M/S Vca Estate Private Limited v. Baldev Raj And ORS
!"!
#$%&%
!!!!!! "# $ %
& "'
!!!!!!("# # '$ ()'
% **
*
#)
!
*#'$ '# + ", -" ( "#!
!
.(/ + ", -" ("# # 0"! !
11111 *
*
%+ ,-.
!
2' (#
( - % $# , * "#, ,+ 33
' #- - 4' ,5+ / #6 (("
# # "% * "
(# ,!
!
# ,"$#% -" ( "# $* '
($$#, " ( *7 '
"$ ! ! + ' ' " 7 (" $, " #% 6 # *-" '
"$ ('"","(7 ' % 7 *# ,' %"#6 '
(# ( ##9$ !
2'
" #% 6 # ' *# '"8# '
"$ 8%% %# ,"$#% -" ("# # 0"!
!
# ,"$#% -" ("# # 0"!
' '
#"
($ '
6
6 # * #6 9,$ *8# ( + *$ ' '
"$
"' "*&, "# '
6 (# ( - % $# , ,!
2'
" #% 6 #+ - * #6 '"8# '
"$ %# ,"$#% -" ("# # 0"!
+ ' *# $# %# ,"$#% -" ( "#!
!
# ,"$#% -" ( "# $* ' ' 9 6 # %% *8# (
##9$ !
2' 6 # %% 8 -" ($(" % " %# *%"#6 #6 ("# #+ 6 #6 8'
,'
" # "#7 ' %"
*#
# ("# #+ 6 # ,"# # * ,%$+
!!+ %$ 0"!
+ 8'
,'
("
'
# #7
($ "
--#, #6 "$ 6 #+ '%% * - * * (", #6 '%% * ,"# $, *7 "% * " $$%%7 (("
# *7 ( !
: -$' $* '+ #,
($ " *8# ( + ( "# #" , $("# ("# #
##9$ ;
-"
"/ #6 * ,%$ %"
("(" # * "+ *$ (%7 8 ,
-"
("# # 8' '7
#" 6
(("
# # * "!
2'-"+ ' $* ' '
:"#5*% "$ 7 (("
# "% * " -" &$ , #6
($!
;!
"' '# + %# ,"$#% -" ("# # 0"!
$* ' ' ' -"$-"% "*&, "#!
< %7+ %'"$6'
' 9 * ,%$ %$ 0"!
+ 8'
,'
' *# - *7 %# ,"$#% -" ( "#+ 7
'"+ ' 9 #"' ,%$+ * #6 %$ 0"!
+ 8'
,'
("
-" 7
(, - , (-" #,+ '-"+ ( "# "$6' ' - % $ -" (, - , (-" #,
# - #6 (# ( $# , ,!
,"# %7+ 6#$ 6 # 8 "* # -"
("# # $# $# $
#-%$#, ,", "#!
2'
%7+ ,"# "# 6 # 8 # 6 *7 ("# # 8 %"
$#"#*%
#$!
<"$'%7+ ('"# #$ * 8'
,'
' *# # "# 6 # # ("# #
6 # "
#" *%"#6 ("# # # +
-,+ *%"#6 ( "# " #+ 8'
,'
$((" 6$ # ("# # ' ' 8 % # $# $
#-%$#, ,", "#!
# ,"$#% -" ("# # 0"!
-$' $* '+
8
-"$ "*&, "#+ (# (
*% *
!
!
: %"
$* '+
#"- # "#7 (
*7 ( "# ("# #
,"#,# + "#%7 "$# #-
- "$ ("# #
!
+3+ + 8'
,'
#"
($= '"8 + ("# # 7 %% #6 -$#
"$# ( "#+ '-"+ (# (
*% *
!
!
> ' ' %# ,"$#% -" ( !
?!
%$ 0"! 6 # (" $, '$# ) @
;
! !
" # $ %
&
&
' &
(
)
$
&( *+,
- &
( )&
& & & )
( $ !
$ *../
"
"
&0
1 A!
2' 6 # *8# ( + 8'
,'
" #% ' *# (" $, *-" '
"$ 8'
,'
' *# '"8# %#
,"$#% -" ("# # 0"!
8%%+ ' #" *#
($ *7 %# ,"$#% -" ("# # 0"!
!
2'
", * ,%$ *7
$#, #" ,
##9$ ; ' %"
#" *#
($ *7 %# ,"$#% -" ("# # 0"!
!
3!
2' -"$ "*&, "# 8'
,'
' *# *7 %# ,"$#% -" ("# # 0"!
,# * ,"# !
2' ,"# + '
-"$'
"*&, "#+ * #6 "
%(( #6
#$+ ,# * ,"# "6'!
!
> 8 6$ # %# ,"$#% -" ("# # 0"!
' 6#$ " #% 6 # 8 "* # *7 $# $
#-%$#, ,", ("# # ' # 6 ,"# "# 6 # 8 %"
$#"#*% %"
' ('"# #$ * 8
#,",%7 # "# !
2' "*&, "# --, '+ ,,"$# '"-+ ( $# , , 8"$% #" !
:"8 + '
"$
,"#
8 ' ' ' "*&, "# 8'
,'
' *# *7 %# ,"$#% -" ("# # $#$ #*%!
>
% %8 '+ 6 -#,+ "$ "#%7 '
9 #, * ,%$
", '"- *7
$#, #" ,!
"'
,"# "#+ 8'
,'
2 9
(# , # + '+ '7 #"
($ *7 %# ,"$#% -" ("# # 0"!
!
"
-
"*&, "# 8'
,'
' *# ,"#,# + '
"$ 8"$% #" 6"
#"
*,$
8"$% ,"# $
%+ 8'
,'
#" ( *% $# , ,!
-#, 6+ "$ 8"$% #" '"%
% *,$ ,"( $*&, '
* " #" *-" -#, "$!
2' 9 #,
8"
,"# "#+
!!
9 #, * ,%$
", '"-+
"#%7 * ##"'
#6 "+ #"'
#6 %!
-#,
'
6 7 * &$ 6 # :"#5*% $( "$
@
B+
!"
# %"
#"' &$ 6 # :"#5*% $( "$
@ #$%# % %# % & ''( % & )''&*1+
,( # '-"+ %8
#"
%"#6
0 3 4 !
-
+ ,
56 7**
%
**,/6$-
8 % &
2 &
2
(
***
9 % 4
**,/6$-
9 4
*/
2 &
**,/6$-
&
?
2 &( 9 4
*/
(
:
&
( **
(6
;
& ( (
&
0
**'
0
$ !
,$ -$ *+ (
<
5< &, - 3 ! !
%
&
%
(5 7. %
! 3 !
7 %
1
& &
&
(
& 0
$
& 7
1
%
&
=
**
%
(
$
( $ $
% 6 >?@ ,
- **A< (
& ! <
< &, -
2 &
&
B (
& , -
)! )CD, - 0
(
(
7
** % (
%6
(
&
<
5< &, - **+
7
( :
2
&(&$ &
0
&
(
&7
1 **/ 2
7
1
%
(
( 0 (
(
( 2
( :
&
&:
1 !
2' % # (6('
&$ 6 # (
#$ %# % %# % & ''( % & )''&* + , %"
(" $, $# ) 7* < (
(
B
&
*/ &
0 $ <
& 0
2
0
(
(
&
&
&
&
(
&
&
(
&
&
&
E B &
& &
( $
0
(
0 &
&
<
&
%%%%%% */+
**,/6$- %
F % F
(
$ $
6
2 F
F
(
8 $ $ < B
, - ! &
6( &
(
(
(
%
**,/6$-
8 & &
(
8
2 &
2
(
&
&
&
*/
& & ( ( & , - %
=
** $ $ *//
&
&
:
&
< 0
< (
&
& (
&
&
(
1 !
>#
8
% (" %8+ ' "*&, "# *7 %# ,"$#% -" ("# # 0"!
"
#" $ ,," #6%7 &, !
!
>#"- - "*&, *7 %# ,"$#% -" ("# # 0"!
6 #6 9 #, #"' ,%$
("
#6 -" - #6 $ -" (, - , (-" #,
,"#,# +
%"
#" #*%
8
% (" %8!
C'#
6 #+ ' 9 (, - , ,%$ ( #6 * "#+ 8'
,'
# $# ($ '# -, ' '
" "' ,%$ ("
#6 # % # - % $ -" (, - , (-" #, ,##" "$ % #, "( * ,%$!
>
#" , ' '
#7 * 6$ 7 '
6 * ,%$!
"' '# + %$ + (" $, *"
+
'
7 ,%!
2'-"+ '
"$
,"#
8 ' -, ' ' 9 #"' ,%$+
!!+ %$ + 8"$% #" # ' --, * ,%$ 6 "*% + '#,+ '
"*&, *7 %# ,"$#% -" ("# # 0"!
%"
&, !
;!
"#D$#%7+ (# (
%%"8 !
:"#5*% !
E$ , #'
'
+ # :"$ 0"!
;A+ ,"+ #,'/$%+ "* % 0"!
AAA 333
#"
# "% * " &$ ,
($ *8# ( + $*&, ," (% #, $"7 ("
"#
#,%$ #6 , ,!
!
, (( *-" %# * " + (%, * - 9 ," $# , *7 %# * " ' ,"# # #,!
!
< '%% * (
%# * "
,," #, '
<"$'
,' $% * ,+ # !
?!
# * "
%"
D$ ," (%
;
(", #6 (
(, * $# , 3 ,!
A!
D$ % %"#68 '
,"(7 " * # :"#5*% !
E$ , #'
'
!
%&% +*
*
. (
C'' (/ #6"#
)
F0"
C'' ("*%
)
F0"