Amrit Lal v. Surinder Pal Jain
!"#$"%&'&#()*++* ,-&!. / 0"!&!&#("- 1"-'2' 32-&(4"- / &( 0+"'5#(4"(!
#- ,)
#(67/" -+2'!&%"+3+8 /& -"'"(!)
-+-2(3&(9/ :41#% !"$#-!;"5"!&!&#("-+ <<< +3+8 /& :+ - /
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
> ;" 5"!&!&#("- ; 4 !;" -","4? #$ %; //"(9&(9 !;" #-4"- #$ ''"'',"(!#$5-#1&'&#( /-"(! ', 4"7?!;"/" -("4"(! #(!-#//"-72! '; '7""( 4,&!!"47?/" -("4%#2('"/$#-!;"5"!&!&#("-:(#%; //"(9" @ ' , &(! &("4 7? !;" 5"!&!&#("- !# !;" ''"'',"(! #$ 5-#1&'&#( / -"(! , 4" 7? !;" "(! #(!-#//"-+ ;" 5#&(! &' (# /#(9"- (4 '! (4' '"!!/"4 7? !;" 4"%&'&#( #$ #(67/" !;" 325-"," #2-! &( % '" -"5#-!"4 ' C
6:
!
" ' 5"- @;&%;: #(%" #-4"- #$ 5-#1&'&#( / ''"'',"(!; '7""(5 ''"4 (4!;"-"&'(#'! ? 9 &('!!;" ' &4#-4"-:!;"!"( (!&'7#2(4!#!"(4"-!;"-"(! ''"''"4#(!;"$&-'!4 ? #$;" -&(9 $!"-5 ''&(9'2%;#-4"-#$ ''"'',"(! (4#($ &/2-"!#4#'#: (#!;&(9-", &('!#7"4#(":"D%"5!!#5 ''#-4"-#$"1&%!&#(+"/"1 (! "D!- %!#$!;" $#-","(!&#("44"%&'&#(&'-"5-#42%"4 '2(4"-) #$ % &'(( ) *% ( *$ !! ' + , + - ., , + ( . ( + ( . (%% + . /( ( (. ( +%
% & ( *$ !! . 0 12 3
( ('*4"4( .! .! ( ' ! (. ( - ., , , . ( , +.
* . + . .( .+ +, ., -. % $% 5. (,' + . . . ( + . . .( , % "% 5 . . (,' .( .%. ( (' -, ( . . , 2( . . ( , . % 6% . . 2( , ( ' . . , .
( . ( % . , ./(' , ( .% .' ' , . .(' , ( ( ( . , . , .( '.
(% ( .(% 7%
/( ( . .. ,. .('. . ( ( , ' , . , (,. (%8
B (%" !;" 5#'&!&#( &' ' 7#1": !;" &,529("4 #-4"- #$ "1&%!&#(% ((#!7"' &4!#7"'2$$"-&(9$-#, (?&($&-,&!?+ (1&"@#$!;"5#'&!&#((#!"4 7#1": '@"// '!;"4"%&'&#( #$ #(67/"!;"325-"," #2-!&(C
9( !(# 9-#2(4' @; !'#"1"- "D&'!' $#- &(!"-$"-&(9 @&!; !;" &,529("4 #-4"-'+ %%#-4&(9/?: $&(4&(9 (# ,"-&! &( !;" &('! (! 5"!&!&#(: !;" ' ," &' 4&',&''"4+ +3+8 /& 249" *++* :
2 9
) ;<
) ;<