Narender v. Sub Divisional Officer And Another
! "!#$% &
'
"
&!%%()$ &'
'*+ ()$
, +$()$ '
*+()$ ' -
....
/!&%%(& &'% & %! % 0!1"!#$% (
' "!# $ 234 ! ( ,&% 2
3 540% 167 &
234 7
& !1& 11 ( &8!% 1& 6 1&% 5# 1 ) %% %# 1,&+ 9::-(8& ( (8%%
((6'
+8' 06# &5
-;+&& $!$%%1 (*&% ! ( ,&%
)' &&'%(%%5&+
!&66" !''& &'% &&&'%%1+&&# <0 "1&6$ ''%# &1&
& 6= 1%5( & &1 & + &' +&
1 &6'%=&&'%&$ # 1!% %5'51&% 5#%%(&+$ (&! # 1
:9 :
9%%1!'&'% !#6 1%!6 1 1&16 &5+ +&& ' + =&'% !#6&!6#!&1! ;
9& 1&1>%&% 5 6& 6'%=&'%1&6 &%! ' &!#+%%%%8%% ( ( &+$ !68 $!%!#+%%+ &+8%% & ( & %& &6'% & #%5%%1%%5+&&&5&$ 1& !%&%6(&'%& %&!?! )%1+&&!(&6$''%
60!
-
11(&'!'' % + 6 + '%5 1 & ! +%% ''% 1 60! )' $ & ( & '% & ''% &11 & 6 & % 5 6&6&& &6+%%
- &&# <0 "1&&6&@# ! 5(:%1 +&&!6(+&&%!'506# &5 - ;!%5$ #5&3%? + :
' 1% 6'
,&+ 9:>::(8& ( (8%% +& $!$%%1 *&% ! ( ,&%)8&A ' 18%% $ #5 & '+ -= & 06# $% & !#+%% +%%8%% &'%%1+&& # <0 "1&++ &%?!=&'% &# <0 "1&&!#6& !%5+ $( & (&% +
&6'%= & (1&$ 6" !'6$''%& BC!$ B1 ' $( 234 ( ! 1&'!#1 !&%#!& #+ 1%5
&6'%=&!
& ?! 1 '$ #5 $!'+ =&BC!$B1
$ & % # 1 & 99>B4 ;
- 9 & 9 B49 ;
9& " ( "!#$ ( ( ! $1&6 !#6& ' ="
1%5?! &6 !''&5%$ & !&'!#1 !$%%1 &6 6" !''(+&9 =6" !'&!
6%5 ,!6 ( '%( <0 ( 1&!$ 0 = !
1 ?! 5 1&!$ '
! & ' #5 3%? + 6+&&+!&!#+%%+#1 !
; 8%% ->>8& =1&!$ !
& '
!&
' 3%? + +& !#+%%+! 8%% = $66 :9 :
98&'%C'%&#!&'% '= 6 +&6$66;
9=& '%!#6& '%5#!&6+!# 5= ( %1+&6,!6 D1 ( D! B1 & 6# (76'&%& '%&'
1&'%#!61 !''%5 & 67* %+&&&%'; +&!5 = 1%5( 77 ' + '
' ( +&& '%
!1=&$1 '&5&'
1+1& '%+ $+&6'%5 -(>+6''%5 /&'%& %%56'%&# 1&!$ ' 5&!( & ( & ! # 0 5 ' *& '
5 6%&!''%
;
) & 1 1!6( & % !
$% D!1
$
( ,&% $ & ' 6!?!?!&%%&'%&!
@%1 11 $ #5 & ( '% & '
''%# D!1(,&%(+&&+1 % )% D!1(+&$0!16 %%+&''%' %5 +6& C& 6 $ 1+&%&'%5
6!%%%'%& :
3+$ ( & '% % +& & &''
&&!
#5+5%1&'
$ '( +&& + ! '( +& '! ''
/&$& % !% &' #11 & !1&&
) 60!%+
-!% 5?!#% %(+& #5&!
8'1$+%%& !6%!1&! &' (& 51 1 & !%%%( 5&'%&$11'
6(#%$ #1$!
&'%'%! 1
' #%% 0!
5% 60!+&%%&1 C10!$%5 @ %51# 1 ' 60!( ' ''
&1&!
6!+&%&%1%% &6 %& & %56 % 6 &!
(&!& %#1 %! "; &"'%)'
$&0!#1 +& &!&'% &1&#!&%&6 &&!
/%1&!&#'
'%&&'% C6&6!&' >'% %5% 1 60! *& %!
+&!!''% 68'1$+& %$%1%''&
: ''% 1&' 6!?!$ & %%'%&! "!& 1&+&& %!
%8 % 5$&6 +!#% &% %! ! & !6& )# ! 6& '% &''% &11&% 5 6&6&& &6+%%&&#
<0 &6&@# ! 5(:%1'506#
&5 -;+&!&''% *&06#' % ,&+ 9:>::(8& ( (8%% +& $! $%%1 *&% ! ( ,&%
)& !6& )8&A ' 18%%
%$ #5&'+ *&06# %&& !#+%%+& 8%% (+&&++ &' '% & # <0 "1& & # $ !#6#5'%<0 "1&(&!#+%%+
&6&'%(&+$ (1&!$ (#
'% & !#6 ''% & BC!$ B1 ' %$(234 7( ! && !#+%%+& &%#!++ 1%5
&6 &'% 3& ?! '$ *& % 5' 6&?! &6 +!& !#+%%+#1 !8%% ->>8& ' ' 3%? + !#+%%+& 8%% E&&% 5' 68& '%C'%&(&' 66!6 (&+$ %
9 !#6+ '(+&&+!#
& ''#1
!#5 % 5 ' 6 & '
( & '% + ! # %1 % 5#5!61 1!''%5 67*'%+&&&%' ; +&!5 *&'
1& + 1 $1 '&'%+ $ $ 5'%5 -(> @!
& 6 (&'% &6'%&#
1&!$ (+&+%' 5&6
@ %%&
(&'%!%#&$1' 6
#% $ #1 & $! & ! 1 5
' #%%0!
5% 60! &6 & &6!#&615'' !1!
6 1 & !#+%%
& 6 &1%6 %( & 51'
'1%& &$&6 *& %!
&&!1&%%& &1#!&$%5'8& !$+5 1&' 6!?! +&&$1!5' &$11 $?!(656 1$1 ?!
%1&#+&' *& '#5 % )% D!1(,&%%6!# !% $ 5!%''
&+&!56' &6 '
' ' '$ 51! &!%%1%' '
' %5 & % )% D!1(,&%$ 6 &6 $ 5 & 6 $ 1& '%56!6'!'&'%%%%'%&(
&'
% )% D!1(,&%' &' 1&  1 60!! 1
' #%%+&$ %#%!% 6 65 6%%5 60!1 3 +&' %%1&% 5#1& 1&'%>''%%( !&5' %&!%&$#1 #5&% )% D!1&'%''%%
/65#6& &+&&6 6!'
# &!
(& %' '%5$ 6 $ 6& 6 '&(&' + !!%11 6&!
+& 1 & % 5 *& + ' & 1 (3+$ ($ - (&!
# $& '' &$###5!#!6 5 & ' & % 6'% & ''% 1&!$ & 5' & $'(
!''
1&&''% !&6'%6&% 5# %%+#5& %!
@ & ( & % + %%
"!&!&' >'%#$++& %%& !%1&%5 < 1 5?!#% % %1+&!%1! '
%16 % '1!#!6+&!& +&56 !%% &+!% & !%%!
0!
3 65#6&#&&6'!1
# 5(' $ '1 1& 51 '
$ ! "; &"'%)(+&&'
$& 0!+!%# !+&!'%&#!& %&6&&!
-
*& $'+&!6 &6 6 E&%C 1'+ ! "9&! /( & ' #5 & % !
+%% #5 % )% D!1( ,&% % ( !%%5( ''% 60!%#5&''%>'% 6
" & 6 $ ' & # 6( & 6%%!''% (5(' 1%5
0
!"#$ %&"'
!()$* "&#
'# !+,
"&#