -

 

"+  

   ! +

+ 

*6 +

, ,  ()(*

 6

& 6 @    *E  9EB @    ! 9EB