Vatsal Gaggar v. State Of Punjab

         

































 



 

 












  ! "
#$
%&'(

)*   

  

    +  

,-
 
*. 
/0
 
1


1 , -
*. 

0
)   
 *0!
0 -
 -
!3 4  
&
,-
*. 

 
'

*/ ,-
*. 

0
2),     

!

" #  0
) 
)
0 
4
,*
!*

 5
  

6 

6!,
4 ,

0
)

 
$7
&8
* *

9

6 *
!*

-
 8-
9-
5

7
* 
-


 2
-

,
 
*,
/-
!*0  -

 
,
22 
!*0 

0
4 
 

0
 

* 4,
 2
0
 *
0 
0
$7
/ 
,*6*

0
 2

!*
*
/0
2 *
0 ,,/6
 2+



   




 

 !"

 #$       % &   '
'

(&   '  &
 )   $  *   
 

+  !,(  -% &   '  

+!,(  + #!)'
"




,

( +      --

 ( ,  

.

-   

 (  ! )/00 ++

      1!+)

 

# +)  ) 2( ,   ) ,  #
#( #

$
$

!   /0  3+,, , +     )
41 %
- , (  & 

 # ')6

+

'%    #1+  , #

   )& ' 7,& '  + - , +  , ( ,    , +   #  )
   

 -  

 -  ( , 

  -     

) /0

   ) 

)  )
+ 

+  )  + ,!)'
"



    )/0 /-  +* 

 + - (    - 

( )  

 

 + -   

- ( , 6       1-  -     5   

   ,)

+ -   $   
 6#$  :

*

!,

0
)
*
0 
0 ) ! ,

0
$7
/!,*
* 
0 
0
3! ;
 6
0
 !*



7

) ,,;
 4!*

0
 !* / 4
60
<

0
) 
)
/ 
0
 2*
 0
$7

0
* )
/ 
6.
26
!=/
) 
/0
0 *

2) *
0
 !*
1 / 4
60
<
 

*

!,
! 0
*
0 
0
) 

 ,
;
!*

( 0,

(!
*2 
>((?- !3 4
,,6

0 ,
"*! -
( **/ ,
*
0
0 
4 ,,;
2), *

0
) 
 
,;

0
4 

!)
*! 6
.6 -

 ) 
0 
0
.0,
/00
/ 
!*
4;
0 0
!*

(55 5
>,=/ 6?

/*
4;
0 ) 
0
)
/ 
) 

0
0!

0
2

0

,,6*
*
 *6

, *



!,-
0
 2

 
4

$$

 4,0*
 2
0
/
, 
*
 

0
24,
6 *
 0
 2

0
)
*
0
2),  !*
*
/ *0 6*

   ;
*

 

*
0
3! * 403
60
 *
/ 
*0 6*

 



*
 
!,
))
0
) ;

6 

4 ,
 0
)
*
) ,,;
 . 
0
),

,4
 =
4;
0 )
/0
6 *

0
) 

0
*

0
2
 *

0
6 !*
0 
*! 6
.6 -
0

 6 , ,;
0/
0 
0
.0,
/*
4;
0
)
/ 
!*

0 )
*
0
! 0
,
!)
/
, 
*
 

0
24, )0

0
)

2)0 @
0 
0
),

,4

  4,0*

,,
8

*
!,

0
2),  
,
))
0
6  
6!,
4 ,

0
)

0
6 !*
0 
0
2 
!*
;

4
*
*
0
.6 

,,
!*
) 6 
 .6
0 *
, *
!,

0
) 
*
 ) !6
0
 *

0
 

 ) 
0 
0
)
/

*

 


!,) 4,;-

;-
/!,*
4
* 2*

0 2

  ,
&
!!,
)! )
/!,*
4
 .*
4;
! 0
*
 0
!*)  9 1)6

./
0
,
 4!*

0
)
*
0 
0 
0
3! ;
 6



7-


 4!*

0 ) -
0
) 
)

,,/*
/0!
226
!)
0 2 

0
 
,

2 ;
) 3!*
0
!2

0
  ,-
0 )   ,


 * *

4
, *

6!,
4 ,
*! 6

$ $

  ,

0
! 06
4 ,
4*B! ;
4*

0
  

7,, 6 B  ,
!  5 &06
4 .*
0  4.
0 ,,
4
 !*
D) 

)

0
! 

2 

0
 
*
0
  , ! 
0 ,,
4
) *
/0!
46
) 3!**
4;
4 . 

0 ! 

"  #




 &'()*+ Whether reasoned / speaking? Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No