High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/937/2022dismissed

State Of Haryana v. Shubham Alias Shubhi And Others

2023-05-24Mr. Justice Deepak Gupta17 pages

!

""#$ *+,

- .

/*0

1,

/23245/232 6 2,

,7 6 , % & 89%

/ :

:

;

" ""

#$ % & '

( )# ** +# *, * * - ../" .01$- - '2 . 3!!4 " .05 67 - "/ "/ " .0 * 8 # 9*'

( */:./03/04" .." 8/40 8 7$;*"3*

<

**

#

* * .::

7*

" ""9*'

( ":

" ""

9*

'

( )* *

9*

) *

)*

*+*

+ "!

" ""

)+/.

" "" ) *+*+* ) *

#$

) ) 7* .:: #*

* * :

7+)*

** *

) * +* # 9*

'

( + "!

" "" # * 9* +* ( 3*+ *

9 *

*

* ** <$

* *

* + #

## ## #

=+)

* $ )

*#< $ >

* * ** * ( * ""

" .0 # ../

)* '

) ?

& 8 * - "> 4"

7) ) ) #)# )* ** # * ) * ( #*(#

)*

* "@

# *() <)#* +

)

*

# <

) (* <#

( * *( * *

) ) # )** 9* *

# (?+.. &" -( )

* 7) #* *

* * ( ) A'

* *)# #

+ # ( ) *** *"!

" .0 9 + # * ** # $**) ) B$$%C) ** ( < ( - B$$%C

B$$%C) :

" .0 4 " .0 @# * # ** 8 *><

#(

*, #()*+< ( @**

* *# (?+) *+

B$$%C * * * ** )*+ ** - 9+* * -* ** *) *+ B$$%C * + * ) /@

* ** # A #( A #- A- < ( D) #$$% ,

) ) & +& *8

* #

*

** )* *." 8/:./40 8 " . 7$)* * 9 ** < ( E * )

+ "0 " .0

< +* * E .4)

** )* */./$ $

)*+* ** *

* )++* *) *# # < $ + *, .

7*#

< $

*, ** #

* * ++ * * * ** ) +* < * #)#+ < **#

** )*# #*+*

) **+* <*+ + #)* ))

* +

* F #

*, *+*

:@

** ) ..

*

< $ $

."

% < $ *# #

* +* # * #

* )

!"#$

%

&

'

(

)*+ ,#'

-

" .

% /

)

%

)

% /

) %

%

-

0 % /

%

1

&

%

1

-

2

/

/

3

%

%/

/

/

&

$ 1

/

%

%/

45

/

6

7 0

3@

"

%

"8339:

%

010

% "

%

;<#5 & &

"

/

%

%

%

"

%

" 8339:

&

"

#

1

/

%/

5 0

&

<

% < #2+

/ #'

"

&

'

( % /

)

% 1

% /

%

=

1

%

1 - )

%

-

/

&

$ 1

#2+

* 1'

&

#>

%

/

)

45/

1

"

)

8#2+:

%

)

>@

/

%

2

1

%/

)

/ ;<#

&

<

%

%

0 ? %

/ #'

/

%

/

&

0 &

& / %

&

?

% & %

%

%/

/ /

&

1

%

/ * '

;<#7

6

)

/

/

;<#7)

%/

)

> %

< #2+

%

"

& /

/

%

6 /

#2)3"

"

% / &

")=

/

+

#2+

% /

-

% /

4@

-

%

%

%

/

/)

&

< 1

&

&

%

%

/ 1

% < #2" 3 > 75

"#

" )

< %/

#% #

"8339: 0 "8339:

&

& /

%

%/

1

> %

%

> "

%

;&

%

& /

/ %/

@ ?

#2+

%

% /

& /

% /

&

)

/

%/ /

% /

% #

#2*"0A %"

"

%

"8339: %

010

%

=

/ / / %

%/ = B / / !@

%

" 8339: ?

"

%

%

;<#5 & &

&

9

1

"8339:

;<#

#2*"0A %"

& %

9

"

%

"8339:

% /

."%=%

;<#70 7

"

%

;<'=7 "8339:

5

% ;<'=5 ;<'=@

> )*+

"

%

"8339:

%

> )*+

&

&

/ ;<#= < / *

"

%

)

/

(

%/

/

& ;<#7

;<'

&

/ ;<#5 #2+"0"

-"

+

> #8

: 1

% 1

;<# & &

%

&

%

%

B %

&

$

> # 8339:

= @

> #8339:

& ;<#

> #

/

/

0@

%

& ;<#@

/

&

;<#

% %

B %

1'

%

& %

9 1

#

&

!9#>

& '

- 9

>

/

&

;<#7

%

%/

&

'

%/ & 0 >

/

> )*+

&

/ ;<#71

#

& ;<'=#>

<1'3

;<'=@ ;<'= %

B %

#>$ %

#- % " $ %

B

)!?3% %

"$0;<'= ;<'=+

&

/ ;<#7

/ #2*"0A %"

#2+"0

-

#2)3"

"

#2 )3 "

& "

#2 )3 "

/ &

%

#2*"0A %"

"

%

"8339:

% %

010

."%

) / #2*"A %"

#2)3 & "

/

%

%

#2*@A %"

% %

010

% /

. @

/ /%

= B / / "

%

" 8339: ) #2)3"

& "

/

- &

"0A %"

"8339:

1

& %

9

& &

)

"

%

#2)3"

& "

"

%

"8339:

%/#2*"0A %"

"

/

#2* "0 A % "

%

9

"

%

"8339:

#2)3"

& "

<

"0A %"

& %

9

)

%

"8339:

)

)

)

)

&

%/

%

- >

)*+

#2*

"

%

"8339:

/ &

%

;<'=5 ;<'=@

&

/ ;<##2*"0A %"

& /

&

/

1

"

&

/ ;<#

&

/ / %

..@

&

/

&

/

&

1

%

1

/

%/

&

/

%

/

%

?

#2*"0A %"

&

"

*3 #3

%/ ;& 1

0

&

> &

1 &

7 >

%

%

>

C& /

)

@

%

( "0'

% %

%/

&

&

A "

1 %

%

%/ & ;<#@#25 "04")=$

!

%

%/

'

&

0

<

'

1

% 5 #

"

%

;<'=

#8339:

& #>

1

8

:

% %

;<'= ;<'=+

B %

;<'=@ ;<'=

."@

>

;<'=

/ ;<'=0

&

/ %

% & %

/

&

/ %

1'

B %

!

& 9 #>

=

#2+"0"

- "

#8339: >

%/ )3"

)3!

% "

/

) #2)3"

"

<

/ % ) &

/ 1

%/

/ % * ?

<

*1'

&

#>

%

C& >

/

$

;<#7

%

C& "

>

0

/

&

"

6

& %

& %

)

/

%/

#2+

/ 1'

0

<

/1'

& #>

%/

& 0

%/

+ '

%

% 1'

%

B ./@

% B "

/

>

&

&

%

% ;<'=5 ;<'=@

%

&

2

&

%

@ 1'

;<'=#@ ;<'=

1'

%/" % 0 = $

1'3

%/" $ 0

/ < '

/ @

1'

% "

/ %

%

5@*5++ )!?3$ ;<'= (

-

/

# %

**+ #- > $ ;<'=5 (

-

- "

/

+@

%

%

7@@ #- %D" $ ;<'=

(

-

-

"

/

3 B %

;<'=7

% (

- B

%

B

%/(

- ;<'=*

B %

)!?3$

& %

B (

- # %

;<'=+

> *7*77 A "

3

> "

3

1

(

-

"

B %

;<'=7 ;<'=*%

(

- %

B %

B

)

;&

%

B %

#2* "0 A % "

7 .:@

"

%

/ &

&

/ ;<#+

;<#*0

<

7

)

;<#*

% &

?

%/

%

%

%/ #2)39

"

<

* 3 #3

&

%

/

%/

&

)

&

%

%

/

% %/ &

/

#2+ "0 "

- "

8

:

%

%

&

/ ;<#@

;<#+

)

% *

%

0

<

%

1

/ %

1

"

%

%

1

8

: % ?

%/ .3@

-

&

%/#2*"0A %"

#2+"0

- "

1

/

/% / - &

> %

%

&

% % & % / %

/) /

% % % / %

%

%

1'

%

B %

<

/ %

/0 &

&

/

% 0& &

&

% /

% %

%/ < %

%

%/

B

E ./

+ +#< $ $ +* *# * #

* ** +#+ # # $ '

** + ** ( ** *(

* # ../

* # < $ ** # A #( A # -A- B

C ) # #+ # % < $ * # # *+ *

* # ) +#**)*

.>@

=+) *+) #+ ) #

.:

7+) *

)*+) +# ## # 9

%0-; ! ' :

) -( <

F (G HG- F # HG- .4@