High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCEA/9/2020dismissed

The Principal Commissioner Central Goods And Services Tax Commissionerate, Ludhiana v. Suraj Solvents And Vanaspati Industries

2023-02-22Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra10 pages

! #! $ " #$"% % #$"

% %"%

%#"& $

' ( ') % (

( *** "% & + ( ( (

(

! - % % (

% . %(

+/( +

0 (( +12/3(4 +12/45 - % 6% ( ( %

7 - - -

#" ( - -

(

%#, %892:9;;(+ +12/ <"- #"

- # -

( "% %

( %- - - - ( "

=- "-(( "

7%( %8

- ( ( %

7- ( - - ( "( ("

( ! (

+;;:+112 $ />,(-

0 $ +1??3( @$ +1??A5 -

- (

- # 5

5 !

- (

$(. !-

" # ( -

%# % -

# (( ( % % " -#" (# -

% "

" ( ( 7 (- < "

( ( -

% ($ />

3+5($ +1??- <

2B( ( % %#"

(

( % ( (( "

'!'

(

- -

# ( %

"-#, $ 1($ />

3+5($ +1?? : !- (# - ( %

#%(

- - # % -

# ( % #"

( (7- %(

#(( ("

#%#" (# (

- ( "

"( (2B(

( (

6% (+;;:+1129+;9+111 (

% $+/9:??1/:>, - - <#

$ />

3+5($ +1??-7#$+::/1/1C:,- -

% - - :>;2:;;:- % " ++, (

0 3(40 45#"7% ( ("

" - - #" +C;?:;;9

% " "(($?/+/>?, " $ />,+ - ++, (0

"D % %%

(

#(#

;C++:;;C

- (

8>;(:;;>- (

'('

#( :1;9:;+;- % %

#"#

- # 7 % "( % ( - #"

:9;C:;++ -#" ( $+::/1/1C:, #" 7% ( ( " - (

"(<

- 9 (

% #( #

-#"#

:/;?:;+2- % (2B(

( %- #

( #

" # #" ((

E:?B

"# !-

# % ( ( ( (

- #-#< ($ />

$ +1??(

(

#" % ( (" ( ( ((

- - % " % ("#"

"( <

( # ( (

% - #"- $ />

- - ? D % (

(

-%<(

-- (

')'

&, @F 0

8- 6 - % %

( #"

% # 7 -(

( 7 -$ C

" " -

" 7 #, 93 5 # 2B( ( %

(#, 93#5($ C(

$ :;;:- $ />

(

0 $ +1??GA / (

% % - # #

($ />

($ +1??- (%

%- " ( ( ( (

- "

<(("%

% ( #

" #-% " #(( ( $ />

3:5($ +1??- # " - ( (

% #

-%( # ( (

F#- % % :/;?:;+2- #

'*'

C - %#" ( (% %#" #

- "(

# ( ( (

E:?B #" <( ( ( C13:5( D :;+;3(4 :;+;45 (- % " #"#

(2B(

( %- > !- # ( $ />, ($ +1??

- ( ("

( (

-( (

(- ("( % ("$ />

($ +1??

5 ( ( ( (

- H $ - - % % ( "(

- - % " -

- - (- ( "( - % (" 7 ( (" " - - "

( %((

- " - (

2B( ( %"((

%#" (

(% (

(( "#" $

'+'

+1??-#< C1( :;+; $ />

- C1#, +( :;+; $ +1??

# #

" ( 395( D ( % ( 3?5( #, :-

" - ($ +1?? #"

#, 3+5

%- ( 7

(

% - " ( (

("% ( #

((

- (- ("( % ("- (( - D I

:;+; ( 2 " "

- -( ( - -

%(% - (

-(( % - " % "

( (

(

"( ( (

(

% $?/+/>?,

# ( ( (

E:?B

','

( % "(

%#( #

I"- "( :;+;$ +1??- $ />

- (

(

#" % ( (" ( ( ((

- - % "

% ("#"

"( <

( # ( (

C1 ( :;+; - %

" - ($ +1??- <

%- ( 1 ! # ( ( (

%-<( ( C13:5( :;+;

- -

- # ( %"#(

(

( % 8 #

C13:5( :;+; ##"

#(% # %(

($ +1??- " 7

!% -

# #"

J% ( %-. /"01 -$2 3

2 :;++3:C>50+/93 5-

- %8

- -

( - (

:;+;!- -< "

C13:5( :;+; " ## ( %"

#(J% $

. .14

&%1/'30.%2.2$2&5!6(7$ !,6"27- "(

( % -

, % - # 7 - -

% #"

( % %- " (

" (%( #< >93:5( :;+;

#" !- # (

( - (

(

- ( +; H# " "

- % - ( ( D I

:;+;

% - "

( ( <$ />

($ J-

% "

( %- #

% ( #

-<( ( ( C1 3:5( :;+; #

% " (

( (2B(

( % -

'5'

% " #

- ( % " 6 7 6"% 7 !

F 7% K8 F K8