High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/517/2019dismissed

Union Of India Thr Its Deputy Chief Commercial Manager(Claims) v. Kanti Devi And Others

2019-02-20Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill7 pages

!"!#$

#!##%!

&''(( )*"+" , !-! #% .*" & "'#%#

/$ 01/ 2 2211 *"# $ /*2 #3 4/ (. 5%-

5* ''((

((#6!# .'*"# ''

(!" *%%

88'

""%93

3 ( !4"*!9+# (5 .

#%!6 *. # .5 .

#%!6 *.5 -!% 7.! . . *"'#%# "5 (6 ( .!*" ( / #:.!5 .

- 9# *%% "

+ *3 4'#"

"8( " . 9*!

" " *

# ;5 % "% 1 ( / #:.! (#6 7!

. .!" 7! , ! -!5 9

<< ='*"" !# *4 <.

*'+*

3 2

#!'

5 * .

-!#6 '+* .

7 ! < " >.# ( %

2#!'

3 2

!#5 9 . .4 .

(!6.

*4 . %*!#<!#6 7

*5 9+ +(% # *?9

!#.

(* %3( ."

!#.* *5

*4 .2#!'

!#51 #:.!@"!# % "%A5*+".% *%" # !#5+#%* .!4'*""!#

7!(( ("6 #!'

!"7!5, !-!5 *!% "

' .!4 *4 9 *%!#6 . 7*#6 !#5 9+ . 4 !45 1 (

BC / #:.!7 ".!

93 ."!% #%.((%7# #% *"+( .

-!#6"+"

!#%6*!-+"!#:+*!"5.%!%# ."' ,

-! (#6 7!

. .* (6 ( .!*" % "%1 #:.!5'***% ''(!

!#+#%*2 !#D

3 ( !4"*!9+# ( 5 8* %7!

.2 !#;?

3" 5 5 * "<!#6 4'#"

!#5 #

+# .%

.1 #:.! . ( *#% *!9+# ( -!%

885 6* "8 ( " 4'#"

(#67!

"!4'( !# *"

E ' 5 *4 . %

!(( * (!F

!# . 4+# .

"9#*%*% 9'

9( "'* ((7!#6

9($? 2* 4

(

!#".!' 7!

* 4'#"

''(!

4+# 9 %!"

*!9+ %'#%#

4#6 ''(!

, !-! >!

"55G?@ +'"7

#(3A

(#67!

'*'* !#

!# *"

/!#*% +6.

"55G?@ +'" #

#(3A

(#67!

'*'* !#

"+9:

+*#!".!#6 % +4#

*3'*H+ .* *(

!#".!' 7!

. % #:.!5 (#67!

..* 7#'* I !

!".

"55G?@ +'" #

#(3A

(#67!

'*'* !#

"+9:

+*#!".!#6 % +4#

*3 '* H+

BIC .!" *(

!#".!' 7!

% ( / #:.!5

(#67!

.!" 7# '* ; 9( 2#

"55G?@ +'" #

#(3A

(#67!

'*'* !#

"+9:

+*#!".!#6 % +4#

*3'*H+ .!" *(

!#".!' 7!

. % #:.!5 (#67!

..!" 7#'*

!#<+ +6.

"55G?@ +'" #

#(3A

(#67!

'*'* !#

"+9:

+*#!".!#6 % +4#

*3'*H+ .* *(

!#".!' 7!

. % #:.!5 (#67!

..* 7#'* D !#<+ +6.

"55G?@ +'" #

#(3A

(#67!

'*'* !#

"+9:

+*#!".!#6 % +4#

*3'*H+ .* *(

!#".!' 7!

. % #:.!5 (#67!

..* 7#'* 2#!

+6.

"55G?@ +'" #

#(3A

(#67!

'*'* !#

"+9:

+*#!".!#6 % +4#

*3'*H+ .* *(

!#".!' 7!

. % #:.!5 (#67!

..* 7#'*

B;C .

- .

*% ( *#% +#"( * ''(( #%

("6# .*+6. .!4'+6#% *% *#% +#"( * ''(( .

" %* 7#

!# .!" +* *%" !% -!

% ;8

#%*%932+<.7!#%*2!#6.51 '!( @/ !(='*""A"'*

. "

!% !% -!

5 # '*"# "+%%#(3 :+4'% !# *# #6!# !#57.# ."

!% !#.

(* %3 *""%.

( .'(

*45 *"+( 7.*5 ."

!%'*"#7 .*7# ##"!% !"+* .*"

%!# !% -!

.% +(%# 9 !#!#7.! ..7 -((!#6 #%6 "

+ <

".:+4'%!#*# .#6!#.!" +* ## *(3+'#

!% -!

2+<.7!#%* 2!#6. " !

%" # *( #3 "' !! # 4 7.7 .'*"#57.6 "

+ < !#"

.#6!# #% .*7###"!% .

"9#+* *6+%

."' !! "

#%.

<# 93 . *"'#%# " 9* . *!9+# (

( !4 ''(!

!#!"9 "%+'# . (" #%*!-(+"6*+#%" ( / #:.! %!% *"+( .

-!#6 9# *+# -* 93 #6!# !#7.!( *""!#6 #%

.6 "

+ < 7!

!#57.! .7 " 4!#6*4 #!'

"!%.+"5

. % "% 7 "+! !%5 # -*% +#%* 2 !#" I #%;? .#%!

3" 5 % # !#% #3 4*!

*6+4# " * !"% 93 ( *#% +#"( * ''(( " '* .

#% !* +4"

# " . '*"# "5 % "% 1 ( / #:.!5

#!% 93 .!" 7! , ! -! 9

<< ='*""

BC *4 <.

*'+*

!#* #!'

!"# %!"'+

.3 (!6.

2#!'

3 2

%*!#<!#67

* #%7.# .3 49 <5 !#57.! . .3 7* -((!#6 !#5 .

(* %3 ( . "

!# 2!# % ( / #:.! 7 # !((!

'*"#5 . 6 '

#! #% *

*%" '(

*4 .+**!%(3 9 # !# * #!'

!" 7!, ! -! *!% "

' .!4 *4 9 *%!#6 7*#6 !#5 9+ .!" '* "" . 6 "

+ < 7!

. 9%3

#%"+*%6*!-+"!#:+*!"*"+( !#6!# .!"%

."' !

"( '*"#57.9 !#*4.!".4 7#

4 .!" "# !

!".

#!'

5 .

% # * "# 44!

"+! !%

2#!'

3 2

!#5 7.! . !" *+#% ; ,!(4 *"*4.!"%"

!#! #!'

434!#%5 ( / #:.! 7 #=!+" 4 .!" "# .+"5 *6+4# !"%

1 #:.! 44!

%"+! !%93:+4'!#69* 4-!#6#6!#5!"# '

9( -# .*7!"5! 7!# *'*

!#" * 9

<# #"!%*

!#5 .# . #5 7.! . %- # " +" :+"

! 5 ".+(% 9 '***% . ( *#% *!9+# ( .

"5 7.!( '

""!#6 *%5 *!6.

(3 *(!% +'# . :+%64# #09( 2+'*4 +* #!# #%!

)" * 9.

< )!:

,+4 * #% .*"5@8A 2 57.*!# .#09( 2+'*4 +* .

".(% "+#%*$? J %+9 5 !

!" '""!9(

7 *'*

!#" # 9 6!-# . ='*""!#

BDC J !%#

( ((!#6 '

""#6* *4

**3!#6'

""#6*"K5 .!*"

9!#6

#(3

''(!" 7.# '*"# .

+ ((3 6 !#"!%

#% .* * ((" %7# *4

!#57.!( ." #%9!#6

!# (+%" "!

!#7.* '*"#!" *3!#6 9

#% (("%7#7.!( *3!#6 %"2!#

.'*-!"!#* 4'#"

!#!#

3" !" 9#! !

( '! (6!"(

!#5 !# +* '!#!#5 !

".+(% * !- (!9* ( #% 7!%* *'*

#% # # **7 #% .#!

( # # 5 !# +* '!#!#5 . (

9- 4# !#% 7 !# *'*

!#" ! # 7.! . %- # " . 9:

. "

+ #% "*-! "!

"'+*'"".+(%9'***%K

.* 2 !# ;?

3" 5 '*-!%"

7.# !# . +*" 7*<!#6 * 35 +# *% !# !%# +*"5 .# 7.

.* * # .*.

" 9#

#3 7*#6+(

5 #6( * % +( # . '

. * 3

%4!#!"

!#5 '

""#6*57.!"!#:+*%*<!((%5!"# !

(% * 4'#"

!# .+"5

<!#6 !# #"!%*

. -!%# #%

( # * *%5 !

# "

(3 9 "

. !# !%# H+"

!#7+(% ((+#%* .%!#!

!#+# *%!# !%# 9 *%!#6 ## 9.(% 9

(!# .'*"# " /*-*5 .% #%.!"7!, !-!57* .9# ?

!% '

""#6*" #% . % "% .

% "+"

!#% !#:+*!"

BC *"+( !#6!# .!"%

.57.!(9 *%!#6 !#.+"5!

## 9"

% "%1 #:.!.

% 44!

"+! !% #"H+# (35%# !#% #3!#!*4!

3*!((6 (!

3 !#!4'+6#% *%'

""%93 .( *#%*!9+# (57.! .4 3 ** #3!# **# 93 .!" +* !# .'*"# ''

( # 5 .'*"# ''

(!"%!"4!""% %" >.

.*2'

<!#6G

"#%$ "G >.

9($ "G