Naresh Kumar And ANR. v. The Appellate Tribunal And ORS

 

   
      

!"#$%&#'()($* + +

!,#)-./0!,!*&!*$"-#, ++++#"("($*#,) 1#,)/) -# 22#33!"# ,(4/*!35 6!(*"#*!*'# 7 #3%!,#  $%  !,#*") !*& 8#*($,
("(9#*)'"5!*&$"-#,) +++++#)2$*&#*")
6  :;6+8
1.8 ;










<<<< 1.8 ;5+ ;












 

!










 "


# "


$% $&


'

(
 %)


*










 +
 ,-

. , 
#

'/0
1
2) 3"#
"


#





$-

, '

(
 4)

*
 






" 


$% $&


' %)


# 5






 ,


4

*




 






'

(
 )




6


7
.
8


$$4
'



9 

$$4:)

"







*





;



!








*
 ,




 8




!

<
/
!
" 
,







 *





 


* 
;
!







#

 
 ,
  =# 

*


"
 
 #



""

*
*






  ,



*

 >
!

 




"

"

 , 

#

#

 

!
" 
&








*
 ,




  
#

*
"
#



 


?@
1"

% $-

$-


 *



#
 (
"






!
" 
-






 



#=


"



#

##
 

"
 

 "

 ,


#*
## 
!
" 
$
 






#


# 
"
*
   ,



"




 *



# 


(

(

!



" 
%


 




#*





# 



>
 *
'

(
 )


*













 *


  ,



8




 


*



 





 

,










#



"


# 
*








 





" 
$
 

 *


# 





 " ,


?
"
3"#


 $% $&


 






 ,

 






; 









" 





 


#
 


.
?
0
' )
5 


 






 ,




  




*

;

"

 

-4,
!
" 



 *
#

 #




#











?2


# (
3"#


$




?2




 


#@
 
#
 



#

 "*








 



"
6 &,, 




 
 >





.





 

#*
 




 
*




 *

@


#*


 






*



#




$-

,
'

(
 4)


"




 $% $&





*

?
"
3"#









#
*

#



*
#

"*








 # 

*




  %

A






 "#

"



*




 
"#

*









*

;

 
1
+
<#*
 *

*

 ,







 
"#

*







 

#*
#
 


*




  ,




;



"

 

 ,



 



 "





#

*

;

!






"#




 
 '
(
 

 ,)


"#

*
 













 # 
#


 
5




 

.#
2 
/
.

>



 6 %4%%

$&







A
"
 #







*
 



>"#

A











 


$-

,
'

(
 4)






#  



 
*



 






 # 




 


?

"






$% $&




*
 ?
"



#


 


 






 







 


*

?
"
#



 

"






!

 #



 
#


#*

#

"


 $% $&















 


 @ 


 ,



8


  


 




##






 ,




4
*

"
!

" 
 




=# 
'

(
 )

 *

*
 ,





8

 







 


 *

#
 








 




# 








 


*
 ;


 *



 ,





 '

(
 )







 


 


  

                        !

"#  $%   &'



((         )          *'    "    

  "*' 

+

!

>
 *

*




 
 










#

#
 

 ,


 *
'

(
 )

 


 


  

           





"&  ,    )"   %      * %*  *'  % 

" + &

?"



"#







*










$ -4,
' ,)

 
*





  



 = 


#



 , "








*

 



*

;







*


#




 ,

  

"










$ -4,
' ,)


*
 

 
 ,


 


*
 ;





 


*
"
  


#


"#

*


 










#


*

;


*

 
1
+
<#*  *
*

# *
#
!


  
*










 @


 *
'

(
 )


#


,








 ,


 


 ;



 






#


 



"







*

"

*
#
#


#





*








(






#*



*



*
 ,
#











$ -4,
' ,)






 ,
"








*


 
 #





*
















*
  
1
+
<#*
 *
* 
 

>
*
*


# 
>


 

*

;


 
1
+
<#*  *
*




 


#
! ##*
"
@


"



"
 



#







*
 *


"
#
*
"
 ,


 
 
*








"
*  
"


*

;

 ,
 *
"




#

*

;

 

"#

*






> -



"#

*













#*
#
 





 ,





 


>
!


*

*










*
#

 

*
#* #

#=(


 *



















 


*
"



2
  
 

'

(
 

 ,)




 




*
*


#




 

#
*








=




 *















 ,
'

(
  )


 "
"


#





   ,








 

 

 





 ,

"

  






#





 
#


 

 
#
 


  ,









'

(
 ,)

*


"



 



" 


 






 


* 
;






"




 #*
#


"






*









 


##*

"



#



"




*


#





>
* *


# 
>





 





*
"


*

; $



"#






 








# 



 

 
*

 
5




.# 2 
' )




> 
+C 
. #





9

  

    

                 



! "#
$%

 


 
 

.
8

$$4


*












*

( 



#






8

















#


"
 #


2





B


 >"#

 

 


))) ))) ))) ))) ))) )))

"

  &  '

  !

# &
  %(

 




 

 



 (  

 



)

 



   

*  &

 +  

  ' '+, 



(

+ 

 *       

* 

 ‟   -       *        &   

    

&  &   .  



(

 *  & 



* ++ 

/ 

* 0   (    

 



*  &     * &

 &

   1 (+

 

 

   &

    

   1 

  




   1  , $ * 

  

   *  (  &     

   2

       

      &

   1  3*  ( 

+

+   

&

&  &

        + 





  


94* 5


  

 '',   (  6 ))    

 

 $

%

@"



>"#
 
+C 
. #




   7  

!

#   






*






$$4






>"#




9 - "."%  & /*   0 "

1  

"    %,     ((23 4       "  0  5   ((23    ,"

 

 
    " 

'    6 +  *.

   3   " " " %, 

       4

    "    1  

"  -

* , "  

"  *    "*' *  

'  

 %   *              "  3 ,  ."  

   

"%  ,     "!  , 

 %  7 % 82   '    ,

   % " (  * , ."%    " "" 9

)))))))))))))))))) 

    & 

)  

)

 &

  

   





/ 

 *  &

 



 

 +  


    1  , $*

&

   &

   1   (

 *  *  

& *  (



  

)

   

 *&

 

    *

 9
   1  ,( )))))))))))))))))) 8 ,*   * ' " :'  ,*   * % ) %"   %        06    ((2     ,    * %         

 , ' ‟
;    "  "       ,      



  

%  %  ,  

" % "   "  "  -" %  )   


'+  %  * "   %' 

%


' '

1"+  "     " 
%             

'+ :, "%  %,     ,     *'   < "  "    

 "0  -0   --    " 
;       "      06 + +        

 -:    &  8 &    :   & 
    1 ; 2    :*.

"!  "           9 -     *

&

.   

 



*  &



0+ * (  + 

 &

) &   (  & 

   /

& 

& 

< (

   (  + +

+  +&

   

+        2

     /&    &   

  *    

  )      

 

 *    

    &



    %

          "     0 "    0 



" 2  

" *  =

 %  ) , &     " , 

  ) , "

 "'  ,           ))))))))))))))))))  ))) ))) ))) &         "     6   *%       

"  * %

    

'     6 



%   

(   

"    *     "  *'    ; 

*

 ""   2 

' 

 ," "  >#" 

  0,0 

 ," "  > # ))) ))) ))) ))) ))) ))) )))+

D



"
A ,&4 ,

"

 >"#



# ,








 
*

+C 
. # 





*
 ,=
8 
 


*

# 


"#

 






>

%

!








 
5
 





9=



,

   

 ''=        

 ;
 

 

! #44! * # >$

 



 

-?>.* +&*   (.&

   

  



, * )

     &

     1    &

    &      &   &  

- ;   



      *

 ?@8 



&

       



 



, )

  

   & 

     1   *   

   (     

A*  

    A  *



(   (+  (  

& 

  ()     &

:   2

 

  &

)     (

     &*  &

, :  &

 + &

 

   *   & 2 

 ) &

   <

 ( *  &   

 &

 ( )       &*&

   1  8(     ?     ?, <   0  "" 9 
-    ' " 

"  2  '1 '%   "1% 

 % 

 0,0   * %1 %'   

 % , 

"% ' *  ""%    

 -  , ' *.

,   

"  2+ 8    *           1 %'  

"  > '  "   8' "   "  "



 &

 )    &   *      &  

+  



* +



 + 

 *   &





,


 B*   *  





 

   1   

A&

  

+

/



A  

  *  

+ ( * +



 + 

 *   &




 B*  ( * 





, "%  &

 *   ( 

< 
      
)

*  5         =  (       (

   9' - C

 *  

  

  & 2 * 

&

&+

   

 & 

 &





*  &

,

         

&)

 

, 

*   4



&

; 8@ "

* !" % <    0  1"

 0     .*3   

(@       "  ,  ,       ((2" '!  "  " "  "

" , '    

)  &

 


 6    ( 

 &  (+ / +

&& &+



  

  *   )   &

 
 
 +

. 

  

 

 (  *  



 &

   *   &  *    

  

$  ,(       



    





,(    

   *   & 

 

+   &

  

   ;

B

A &B% $
"


>"#



 



$

,

!





*

 


 

;




8= ,
! 



'

(
 )

 



#
*  ,


# 
"

#
*
#


 







 *
!






 &







 ,





#

*

;


#


 


 

?@
1"

% $-

$-


 *
 

#



(
 
#



#
*
 ,


 -








 



#=


"



#

##
 
"
 




"

 ,


#*
## 
<
# 

#


%















""





 ,
 

*

 >



"
"
  ,


#

#



;  
"
%B


 @


"#

*

 




*

 



 
 


"


# 


*




"




 



 ##
3"#







 ,
 



=# 


#

*
 


  


#*






"


 




*

"



 *
  ,

.





*






 


#




$-

,

 "


#


# 



 

"







$% $&




#

# 4

E "



  


#
 

$% $&


"
"




 
 

 





"
#


#

"*

#

#




1.8 ; $>#04#,5

     1 6
= @"F G 6
  F G