High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/27739/2024disposed of

Union Of India And Others v. No 14491128a Ex Nk Sukhbinder Singh And Another

2024-11-29Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma8 pages

!"#$%&$$&

!"!'"( !"#&$$& ) * *

! +# ,-+ & **

* .

,-+ *& ** * + "#$%&'() *"+,-+,,.$&,."(/&01.2% 3"2,%4%2-2-5%"+ *""+,-2!%6/&01.2%.5& *"7.(,%".5/&01.2%3""%+45&%52 *

* .

,"$#,2,%-5+2.529"-24%2-2-5/2,%4%2-2-5%"+,%"%-5 5-535&-./4".(+3"2,%+%22-5#.+-&%32,%"&%"&.2%&

:55%;$"% </ .+ 4.++%& '( 2,% 6%."5%& "=%& "1%+ "-'$5.6 151%"5%&/9,%"%'(+2,%16.-=3"%+45&%52 3"2,%#".523 +%"0-1%%6%=%5232,%&-+.'-6-2(4%5+-53"2,%+%"0-1%"%5&%"%&'( ,-=-5%3%51%%1$"-2("4+:<,.+'%%5.669%&/'(15&5-5# 2,%+,"23.663

&.(+3"=2,%"%>$-+-2% ?(%."+3>$.6-3(-5# +%"0-1%3"%."5-5#+%"0-1%4%5+-5-52,%

0(1'020(34 !'"

%+45&%52 9.+%5"66%&-52,%5&-.5"=(5

.5&9.+&-+1,."#%&2,%"%3"=5 @-52,%".5A3 .-A%+45&%52 9.+#".52%&"%2-"-5#4%5+-5/.+.&=-++-'6%2 ,-=.+4%"2,%%5+-5%#$6.2-5+,%"%.32%"/"%+45&%52 9.+ "%%5"66%&-52%3%51%%1$"-2("4+:+%"0-1%<5

11"&-5# 2 2,% 4"%0.6%52 46-1(/ $45 .22.-5-5# 2,% .#% 3 +$4%".55$.2-5/"%+45&%52 9.+&-+1,."#%&3"=+%"0-1%-52,% 5 .32%""%5&%"-5#.+%"0-1%3

(%."+.5&?

&.(+/ 9,-1,9.++,"2'(

&.(+/+.+2=.A%2,%+6&-%"%5.'6%&2 1=46%2%2,%>$.6-3(-5#2%"=3 ?(%."+/3"2,%4$"4+%3#".523 +%"0-1%4%5+-5/2,$+3"2,%+%15&+%"0-1%"%5&%"%&'(,-=-52,% %+45&%52 9.+ &%5-%& +%"0-1% 4%5+-5 '( 2,% 1=4%2%52.$2,"-2(3",-+521=46%2-5#2,%"%>$-+-2%>$.6-3(-5# 4%"-&3"%."5-5#+%"0-1%4%5+-5-52,%

%%6-5#.##"-%0%&/"%+45&%52 3-6%&/'%3"%2,% 6%."5%& "=%& "1%+ "-'$5.6 151%"5%&/ 9,%"%'(+ ,% 1.+2 . 1,.66%5#%22,%.3"%+.-&"%7%12-5"&%",%+.-&/'%1.=% .669%&0-&%"&%"&.2%&

,%4%".2-0%4."232,%+.-& "&%"-+%;2".12%&,%"%-5.32%") ;;;; ;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;

? %%6-5#.##"-%0%&3"=2,%.3"%+.-&"&%".+4.++%&$45 2,%:+$4".</'(2,%6%."5%&"=%&"1%+"-'$5.6151%"5%&/2,% 4%2-2-5%"5-535&-.,.+3-6%&2,%"%.#.-5+22,%-5+2.529"-24%2-2-5 '%3"%2,-+$"2

*'567

7!"

!819 2 "

(!'"

28!

19 :

1717!"

& @ ,%6%."5%&1$5+%63"2,%4%2-2-5%"++$'=-2+/2,.22,% 6%."5%&"-'$5.6,.+3.-6%&215+-&%"2,.2-52%"=+3%#$6.2-5 ?32,%%5+-5%#$6.2-5+3"2,%"=(/ @ .5&%#$6.2-5

32,%%5+-5%#$6.2-5+3"2,%"=(/ /2,$+56(2,% =4%2%52$2,"-2(9.+%=49%"%&215&5%2,%&%3-1-%51(-52,% "%5&-2-53>$.6-3(-5#+%"0-1%/2,$+'(2,%+6&-%"3",-+'%1=-5# %52-26%&2+%%A2,%%5&9=%5234%5+-52,-=,%+.-&%#$6.2-5+ ."%%;2".12%&,%"%-5.32%" :!B*C/ @ < "#$ %& '( '

(

) "*+ '( "$

& !

:!B*C/ < ++ , - "#

& ./ '( 0 '( "$ '(

) !

1 *"%0%"/2,%*-5-+2"(3%3%51%0-&%6-1(6%22%"

: <D

DD:%5D6< &.2%& @ / -5+%"2%&16.$+%:-0< -5 2,%

%#$6.2-5

32,%%5+-5%#$6.2-53"2,%"=(/ ,% "%6%0.524."29,%"%3/-+%;2".12%&,%"%-5.32%"

4%"$+.632,%.3"%.=%5&=%529$6&=.A%-216%."2,.2 "%6-%3 >$. 15&5.2-5 3 &%3-1-%51( -5 "%5&-2-5 3 2,% .44+-2% >$.6-3(-5#+%"0-1%/-+2'%.11"&%&5=%"-2/+.+2%5+$"%2,.2.5 ."=(4%"+55%6-+%6-#-'6%3".26%.+25%+%"0-1%4%5+-5! "

,%6%."5%&1$5+%63"2,%4%2-2-5%"+3$"2,%"+$'=-2+/2,.2 2,%7$&#=%5232,%6%."5%&"=%&"1%+"-'$5.6/"-51-4.6 %51,/ %9%6,-/"%5&%"%&-51.+%2-26%&.+ # $ %&

9.+521""%12".2,%"9.+152"."(26.9.5&3.12+/ 2,%"%3"%/5"%6-.51%$#,22,.0%'%%546.1%&52,%+.-&7$&#=%52 ,%"%6%0.524.".#".4,+/.+11$"-52,%0%"&-12:+$4".<."%%;2".12%& ,%"%-5.32%" #,

3 #+4+#4"

. '( 5

678 ) 9 :6 "+4#44" ;++ ; ) 9:6

#44*#4"1<

( 7

( 8

< ( 6= 3 6 > ? @?A*4#4"B41""#4"B

2, < ( 8 2,

9 ':6( < &&&& &&&& + C 3

. '( D A '(

(

6 7 8 "+

8 8

E F

78 )

6 7 8

E F

E 86 ; = GE : 7 : )

3 6 : , '( !

‟ ( )

! " *

'(8

( '( ,

@ #'#(2, #441,

"+4#44" ; "#7 7 ;'( + "

,-. -/ " 0

/1-/ -/2 '( ; '(

8 8 , 3 6 F

' (D A'( ;+1 "8

!8197 !'

-51%2,%%;4+2$6.2-5+=.&%-54.".#".4, 32,% 7$&#=%52"%5&%"%&'(2,%5E'6%4%;$"2-51.+%2-26%&.+ "7!"!8 " 700" "!19

) &*'

*7"49 /"%4"2%&-5 -/32 ,-,/ 4.".#".4, 9,%"%3 '%1=%+ %;2".12%& ,%"%-5.32%"/0%"1=%+2,%&-+.'6-5#%33%12+/-3.5(/3+$4".%;1%42-5 :-0</.+'%1.=%-5+%"2%&0-&%46-1(D6%22%"&.2%& @ /2,$+/ -52%5&%&29"A.+.5'+2.16%".2,%".#.-5+22,%+6&-%"16.-=-5#"%6-%3 315&5.2-5-52,%"%>$-+-2%+,"23.663+%"0-1% "#

& "# &

= E 8,

, E

#+H "I$ "+ #44" & ,,

,%"%3"%/2,%7$&-1-.60%"&-12:+$4".</&%+"%5&%"5%#.2%& 2,%+$4".."#$=%52".-+%&'(2,%1$5+%63"2,%4%2-2-5%"+/2,.22,% %=49%"=%52215&5%2,%"%>$-+-2%+,"23.66/'%1=%++6-2."-6( 0%+2%&-52,%=4%2%52$2,"-2(/%+4%1-.66(9,%52,%,%"%-5.'0% $5&%"6-5%&4.".#".4,+/.+11$"-52,%0%"&-12=.&%-5*'

*7"49

, (0

/.66$&%&2-52,%0%"&-12=.&%-5,.=. .$"E+1.+%/& -50%+27$"-+&-12-5-52,%"-2$"2/22,"$#,7$&-1-.6-52%"0%52-5/ 2,$+=.A%2,%%+4$+%&15&5.2-5

5+%>$%526(/2,%1$=$6.2-0%%33%1232,%.$2,"-2.2-0% 7$&-1-.64"5$51%=%52.+1.""-%&-52,%.'0%%;2".12%&4.".#".4,/ =.&% -5 )

" 2,$+ 1=46%2%6( 1$52%"0.-6+'2,2,%+$4".."#$=%52+".-+%&'%3"%2,-+$"2/'(2,% 1$5+%63"2,%4%2-2-5%"+/2,$+3"&%5(-5#22,%"%+45&%52/2,% '%5%3-232,%+%"0-1%4%5+-53",-++%"0-5#-52,%/=%"%6(52,% #"$5&2,.2,%,.+521=46%2%&2,%>$.6-3(-5#4%"-&3+%"0-1%/ '%+-&%+52,%3$"2,%"36-=+(#"$5&/2,.256(2,%1=4%2%52.$2,"-2( -+.$2,"-F%&215&5%2,%+.-&+,"23.66

5%2,%6%++/ -5 2%"=+ 3 2,% &%16.".2-5 =.&% -5 2,% ,%"%-5.'0% $5&%"6-5%& 4."./ .+ 1.""-%& -5 2,% 0%"&-12 :+$4".</ 2,% 16.-=+3&$.63.=-6(4%5+-5-5.&&-2-522,%3-"+23.=-6(4%5+-5/-3

"%>$-"%&/9$6&'%"%+2"-12%&3"= /.+%50-+.#%&'(2,% *-5-+2"(3%3%51%B%22%"&.2%&

7"02

!8197 !'

5.32%"=.2,/2,-+$"23-5&+5=%"-2-52,%9"-24%2-2-5 .5&9-2,'+%"0.2-5+.'0%/2,%+.=%-+&-+=-++%&

? ,%-=4$#5%&"&%"/.+4.++%&'(2,%6%."5%&"-'$5.6 151%"5%&/-+=.-52.-5%&.5&.33-"=%&

@ -+4+%&3.65#9-2,.664%5&-5#.446-1.2-5:+</-3.5( ;*

* .

< ;* * +< &$$& 57.6 9

037"4=