Sarabjit Singh v. State Of Punjab
!
"
#$% &'
%()*)&+, - -
,
. / -
0 -0-0 /
. / 0-
0 /
!
"##$%&'(#)()'
!
* !
+ !
"##,(-$(#)()'
!
!
.*
!
"##/(/(0#)())
1 2 -0-0 /
- ,
4
5 4 * !
4 5 * 5 4!
3%#4)+5* )+
)
4 !67. 0$('
('
)(,' ! ), /, -$ .!!1 5!
! ! ! ,&-$ 8
!8 ! 0)( 0/% 0/- 0%,7 " ! )$ $0 $& 4 !
6
1!6
! 5 9 4 ! !4* * ! 5 # * 9
9: 4 !5 ! ; "+7 ,) (& )()' < #0* ! 67 : * 5)(,' *!
!
4 ('
(& )(,' ! ! !
)% (, )()) ! 5 !
'
7 !
54 ! * 9 4 ! 4 !#!!* 5 !5 4* 4 ! 54 7 ! ! 7 ! ! 5 = ! . +$(>%(%(* 4 !! )/ ('
)(,' 8 7
45 ! 5
5 !5!!
! " ,5 ,(4 &5 !5 7 ! 5 ), ,, )()' <4 5+1! 9 4 : 5 3 !4 4! 4 ! 5
! 45 ! + 9
7 * 4 4 9 4 ,, (- )()'
,% (- )()' *
* 5 ?
1** " 4 * 4 27@ "
#($* &'
$
67. /&,/ (0 )(,'
! )) )$ )%# )& /, -$ .1 !
6
1!6
/
* ,, ,( )()) <
#$5 ! ; "+7 !! ! *-5 * <# !!
7* ! : +($ > %(%( * * * !! * !
5 !! 5 ! 5 !4 -
$(( 4 <! * ! * 4 34
*5
4 *
%
! !!
54 : * 434
!
($ (/ )()) < #0
*! * !!;
A + 4
5 !! 534
4* = * ! !
4* ! 5 :
#($* &'
-
7
67 . $/ ,$ ($ )(,' ! '%& 0,, 0/- 0%, 0%'
,)(#+ 7 "
! ), )) )$ )$# )& .1 ! ! )$ $0 $& 4 !
+ 1! !
* !4 * /4
!
7 * 67 :
5 ! ; "+7 (& (- )()) ,% (- )()) < #, #' !
! ! ! 4 5 !
* !
4 ! ! ! ! ,-(5 (- (- )())
&
" * 4 4 "##$%&'(#)()'
! = !
! 4 7
! 0-)"
"
,(
"##,)()&#)(,' 5
7
* 5 4 ! * 5 * * * . +($>%(%( 3 !
! !* !5 3 5
4 ! : 3 * !
! (% ,( )(,$
!" #$%&& #'% $* ! "##)&,$#)(,0
5
* *4 !! * : 67. /& 67 . 0$ 3 ! @! * ! ! *5 3
! ! 5 * 47 ! ! 4+ "
7* ! "#00(%(#)(,$ * ** * 5 4 ,/ (0 )(,' * " " ! ! * *5 3 ! #
! "
"
! " # $ $ # %
&
'
( (
)
"
&* +,*-+-+ . /0 0
! !
. .
123 $ "
+4 + +52
2+
52
! "
.
.
!
600
!
. ."
0
7
'9:
+5 5+ 55;5
(
"
..
$0
< $0 )
&*+,*-+-+ . "
#
$
" .
<
$
. " 0 .
$
"
$
2+
( " + + +52
! "
.
=== === === $ "
. .
'>
% %
&
0 ++4
" # . .
%
?
9 % 1& 3 .
"
* "
!
# .
@ #
6!
"
( ( "
"
#
0 !
0 C +2 +2 +52
"
. .
(
"
"
. =
.
!
! . " "
.
0
.
!
$
(
" +4 + +52
! "
"
5++ ! " # %
&
' ( 2
.
$0 ) ! C &*+,*-+-+ .
.0
14 3 $ (
"
1 B#*#*5 + D* +523 +D + +52 ""
! . " 0
.0 0
+ +52 ,,
5 )% (, )()) * ! @
*4 5 !# + !
54 7 ?!!
*! <4 !
!67 ,)
> * !
4 4 5 ! ! ! * : * * * !5 BB ! ! * !#!! !! * !
7 * *! ! * * !
* *! 4 ! 5 !#!!# 1
,'
'
( ' 4 67. /&,/ (0 )()' ! )) )$ )%# )& /, -$ .1 !
6
1!6
&) )
'
* * + ,, '* - **( * ,0
!
4 67. $/ ,$ ($ )(,' ! '%& 0,, 0/- 0%, 0%'
,)(#+ 7 "
! ), )) )$ )$# )& .1 ! ! )$ $0 $& 4 !
+ 1! "##/(/(0#)()) * ! 5 !5
" * 4 ! ! 5 ! !#!! ,'
() )(,& !
5 )& (, )(,/ < #$ ! 5 !
!
4 ! !4 4 ! -) 5 ! ! )&&"
"
4 5!
* * 5* 3 !4 !
" !! 4 ! ! * ! !#!!,'
() )(,&
# %"
! "
9
" , :
" %
" % . B .
" B 9
"
" . .
"
.
,$
4 * * ! ,/%) *
5! * * !! ! 4 !!
" !! !#!!
" ##%$$#)(,& ;
A+ *! ! " . '/%'' '/-$')())5 ! !
! !!
* !
!
4 3 " )% (& )())
* ! # 9 C
B#*24-22* +
0
. 0
!
G.
"
9
6
9 &
! "
"
C 4 5 + +52
$ .
+2 +- +5D !
>
B" 6
.
0
.
0 .
/
" . = "
=
.
0 /
!
?" &
C" . 0
B#242* + . 0
"
B9* * -* +5D
0
" . .
.
"
0
"
"
! " . /
" 0
.
"
!
"
0
'"
,/
* * * : ! ; "#'/-$'#)()) 3 ,) ,( )()) ! * !!
4 *"! ! !
!5* * # >
"
""
" :.
- +D +
"
. ""
. "
.
/
. !
?"
" 0
" :.
!.
/
!
"
! "
= 0 ++++ "
$
.
$
0
>
,%
!* !!
!4 ! !! ! !* 5 *
" 4 5!
! C
! !
!!4 !4 5! 4 5!
*
! !!4 ! !! ! 4 <" .'
*'/ ('0( 1 * '"# %$2* * * 4 5 !! ! ! ! ,%')"
"
* !4 9
" * *
! !
!
! *
* !5 *4 ,-
7 4 !!4 ! ! 5 4 5!
* 5 5 !! ! !* " !
,&
4
)'' '
*' *3 4* * '" # % 2 " #; + !
* <4 D * ! ! ,&/% * ! 0'1 !4 ! ! ! ! 5 ! !!
* ! ! !! * ! 4 < !4 * *
)(
! ! 5 <4 *
! * 4 5!
!
!
4
),
0,, '* -"&) ) 55$ **( * ))
7 "##$%&'(#)()'
! 5! 5!
*!* ! * 4)
/(( 44 ,
* ** !
4! 5 !4!
<5 4 ,) '! ,)
! 45 /! ,,4 >#0% * ,( 4 4 * ! ? !!
* ! '% .1 ! 6 '
, * ' !
'
'! '
, 3 !!
! * ! 5)(,' ! 5 )% (, )()) ! *! ! *
)'
7 !
!!4 ! " * 5
4 ! * 5!
0,, '* -"&) ) **( * )0
9* 4 *! :
4! 4 4 ! * 4 27@ "
*! " ;
* 4 <4 27@ "
4 5 : 7 !
! ! *
: ! * 4 44 ! 5 27@ "
)$
!!
6 *( '
+
2 .19 C 7 ;D12@ ,$ ,) )()'
73 + .@;7 ;D12@ E
F F