High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR(F)/1717/2023dismissed

Ruchi Sharma And Others v. Harsh Bhardwaj

2024-04-08Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra11 pages

!" # " $

% &'$($(')%*+&

,- -. / -0

0 100 0-!-/23

/ 5555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555

% &'$$')%*+& 0-!-/23

100

,- -. / -0

/ 0 " 6/,

7 +' 8!9+

+ !

!"#$%&' *

")!*,-$%&' * +

........

+ ! : /(* -- & (!! &* ) 0' -

& # '* * (&*-) 1 (* * ( -

2 (0'-

&'* * ('!*&(!! 1

(&& $) &03 (* *)!4 &1$-*!3 $ *&0&

* -*

) 0* /56 5$ !&

#(03#(*!& 3* (*

8 #*$ (-* (*!& )

('0 && 01

8$5)-

(( 23#3 (* $ ) #** )3* 11

( !

(-* (*!& )3* 1 ( -

& 9( $ 03 #3 ( & ) $ ) ( 0 &* )3* 1

1 *& (*-) 1 &&$#(03

(-* (*!& ('0 1

03 (-*!3

( :

3 &( $(* * (!!0& ) (**1* ! - ! 1*' -*

) 0 (-*!3

2* ( !'

() ) &* ) ! )

#*! 1#* ((-* (*!& ( *!& (-

&-*

) &7 8

(1 (3('0 (# (- *- *!(-03 )

$#( (&0 -* 0('* 1#* (( & 0; 1 ( !

&- & &#3 < # ! !!1& )

# #:* 1#* () &-) 3* "=/( !1* '

> &# &#* 11 !3 > ))?*- !3) -

( *-*!* 1 $#( ) &( -* (*!& # 0!

(- !' %&* 1!3$03#3 *!* ( *&-*

) $ (3(')3&1

% ))!* 1

(&! 0

*!& & '*& *-) 1 & & & & $ ( )

&* )3 - 8$5)-

(( (* #-* (*!& & *

- (& *!* 1 ())!* *!! (& * !&* ) ! *!! & #( (3# !&

-;* @#'$ ( *&))!*

# &* -* & A ) #* !&3 -

& !* &* * *&$0 * ('*!& ( '* *

> & ! ( '(-

!31 &

(*-) 1 &&* !*0! 0 *& (?

$ #(*($ -*!3 (&&!* ()3-&03) 1

&* (!*0! 0-&**& (?

$ #(*($ (-

8$5)-

(# &* 0)*& (-* ) & (* -

& ' 0 & @( 1 & ) & &$ 1 ! ?) (* &$ ! (* 1$ -&** $ & $(* 1! ;* 1 3 ) -)!*-

(* 0 *& A *& 01 !!3* & )#*

(* *!

$#(# 1 !3 >:( )-

( *-*!* 1

< * $ ($1 & 03! & ! (-

&* 0)*& && ' 0 & - 6$5)-

((-* *- - (*))& #!! - 1#* (*&3 &3A *-

< * ( 0-*

&03! & !

(&) &03 (-*!3 &!* ()3-

) * &$ ( - * !!

0!* (3 !# ( 1('3*!3 (

&-*

(* 1 -

8$503#:* 1* @!

2 &&3 &( 0 (* 1

!* - $85)-

$# &03( 2 1! $ && 1 8$5 -

(!3-*

( ! 0 (-

&03(

0 0 **

(# -*

$#( !:0

- 1 #* ( ( ?) #(*! :* 1 ( -* (*!& * /($* * 1 & (*-) 1 &&* !*0! 0 *& ?

& (& ' 0)*&*

03 ( )

< (* 1&$ ! & ! ) ( )!&!* )

!"#$%#%

$"!&'

!)#)$%#%

$"*!'

!.#*$%#%

$/!0

+ 1

!!#)$%#%

$ !

$! & !

( 1 &

(*-) 1 &&* !*0! 0 *& (?

#(*($(( 0 &* )3*

8$5)-

(( ) & ( * - #:* 1 #* ( ( "= /( !1* '

> &# -)!!& *1 - (* '* :)* 1* '*# ( (( 0 ( &03) 03 &11* 1(*-*

'!!* *1 &( 0 0! )3

(* ;0 < * 0-*

(* -)!3& &* &)

) (* )

&$ ($* ) * )3 3-*

-* ) &

9* (1&

* &03) (

!& *'-*

-(*-$* ( 0 !31 & 03(* ! * (*1(!3A !**&) $0* 1

2% 7(# #)

2 1! &* ! (!&* 1(*1( ) * (-) 3 03( ($-#( (* (* -

(!3* - >:( )-

7(* ! (* 1

- B$5)-

(- ()

# &03( &*

!!* *!!3&)

) 30&3 (* * ( ! !3$#( * 0!*1&

&$#(!*'* 1#* (( *

* -)!3& # 9* ( 0& 0-* * $* 1& *!&03 !*0! 0&* -* &$ #( *!&03

& ' 0!!#& (*

* (* *!!3)0!-*

(-* ) * !*0!

)3 3-*

<('(&! & ! * *&0! ! ( &('! 1 ( 1( (- *!)!& & !!3

/(* &* ) 0 ( #* &-* (*!& ) *'!3

&!*'* 1 ) !3 -(*- /() * ('!'!!&!!1 5

!!1 1*

( ( /( 1( ( 3 &!1! (!!1 !'!!& 03 * 0& -* & !3 (0 * ( 1( -

('*& $#(*(* 3 0!&03 * 0 (* ) 3 ;

$ ( #(*( 0 *& )

#!!& &)

%&-*

&!3$ *-*!* 1 ) &7 8 03 $

# &#* 1 !30 >:( )-

(03#:* 1* ) & -) @* !*-* (( 0 -)!!&03)

*1 - () </ 1 8 B &' * $( (*- !* &)

) (* )

@( !*-&

* (!&* 1(*1() (-) 3( ( &* 11& -$) - 1

!* -- ()

$# &03( 2 1!

/(#!!

!&)) * !#* (( 0 &* & 0!*1

(* #* &(*!& * ) *' (

#( ((( )) 3 )) 3 * * *&& *-)

3 & !- 0!*1 (( 0

(* #* &(*!&

3 (* 0!

(-& * *!

$ (* )0! /()'* * 7 8 * - *!!1* ! &* 0

&!*0!!3

(#! (0 * (#* &(*!&

@ C0!7 )-

(* *') -

* & , 23 !

#$%%*)( !*&&# '* 1 *&!* & -* (A

- -*

03 0 '* 1 ( 0; *' 1

1 *

*- 5 )-

!*- 3* (&) &

) * & &

'1 3

(*! (-*1$ ) * (-

( ( ) /( #(*(# !&#*1(#*

!* * + 0! & (#* &) &

(*!& +#( ( ())!*

* & & &) * !!3 A !**&+#( ( ())!*

( 3* &)

* -+ #( ( (* -* **

0!(

( - && !*'* 1 (# -& * (- *- *!(-+#( ( ))!*

# -)!3&)* (-*1+#( ( (# #:* & * ( 0 * (-*1+#( ( (#*# A *&

** ( -)!3-

))

* * 1 ( -*!3$ (*!& * 1$ &!:* 1 & !

--0 (-*!3+ 0! !* *1 #:* 1#* < ( ! 0 #!!

!& * *!)* 3 (( 0 &$(* !* -$ 0!?) (* # -*

$ &&) &

-*!3--0 #(-(* 0!*1&

& (!#$!*0*!* * * 3$# !&0A *& 0 :

*& $ *' ()))* A

--*

0 )*& /( - ('& 1& &&!*'* 1 ( 0 &$ #!! ( )*!!* 1* ! &(*1( !*'* /( )! (( 0 (& ) 3 * - & 0 !'(*-(* -!& 3

(* #**(* 0! 0&*& &( & !A !**

!* ! 0)!& )

- 5

# !/$!0%%"

$#(* @ C0! 7 )- (&0 '&

/(-*

#&&- 0 0! & !* *$ & '*& * ( ( # ?

- *

#&& (#* ( !& * (0 ?

#(*( 0- )) *' 00!

$ ( !&* 0 -1 &*' (#* 3 /( ** 3 (A

0&; &1& (#* ((*!&0!

(- !' #* ( 0!-

< (*

* 0!0&*&3 1-

/( 1($(( )!& & &&* !*&'* (# ((& *1 &- () </ 1- (-) 3$#(* (# #:* 1 8 B &* (*- !&)

) (* )

0 ( * ) -& 0)0! 1 **

- 3

(* #* &(*!& &* -3 *&&)* $(

3 (*

) * * &)

) (* # )

0 &

(* 0!

(* -*!3 &&* (1(* !1!0!*1

( 03 & (*

% ( - *-$ * -3 ! 0

(0!*1

$0* 1( 0 &5 ( )3

(* #*5(*!& & (*1()& ! (#*

* (* 1& 0-& 6

AIR 2015 Supreme Court 2025, #(* *-*!0 ' # -& /(

* &03! & !

#* 1& (* !*0*!* 3 )3-*

(# -)!3& *-) * 1 (*-) 1 &&$ #( # )'& 0 11&-

- 3$ ($ (-*!3 # A *& )) !30!

(?) &* A (*(*!& 0 # &(*- ! ) (** -$*

*0 & (*- < )1)(

( '* * (( 0 &$(( 1*' 0 !- (#* (* -(#*# $6$6B5)-

> & ! ( )

( &

AIR 2000 Supreme Court 1398, #(* # (!& #( 0 (

(( 0 & &#* 1$ (30!*1&

*0 *

(*!& ( -))

) ! ( *-) 1 & &$ * * '!& )

(&*!& (*&'* A (* * - < (*&'* *!&

$(&-*

&(* -

(!3* - 0 $ $+* *&'* & & 8 $ ( -

& (* -

(!3 * -

$B $5 (&03#:* 1 7 * 1* D! * (*&*&'* *!& $(!*-& ((& *1 &

-(* ;0 /(-*!3 0 '& (</

( )

( 3 $ (*

! 1 * - #

0 $B$B5 /( )

-*1( (' *1 &- (* ;0 !*-&03(*-$(#'$* & 0 !'(*- - (* !*0*!* * -*

(* (*!&

% ( *- *!* 1 ))!* 1

*!! $

# 1( & --

- 3$ - ( (*

!* - # 0 >:( $ )(* </ (3

& $ 0* 1 (* -* (*!& $ !3

!& 0

&03

#* ( -- $#(*( (3 #('* 1#(*! (3#!*'* 1#* ((*- $ () ) &*

)3-*

(* (*!& * )) (*-0 * !3

!& *' - (-

$#(*(* 0! &!* * & * (0 *&& 00!

0 0 -1

&11* (-* ) 3 /(-* ) # !3 -& 1& &&!*'* 1#(*! 3* 1#*

/(-

$#(*(( 0 &* 0)*&03 )

(-$

0 0?0*

#(*! :* 1*

*& (*&3 &3?) $#(*(0'* !3* ! & (*$ ! (* 1$-&*!?) $& $(* 1! & '! ( ?

* ! *'* * 0 ( - *-$ (* -

8$5 )-

($&* 0)*&03

$* ;

$ 0! !* *:)* 1* '*# ( #* (#(- (3 !*'* 1 * ! )'& 0 (* 1 - * - * ?) & (5

*0 - (* ?) $ ( 0 *

'*& 0!&0 (-*!3 #* (1& (? -

&) $ (* !-

0 &&* 1!3 (-

&* 0)*& (-* 03 #3*

!3 % )&* * -&0'$* * (!&

()3-&03 (-* ) $ :* 1 -

$ ()3-&03

1 *& (*-) 1 &&& & ' 0) & (* 1$ (-*!3 $#(*! :* 1!! ( &* - *

*& $ (& ) & ( *-) 1 & & 1

E 8$5)-

(( &

*!!1!* 3* *-* 3 0 &* (& ) & %&* 1!3$

()3 -&03 (-* ) #!! )

(* ?

(03&!* &

#-* (!*-) &* )

)3-*

( /(-*!3 (&0 '&

!& *' 3-*

# -& (# 0!

( ! %&-*

&!3$ (* 2% 7(( !( &-*

(# 1 -

8$5)-

( &# ! (* 1

!* -

$85)-

7(* ! ('* 1 -&) * (-"*

#&*

0 :

/(!*- (# ('* #)

2 1! (&! 0 )**!!3& *&03( /( 1($* *&'* *!&03($ ((& (# (* - 0- (! &* !3 (0 * ('*& 0!&03 * 30 '

(* - 0-&03 ( & (* 1$ ))

03& 3* 1

)

$ (* 1* 0& & &

'1 3 & 0 $ (!*-) :-*

0& *&

(1 (* )0! 1' (* 1 (*

- &&!*'* 1$#(*( (# -& *

(- *- *!(-0 (-* (*!& ('0 (!&

!& *' 0!-

- 3 (**

/( - )

0 0 * **

( 0!#

& 0 * (* 1 /($* * (!& &) &03 (-*!3 (03&!* )3 3*

( ! 0 0 * 1- 3*!!1!* 3$ - (! * *-*

9* ( 0 ' $* * (!& (* &* 1 1*' 03 -*!3 (* )*

! & ' 0 )(!& && #

03 (*

%&* 1!3$0 &* -* &

> )( )3 (* &0)!& ) (*!

7 %+ !