High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/30650/2024dismissed

Union Of India v. No 4191900h, Ex Sepoy(Acp I) Raj Kumar Singh

2024-11-13Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma9 pages

!!"

#$%&%'()(*+ !!"

!"#$%&'( )*+, -$

. *% ,+ -.,

/

-., , (.

/&0 1( 2&3!(45 % 1 4%$

.!(45%

/

0 #1

7 .

8 % !% ')9

%&

. :'(

# ) %/&3 (-;57 /

35 !8/& % 5 8. /

.! 5-%

. / &3- 4 / &%

#'$2#1#'342*5 *% "#$%&'( )*+, -$

. 8 33

(-& : 8 5.- 4 58 < 5.-4 5!

% 5 !8. 338

. / &/ 3 .8

7!% 3(!/7 /

3 5 . /

. / &

3- =.

=3 8 7 %%3 5 83384 :'(

# ) 7% 4% #5

!" #

" "

!

$ % &

'

" ()

;3

. .. 4 - ! % ')9

3 .

8 % 267())(*)&$8%1%#*%5'2*)%1&$8%9%$($(*%) ( !3 5

3%

')4 + .- /& >/3 (%# !8/&!

/-

4 8 #% 3 38-

!3 7 /

35 34 5. % &

33&! 5 <

/-%.%

4 5 /& >/3(%#

5 3 ! "

# $ %&' "

( ! ! ! ) * +, -

.

% #,!5 : :7 %.% /5-#5

* " % + "

' " ( ' "

%* " (,!

"

" -

%

"

%

.

" "

"

" "

+" /" !

!

%

%

% #

""

0 !

" #!

/" %%

"

"

1

2" %

" 1 "

% 2" 34" 2"

5

5

"

2"

*34"

+"

5

" %

%

" %

"

" ) ? (

.%.% 4 5' %)533&

55

5 &53 - /&4 53& 35! 3 -3&5

.%%

4

/3 .< -&%

3!/ 3

. 3&%&- #

%& % ! /&! 3& 53 -!

/5-

. .8&+5! ! <

/338!/ 8 % /

. 5 %% &%

.8 % : 5

%.% !(%# 53 . 8 + 53 % 54

.% & 8

7 4 83%%4/ 55%

+ .- /

. /0 / "

# $ %&'

"

( !! 1( %, - ) * +, 2 3 !/ 734 %.%8 #5

6

"

"

" * %

"% . " "

* ,

,

$ $ 3 ,

3 , ,3, 3$ # $ ,

*34" !

" %"

" %

" "

34"

"

"

"" $

#

# ,

,

, - .

%!

7

34" "

"

*

"

267())(*)&$8%1%#*%5'2*)%1&%)9*5%*$

!3 5

3% /- + .- %%3 5/3

5! --/ 5 5-/ /3 - 8 3&

5 % / &% 8- %% / 5 .-@

.

.')! 8 3 3& 3

+ /3

5

%

%% .

- !%353 5 . B 5 + .- % /& >/3 (%# !

!

5 3#:(*5%(*48;) *(*&*5(##*5 $8%)!8 5 (:(199%#1<<" &! .

7 34 %.% 4 5#5

* " , 8

0 * " $ / 4 , 9 :6

"665** "

%

"+ +"

"

% * "

"

!!!! !!!!

-

* " !

* " ;

<7

"

"

665 :

"+ +"

" %

- "

%

665= 6

9 ) *&%%*'%)&$8()2$

7 .!4 /3&

5 &3&- /& .. 48/&533 . 5 53

.% /&5 ! % !

.3&- / -@ -/ /&4 53& 35 84! #5% /4%

%3!3 .4 55/& (%#

5 3) * +, - .

% #, "$(

5 3%, - ) * +, "$(2 !& 5%

35 !/5-

.

3 # % 4 -!/ 8 / 5 3&% &-

.%

B -&! #5% 4 % #5%.%!55

4 5' %) /& (%# ! # !

5

/3 ./5- 4

.. 4! % ! 4-

/3 .

.. 4! 8 3 35

.5

5 5 4 .. 4 * 3 3&! /& 3&

.53 -! 8 3 5/ 3 - /& &% %4 53& 35 8 35 43&

5 -/3

./35@.

.

. 333 .. 4

;-

.85 5 8 555 % % 85

.5

5 5 / -

.84&

5% !

/3 .4

% % !/&!

5&/

-

5 -!34 5 5

55 % % ! % !-@

.4 5/& >/3(%#

5 3- *(*&*5(#;) #7:$#>!

%

!" *1(*%= !5

!8

!

53 -# !/

.!

/5- 8 5 7 34 %.%55

4 5' %)#5

8/ '

( 2" %"

" "

" " "

" % % "#

* '

( "

4 " 9 '

(16=1>'?#4(

" @ > A%

% 0

? % " %

0 ? %

- % " 5- "+"'

(

'

( "#

=*

. 34"

* "

7!

5

/3 ./5-4

% % ! % !-@

.4 5/&(%# !

5 3 - *(*&*5(#;) #7:$#)29#

< 3!53 38-

4 5' %)!8

5 4 ./5- 84 5 ! /4* 3 3&! 8- .!4 5 ! /5- 5 - -

.! 8

%-% < 3 % % 53 -! !

-8

$

5 4 5 ' %) /5- %

5

! ! % 8 5. - 4 5

;

! %

- 4 5! - /7 /

35 !

& : 7 .!%

-4 5' %) %-%-

% 5!/ - 3& 3&/ &@

.%35 84!8 8- -

4 % % ! / 33& 5

/3 . < - 7! 8

/3 .

4

% % . 4 5 ' %) / 5 5- 3& 3 5 5

5

.5 5 < % % * 3 3&3

/3 . /5- 4

% % @

.< %%

./

.-

4

? "4 8

5 53 38 -

4 5' %)-@ 53 / #% 3 38

-!/&!#% 3 38

-!-

4 5 ' %)3-@

5 / 4 5 %

3 5 ! !

! 3 3 5 ! & -!@.

. 8- -

! !

335-%3- !%3

!/ %5 4/3& 35

(*#1 5%&$8()2$

: -!

-

8 %

8 /4 ! - - 7

-% .

-

-

$

5-

5 3/ 5 ! !33 %

.%%3 5 ')! &!3 ') %

/

, !!"

( A(C %@

.9 0 D9 %/3 D9