High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/50095/2019disposed of

Maha Singh And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2020-08-19Mr. Justice Raj Mohan Singh20 pages

"#$" &

' #

(%) *

%+&#"%,-./

% *

% %

*01"%23-.4-(%) %.567,%#"%,-./

% ,*5 9: ;"

" <

0 7* % "

%$ "%7$"

! " .552 *%) %

# " =% % , **5 -

, 552

%$ , *% * % )

$ " =% % , **5 -

, 552 #

> ?&< "

55 *%) % 57 *

%&'(%)* : &%) % "*

%@7"$ =?

% $

7 %#

-!- -> >- > -> ?&7 %#

>%->> / # 75

# 75 ;%< &% /

% .

- &5

# % #%- %

"%0"%-2 5555 7< @7 *%

$%$

%, < ,*%, 9>: =?2% $

,*5 - 2" 55 $ " ! - "

/ % 3 5)

,%%$ # 5 % %.

<7 > &- 2"

) % /55$ %7$ 1 3*7 17 # - #2

%- .5 %- <0 )

, %, < " * % 2

7*)$ "

/ " 75)%, 2 "%%;"

)

,*5 " ,*,*5 %

/ 37% "

2% / % 5 %

/ 37% "

%- )<

7 77

37% B ,*5

, 5) .* 0 , "* 5 "%0" % ;"

,*5 2%

%% &4?#-"

0/ %2

", -<7 5

%(* 5,*5

7% %55 $ "

* %2 "#$"- &%/

$ ,-&%/

?"2%-# "- 367,%-(<5=73' 0)& "525$2 " %* %-2"* 75 7* ,

7 ##;.

55 $ $%7 " ,*5

< 5$ #

$%) 9: .

% , " % $ % -

7 #

> ?&2 < *

%- 2" ""2 " )* 37%) * % ,*5

$ %7 5

9 : 7%$

%/ $ * % -

,*%, 2

*% <

,*%, -< " *% 7$"

@7"$ =?

< ,*%, 9: ' % %

-< " *% 2

** %<

% %57% ?55@$ %

, %

$ 7

,*%, @7

9: ?*7%7

% %

-< " *%

"/ ** % <

% "

+7 5$ %

, "/ <

,*%, " <

7 < % /57 %) 7<,, <) ,*5

*% )

9!: % 7 5 % ,*5

% $ 7 ,*%, @7

: 1 " *% "/ * " ,*%,

*% 7 /57 %)

%/5 9 : % #

7 5 %7

%,#&15 #$"

" ,

% 557 %/

$ "55 " <

% 9: % 7 5 % *

%7<, "

% < 2" "

7 %#

> ?&2 > 275

%*%

> ?&D$"

5).)"7% 2" " $ %5

%2" " 7 7

% < 7%$ *

) ) / <5)*-%7<5 552"%%) *7%7 275< $% /7"7% .) "

75*<5 )

%, *

%275< 7<3

%, 7

) 37%) 7 "%%) 7%

7% ;"

%"$/ *5)% *

37%) < $$ %7 5

% *

)

37%) 7 " %%) 7% 7% ;"

*"<

% , " % $ % =? ;"

7%%

0*5

55 7

% %,27 9 : ' % %

-%%

2 ) - 55

%$ ) 9>: . * % *- 37%) * %

,*5 2 7 < $ %7 5

; "2$ %

7% 5

,*%*% 5< 0755#7< % " " ,%%$ #.( #7<7%5 ( , ,

,*%*% 5% $ <%"

37%)2$ %7 5

7% ;"

,*5 2 "%$ %,

"* 5 9: ;"

(E<5 .* A7%

%7 %

37$, %+,-&.%/* 0) 1%1* "%,%2%),12%3

$!# -42*.*

-21 !3,%5%'%60) 1%1* " %2/%'%%'+

1,*2)3 $$ -42*.*

-21 1%1* "7%2'%1%8% 0) -'&)9%./ %'+ 1,*2)3 $!! -42*.*

-21

#$3 " 7,, 7* %/ %) 1%1* 1,2 -:,

4*(&%6 *663*9*6,&0)%05 1 %'+,-;"),%' -2- %'+ 1,*2)3<= < 26=#<

= ;"

5 $5* 7,, 7* 37$, 552$, %

" " # $

" " "

! "

! " "

" " %

" ! &

' "

! "

( %

# )*

(, ( # )*

# -.!

+ # "

, # !

/ 0 1

" " ! "

! !!

' "

! ! !

" !

! ! 3 9 : =7551 " "7% 7-69&'+*2 &':,%'+

1,*2)0) 1%1* "-'5%>%'+%'

1,*23!<= < 26=

? * *2 % 7 % #

%&- "5 " ($" 7% " *2 % @7"

% % " / 37

*% /

<7 *%

52 ;"

*2 % % 5,

, %,5*7

5 -% %

*2 %% 75,

(2 / %

*2 %% < / %)*%$5) 2 "7 , % 7 ;"

%)<%2"

*2 % ($"7% 7 %#

%& ;"

*2 % 7 % #

%&- <

*% / <7 *%

7% 9: ?,%5%'%60) 1%1* " %2/%'%%'+ 1,*2)3

$$ -42*.*

-21 *2 % ($"7% 7 %#

%&-2 <) (E<5 .* A7% 2 "

*%,

%$7 5 ?

5 " 7 "*2 "75< % *% / <7 *%

) 7% % %2

7% 37

&<5)

< )

" 5 ,

", %,5

A"7 / 5 2"

7 " *2 % "75 <

# 55 (E<5 .* A7%

$%F <)

2) 557 % 2"

7 "*2 % 75< < " % 5$ *% / $<7 *%

7% 37

7 8

" "

# 7;<071

# 7;;01 - 8

&9!

! !!

" !

) 8

&9 :

" 5 :

2 !

# 7;;01 ; 8

&9 !

< 8

" 0

1 =

" 8

= !

3 9: ? &%' &':,0) 1%1* "-'5%>%'+%'

1,*2 < = < 26= ? - (E<5 #7*% , 7%

%),*% 55*% /7*%

< %/ 552$, % ; ! !

&9!

# -?

:@0 1 0

" '

& 9!

! "

! " ! !

% !

" "' ! !A " #

" #

" "!

% + !!

@ "

" !

" "

" "'

! " '

! !

' 01 !

3 9!: ;"

(E<5 #7*% , 7% 7% % %

/ 2 &%' &':,0) 1%1* "-'5%>%'+%'

1,*2 < = < 26=? -&.4*/ -52%50)'& '*22&1 2/1,2 -:, +.&'&)12%1 23 3 ,%'+&:%2, %'+ 1,*2)3 <=

> #$ %$7

7 %#

> ?&;"

(E<5 .* A 7% 2"5 % 5)$ 7* &%' &':,) (%)* <)-42%="

5 " *% < 552 ,*7

/ "7$"

% ,*7<5

7% % "

7 7

%,5*%

$275,7 <7 *%

52 ;"

%"$"5$"

<) (E<5 .* A7% "

* %5 7% 2" "% %7 7%

75 < ,*7 / "7$"

,*7<5 7% 5$"

< %/ ,

&%' &':,)(%)*<)-42%=;"

(E<5 .* A7% *%

@7" %,5 *%

$ $%7 "

7 275 ,7 <7 *%

2 "

7 7% "2$)

, *%/ )%$

);"

< $ * %5 7% 2552 < ,*7 % % <%$*

-, )"%,)<

*% ?

% 7,

7 %#

> ?& 2552 < ,*7 =?5$2 "

@7 5*%

$2 @7"

9 : ;"

@7"$ %,5*%

7 %#

> ?& , 7* %

5 7<

(E<5 #7*% , 7% %2&'+*2 &':,%'+ 1,*2)0)

1%1* "-'5%>%'+%'

1,*23 <= < 26= #.

7 % (E<5 .* A7% %,5 7

,*7$

7 %#

> ?& ) "

) ,*7<5 -<7

($"7% 275< $7 $/ @7

, <

*2 %7 %#

%&=552$*% *5

52*%> 37$, -7

' ! !

# )*

! '

> 01+ # )* !

# -? , # )* '

01 8

> 1

" 8 !

01#

" #

+ !!

# %

" ' ! "

0C1D

" 5!

" !!

" '

! 0C18

" !

! " '

0C1D # -?+

! "

! # -?+ &9 !

# -? + %

# -?+ & " "

" !

% ! ! '

" " !

! !

0C1 8

# )* !

! '

! "

" ! ! =!

! !

! ! !

! # )*

"! !

# -? + !!

! !

! '

# -? +

! '

" ! 3 : ? 1%1* " %+,/% 2%+*), 0) **4%8 %'+

1,*2)3 < = < 26=- (E<5 .* A7% " $%

7 %#

> ?&< $

) <

< *%/

*% -"2 / %$7 5 52 %2&'+*2 &':,%'+ 1,*2)(%)*<)-42%=2 %

%%$ &%' &':,)(%)*<)-42%= %*%

* ? * " 7<

/ 2 A*%

%2&'+*2 &':,%'+ 1,*2)(%)*<)-42%=" < 552 -

*$/ 2

% 7,

" : D " " < 2, %

: G"5 $"

*2 %- ($"7% "

A, 2"

%*<5 ) 75 ,

<5 0 7 *%

$ 275 *7

**% *% 37

7 *%

$ 275% 5 )

7 %#

> ?&< 55)

55 7 %

$%) "

" <

$ #

, , - ($"7%

275 <

5) <

7 #

> ?&, =? >: ? -

7 %#

> ?& $$%/

%, %$5

, 2

% , " % $ % =??

%*%

< #

> ?&D$"

5)2755 , * % : ;"

%5" %

% "55"

: 1 " *% "/ , <5) % 5/ %

: ?/ 2 % * - "

%275< / %)<5 0?7 " 7 -"

37%

($"7% 7 %#

%& <

/ 2 $7 5 %2&'+*2 &':,%'+ 1,*2))

7*% : @7

5) " *

552 =?

% $

7 %#

-!- -> >- > -> ?&7 %#

>%->> / # 75

# 75 ;%< &% /

% .

- &5

# % #%- %

"%0"%- . A7% &2 5555 7< @7

$%$

%,-% "

<)@7"

E" # !

< =

%* 0$%

%% *% <5