Dilbagh Rai Dhingra v. State Of Haryana

 

  !"!#!

$!!! !#!

  

%&'()*+(,-.-)/0 10  %-23&45&-%5-/46& 000('-'-)/(6 7(6.8. 9'&'()*&6:&/& 000(.;)/+(/'  !<= >"?< @ A!<!!

#!

$ 6(.(/' 60B&8'&C%8''DE+F),&'(D*)6'5(;('-'-)/(60 60G&2H-/+(69-/457-6ID960%EBD&6:&/&0 60&J&/&2-IDE+F),&'(D*)6'5(,)C;2&-/&/'0 KKK !<!!

#!

$L @ 0 M5( ;6(.(/' ;('-'-)/ 5&. 3((/ *-2(+ 8/+(6 9(,'-)/ N
600
0 *)6 46&/' )* &/'-,-;&')6: 3&-2 ') '5( ;('-'-)/(6 -/ OP Q)0RD +&'(+ 00  8/+(6 9(,'-)/ N P

9(,'-)/. NRD NRD N &/+  G P
&++(+ .83.(S8(/'2:

&' )2-,(9'&'-)/)+(2M)J/D(J&6-0 0 M5( *&,'. &. /&66&'(+ -/ '5( OP &6( '5&'D '5( *&'5(6 )* '5( ,)C;2&-/&/' &/+ )* '5( ;('-'-)/(6 5(6(-/D /&C(2: T-.5&/ U&2 &/+ )5&/ U&2 6(.;(,'-F(2:D )J/(+ V .5&6( (&,5 )* & .5); Q)0 -/ Q(J 9&3W- &/+-0 E*'(6 F(6-*:-/4 &22 '5( +),8C(/'.D '5( &6I('
)CC-''((D (J&6- (/'(6(+ '5(-6 /&C(. )/ 2)' Q)0 F-+( &;&' Q)0 ND )/ 0 01 0 M5( ,)C;2&-/&/' &/+ 5-. *&C-2: '5)845 J(6( -/-'-&22: 8/&J&6( )* '5-. *&,'D J(6( -/*)6C(+ '5&' '5( 5&2* .5&6( )* '5( ;2)' 3(2)/4(+ ') '5(-6 *&'5(6D .-/,( +(,(&.(+ &/+ )3'&-/(+ '5( ,(6'-*-(+ ,);-(. *6)C '5( 9(,6('&6: X0 0 &6I('
)CC-''((D (J&6-0
)C;2&-/&/' ,&C( ') I/)J '5&' )/ 00 D & *)64(+ -/+(C/-': 3)/+ J&. .83C-''(+ 3: '5( ;('-'-)/(6 &/+ )'5(6

  

  !  "#

  $% &' 

 



(  % # #

   ##) *  + & 

  

), - *     ) . **( ++  & 

 &%  )+#      # #

 *     ,, 

 & &) &%  +    '

 * *  ++% 

) 

 (  % #  )+# * * + /, $  &% 
)),     $  +#
 #  +% $  

 # 1

 $ **( $  &2 * +(

 + )+#  * 

( ++%, , "   #  +  &)     * (#

   *  *  )+#   *  *  +  $ 2  + * +

#*  

 /$ 3&4  , 0*   *  *  *  )+#   *

 &2   + $  * *( *  *) *  + ,  + 6- $  #% $ )(  1 ) % *)

)  



 & *##% )+#, / ##  * 

 )      +    *  *  )+# 

)#*

 # 7 

  *( *  + ,  +   %  $##

 2  (    +$ , ., "  3  #  &%  # *  )+#   &)   )+#  $ & +



(

   #  ) &*   
 #
 , $(  ) #

 & #  + 7 $

 &

  (, 8

+  % *  +

   *  + 

 '  )+#    *# 2 

 6- /,9.  , ,    3 :0  .   9 -
 # 3 $
% 8

  

 !  " "#  "

$!

 !" % & !"  ""$ "  '( ( "

) ! 

 * +"  " " *  ("! "" "#  $"   , "  "+  #" " (   # "(  (

*   +, $$ " " #!(   +") #!(     ( "  "

$! * () ,$,#"  !"# $$"   - ".%! *  /($ 
"(    "#0 34567897:7800 ;<20 =5:>?@A:7@>00 AB00 CDBA:?>8>D@E0

 F F /

G)

 "%+ ) !,)   $ "# $" ( "#  +" "  ( " "!,  $  "#   ( %( +! "  $($" " ( / " G

  &", $"    

 " % &  $!, *  $+! "#  $ %! "(! %  "!,  & $"!  *  '( !  " "# ($"  "(

 " % $"$!, &  # $$! " "#

  "  (  +, "#   ("I $"%!, "# $$!  #! '(   "  # " "       #  #"  "#  $", %!

J "#  $", %! " "

 & #   $  "# +" "#  "##  

 )  "(

( %  ( $  ! &  ( $" #"  "#  $", %!

K $", %!  " " %  

 "# (!  

 " %  "!,   "(  "+   & $"!  (   & " " "  &",  , L  * 
"( + "  F   )

 ,   "# $" #" # ! 

" $" ) "  (% "

 %, ! "(! #"  $   $ + !  !! " &$!"  $"%!, "# "

$"

     '"( "    ) "

 



 

 ! " # $   %# % $ 

 &$ #     %  ' #

( # 

#!

# # $   $  

'#  " $$

" % # ' #  #

 % )

 *+ + +  %(

 + +  #



# $    '% #

# $  $#, ,   #

"$  % # - !

 ' # "



#  #

 ! %#  # ' -  # " #   - . - /0 %# #  '#.

 #  '#+ 1#

"$    ( )  

 # ' # 

# $

# .

, !

%# #  /0

 2  34    *  % ' 

 # " + 1#  $ , .  !  ., #



# $    #   /0 # .  " .,#4  2 5 '% (  + + + + 1# 6 # .  $ 

 

 7 899:;<=:77 >?@AB7  $ %# # #  ! ( )  

 # $ 

#

"$   '  



 C D +D +

"

(
   '



$ (  D,  ' 

$  + # '$#

# ) 

"$  %  $ 

 

7 899:;<=:7>?@?7 + 3+ 1# '  '  # $    # /0 . '

#( ' !

'

"

$ # $ $, %# # %  #  "

# !#

#

"$   .

 %# # #,

'# 

 

# $  E% F'. - G #%+ 1#

.H 





#

"$  #( ' .

  )   ., #



# $    ' $ ,

# $ $   %# 



 # #  

# $   % . ' # %  # " %#  

# $   % ,  .!

 # &  # !

  

- $ + 1#

   '   . H   # $$# 

# $   # ' #

"$  

# %    "$ ' % # # (     

  

     !

"

# $ %  !

%$"
%$ # &! !

' $"

&! !#  ' ! (

 %   %!

$ !



$%  

  !  

! (



!



%  $ )  ) *+ ,-.-/++ 0/10/2/3-/4++ 56++ -7/++ 89:9;9++ <29++ =3>?++ ,7.0@.A+ BB )
))
 D# E ( F!

G%"
% ! (

!  $  &!

%

 ! (



 !

%!

  (

$

 !

$$%

# !

 $  ' (

 !% !

$%      $"

H%  %"

$#&!  '$"'( ) ) I( F!

G%"
% + 8:;++ <29++ ,.3-J27++ K.03.3>+ #

  G

  G
C#+ ,.473.++ 87.L47.06++ <29++ ,-.-/++ JM++ N.O.2-7.3A+

  G

P G
DB#+ Q09++ R.0/27++ KL@.0++ S.3T?.++ <29++ ,@-9++ =3>-.++ =T.0U.?++ .34++ V029+ #   G

  G
 B# &!

W"%  !

&  $"' (

+ ,>447.0.@++ ,.-?>3T.11.++ S7/-0/++ <29++ ,-.-/++ JM++ S.7.0.27-0.+ #

   G

DBC# &!$! 

(   !

" 

(' !

% X $! + YL05.Z27++ ,>3T7++ ,>55>.++ <29++ ,-.-/++ JM++ [L3O.5+ #

B  G

D !

!% \) F!

% 

'  !

$$%  !

W$   !

$$%

% ( ""

 ' $" !

(   

] ) F!



  !

"" $ $ %  !

$   &!

!

!

$$%

! " % ' %

 "  $$('
% "

$'$ ^(  $ ] ) F!

"( '!

"" $

_%$ ] ) F!

"( '  !

$$%

 ` !  "

  !

!

 $ ) WW WW WWa ) *    '  ! $"' (    ! ! ' (



 $ ') F!

% % $% % '    !

$  $$%$    '   % $# ( & !

 

 

  !

!" #$ %% $ & ! ' !    $! %(%$&$ )!  *$'$&+! , , -$ &* * & !

  !

! .% $ $ %   &

  %

 ) % "

$ * $ '  

 '. !& & '! )% #%% $ ' $ $*$ .!* & $

! !  %.

%! ! *'! ! %! $ ! ''$ ! & $ &%

* $ * $ # !!!  ' * #$ $ .

" #$ $ $! )  '%& ) $

 ! &  )., -$!" $ '! 

! #$ .# $ %*$ & $ && +*  !" $!
 & ! $ '   )

 %  *  &

!! &  ' )%, !% % " $'! ' !! !!, /, -$ )!.  $ ).    & $ ''! &   * $ '!  '

   )

! ! '!! &'   $ !&$ !, 12324056278629:0;0 <<=>?=@>@A0 B78CD0 ( F$$!'( *G!  H!GI F$$')% H!GI