High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/444/2019dismissed

Mahender Devi v. Kalawati And Others

2019-12-16Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill8 pages

"# $$%% &' (%)" $ ! "#

### *

'+",!# "$$%% --- ### $ $$%%.$% //# ,'/

1$ 2"%%3#%4'/#! 5%% )" 2"' % % 2"$$%%.$% " )%%,'/

2"%%4'/!#)""$$%$

2"$$%%) 7 2 ",' "" ' %) % 2"$% 8$$%%% / " )$ "%%"$%!" 9%%

2 "

# '"%"" %%/9%%

/)""'

/!5%%

# #' " '%%!# / '$"$% 3:'%% /"

/"$ '%$ "'$$2)'/"; $%"# "))# %2"

#( %

#<)'/" %2(%), ) ' ")%+ # "

")%+ ( %# ! "' "$% '/"#) %%""'/" # )

# !% ! )""2

1# ( %#')""$% ""' <" ! ' %# ! " # =' /9%%>

:'"/"$$2!)"""" # " % %2 #' "$% ""' :'%"?)#!"'/" " #) '"$$2@%/$$" $'!" # $$2 #' " !)"" %

$3#%' 683

% #' "

#A '/ 11+% > % ) 2)2 " #' #'% '/> +% 0 %)% *% ) ' #"" /%)'% / "! ' "

# %%+ .(%), "$= +/"

#!+"" '

/!5%% %%/9%%

)$$ /" #'; '"$%")"" # +) '" !"=$" " %2/ 9%%

)

*$<"9%%)"# ) %#" $% "" "

' " ' $$2 ) '/" " 9%%

2"$% <" $$" $' " / '9%%

;!"'!$2"" %%/9%%

<"'!"') % 7"" "')"% %/") &'$% 2 ,); " # "% ) / ' "")# /$%2)"'"#/2%"$ /" ; ""%9%%)=' 2 "

# ''' %' "$% ""' !"9%%)%%% "9%%

)=' # #'

"'/"9%%

% / '

$ % " ')$2 > ""' "$% ) $=$

@%%)/') 2"%%3'"

"$%/

9"""$% % % $2 B**

9"" ' " $% % " $ B* > 9"""$% "' %' %"$'B* 9"""$% "%'$$"' % "3'B* 1 9"""$% $$ %/"$'

2")'B* 9"""3#%'",'2"$ 'B*

0 9"""' $% 8, 8 , 2$B* 6 % 5#)% 2 ""$ A % 3' / " # %'"9%%

!'/9%%!)''

2'$''

!)""'% $%% 2"$% ; #""

#$)2

<" ! %"

!")#2 /% "%"" $% "% " "

# +" "

#! #!)'%+%2"#$+'$$$% %2

"/"

'"='9%%

:'%%2/ )"% "' ""))/) " %%/"$% ""' '"9%%9%%

!='/%

" '

/!5%% )"% "%#%9%% "

# 3:'%2!"') $$%$ 2"$$$%%) 2" %%4'/!A%4'/ %'"9%%>

)#'$!" "2$%/# 2"$% "$A %4'/%'" "9%%

$# <" ! "$$2 "%% " 2"$8(%), /"%2%/%" "

# $$% % 2"$$%%) 2" %%4'/!#,'/

//#" !$$$%" %

A'% "$$%%/'" ""% ' %)"# %) /"' % "$% ;/'"9%%

'' '$''

#"'/"/;" ""+$/"%%" " 2 9 ,"/; '"'

"9 " "" "/%)"" ""2) :'# //"

'!" !":' 2 '$''

''/9%%

A'%% " 2 9 , "=""$ /% 2" " '%% 9%%>

=' 2" #' "$% " "' . ;#" %2/'"9%%

%$# '' 2'$''

9%% >

#' " $% " "' ' %%2 $%2<" !2!"$% )'% %"$$2:'"= :'"'$" 9%%>

;!"'!$2""$$% %%)!

$'/,'/

1$ 2"% 3#%4'/#!5%% )%%,'/

6$ 2"%%4'/! ' % 2"$$%% "'/"' ;"#"%'% "$$%%"#$' " %)%%$"$2 " '" 2% '%3'2 <"%"$ )"$$'<"

$% !)"") # ( % + /" " $$2 :'! " 9%%

;""$$2:'"$$2 )"""

#"/ " % %2 " "' 9%%

! %2'/9%%!" %2 2"%%4'/ "

" '$' '

''/ 9%%

2"%% 4'/$

" $'/,'/ ; #"")%%5=* #%" "'

$ "

#) %+$$ " " #9%% % '# $/ )"% "9%%; ""% )9%%)/'

" 2/""

# )#2)%%) "$ / 9%%<"'/"" $ '/ 9%% $ ! " / '

" $"9%% /"' '$''

!" 2 $//'$/' A%4'/""%""/% 9%%

)$' 2" !" $% " ) " " " % $$%) # $#/"9%% 2)2 2# <"9%%" /"/'"%2 $2 " ) $' )"' $ $ " 3'! " !

= " )%%"/) "9%% %#;"#) " !%%4'/!

"/"%2$"%""$$2"% #

)'%!"'!#%# 2)2 '%''$"%2%/%" $ A'% "$$%%' % $'2 2" / /'

2%'%"2 "

")%%

"# %#!" 9%%>

#' "$% ""' )'% $%2$$2"'%#%#$"9%%<" /'

, /' %/9%%>

%'$ 2"$% % %"$$2 %' "$% "% " ," 2" !"9%%>

)# '$ "

:'""% %

'/ 11+%> % !"' "$% ! )2

<"%) %2$ " $$2%%/%2 :'" ##9%%>

;" /$$2 > +% 0 %)"""

#" # "$% %2!)"""#%#'$" <"$$%%C'" /"%2 ; 2$!:' %) '"% '

%:' %)!#%# "$$% A'% "$$%%' %$'2 %%/%2! 2$#2 $'/,'/

1$ 2"%%3#%4'/#! 5%% )%%,'/

6$ 2" %%4'/! )""%% 2 2"3'$$% "/'

/%2!"$$% )" #%&'%((

)*+, 9""$+/D

ED 9""$ %