← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/8535/2018dismissed

The Pr. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Faridabad v. M/S Knorr Bremse Pvt. Ltd.

2019-12-10Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari,Mr. Justice Vivek Puri6 pages





!

"

# $% &

!' 

& !

& ( &))*

+ + ,

#))-.

//)) ( /01 ")2 +++ --.. 3+ 4 5%/ ) #3+ 6+ ++ !-   ,

#))-.

//)) ( / 01 ")2 +++ --.. 3+ 4 5 %/ ) #3 6 ++ !-  7 ,

#))-.

//)) ( / 01 ")2 +++ --.. 3+ 4 5 %/ ) #3 6 ++ !-

!*

8%6

!+ $ 9

$'

:!

8%6

!+ $ 9

;;

# ! 

  

 

   !

"

 #$%   &  #$% 

 !

'''''

$'

:!1 $+ (

 )$    # * +,,-.,/+,,0.(, +,(,.((

+

1  %$%

% # * +,,-.,/ 2 #.

/343.+,(/!    )  $      %      !    



    

     

   

  !!

   ! "  ! ! #  "       !      

# 



 #        "   #    "  

      "   

    $% & # '(()    %#)%#*+#,$'- . !&   

 

 

         #   !         #  / .

   !/    0 1             23.                  4 5*#%5)#,))-       %5#'()#'(*- ! / / %+#(5*#,((-/ 2   2!  0 '*#,6$#,)%-

  

 





"        

  

 7# ! 23.

  .&#     "

 4   !&        

  .&   

4

   8.  4  23.



 9 :/ 

.&

       



 !                

         

  !8.   4

  

     

!              

      

   !&   &  $ & # '(%%  "

!    

   '#6'#*+#((*-              ! %#*%#$*#$'$-  / .!  !

! 



 

 +        $% & #'(%'   

/   /&     

!!

  8.    

  0  

         !9 ;%,''(%$ %)''(%$#

#!    2  2   * ;# '(%5  

"     

        2  

!

  .&#8. 9    . !&      . &       

 4

#    < !

   9  '





!

   =-

    !!  

 :! 

"           

     /  #

  2;:  

 / 

             

    "  !  

 

   23.             . & 

   



              

                    

        "     9 0 

    ;           

7   

 

  

       

  



   2   #;            

  #    "    "  

 9   



  !



 ! 



&.

 6'*   !            ,+( /    



  !   

!;  

&./ %5'%>     0          $6*> 

      4

       .&               !       4



2        +     )5   2 #      $  

 7   $) 2 #8

/343 +,(/.



     

    

    



   !





"

#$ % ## 

 &'&

 ## #    

 ( 



"

#$ %) * 

     

            

          



 

  



"

#$ %

  # ) + 

     

            

          



   

 

   !, !     %  

 %

 -).

-

 

 4 ? 2         4

2

 .& 

; 

  !  9 !    



 

 !

  2 

(*-%%-'(%57   

   2 

  

 23. 

.& ! ; 1            

;               

   

  

!9 :/  ,          

!    

      



<  !

.   =-  

   

       

      

  

 

 !     "    

 

   

     #  $   

%

 

 

  



"

 " &''

 

 

 

$$ 

"      $  &''

 

   $    

    $

   

        # 

 



        #  "      

  (

< 6 & 

1    %(2  

/

 6'2 9 0 #  . &      2       #  

     

         

   %( 9  ! #             

    

  2           

 ;           23.2 .           #  

   ;    



!



 

  < !

 %%

#    0          

  "#          9  ! 

!    # 1

     !     (+

#%%5     $'

:!

$ &

+ + ,

;;

# !

 $ &

9 :  *:8 9" ) *:8