Raghubir Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others



       



 !

 "




 !

"!#

,
-./

!  !"

# !

,
-. 0 1+%'!

/,
-.2 "#!&+%'!

,
-.. 0!

#0 1

2,
-.- "#!10 1

#



.,
-.3  '&!+%'!

-,
-- +%" 41 

3,
-- "


#+% "



,
-- "&*'!

"!#

,
--/ "

"!#


1

,
-- 14%%&"!#

,
--2

 0"



/,
--.

+ "



,
--3 "#& 0 !

2,
-3 11

.,
-3

"%% "

!'

!#

-,
-3 + 1"!#

#+#

3,
-3/ '!

%#+% 0 

/

,
-3

!#+% "!#

0

#

,
-32

#4!&"!#



,
-3-

1"

# #!

,
-33 ""

!1 # 

/,
3 "


#+%

,
3 #&!+%'!

2,
3 '#!&0&

!



.,
3/ %%1

-,
3 !"

#0 #

3,
32 #&!+%'!

,
3. "

4

,
3- " !&

,
33

%#

,
3

%%#*+'

/,
3

* #!

,
3/

#

1"!#

#!#

2,
3 0#&+%'!

.,
32

#4!11 41

-,
3. '!

%#+% 0

3,
3-

4%"!#

.

/,
33

 0"

/,
3 "'!& !+%'!

/,
3 +!#%"

0 

1

/,
3 01&!

//, 
3/ !#+% 0 1!0

/,
3

 %%&0

/2,
33

10 4

-

/.,
3. 1#"!#

/-,
33 

#

/3,
3/ "

+%'!

,
3/

%%&"!#

1

,
3 '!4*#& 0

,
3. 0 #"!#

,
33

#!"



/,
 '%%# #!

, 
 !"

#0

2, 
  '%%#0 !

., 
 %#+% 0

-,
/ 0 1%"

0 !

3,
 "%%  #!



2,
2 #%%&+ 11

2,
. 0#
#+ #

2,
-


#+% "!#!

2,
3

&

2/,
 !"

#0

2,
 %%1

#!

22,


#" 4& 1



2.,
 "#!&

*&

2-,
/ ' #
+ *

23,


 0"

"

1#

.,
2

# %

.,
. '!0 #

1

.,
-

*
#+

.,
3



!& +%'!

./,
 %"

0

.,
 #!"

! 4

.2, 
 0#&1 4

..,


 1

.-, 
/ "#!& #!

.3,
 "#+%%0



-,
. 0 1%"

+%'!

-,
- #0 "



-,
3

# !

"!#

  %1

-,


'!#+% 0"

!0

-/,


%"


+ *

-,
 0 !

"!#

#!#

-2,


4%"

0 &

/

-.,
/ 0#&1+%'!

--,
 #%%1

-3,
2 + 0 *+'

3,
. #%%&#

1

3,
- !& +%'!

3,
/

'!#+% "!#

3,
./



4"#&"!#

3/,
.

0%"

3,
.2

 0"

"# #

32,
.. # %#+% 0

3.,
.-  '%%#0

3-,
.3 "#4*0 + 

33,
- %"

0 "

#

2

,
- !&0

, 
- +1 !

"!#

,
- "&*#

,
-/ 0 1%"

0 !

/,
-

40

,
-2 #"!#

"!

2,
-. "&* "



.

., 
-- "

4#&!

-,
-3 1%"

3,
3

1

,
3 "&* 0"

,
3

40

,
3 !1 %+

,
3/

#4& 1

-

/,
3 "#+%%"

!

,
32 "#& "



2,
3- " 1+%'!

.,
/

# 40

-,
/ "%% +%'!

3,
/2 + ,0!

#0!

3

,
/ "&*1"!#

1 #

, 
/ " 1

*1

  # $ "$$ # $ "%&  $ 5

,"678
9"7:9;7

,<=
9 ,&:7+688

, >:
9:9?@77  ,

,<6 789778: 89 =9;7

,068@06 ,"7: >9:9

,78
;89:9 ?@ "( "' , ''' $$( )*+!

)767:8:77A6?@7777789 A7>7@?:7B6>, ;:9 ?A7>7:?
 *,-./0)"01,-2"3*3456 *)7*1**1853-4)9 , &@77@=??88;7>6A7:87?5 :020+ )034303051.184))30;+49

<=

>563-4 519303.305156180*65)3-4099.*1;456*1*??)5?)0*34

)03()84)5) 0)4;3051(49?4;0*++7013-41*3.)456*

)03  56  65)  @.*9-01,  3-4  0A?.,148 *;3051  56  )49?5184139  15   *18    01  9-5B01,  3-4 5.393*1801, *A5.13  56  9   (C>( < 51  039  ?5)3*+ *,*0193  3-4  1*A4  56  3-4  ?43030514) 35B*)89  3-4  151



?*7A4135641-*1;48;5A?419*3051849?0343-46*;33-*3 )49?518413  159   *18    -*24  153  099.48  *17  6)4984A*181530;4353-4?43030514)930++8*3401*;;5)8*1;4 B03-3-4?5+0;7 114D.)4 >!(B-0;-3-47 )49?518413 159 *18!-*8016*;3.184)3*E4135850134)A9563-4 5)84)8*348



 114D.)4 <!?*9948/73-09 51#/+45.)301 > 
C *+95*B)0301 3-41*3.)456   "80)4;301,3-4)49?518413935 )46.183-49.)?+.9*A5.13F9
C  ?4)"@ 434)( B-0;--*9/441,5384?5903486)5A3-4?43030514)30++8*34 /73-4)49?5184139(*9?4)3-4;*+;.+*30519 114D.)4

 !*18*+9535099.45/G4;30514)3060;*34353-4 ?43030514) 01  )49?4;3  56  3-4  ?+53  01  @.493051  04  +53 5C ("4;35)9<>(09*)H 1"768?@77  6A7:7 7    ,,-   9    @6779  ;7>     7      ?  C67779      @77    @= 778?887D ,/2,.3@C,,7>8=9

,/9392(  ;  6>    A  :  ?    @77,  7> >>7:9 78?77:7
6:7
.3. -
 

   

     , 7  ;  7@  ?  A=        2,,-9  C677>   @6777@7778?@79 ?6778?@(8687?A7? , 6A7:6>677?78?67 =678(86879A6=:=9@667@6> 9;6>A6,68977777 @@7>

./3 , ;:9677967>



@=?7@7>97??@87=? + ,-,39;7;7@6> ,/2,.3@C, 78?,7>8=9?68?@9
@
69:7/,, 2 977@77 ;7;,)697?7 2 9776>8 68 ?   @9  A? 
@
69   @7?788= 6A7;=?77977;68 A@@77>8=,!76A7?AA= @677, 67886? ,-93.9-2(9A 6@E7 ? ,/2,.3@C, 976A ?867>6;A@8?

@, 688=9 7>7?@77:88=??,)97 @7777@776A77@8688 7(@89@7A7>78;?68;987@@=,&69 ;67  88>67>6 ,-93.9-2( ;;A@8>7@77  98=6A6 :@66, 7>9@@8=7?6<7>?67 A?
@
68/,, 2 , ;:9 >6@6779?6 6@866D ,3-,@C,98"768? @77?

78=6A7@=7@@8=6,)9@66 @A=
7:78
677?:6978= @7>A?%E67>
6@77;68@667 87(7A?7
697?



);7798778: 8@@7> A8??@   "'7@6>;6 79@77A:;797667A8,17<;79 E@77A787=B67?=;97>7:7697 A?=?9=668A;967> >7@77,7>8=96A7;67  9 @77  :A:;7977A6?@779A :A;7;,)69776>=E7:8 7?7?;A@888A86;77;<? =,9;?97?> A="6@
69:7B6>,/,97 9-)*60*1853-4)92"3*3456*)7*1**1853-4)9(


!"
>97 867:8=  ;<  69    =  78(@(8687 ?7>A7?988A?67@77, &A7>98"768?@776A79 ?7>6A7:6:7:7@779A7@?7 ?A=8"68, !;<?@77<6A:9@7688= ?76A8??@6779;C67 8:=?677, ;:9?2,,-

/,,9@8=?A:977:A7>877 767:8:7@779;77E@7E9 @:787=867:7=65 )84)8*348
<
   
> C>
 !



:-4?43030514)0A?.,193-484A*18)*0948/7 20)3.456114D.)4  (*1530;4013-09)4,*)8-4 ?43030514)  *334A?348  35  944E  3-4  843*0+9  56  3-4 ;5A?5141393-*3-*24,51401353-441-*1;4884A*18 /.3  3-4  )49?5184139  -*24  153  95  6*) 704+848  35  3-09 )4@.493

4(3-4)465)4(B03-5.3;5AA41301,513-4A4)039 56  3-4  099.49  )*0948  01  3-4  ?)49413  ?4303051  844A  03 *??)5?)0*3435809?594563-49*A4/7,0201,80)4;305135 3-4)49?518413935;519084)3-4?+4*563-4?43030514) B03-)4,*)8353-49.??+756;5A?5141393-*3-*24,514 01353-441-*1;4884A*18-09B)03?4303051/43)4*348 *9*)4?)49413*305135/49./A03348353-4)49?5184139 B03-01*?4)058563B5B44E96)5A358*7(B-4)4.?513-4 )49?5184139  9-*++  9.??+7  3-4  ?*)30;.+*)9  35  3-4 ?43030514)B03-0165.)B44E93-4)4*634) 430305193*189809?594856H )84)8*348



  > 
C! :$4*)148;5.194+65)3-4)49?51841399./A0393-*3 -4-*90193).;30519359./A033-*384A*18)*0948/7 20)3.456+4334) 114D.)4 !?)58.;4801 
> C>

 ( -*9/441 B03-8)*B101204B566)49-?5+0;7 56  8*348

 
C 93-484A*18-*9/441B03-8)*B1(3-4;*.9435 60+43-09?4303051-*9/441)4184)48016).;3.5.99*18 B-41  6.)3-4)  84A*18  09  )*0948  *9  ?4)  14B  ?5+0;7( ?43030514)B0++/4*??)0948563-49*A4 1204B569./A09905156+4*)148"3*34;5.194+( +4*)148;5.194+65)3-4?43030514)944E9?4)A09905135 B03-8)*B3-40193*13?4303051B03-+0/4)3735?43030514)35 *2*0+53-4)+4,*+)4A487B03-)4,*)8356)49-84A*18(06 *17()*0948/7 01204B56?5+0;78*348

 
C

/

09A09948  *9  B03-8)*B1  B03-  +0/4)37(  *9 *65)49*08H &@777>8=7@?7A:, @@877  97?=987@?,

).1*++0!   .8,4  %0E)*A,,*)B*+!

.8,4 

 *G*1 @<7>(5 *%"(#

 @A85 *%"(#