Satpal And Another v. The Financial Commissioner Haryana And Others
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
- -
.#$/#0 #,&$1%2 ------ %$*$*&,%2+ 3%2+4+
#27#,# &$1%2+
------
%+/&,(%,$+
8 9 -
. .
2%+%,$ 294/*0 4/$#6 (:&)#$%
/%$*$*&,%2+-
+- /#+#,# !1#;#,6 #27#,#-
- - .
-
9
- %$*$*&,%2+
.#$/#0 #,&$1%2 2$*)0%+ &,+$*$4$*&, ,(*#6 *,$%2 #0*#6 +%%<*,= ,#$42% )%2$*&2#2* +%$$*,= #+*(% &2(%2+ - - - -
6 2%+/%)$*:%076 /#++%( ++*+$#,$ &00%)$&2 ,( 2#(%6 !#?;#0* #0&,=;*$1 .#,#( #<+%%5 - -
-
-
/2#7%2 5#(% +%$$*,= #+*(%
6 /#++%(
#27#,#
+1&2$ &55*++*&,%286 (*+5*++*,=
- - 2*%'076 2%+/&,(%,$ .4<15#,(%2 #, #//0*)#$*&, +%%<*,= A&*,$ 0#,(6 )&5/2*+%( B1%;#$ 6
/%2
#5#?#,(* 7%#2 -
+#*( /2&)%%(*,=+6 *,$%2%+$ /%$*$*&,%2+6 ,#5%07
+& &&0 1#,( +& %1#2 *5/0%#(%( 2%+/&,(%,$ -
#//%#2%( /2&)%%(*,=+ )&,$%+$%( +#5%-
)&,)%2,%( ++*+$#,$ &00%)$&2 +#,)$*&,%( 5&(% /#2$*$*&,6 - -
#<+1# 8 %78 )#00%( '2&5 '*%0( +$#''-
/&, 2%)%*/$ #<+1# 8 %786 &?A%)$*&,+ $1%2%$& ;%2% )#00%(-
/&,
)&,+*(%2*,= &?A%)$*&,+6 #<+1# 8 %78 #//2&:%( #<+1# %%58 )#00%(6 - - - - #//%#2+ - -
/2%(%)%++&2*,*,$%2%+$ /%$*$*&,%2+6 )#5% #00&;%( &00%)$&26 - - 5#$$%2 2%5#,(%( ++*+$#,$ &00%)$&2 (%)*(% )#+% &, 5%2*$+ #'$%2 5#<*,= +/&$ *,+/%)$*&,-
- $2#,+/*2%+ &00%)$&28+
)#5% (*+/&+%( &'6
-- ;1%2%*, (*2%)$*&, *++4%( (%)*(% )#+% $*5% ?&4,( 5#,,%2 #))&2(#,)% ;*$1 +#,)$*&,%( 5&(% /#2$*$*&,-
- #//%#2+ $1%2%#'$%2 #, - - 6 #, #5%,(%( #<+1# 8 %78 #//2&:%( #<+1# %%58 )#00%(-
, #//%#0 #=#*,+$ - - 6
/%$*$*&,%2+6 (*+5*++%( &00%)$&26 !#?;#0*- &;%:%26 5%#,$*5%6 #, - -
6 /#++%(6 )#5%
#5%,(%( +4?+%C4%,$076 - -
$1%2%#'$%26 +#,#( $#<+%%5 - -
*++4%(-
-
&2(%2+ ;%00 +#,#( $#<+%%5 ;%2%
/%$*$*&,%2+ '*0*,=
&55*++*&,%2- #//%#2+ /2%+%,$ 2%+/&,(%,$+ $1%*2 +%/#2#$% *-%-
&55*++*&,%2-
&$1 +#*( /%$*$*&,+ )#5% (*+5*++%(6
-
%,)%6 /%$*$*&,-
- 9%#2,%( )&4,+%0 /%$*$*&,%2+ +4?5*$+ *+ #=#*,+$ +#,)$*&,%( 5&(% *,#+54)1 /%2 5&(% /#2$*$*&,6 )#22*%( &4$ <%%/*,= /&++%++*&, *,$#)$6 ;1%2%#+ /#2$*$*&,6 /&++%++*&, /%$*$*&,%2+ (*+$42?%(-
*+ +4?5*$$%( /%$*$*&,%2+ =*:%, =#*2 545<*, 0#,( ;1%2%*, 1&4+%+ )&,+$24)$%(-
*+ ,%>$ +4?5*$$%( &,% )&+1#2%2+6 ,#5%076
#A 1#( %>/*2%(6 1&;%:%26 1*+ 0%=#0 1%*2+ ;%2% ,&$ *5/0%#(%(-
*+ +4?5*$$%( /%$*$*&,%2+ =*:%, 0#,(
%)$- &- B*00# ;1%2%#+ $1%7 +1&40( =*:%, 0#,( B*00# 6 $1%*2 /&++%++*&,-
*$1 +4?5*++*&,+6 /2#7%2 5#(% +%$$*,= #+*(% *5/4=,%( &2(%2+-
- %#2(- - /2%+%,$ )#+%6 /#++%( $1%2%#'$%26 +#,#( $#<+%%5
*,+$245%,$ /#2$*$*&, /2%/#2%(-
;%00 +#,#( $#<+%%5
/%$*$*&,%2+ '*0*,=
(*+5*++%( #0&,=;*$1 #,&$1%2
/%$*$*&,6
&?+%2:*,=
!
" #
$%$& '''
()*+ ',-*. /
(.,!+
"
" #
$%$ & 0*+ ()*+ 1,!*+
'1,!*(
2
3
(4)0()*5
7
!
6$%!!7 6 8
(.)'()*+
!
()). 8
9
: -
2&5 /%24+#0 #?&:% %>$2#)$%( &2(%26 *$ *+ 2%:%#0%( &?A%)$*&, /%$*$*&,%2+ $1%7 #00&)#$%( =#*2 545<*, #2%# (%#0$ ;*$1
&55*++*&,%2 &?+%2:*,= =#*2 545<*, #2%# #00&)#$%( /#2$*%+ /2&/&2$*&, $1%*2 2%+/%)$*:% +1#2%+-
*+ &?+%2:%( #/#2$ '2&5 =#*2 545<*, #2%#6 /%$*$*&,%2+ #00&$$%( B#,#0+ #20#+ #=2*)40$42#0 0#,(-
- + 2%=#2(+ )0#*5 /%$*$*&,%2+ $1%7 #2% %,$*$0%( 0#,( )&5/2*+%( B*00# B*00# 6 /%$*$*&,%2+ ,&$ /0#)%( &, 2%)&2( #,7 5#$%2*#0 +1&;
)0#*5%( #2%# $1%*2 /&++%++*&,-
#?+%,)% +#5%6 /0%# /%$*$*&,%2+ )#,,&$ )&,+*(%2%(-
- 1#$ #/#2$6 )&4,+%0 /%$*$*&,%2+ 5*+%2#?07 '#*0%( +1&;
;1#$ /2%A4(*)%0&++ )#4+%( /%$*$*&,%2+ ;*$1 5#,,%2 )#22*%( &4$ 2%:%,4% #4$1&2*$*%+- ))&2(*,=076 )&,+*(%2%( :*%;6 ,& *,$%2'%2%,)% *+ ;#22#,$%( $1*+ &42$ )&,)04(%( /2&)%%(*,=+-
- :*%;
#?&:% (*+)4++*&,6 (& ,&$ '*,( #,7 5%2*$ +#5% *+ (*+5*++%(-
- %,(*,= #//0*)#$*&,
+6 *'
#,76 +1#00 +$#,( )0&+%(-
.
!
- -
+A<+ 1%$1%2 +/%#<*,=2%#+&,%(
"%+
& 1%$1%2 2%/&2$#?0% "%+
&