High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28478/2024dismissed

Union Of India And Others v. Smt Narayani And Another

2024-12-17Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma8 pages

!"#$%%$

! &!' !"%$%$

( ) )

!"!"" *" +,* $ ))

) -

+,* )$ )) ) * #$%&'()* #+,-+,,.%',.#)/#.0&12%0+&1 32#4,&5&4-4-20&#+

#6-7#.8-0$,/'92:.4&32##&+520'&042 ;;;;

)

) -

,#2%$,4,&-0+4.04<#-45&4-4-20/4,&5&4-4-20&#+,&#&-0

0-20230'-./5#.)+32#4,&+&44-0$.+-'&234,&2#'&#'.4&' = >00&?%#& @/ .+ 5.++&' () 4,& 1&.#0&' #8&' 2#:&+ #-(%0.1 :20:&#0&'/<,&#&()+4,&:1.-823#&+520'&042 32#4,&$#.0423 +&#9-:&&1&8&04234,&'-+.(-1-4)5&0+-2032#4,&+&#9-:&#&0'&#&'() ,%+(.0'23#&+520'&042 -0&3&0:&&:%#-4)2#5+>@,.+(&&0 .112<&'/():20'20-0$4,&+,2#43.1123A'.)+3#284,&#&B%-+-4& )&.#+23B%.1-3)-0$+&#9-:&32#&.#0-0$+&#9-:&5&0+-20-04,&

/'0&/1/'23 &!

,&,%+(.0'23#&+520'&042 <.+&0#211&'-04,&0'-.0 #8)>,& &$-8&04 23 DD@ 20 = .0' <.+ '-+:,.#$&'4,&#&3#2820

AD.4&,%+(.0'23&+520'&042

<.+$#.04&'#&4-#-0$5&0+-20/.+.'8-++-(1&42,-8.+5&#4,&&0+-20 &$%1.4-20+ ,&#&.34&#/ 4,& ,%+(.0' 23 #&+520'&04 2 <.+ #&

&0#211&'-042&3&0:&&:%#-4)2#5+>+&#9-:&@20 A= ::2#'-0$ 42 4,& 5#&9.1&04 521-:)/ %520 .44.-0-0$ 4,& .$& 23 +%5&#.00%.4-20/4,&,%+(.0'23#&+520'&042 <.+'-+:,.#$&'3#28 +&#9-:&-04,&20 AA.34&##&0'&#-0$.+&#9-:&23 )&.#+ .0'='.)+/<,-:,<.++,2#4()A'.)+/+2.+428.7&4,&+21'-&# &0.(1&'42:2851&4&4,&B%.1-3)-0$4&#823 C)&.#+/32#4,&5%#52+&23 $#.0423+&#9-:&5&0+-20/4,%+32#4,&+&:20'+&#9-:&#&0'&#&'(),-8-0 4,& = "%+(.0'23#&+520'&042 <.+'&0-&'+&#9-:&5&0+-20 () 4,& :285&4&04 .%4,2#-4) 32# ,-+ 024 :2851&4-0$ 4,& #&B%-+-4& B%.1-3)-0$5&#-2'32#&.#0-0$+&#9-:&5&0+-20-04,& &&1-0$.$$#-&9&'/#&+520'&042 3-1&'/(&32#&4,& 1&.#0&' #8&' 2#:&+ #-(%0.1 :20:&#0&'/ <,&#&()+ ,& :.+4 . :,.11&0$&424,&.32#&+.-'#&E&:4-202#'&#,&+.-'/(&:.8& .112<&'9-'&2#'&#'.4&' =,&25&#.4-9&5.#4234,&+.-' 2#'&#-+&?4#.:4&',&#&-0.34&#* ???? ????????????????????????????????

! "# $$$$$% C &&1-0$.$$#-&9&'3#284,&.32#&+.-'2#'&#.+5.++&'%520 4,&>+%5#.@/()4,&1&.#0&'#8&'2#:&+#-(%0.1:20:&#0&'/4,& 5&4-4-20&# 0-20230'-.,.+3-1&'4,&#&.$.-0+44,&-0+4.04<#-45&4-4-20 (&32#&4,-+2%#4

)&456

6 !

7081/ !' &!

17 0890606 !

,&1&.#0&':2%0+&132#4,&5&4-4-20&#++%(8-4+/4,.44,& 1&.#0&'#-(%0.1,.+3.-1&'42:20+-'&#4,.4-04&#8+23&$%1.4-20 2 C234,&&0+-20&$%1.4-20+32#4,&#8)/

.0'&$%1.4-20 2234,&&0+-20&$%1.4-20+32#4,&#8)/ /4,%+201)4,& 285&4&04%4,2#-4)<.+&852<&#&'42:20'20&4,&'&3-:-&0:)-04,& #&0'-4-2023B%.1-3)-0$+&#9-:&/4,%+()4,&+21'-&#32#,-+(&:28-0$ &04-41&'42+&&74,&&0'2<8&04235&0+-2042,-8,&+.-'&$%1.4-20+ .#&&?4#.:4&',&#&-0.34&# >!

@ &'($ )*

+ , +

!- &./ + +

&(!

+ ! +

! +

! ! ! ! * $% >!

D/ @ //$ 0 ! +

1 !! &' !

23 + , 4 + +

&(!

+ $

! - $% 5$ 2#&29&#/4,&-0-+4#)23&3&0:&9-'&21-:)1&44&#2 > @

>&0 21@ '.4&' / -0+&#4&':1.%+&>-9@ -0 4,&

&$%1.4-202234,&&0+-20&$%1.4-2032#4,&#8)/ ,& #&1&9.045.#4<,&#&23/-+&?4#.:4&',&#&-0.34&#

5&#%+.1234,&.32#&.8&0'8&04<2%1'8.7&-4:1&.#4,.4 #&1-&3 B%. :20'20.4-20 23 '&3-:-&0:) -0 #&0'-4-20 23 4,& .552+-4& B%.1-3)-0$+&#9-:&/-+42(&.::2#'&'208&#-4/+2.+42&0+%#&4,.4.0 .#8)5&#+200&1-+&1-$-(1&32#.41&.+420&+&#9-:&5&0+-20

A ,&1&.#0&':2%0+&132#4,&5&4-4-20&#+3%#4,&#+%(8-4+/4,.4 4,&E%'$8&04234,&1&.#0&'#8&'2#:&+#-(%0.1/#-0:-5.1F&0:,/ &<&1,-/#&0'&#&'-0:.+&4-41&'.+ ! "# $% <.+024:2##&:4#.4,&#<.+:204#.#)421.<.0'3.:4+/ 4,&#&32#&/02#&1-.0:&2%$,442,.9&(&&051.:&'204,&+.-'E%'$8&04 ,&#&1&9.045.#.$#.5,+/.+2::%#-04,&9&#'-:4>+%5#.@.#&&?4#.:4&' ,&#&-0.34&# '$0 , !67 '/$8/$'8&# 2 9

; + <- !

= > :&/$8#$'88& ?//

= > :

'8$8.$'8&5@

; !

@ :

7 :+ A

B$C $.8

'8&D85$&&$'8&D !60!

@ ;60

!= > :

+ + @ **** **** /#$

+ <

E 7

+ <

2 F C $

!+ , !

: !;

+&/! ! !;

;

! 0

;?!G ;

- + + !

: !;

G G ;

: ?HG! >

> - +!

! 7 :+ > $0 $

& ‟ '

( )

* ) )

;

+ 0

, !

+ % + !

6 0 '885$0

++ &/$8#$'88& ! ? &'

? $+

,-.-/ 0 /1-/-/2 ?

! !;

;

0 7 :+

$ !

$ + F C $ ?/5 +$ !7 !' 7086 & 0$

-0:&4,&&?52+4%1.4-20+8.'&-05.#.$#.5,2 234,& E%'$8&04#&0'&#&'()4,&"20G(1&5&?2%#4-0:.+&4-41&'.+ !6 ! 7 !6//!! 08 ( $)& ! )6!38 / 5/ /#&52#4&'-0-/32 ,-,/ 5.#.$#.5, <,&#&23 (&:28&+ &?4#.:4&' ,&#&-0.34&#/29&#:28&+4,&'-+.(1-0$&33&:4+/-3.0)/23+%5#.&?:&54-20 2>-9@/.+(&:.8&-0+&#4&'9-'&521-:) 1&44&#'.4&' /4,%+/ -04&0'&'42<2#7.+.02(+4.:1&#.4,&#.$.-0+44,&+21'-&#:1.-8-0$#&1-&3 23:20'20.4-20-04,&#&B%-+-4&+,2#43.1123+&#9-:& &'$+

, !

* &' $

* ! !

G ;

0 $G +

'/I&J#( &/ '88& *

$00

,&#&32#&/4,&E%'-:-.19&#'-:4>+%5#.@/'2&+#&0'&#0&$.4&' 4,&+%5#..#$%8&04#.-+&'()4,&:2%0+&132#4,&5&4-4-20&#+/4,.44,& &852<&#8&0442:20'20&4,&#&B%-+-4&+,2#43.11/(&:28&++21-4.#-1) 9&+4&'-04,&285&4&04%4,2#-4)/&+5&:-.11)<,&04,&,&#&-0.(29& %0'&#1-0&'5.#.$#.5,+/.+2::%#-04,&9&#'-:48.'&-0)& ! )6!38

/ 5/ + '/ /.11%'&'42-04,&9&#'-:48.'&-0,.8..%#G+:.+&/'2 -09&+4E%#-+'-:4-20-04,&#-42%#4/424,#2%$,E%'-:-.1-04&#9&04-20/ 4,%+8.7&4,&&+52%+&':20'20.4-20

20+&B%&041)/4,&:%8%1.4-9&&33&:4234,&.%4,2#-4.4-9& E%'-:-.15#202%0:&8&04.+:.##-&'-04,&.(29&&?4#.:4&'5.#.$#.5,/ 8.'& -0 ( ) 4,%+ :2851&4&1) :2%04&#9.-1+(24,4,&+%5#..#$%8&04+#.-+&'(&32#&4,-+2%#4/()4,& :2%0+&132#4,&5&4-4-20&#+/4,%+32#'&0)-0$424,&#&+520'&04/4,& (&0&3-4234,&+&#9-:&5&0+-2032#,-++&#9-0$-04,&/8&#&1)204,& $#2%0'4,.4,&,.+024:2851&4&'4,&B%.1-3)-0$5&#-2'23+&#9-:&/ (&+-'&+204,&3%#4,&#31-8+)$#2%0'/4,.4201)4,&:285&4&04.%4,2#-4) -+.%4,2#-H&'42:20'20&4,&+.-'+,2#43.11

= 20&4,&1&++/ -0 4&#8+ 23 4,& '&:1.#.4-20 8.'& -0 4,& ,&#&-0.(29& %0'&#1-0&' 5.#./ .+ :.##-&' -0 4,& 9&#'-:4 >+%5#.@/ 4,& :1.-8+23'%.13.8-1)5&0+-20-0.''-4-20424,&3-#+43.8-1)5&0+-20/-3 #&B%-#&'/<2%1'(&#&+4#-:4&'3#28 A /.+&09-+.$&'()4,& -0-+4#)23&3&0:&D&44&#'.4&' =

6!/1 7086 & 0$

0.34&#8.4,/4,-+2%#43-0'+028&#-4-04,&<#-45&4-4-20 .0'<-4,2(+&#9.4-20+.(29&/4,&+.8&-+'-+8-++&'

C ,&-85%$0&'2#'&#/.+5.++&'()4,&1&.#0&'#-(%0.1 :20:&#0&'/-+8.-04.-0&'.0'.33-#8&'

-+52+&'23.120$<-4,.115&0'-0$.551-:.4-20>+@/-3.0) :)

) -

;

:) ) *;

%$%$ 0E.1 808 9/26!3< / ! "

< 808 9 0/41 "