Vishkarma Bharatgas And Others v. Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd.(Bpcl) And Another
!"!#!
$!!! !# !
#%&'(#&)*+*' , ,
-+,.*+/012"/1% +'%/&1+
"/1%&%1'3&42'15'1%*'6%'%/&1
!041789
*''(*'%/&1+
! :"6 , 7 !7
7
!!"# $%&# '(
&#)& $%$& '*+,+'+ + -. '+ './ /& 01- 2 *3' . 4
3 5 !7
7
; ,
13 3*.* .+. ++
. + +
+ . 7+ )%+'(%/&)+&
8 + + $$9:$$;
- 2(. < ( 7( $$&&$%&# = &!
* . 7++(++* +* +.
++*. 7 8 3 +7
7 ++7 5> * $%& (
+ 7 ++7 . ( * (+ + (+ 5 > = & 8 ? 7 + >4 > ,?? + ( * @1 32. +
@ 8 . +(+* 7 ( *+(1 32. +
. ( * + 9$& .
+(( 1 32. +
(A 13 * 7 -
+ 7 - .+++(+ .++ < 7+(. +
*7 * * 7 - *( +( 1 32. +
(A 13 * +:A/
* 7 -
+ 7 +(.
7 2(. + < (* +( 13 ( * + + 7*+* 8
! " # ! $ $"#
%$$ ! && " $
!& $ "
!"#"
'
($) ' *"$
# ! + ",$ !$
) "$"-!
$ "$ !"&&! " ! $!" " "$" "! " !
.
- . 7
*
+ 5 > 13
( *$%&$$%& .. + 72( +8 &&7 . + . + . $&&&$%&! 8 . + . .
+ . +. + . +
+ <+* < 7 &%B *$&&$$%&!C ++7 5
> +.
* ( (. 7 (7
+( +8 ( 7 ( ( (++ + 7 ( 8 2++ 7 + . 5> (.
+. *++ 7*= %"%9$%&!.. 7 . + ?* 7* ?( + ++( . ? 72((. ( 5 > + * ++( *. 8 7 *
+*.++ ( ( 5> = 7. +.
+ * +
. ((* . + 2 + 8 = ! 7 . ( (( + + +
* 8 = !. (* $%%&$%&)77+* . + ( (
+ . + 7 *?+ * + = !
+D. (* . ?* = )
%)%!$%&)- ..
*
. + . .
* + 2./"9!:;;!2/#&%++(3 8 + 3 ( > ,?? 7 + + *
* &9%9$%&!
+ +7 ++(> 4 ( + &#%&$%&) + 7
+ < +8 +. (
/&"!&# $%&)++(( .. * &;%!$%&; 1
. . *
. . +(. 7 + 77+ +
. &)%;$%&)
. + . + . 7 += ( + + . + ( + +D. 3
/! .. *7+ + . + = +*
+ +*. .7 7 *
( * ( -.
+ * ++ *
< /! + ( ( 7( + &)%!$%&)8
+ . *. + ( ( 7 ( +/99)"
%!%&$%%9 + +
..
2./!" 2 /&$%:&+ (
?47 . /+7 * 13
*8 + 3 ( &&&$$%&!/ . + 778 + +..
* .. 2./!" 2 /&$%:&8 ( (* (+ +
* . + +. ++. + 7
+- .
+.. + . + *?* 7 *. ++ + + + . . ++ . +. (+ .
( * + + .. * . *
+ *( +. + *++. + 7
+ . + *(+ 8 + = ; /01)231)/+-456(/)778
=
:
; *!, <)=+>4$!, 5$* 8?8,=- , $ ,/@>>, 5 -
9A7:
=6@0+221#+#*B(+<+(/B12 /#=(#6(=5#2 +/+6/+456(/,/#=(#@5+@@+(,6*/0( +0 (3C+/D0(#=0/*
;!, "! $
:!&"5E 5 $"2$> 5 :
:<2 ?9 F- G;$$ %$" " ?
:
#!&"5E 5 $, $& @$ :$2 2"" &" $$ =+>4$!"" "
2 12 ,21
/$ & , $ $ !&"
A? 9
&& ""4* 9?8,4*
" $"+>4$!, $$ 2&
" $ " $
, $
9,2+* $ !$
3$%$21&$ > ""12 / $$1# $
$%$"$ :
:
5E 5 $ " 2$> 5 , H!$! $ !
$ +" & "!!& $,&&,&&, ""
$&" "" $ && /01)231)/+=-456(/)778 ""
$&"$ !"
&&"/$ 4$
B " " $ "
$! $ !
$ $ &
$&$"&""'"
$&&"12 / $&/ $ 4$,/ @>>,5
$, 3$""$ , B5+(+20(106;(2* 1/ , =)- 3;12 2 12
++7 * + .
5 - 51-
= " &%&&$%&;
51- . ( 7 7 $9%!$%&"+( ( 7 2 ( (7 + +
+* 78 7 *2 2 E3*.* + +( 7 $9%!$%&" . . + ++ ( ++ +.( .( 7
51- +( . 5(.. + + ( (. 5 . 77
* $9%!$%&" 77+* 777
5 .* 77 +$%&" (
5 ++*
++ + + + * 7 )%+ 7+ . 7 7 777++ 7* 7 . ( *7 * .
(77 7 7 D.
. 77* 7 7 '(.. +
(++*7* $%& .+
. . + . +77+
* ++(( . . (+* ( 5 + . (+ - 7+.. 7* 7 '(
+( */ * 7+. + . ++ . .* 2 7+D. ( 7+
. = && F + . *
< *(( .
( 7 7 .. < *.. ( .. + = &%& %9$%&# ++* ( . < *( ( D. . ( . + +*= &$8 . .
. . . + * .+7+*7 7 8
. 7 + < 13 .
. + 9$&
7 ..
* ' D *.
( 32. +
/
* 7 D * .
( * 7 - 8 ( 2 . . 7 +
*+ +.. (* +. ++ .. <+*++ * +
* + .+ * (
(( + +8 (.( . +( (( + + 7 &)%!$%&). +* . ++ 8 ( +* +* . 7( = &!.
$$&&$%&#- .++ . 7 +*.(
.+ . 7 +( 3
% &$$%&# < = * (5> ++* !1842&%+1*+&>?3&1&)'4+&3 ('1%/&5&%*%*'&1+ + + (+ 7 . . ++* * 7 *+
C7+( ( +&# &
(
- 7(+ +&!$&
-D 7+.++(. ( .2 . .7 7
++(.
(
7 +(.+ +
13 . +(. . : + = &9. &#%;$%%&8 + . 7 7 +( +.>7 $%& D.
* *( 7 32. . / 7 - . ( 7 D * D. + . 7(+ + 9$& 32. +
./
* 7 -D 7?. 2* . 7 + ( 7 &&&$$%&!.. +D
7 . + 2+ $&&&$%&!. .
+ . + ? . * 7 < ( (13 . &&&$$%&!
7
. . * .* ( 7 + $%&"
+ ( 5 > 77
77D 7 2?
7 .+
( 7 * + + +( 7( *. + * ( 77.
?..
2* *
( . 7+ 7 & G * 77
( D+ ?(7 DH+' 7
!"#$$%&" .+(
'+ '+8 ( *.+ +*(
?(7 7 + ?(7 77D 7DH+' 7 '+ .++ 7 7.+72*
+(+*D /&!&) ( D 7 7.*.++*( 7 + 32.
( * .++
( +(
7 *7 +( + . (. +(+ . + + 1
(+ 7 ++*. + +
+.. (+ 7 ?
7++ 7*+ . ++7
,$%&!.. 7 +( +>7 $%& D 7 . + 2+ . . +*. . + . .
+
+
+ +.. * . + . .
*
( ( 7 + = ; +
* .. ++(. + +D 7 .
( + + .
+(+*
*
/&"!&#
$%&) . 7 + .
+ ( *7 + ( 7. 77
5> 8 .
( 7 7 &G* + +7+ ( 7 . 7 ( 7 ( . (( + +D 7 2 . ++* * 7 *7 7( 7 ++< !1842&%+>?3&1&7&*'1'4+&3('1%/& 1&+5'&%'15'1%*' 2 *3+ ' +. 4 ( +
7 . +* 7+ * 7 '( &G* * 7+. . +
7 .. (7 * . * .. + 7 D
7 . 77* ++*.+7 7 +( + *(+2*+ + . 77
( 5
7+7 +5 '
++ ?(7 ' ( )
*( $ '
+
/$)$$ $%&9$&%!$%&9+ 7 -&)%;$%&). * +=*.* + + (. .?* *. + + . . .
+ +8 7?(7 .
+5 .++ 5 7
D
7 7++(+ . . 7
5 ' ++ + 9& . + +. + 7
+ 7 + + D
7 . *+ + 7. ++ ( 5 > . + ( ++ 5 > . + + 9& D 7 +.
7 +.
= +
+ .
+++( +( + . + . * 7 + ++.. * +* 7 * 2(. + 9$& 8+
< ' ++ ?(7 DH+' 7 , -. / )
0!
#$$%& 7 277* +.* .
+. !3?+*+'(1842&%+@)&>?3&1& )'4+&3('151%*&+ - + + +( 8 ( ++ 5> D. * ++7
5> ( 7+ + 75 > .( -.++
*+ .( +* 8 ( .. *
. .+7+*+ 7 7
5> . 7 + + < 13 .. < + 9$&
8 . .
8 = &9.. +(. + . + & &$$%& 8
+( + (32. +
/
*' D *.
( + 9$& /
= 7 -8 = &9.. +(.+ +* &#%;$%%&.
7 + ( (. 8 &&&$$%&! = &;
. ( 7
+ 9$& .
+ ( 13 /
* 7
-8
+ ( 7 +( + = &;&&&$$%&! + 9$& 7 +(.+ . 7 ( 5 + +?(7 D@+' 7
!'#.+ 7( .( * ('+
. +(+* + 7+ +.+ +* .++ (13 . 13
+*
8 . ++ ?(7 DH+' 7 .+++ 8 ( . 7.
7. +..
* 7
+ . + + . . +
( . ? 7++ 7 *+ ++ . + .
7* D.
8 .
+
(+ + . ( * ? +7 * +( /&"!&# $%&) ..
&;%!$%&;
*
7 + +7 = ;.
+ +. ( . +* - . 7( . 7
=++(.. 7 . + + + .
++ . +
*
/&"!&# $%&) + + + + + . ( 7
7 .. + +( 7( = ( 777+*5> . 77
77
. (++ 8 (+ +
.( . 2 *7 +8 7 *(
. 2 * + ' +
. 77* * +7 *( 7 7+.D. . 77 ++ 7 . + * 8 < 13 . 7* < . +. = &;?. *
7 7+ +*. ( + = ; 7 + + .
* +* ( 77 +$%&". . 7 + * 7 +
77
5 > + ++
*
8 + +...+7 7
* +8 + .++ *
7
* +.+ 7 .+ D . + . . *7 +. (7 ++. < +(+*<+ 7 . 7 ( 7. 7* 7* +7 7.
72.+( =
. 77
( 5 + * ++ 1 + .
+ * (( 7 7*++ ( 7 ( 7.( 8 + +...++(7 .++ +(7=8 + +(.C7+(
. +&# &
(
-+( C7+( + ? =. +&#
- ++=
1 +
. . +7+* * ( 777
5
+(7=.+( 7+.. &G* ( 7+ * 7 > ( (7 + + + . ( 7+ . + &
. + 7 7+.7+ 7 . 7+ +*
1 . %* 7
+ . + + 7++ .++ 7+ 2(7 7+ ++( . &)* .. &! " ++( +(. ( 7 *- 7+ .
+ 7 7+ 7+ .+( *8 7 +( /$ + + 7+ . + .+ +( +* 7 + 7
77* . 7 7 .* + . . 7+ (.* . .
+ + . 7 + ( 7.
.+ * +*+ +
7 ( 7 + $" + *
(. (*( *
+++ + * 7 ( 7 . *7 ( *
++.( + + * 7(* > + 7 > ++
*7 + + 8 +
?#" "!
/ $&& "&&!/ $ "$ $$ !&$.
> ( (7 + ' +
+ * 7( 7 . + $"
+ D. H" (7 *+ + +. + +
* 7 (* +
7 * 7 + + ( 7 7D. ++ 7.. (* +. ? ( * . +( (++ 7 (* 7+
.. = ; ( 7. =..
. *( 8 + $"
+ .+++*
7 ( 7 *++(+ 7 * .* + +&!$&&# & (
-
')34+*' -. +* 7 ++. 7( 7 $$&&$%&# = &!
* < 8 ++
8 * 2(. ;!$++> 5 + > 4 7 + + '.
!!"# $%&# ++. 7 ( 7 * 7
, ,
!7
7
#
2( I :/
+ I :/