High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28068/2024dismissed

Union Of India And Others v. No 670662 B, Ex Mwo ( Hony Flt Lt) Onkar Chand Sharma And Another

2024-12-13Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma10 pages

"#"$#% !

"# &

'( )* '

+ ++ ,

)* '+

+ +

+' $ #%&' () *!*(# *()(+ ,* "

- ....

++ ,

*$** (0"

+* "

* 1 ,#(+"(&,* $(# ,* # #( #23 7 1/+ ( "( # %& * 8 ( # ) # 9 %(8 99 #+0* %&* 98(), /,* $(, #(%8&"

0((880

.%/$.0 .%12"$#!

: ##(,9 4;

4< /<;<( , ( , * (8* $ * 9 , * + * 9 #(%8& , >!

/0(#9*($ #,) @/ 24/3 * ) ,#9*($ +*#(%8&0(( #A54B,8,

#(%8& ) 98() , * 0( :

9 !)"

*&=# 8 #( #43 // 24/;+* * $#*(* "(#(%8&0 * (%(%8 % $($$(=( #%& #9

/,8 #,(""

(846 // 24/<+* () 0( :

9 #=# # #( #45 // * (, +* , 9# (""

(8 (# * () )( # "

#$ , (#:#9(

8$ ($$ = #+ / ,8 # + % , * 8 ( ) #9 %(899 #+* (# +% 9() (880 #=# # #( #23 "

(= "(,* (## 7(9 (,

#$%#&

8$($$ = #,)* (, (## ("( #" "(+%&* 8 ( #) #9 %(899 #+* "

1,#(*(,8 #* ($(* (0"

% , *!

"3 /45

"$/

, "9

#$)(E ( ,, 9= (#:#9(" 0"

+ ( ,8((9 ,# )$0* ,(88) ,(&# =1F1=(&) )% ,* , 9 "

8+%"*% $ 88 #* ()&+# " (* (8 ($ +"*% 9)$ 8 #+(() )% ,* 9)%(( , 9 (%8*) +(* * () )($# 9 #+& * ("" "+*" 8) * 9 $9(%8 %

* 9$ (8% $9(%8 % ($$(=( #% $ (%(%8 )8(& +*(9G #+,)+* "9"8 ,** :#$) H%8 "

7!+9( 8 (

+ " #

=( "(($("* , * (# = #9 ( 7(9 (,

% (

! ! ) * +,-

! % / 0!

! 1 2!

3! 4 #&%5

6.+2 ! #"7, +,

! 0!

82! 9 2! #:+,; +,!

+ , !

+2! , +,

82! #:+,; +,

8#:+,; +, !

! = > 0!

8#:+,;?

= >

3 .

5@!

= += 4 , %% A 51 * @ 4 5 ! "&

7 B

;

9= (#$,* (%= 7(9 #"9"8 + *$*" #8&# 98( +*(0* (#(%8&% (8 #" (&) )% ,* 9)%((# , 9 (%8*) +(#0*9* 7 , 24 B = + * "+ *$* (& 9* #(%8 ) )% #% =(8# #,)* )&+%& * #% ($ #* ,,#(%8&"

+* ($) ,#(%8&"

(& ) )% ,* 9)%((# , 9 (%8*) +0*% (8 0*(#(%8&(G(),24B) +%)"

(= 8& ( # 98(( ,) * #9(8 D(#+ (* 9(##8& "9$*(* (#(( ##(%8&% $(%(%8 % 9)$($$(=( #%&)8(&

(## 98((%

: #%&* 1 2!

3! 4 #&%5

6.+2 ! #"7, < * ) +*$** (" )"($ =1F1=* #"*&9(8(#) (8* (8*,(&) )% ,* , 9 (%8*) 99 #+ "

9(88&0* (* ($ ,* % 9)$ 88 #+* 9#(%*% 9)$% 0*(&#

= +*$** * (8(,* " )"+ *( 0* (& # ( * + * 99 % 8&+ * %& * (# *(""

$ , # ( $,(&# +(* % ) #% ( 8,* $ ( ( ) )% , * # , 9 (%8*)

(= 8&+* ,"=$* #0) G(% , "(=1F1=* 99 #+% #* )"8& +(# 9( +* (# )(1#9*($ #+* "+* 98()( % 8 # = #(%8&"

= +(88* ,(9

(# 99)(9 ( #( * # , %& * 99 #+( % 98 8&9I #+*,# 98($0* * ,(&# =1F1=* 99 #+( 8G( # , )8(& (#- * () % $ ($$(=( # %& % $ (%(%8 )8(&

/4 *(()(&+* % (8 ,*(,* "9"8 *(& * 9(% (8,#(%8&"

* 99 #+%8&"'

(* ) ,(99 "(9 ,* 99 #)8(& +) $% 9)$ 9# #9(8 D(# =1(1= * % $ % 0* ( # 0*9* *0 = +% 998# #% & $*) ,% 8

% & ,* # ( * ,+ )(& (8 % 8&% 998# #9(8D(#+ ( ,) # , )8(& % $ (%(%8 )8(& +(* * () $( 9$ (8#

// * +,* ) #9(8"*8#*(* # 98# *(=

# 9 #) #9(8 7()(,* 99 #% $ )(# +*"*% 9)$ 8 # +* "+* () 088%

) #*(= ( #$ +& * ("(+* #9(8D(# #( * (, 998#$ /2

= +(8# 98( #"(+*()(#(& ,* #9(8D(#,880* $# 8 8(##0!*(" 1

,* JK# #9(88(&

+2442LJ8 ) '

K (8 9"8 J

, +*(% 0# ) #0* ), (%= "9"8 +0* (* ) , 8) ,* * )&+*(, (" 8)(&) #9(8 7()( % $)(# =1(1=** (8*+*( 9() 9# #(% ) # % $ *) (#- 0* ) % 9() (""

#*(* (## 0((#)(($

= + (8 #% ) #+,)* ,(9(*(#+0* * (9((8 7 1 * ",* # +(#-* $ ,+*"

+*"* 88) ,* (E$ "8(9 + =1(1= * (9= # %& *) , )8(& +0* %&+*!)(&998# *(* , # %(* 0(( 8,* $ * )& (#(9*0((%(%8 % 9() ($$(=( #%&* $ )8(&

/6 (##+(8 #% $(* #,)* 9#+0* * #9(8D(#+##(88&"9

#)(E ( (8 #9= ( (89* 9E+"(98(8&(""

($* (#= ,* # +*$* )"8&) , ( ,) #9(8 9*G + * = 8$ * %89E 9*( $ 9 9 9+ 0* ,)+(* * # 9() 9 = +,* (#

)"8&) ,(8 8(8&+* %&)(&% 998# #G(

"* ,+*% * ("" 8) (E$ "8(9 +(* 0(9$ (8%0 #$ #, )8(& # % $(%(%8 % 9)$($$(=( %&"

,)(9 ,)8(&

!(8&+,* "( )"8&

9*G (* ($ ,("" 8) (E$"8(9 +*%&* #9(8D(#99 #+8 (#(998+*(* ( (* #)(9# 9 ,(&# +%& * (##)(# "*%$* 8) ,(&"

8* ()&+(=&( ,9

8(8&* % (9= 9- "* ,+ #$* 9 , #,)8(& +%08#((88& (#(0 88998%&* #9(8D(#+*((9= " % % 9() 9 # ,) ( ,, 9= 9((8 $ 9 9 9 0* %&* 08#% (8,#(%8&"

0 = +0* (# (=+*! % 7(9$* 9 ,* "+(% 9() 9# ) #9(8%(#+* (# 7(9 #* (, '1 (%8& %(%8 $$(=( %& 9 9 0*

(-!( -

9,99# (#"

# ( !

9*( , # 4<-45-//

8# !1M 4< 3 2/

(-!( - "

9,99#(#"

# ' ,#(%8 146(// 0*8 " #"

(9 ((!

+ (N(8(*(88+D($8

* + #=#(8*( = #"

(9 (8& 98 (9(, -(, , 8#( (--!"

9 +* #(%8&9# #

(#$,* 9# = (8*((* ) ,* ("" 8) (E$"8(9 (* 9() )(# ) ,* "9"8 "(# 98( H%8 "

7!9( 8 #(

%&* #9(8 D(#+*() # 0*9**0 = +##,%#* +% 8 #* )&+##)(E " 8)(& $ , + * # 98(( , 8(0 :#$) "( *(

%&* (" )"*(* 9$,* (## 0(( 8, #, + #% ,(=(%8&

#0 #=1(1=* *$** (#" )" %(%8 %* 8 (# =# 9 %* (#" )" % 9() 9( " * "

0 = + * (# 9( =# 9 (##9$#9*($$=1(1=* +(* ,9$ 8& %$* (#" )"+%((88&(8##9(( #&(8"* #9(8D(#+ $($ 8,* (=, (*$+ *$* )"8&) , * ( , %89E 9*( $ 9 9((8 9 9 9*G + 0* %& )(& % 9() (= #*(* $,* # * ()&"

8+ % 9() 9 #,)( (8$ 9,()8&*& = + %&0((8 #% ( #* ) #9(8"+*( # %,(0 88,) # ((* 0((9$ (8# (#% 9() * ($$(=( #%&% 9() (%(%8 )8(&

0 = +( (#$,""(+#98 *(*( %

9# # ( &"

# ,) (# ( *(= %

9# #* 7 "( ( #8&+9 =# 9 % )""(*(%

8 "

+* %&+* !9( #$= 0 $*($ * ",* ) #9(8 %(#+( 7(9 #"( !"98&+* %&9 9 9(% ($ #* "(88,) # (+% # * %&* $ ,* # 9(% (#% ( 8,( (8$ 9 ,()8&*& !(8&+ #% 98( #( ,) #,)8(&

(##+ #% 98( #

% (%(%8 % 9)$($$(=( #%& #,)8(& %&* /3 = + *$* ( # * *( * # 99 #0*8 9() "

,) , 9 "

(* ("

(9 ( (+%9 * 7" )(#( * =( $8(+0*9*)(E * $,* # ( "

(9 ( (+% $ (,* 8*((9*+H $## ( ,) * # , )8(& % 9() ($$(=( #%& #,* )8(&

9 9 +* 8(9E,* (# 7" )(#( * $8(+# 9(* !998# +*( = ,* $,* (## " *99 #("

(9 ( (+* %&+* (# $ ( % # 98( # % ($$(=( # %& % $ (%(%8 #,)8(&

/< * +9 ),* :#$) "

7!+9( 8 #(

!"< # $ % & '

0* +(# 98(()(# *

7 +*(* ,,#$,,+(* *(% #0 * 99 8(8&(8* # (# , (%8 $* % 9() = # * " , *

E$ G( * ("" #$,,% $)(# *,(= = * 0 9 * # 98(( , 8(0 )(# = #9"()(E * (## 98((% ( 7"8(,8(0 )+* %&+* 7"8(,8(0 )+()(# = #9 "((8)(E * * # 9, #% ,=1(1=* , 9 "

8 99 #+ + + (8 8 * 99 #+*((&)

E* $($,* #0) (

)(# * # +(#*(+* ,88 9)"8 ) +("

8 # +% # "

9= ,* %(+,(&+,# 8(&(#8(9* 2/

, + * $($ , * % , , * ("" #$,,+ ),* = #9"( %(8 99 #+(8# ,, ,)(&88 $(8&(# #% "* 8# 5#.0 !

"3 /45

"$/

(, )(*+*!,#) * 0"

(#0*% =((%= +* () #)

)"$ ## +("( 8 ( # %(8 99 #+)(( #(#(,,)

" #,(8$0*(88"

#$(""89(+,(&

9++ ,:

+':

)(*)( 4 /4

;

.15#2< .

"# !

(

< "

4 /4

;"/.=0

(

< "