High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/58653/2022disposed of

Baljinder Singh v. Union Of India And Another

2023-08-11Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger11 pages

$!%&'&"( )

* *

+,&($!- .&(/0 ******** ! & &"(!- 1!-'2'

(&"( (" 0!- ****** !'3"($!( '

) 4 5 * . .

-!'!( ) -* 56(7 23 8 $6"% !

3! & &"(!-*

-* 9-( 92:- 2($8

!( -+ "2('!+8 (&"( -!'3"($!( '* * * .

8 * * ! & &"(!-

+,&($!- .&(/0 0'

#&+!$ 3! & &"( 2($!- .!% &"( ; "$!

-&:&(+ -"%!$2-!

$&-!% &(/ -!'3"($!( '

-!(!<

3! & &"(!-4'

7!-'*

-&!#+78 ! & &"(!- ' !$ =!

-2((&(/

-&%!

:&++ $2/0 !- -,"

92- ' !$ =!

3!-:(!( -!'&$!( ($* ! & &"(!- <'

''3"- "* >> ;?8 <0&%0 <'

6+&$ 23 "

** * 0!

--7!$ ( %%2'!$ %'!

"* ;* 2($!- .!% &"('

8 ;8 ; ?8 8 >8 ;8 ;> 8 -!/&' !-!$

"+&%!

. &"( & 7 8 90((8

&' -&% 52$0&(8

=!0!'

.0:&($!- .&(/0 +&'

&( 2* 0!

/-( !$ =&+ '&$ %'!

* .&(%!

! & &"(!-4'

!@3&-&(/ "( ** 8 %%"-$&(/+78 :"6!$ ( 33+&% &"( =!#"-!

+!-(!$ 2$&%&+

/&' - !

+''8 90((8 '!!A&(/ 3!-:&''&"( -!(!< 3''3"- 8 <0&%0 <'

++"<!$ !/&"(+ ''3"-

##&%!8 0($&/-0 <'

$&-!% !$ -!(!< 3''3"- 8 6&$!

"-$!-

((!@2-!

; 0"+$&(/ 2($!- )

"###"$"#

() '

* ;* 0!

!/&"(+ ''3"-

##&%!8 0($&/-08

(!< &*!* ''3"- "* 1;> >?;

((!@2-!

8 0"<!6!-8 '&$ -!(!<+ <'

7!- &*!* 23 "

** * 0!-!# !-8 /&( 33-"%0!$ %"2- +!-(!$ 2$&%&+ /&' - !

+''8 90((8 -!(!<+ !( 7!-'8 0"<!6!-8 '&$ 33+&% &"( <'

$!%+&(!$ +!-(!$ 2$&%&+ /&' - !

+''8 90((8 6&$!

"-$!- >*

((!@2-!

8 "='!-6&(/ 2($!- )

"$$+"$"#

()

#$ -

#$ !

()

* * ( #"-!:!( &"(!$ %&-%2:' (%!'8 0'

#&+!$ &(' ( 3! & &"( =!#"-!

%"2- * ?* 0!

%+&:'

="2

7!-'

"+$ <& 0 %+!( ( !%!$!( '

2( &+ #"-!'&$ #+'!

%'!

+"$/!$ $2!

3"+& &%+ -&6+-7* ! & &"(!-4'

$2/0 !- -,"

92-

3!-:(!( -!'&$!( ($ 0!- %-$ +"(/<& 0 0!- ''3"-

((!@2-!

-!'3!% &6!+7 -!

%0!$ <& 0 3! & &"(*

' !'

(7 !:!-/!(%7 6&'& 0!- $2/0 !- =-"$ %(("

-2+!$ "2 %'!

(7 $&-!

;

(!!$ !:!-/!(%78 0"<!6!- 6&!< 3!($&(/ %'!

8 <"2+$ #&-' +7 -!B2&-!

3!-:&''&"( "2- 0!( 33+7 6&'* ' !$ =!#"-!

'2=:& &(/ ( 33+&% &"( 6&'

-6!++&(/ =-"$ ($ "- (7 " 0!- %"2( -78 0!-!

+'"

-!B2&-!:!( '0"2+$ =!

6+&$ (!@ '&@ :"( 0'*

3!- 3! & &"(!-8 +' +7 -6!++!$ ($

+&A!+7 ='%"($#+!!*

* 5!-(!$ %"2('!+ '2=:& '

3-!'!( +7 $2!

-2'0 6&'

33+&% &"('8 33"&( :!( '

6&'

&( !-6&!< -!

!'&+7 6&+=+!

'":!

%'!'

& :7 !@ !($ =!7"($ 0-!!

:"( 0'

%"2( -&!'

+&A!

(& !$ . !'

:!-&%8 $ !'

=!&(/ /&6!( =!7"($ 3!-&"$ 7!-* %%"-$&(/+78 +!-(!$ %"2('!+ '2=:& '

-!(!<&(/

3!-&"$ "(+7 7!- :7 ("

(7 2'!8 %%"-$&(/+7 & 3-7!$ ( 33-"3-& !

$&-!% &"( =!

-!'3"($!( '

-!(!<

7!-'

3!-&"$ "- (7 " 0!- 3!-&"$ %"2- :7 $!!:

#& *

( " 0!- 0($8 +!-(!$ %"2('!+ -!3-!'!( &(/ -!'3"($!( (&"( 0'

#&+!$ -!'3"('!

3! & &"( #&+!$ 3! & &"(!-8 <0!-!&( & 0'

=!!( ' !$ 3!- .!% &"(

# ''3"- '

% 8 >?8 2 0"-& 7 '0++ -!#2'!

&''2!

"- -6!+ $"%2:!( 6&'& &(/ (7 #"-!&/( %"2( -78 &# 3-"%!!$&(/'

-!'3!% ( "##!(%!

++!/!$ 06!

=!!( %"::& !$ 33+&%( 3!($&(/ =!#"-!

%-&:&(+ "2- ($&*

#2- 0!- ' !$ &(&' -7 @ !-(+ ##&-'8 ($&8 6&$!

"##&%!

:!:"-($2:

* > 0'

/-( !$ +&=!- 7 &''2!

33+&%( '

/&('

<0":

%-&:&(+ %'!'

3!($&(/ =!#"-!

"2-

<0"

3-"$2%!

"-$!-'

#-":

"2- %"(%!-(!$ 3!-:& &(/ 0!:

$!3- #-":

'2=,!% %"($& &"('

:!( &"(!$ '&$ :!:"-($2:*

5!-(!$ %"2('!+ 33!-&(/ -!'3"($!( (&"( '2=:& '

# !- !@3&-7 3! & &"(!-4'

''3"- "* 1;> >?;

"( ** 0!-!

33+&% &"( &''2(%!

'2=:& !$ <0&%0 3!($&(/ <& 0 "##&%!

2 0"-& &!'*

#2- 0!- '2=:& '

-!'3"($!( '

06!

"=,!% &"( &# 33+&!'

#-!'0 <& 0 ++ (!%!''-7 $"%2:!( '

+"(/<& 0 %2--!( ' 2'

3!-:&''&"( "2- %"(%!-(!$8 '3!%&#7&(/ 3!-&"$ <0&%0 =!

# !- %":3+7&(/ <& 0 3-"6&'&"('

:$!

"##&%!

:!:"-($2:

* > &(&' -7 @ !-(+ ##&-'8 ($&* * 06!

0!-$ +!-(!$ %"2('!+'

3- &!'

3!-2'!$ 33!-=""A <!++ -!3+7 #&+!$ "( =!0+# -!'3"($!( (&"( ($&*

* "(%!$!$+78 <'

''3"- "* >> ;?8 <0&%0 <'

"( ** ':!

6+&$ &++ ** *

( 32-'2(%!

"-$!-

((!@2-!

;8 <'

(!< ''3"- "* 1;> >?;8 <0&%0 0$

6+&$& 7 7!- "(+7 &*!* 23 "

** 0!

'!!A&(/

$&-!% &"( -!'3"($!( '

-!(!< -!/2+-

7!-'*

* !-!8 & <"2+$ =!

-!+!6( !@ -% .!% &"(

# ''3"- '

% 8 >?8 <0&%0 -!$'

2($!- )

. /

0#1 222222 222222 22222 0"1 )

0 1

0"1

533 01 0 1 222222 222222 22222 1

6 222222 222222 22222* ;* 2- 0!- &(&' -7 @ !-(+ ##&-'8 0'

( "##&%!

:!:"-($2:

* >8 <0&%0 $!+'

<& 0 &''2!

3''3"- '

33+&%( '

/&('

<0":

%-&:&(+ %'!'

3!($&(/ =!#"-!

%"2- +< ($&8 <0&%0 -!$'

2($!- ) - 78$#8#848"$#+

;

2 '%

- ; #$< "$#+ <==:%:%</ -;>% ) 5

/ -

- 9 /4?$0:1 "4@#++A

0 1

0"1

#+.? " 9 / 4?$0:1 "4@#++A

9 /4?$0:1 2

#+.? 0#4

#+.?1

- 9 / "+@0:1 #

#+?. 9

0 1

0"1

)

5B 01

& B 1

6 1

010

1010

6 1

010 1

6 01

. 0"1

#+.?

.0"10 1

9 / 4?$ 0:1 "4$@#++A

D '

9 /4?$0:1

.0"10 1 % E

;

E !

; D 0/F1 - "@8"$#@8/F% @.?8"$#@

5 1

9 /4?$0:1

40"1

#+.? '

/ #"

/ #+@$

1 D E- <)

E0-<1

9 /4?$0:1

)

1:2

3 7

071 3 7*

9 /4?$0:1 '

/ 07/1!

37* - 37* )

1 '

#+.?

#$0A101

#+.?

071 E E

8 0 1

E 2 '

.0"10 1

E- <)

' E E E E

7/ '

- <)

0-<1

01- < '

2 '

021 9 /4?$0:1 2

.0"10 1

.0"1

#+.? 1 > '

9 /4?$0:1

2 E E

1 <

.0"10 1

#+.? .

* * 3!-2'+ "##&%!

:!:"-($2:

* > &(&' -7 @ !-(+ ##&-'8 ($&8 <"2+$ :(&#!'

3!-'"('

/&('

<0":

%-&:&(+ 3-"%!!$&(/'

3!($&(/ (7 %"2- +< ($&C %( =!

23"( "-$!-'

%"2- '2%0 3!-&"$ :7 =!

'3!%&#&!$ %"2- & '

"-$!-*

"##&%!

:!:"-($2:

* > #2- 0!- &( !-+& 3-"6&$!'

%'!

3!-&"$ '3!%&#&!$ %"2- & '

"-$!- 0!( 2 0"-& &!'

%( &''2!

33+&%( 7!- 6+&$& 7* * ( 6&!< 3-"6&'&"('

"##&%!

:!:"-($2:

* > 23"( %"('&$!-&(/ %'!

A&(/ &( "

%%"2( '2=:&''&"('

:$!

%"2('!+'

-!'3!% &6!

3- &!'

+'"

A&(/ (" !

#% 6&$!

"-$!-

((!@2-!

;8 %"2- =!+"< 0$ ++"<!$ 33+&% &"( #&+!$ -!(!<+ 3''3"- 8

%"('!B2!( <0&%0 <'

(!< "* 1;> >?;

06&(/ 6+&$& 7 7!-C $!!:

& 33-"3-& !

$&'3"'!

3! & &"( <& 0 #"++"<&(/ $&-!% &"(')

& ( %'!

+-!$7 33+&!$ -!(!<+

%'!

33+&!'

-!(!<+ 3''3"- C 0!( ''3"- 2 0"-& &!'

'0++ -!(!<

3!-&"$ C

!#"-!

-!(!<&(/ 3! & &"(!-8 ''3"- 2 0"-& &!'

'0++ !('2-!

%":3+&(%!

"##&%!

:!:"-($2:

* > &(&' -7 @ !-(+ ##&-'8 "- (7 " 0!- +!/+ -!B2&-!:!( '* ?* %%"-$&(/+78 &(' ( 3! & &"( $&'3"'!$ #"-!' !$ !-:'* * ++ 3!($&(/ 33+&% &"('

&# (7 '0++ ' ($ %+"'!$*

"#$%& "'$ ( ) & '

D0! 0!- -!3"- =+!

)