Chandgi Ram Mittal v. Housing Board Haryana And Another



      

!"#$ "%&'&#(
)
)

 * (+,& -.&!! / )))))"!&!&#("0 1"0'2'

#2'&(,# 0+ 03 (  (+ (#!*"0 )))))"'4#(+"(!'

.56.)777 0"'"(! .0)8 0 (* 0+9 :;+<#% !" $#0!*"4"!&!&#("0) .0)'*9 (& /9 0;+<#% !" $#00"'4#(+"(!#)) .0)8 4&/ (' /; ; 03 (  $#00"'4#(+"(!#)
=7! !") 77 ;)  >6?

) *"40"'"(!90&!4"!&!&#(* '@""($&/"+2(+"00!&%/"

A=

 #$!*"#('!&!2!&#(#$(+& $#0&''2 (%"#$ ( 440#40& !"90&!&(!*"( !20" #$ %"0!&#0 0& $#0B2 '*&(,!*"#0+"0+ !"+ ) )
>(("C20"
? (+ #0+"0+ !"+
) )
D>(("C20" ?4 ''"+@30"'4#(+"(!#)<&+"

9*&%*!*"%/ &-#$!*"4"!&!&#("0$#0!*"4 3-"(!#$#("-#(!*' / 03&(/&"2 #$6$#0!*"/#%E " 0

* '@""(0":"%!"+)
) *"  %#(!0#<"0'3  &(<#/<"+  &(  !*"  40"'"(!  % '"  &'  !* !  !*" 4"!&!&#("09 '9#0E&(, 'C"%2!&<"(,&(""0&(!*"0"'4#(+"(! #2'&(, # 0+ "4 0!-"(! (+9*&/"*"9 '&('"0<&%"*"9 '&''2"+%* 0," '*""!

(++&'%&4/&( 0340#%""+&(,'%#--"(%"+9*&%*2/!&- !"/30"'2/!"+&( ( #0+"0  #$  %#-42/'#03  0"!&0"-"(!  #(  A)D)
 )  *"0"  9 '  (#!*"0

+"4 0!-"(! /40#%""+&(,'4"(+&(, , &('!!*"4"!&!&#("09*&%*%2/-&( !"+ &(!# (#0+"0#$+&'-&'' /#$!*"4"!&!&#("0#(D)
)
9*&%*9 ' $!"0!*" #0+"0#$%#-42/'#030"!&0"-"(!)*"4"!&!&#("0$&/"+!*"'! !2!#03 44" /' , &('!@#!*!*"#0+"0'#$42(&'*-"(!9*&%*9"0" //#9"+@3!*"44"// !" 2!*#0&!3#(D) )
)*"0"'4#(+"(!

"4 0!-"(! '' &/"+!*"#0+"0#$ 44"// !"2!*#0&!3@3$&/&(,#$!*"90&!4"!&!&#(@"$#0"!*&'#20!@" 0&(, 
D
9*&%*9 '2/!&- !"/39&!*+0 9(@3!*" "4 0!-"(!#(

))
A)#9"<"0;&(!*"-" (!&-";!*"4"!&!&#("0* ' !! &("+!*" ,"#$ '24"0 ((2 !&#( (+0"!&0"+#( ))
 )*"0" $!"0;#()D)
A!*"

0"'4#(+"(!

"4 0!-"(!4 ''"+ (#0+"0#$9&!*+0 9 /#$@#!*!*"#0+"0'#$ +&'-&'' / (+#$%#-42/'#030"!&0"-"(!)*" $#0"' &+$ %!' (+!*"+ !"' 0" +-&!!"+$ %!' (+ 0"(#!+&'42!"+@3!*"/" 0("+%#2('"/$#0!*" 4"!&!&#("0)*"#(/3&''2"&(<#/<"+&(!*"40"'"(!% '"&'!* !!*"4"!&!&#("0 9*&/"&('"0<&%"2(+"0!*"2/"'9 '"(!&!/"+$#0#("-#(!*' / 03&(/&"2#$ (#( < &/&(,#$6&(!*"/#%E " 0#$

)1&+"(("C20"
;

!*"4"!&!&#("0* '@""(+"(&"+!*" $#0"' &+@"("$&!#$#("-#(!*' / 03#(/3 @"% 2'"#$!*"0" '#(!* !+20&(,!* !4"0&#+*"+&+(#! 44/3$#0!*"' -" 9*&%*2(+"0!*"2/"';&!9 '- (+ !#03$#0*&-!#* <" 44/&"+$#0!*" ' -") ) 6" 0("+%#2('"/$#0!*"4"!&!&#("0'2@-&!!"+!* !!*" %!&#(#$ !*"0"'4#(+"(!

"4 0!-"(!&(4 ''&(,!*"&-42,("+#0+"0>(("C20"
?

9 '!#! //3 0@&!0 03 (+%#(!0 03!#!*"02/"')"$20!*"0'2@-&!!"+!* !&!&' (#!&(+&'42!"!* !!*"4"!&!&#("09 '#!*"09&'""(!&!/"+$#0#("-#(!*' / 03 &(/&"2#$!*"6;* +*"@""(&('"0<&%" (+* + 44/&"+$#0!*"' -" +20&(,!*" $#0"' &+4"0&#+@2!+&$$&%2/!3 0#'"&(!*"40"'"(!% '"9 '!* !

/!*#2,*&!9 '- (+ !#03$#0*&-!#* <" 44/&"+$#0!*" $#0"' &+@"("$&! @2!!*"' -"%#2/+* <"@""( 44/&"+$#0$0#-))

!# )
)
 &)") $#0 4"0&#+#$$#203" 0' ! (34#&(!#$!&-";@2!*"9 '%#-42/'#0&/3 0"!&0"+@39 3#$ 42(&'*-"(!#0+"0#(A)D)
  (+!*"0"$#0";&(!*&' 9 3;*"9#0E"+$#0#("3" 0 (+"&,*!-#(!*'#(/3 $!"0!*" $#0"' &++ !" #$  ))

 (+  2/!&- !"/3  !*"  #0+"0  #$  %#-42/'#03  0"!&0"-"(!  9 ' "C!&(,2&'*"+@"% 2'"(#!#(/3*&' 44" / , &('!!*"#0+"09 ' //#9"+@2! /'#!*" "4 0!-"(!&!'"/$* +9&!*+0 9(!*" $#0"' &+#0+"0#()D)
A (+#(%"*"9 '(#!&('"0<&%" (+!*"0" $!"0;9*"(*"9 '0"&('! "+ (#!&#( //3 (+*"%#(!&(2"+!&// ))
 ;9*"(*" !! &("+!*" ,"#$ '24"0 ((2 !&#( (+0"!&0"+!*"(!*"0"- &(&(,4"0&#+#2,*!!#* <"@""( - +" < &/ @/"!#!*"4"!&!

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

) * <"*" 0+!*"/" 0("+%#2('"/$#0!*"4 0!&"') A) *"#(/3'*#0!4#&(!&(<#/<"+&(!*"40"'"(!% '"&'!* ! '!#

9*"!*"0!*"4"!&!&#("0;9*#+&+(#! 44/3$#0!*" $#0"' &+@"("$&!#$#(" -#(!*' / 03&(/&"2#$69&!*&(!*"@/#%E3" 0'! 0!&(,$0#-))

!# )
)
 %#2/+@"+"(&"+!*"@"("$&!#$!*"' -"&(<&"9#$!*"4"%2/& 0 $ %!' (+%&0%2-'! (%"'#$!*"40"'"(!% '")*"4"!&!&#("09 '&('"0<&%" $0#-))

!&//A)D)
 9*"(*"9 '%#-42/'#0&/30"!&0"+)*" $#0"' &+#0+"0#$%#-42/'#030"!&0"-"(!9 ''"! '&+"&('! !2!#03 44" /' $&/"+@3!*"4"!&!&#("0 (+2/!&- !"/3!*"#0+"0'9"0"9&!*+0 9(@3!*"

"4 0!-"(!#()D)
A)*"0"$#0";!*"4"!&!&#("0%#2/+(#!%#('2-"!*" "(!&0"4"0&#+#$$#203" 0'$#0@"&(,&('"0<&%"@2!2/!&- !"/3*"* '@""( 0"&('! !"+  (#!&#( //3  (+  *"  * '  @""(  0"!&0"+  #(  !! &(&(,  !*"  ,"  #$ '24"0 ((2 !&#(  #(  ))
 )  (  !*&'  9 3;  &!  % ((#!  @"  ' &+  !* !  !*" 4"!&!&#("0#2,*!!#* <" 44/&"+9*&%**"* '(#! 44/&"+)*"'! (+! E"( @3!*"/" 0("+%#2('"/ 44" 0&(,#(@"* /$#$0"'4#(+"(!#)@ '"+24#( 0"4/3$&/"+@3!*"0"'4#(+"(!

"4 0!-"(! (+!*"0" '#(&(,,&<"(&(!*"

&-42,("+#0+"0>(("C20"
?&'!#! //3 0@&!0 03 (+4"0<"0'")!9 '

@"3#(+!*"%#(!0#/#$!*"4"!&!&#("0!#* <" 44/&"+$0#-A)D)
 !# ))
  (+- :#0&!3#$!*"!&-"9 '/#'!@"% 2'"#$!*"#0+"0#$*&' %#-42/'#030"!&0"-"(!9*&%*2/!&- !"/39 '9&!*+0 9(@3!*"0"'4#(+"(!

"4 0!-"(!  &!'"/$  (+  !*"0"$#0";  '2%*  @"("$&!  % ((#!  @"  +"(&"+  !#  !*" 4"!&!&#("0#(/3#(!*",0#2(+!* !*"+&+(#! 44/3$#0!*""(!&0"4"0&#+#$ $#203" 0') ) (<&"9#$!*" $#0"' &+$ %!' (+%&0%2-'! (%"'; !*"40"'"(! 4"!&!&#(&' //#9"+)*"&-42,("+#0+"0>(("C20"
?&'*"0"@3'"! '&+") *" 0"'4#(+"(!

"4 0!-"(!'* // (#94 3!*" $#0"' &+@"("$&! #$#(" -#(!*' / 03&(/&"2#$6!#!*"4"!&!&#("0@3&,(#0&(,!*"$ %!!* !*"* +

(#! 44/&"+$#0!*"' -" '&!9 '@"3#(+!*"%#(!0#/#$!*"4"!&!&#("0; /#(, 9&!*&(!"0"'!FAG4"0 ((2-9&!*&( 4"0&#+#$ -#(!*'$0#-!#+ 3) 
)
)

  >77?

*2-&E    ) *"!*"0'4" E&(,=0" '#("+

"'=#
) *"!*"00"4#0! @/"

"'=#