Bharat Bhushan And Another v. State Of Punjab And Others
! "#
$% !"#$%&'" #"%
( #
&
'(' )*%+, ! ( '(- -.*(((* "#( '(' -/#"*%+, ! $% (01( #"%
( ##)* $ #
!
% % 340 ( $5 )!6 )! (140% %3(4(0708% 103* 101*97:*834*83; < 10: =%% %. > %
.
* 5.* ,..)= .. # 6 $,
) ) !/ !,/$/ % %0(80(0700(
6 =) %#5,/$. $% (0 % + ) ,// % ( = + * =
+ ! $ ,#.
*!
..5
+ % % .+
% *= , $$ !/ ,/$/ ( / +?
) $= ! #5$5 ),
)=.%# !
@ , %# !$, ! %* 6 %.. # 6 $,
) ) !//5# 6
!"
+ % % %4(80(0700%
$$ # ! ..6 ') A . ! ,% )
*, % %# ! % ..6') A .
=.% % % $( $, / *.
%'*. $ % %00(0(0701 (B $ . @
. " ! ,/$. A $% (0 % 1 / .5 - )% ? ) ,% %81(80(0700( !
,, %A$ % + % -/ ,% % 83(;(0700.)= ! = ) ,% %8:(0(0701 + .#
@ %= $( * %'*.,,.% $ $$
$
+ ,/$/ +. .5% ,, $ %$ A,, %+ #
,. ,. % !!
% , + %.
%, .!
*$ ,% % $ #5.
%'*.( # .!5$+ 340( ((=.% = )/5/?
,% */5# 5 + !!
,5% % % $ + # ! !5 = , %!" ( 107(
6..5 +!, *= ,$ , # % ! ,/$% )! !!
% %
.% -
$ ) +
= !!!
..
%.5,// % !,#
+ / ,#.5
%
, !, .$ , =.%# ! @ , ( C#.
$ /# !, ,.% )
B.S.Joshi and others +State of Haryana +,)
-%./)0.)
!..= %#5 .. ,, !1.*2+)%3,+ ,)4%5.67+,)8
+ % . = $$ +.+ $ % .=( ! *C#.
$ Gian Singh 9State of Punjab and another
%./)0.)
! % . = % .
.= %#5 $ !6 ) ! State of Haryana 9Bhajan Lal8 ::%.// %
(
:8! "%)/ %% &
!
"
#
$
%&'
(
"
)*+ , #
- +
,
(
!("
( - "
-
(
(
.- -
(-
(
/
(
$
($
(-
- (
. 0
1
(
.
(- *
(
2 ( 3
(
-
(
- -
-
-
.
(
(-
(
(
( -
(
-
-
(
.
# "
#
(
-
(
#
#
-
+ ,
-
#
4 $$.5 ) .= %#5C#.
$ $.
!"%)/ % )* $$ =
+
,/$/ ,
)=.%#
.5# !$, ! %#5..= )%,, $ )
$5 ! #56 ) =.%# , ) %!
" * = , $ / .5 #"
,! .
. , )%
340( .)$ !!
% 10:
5 )% $ + %$
% 5+
% ,,, $ " , $ !
# %*$ , %/5# =
( .* !
% , %6 .5!.. = /# %$/ %#5"% .$ % *
(140% %3(4(0708% 103*101*97:*834*83; < 10: =%% %. > % .
* 5 .* , . % .. # 6 $,
) ) !/ 6 %6 ,/$/
%.
5 $
.. / #% #5 / % ,% ! ,/$/ %
,% %# ! , # .=(
%..= %( #"%
( # #$;"
.,?5 B $ ?
)A %& A B
$#.
& A