High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1619/2023dismissed

State Of Punjab And Others v. Ram Charit Shukal

2023-11-087 pages

!" ! #$%&' ()*+(+,- .// 0121(,34-5262-+$17(89 :;;(<<2-19 =(8949 >2? 728*1074@2< :>(9;,-+(-1 ABC DAEF E G E C DAF EA!" HHH 8(9(-1 &9/2I2-J224<KLK4-526 HHH A!"G F

&M N,8 17( 8(29,-9 (-4?(821(+ *- 17( 2;;<*)21*,-K 17( 92?( *9 2<<,O(+ 2-+ +(<2J ,3 +2J9 *- 3*<*-P 17( 2;;(2< *9 7(8(6J ),-+,-(+K 9465()1 1, 2<< 5491 (Q)(;1*,-9/ &2*-;;(2< /

72<<(-P( *- 17( ;8(9(-1 *-182 ,481 2;;(2<K 4-+(8

<249( R ,3 17( (11(89 21(-1 *9 1, 17( 54+P?(-1 +21(+ / M/ K I*+( O7*)7K 17( <(28-(+ 0*-P<( S4+P(2<<,O(+17()*I*<O8*1;(1*1*,-;8(3(88(+6J17(8(9;,-+(-1/ / (28-(+ 0121( ),4-9(< O,4<+ 946?*1 1721 2- (88,8 72+ )8(;1 *- 17( ,8+(8 ,3 <(28-(+ 0*-P<( S4+P(K *-29?4)7 29 1721 17( 8(9;,-+(-1K O7,9( 9(8I*)(9 72+ 6((- 1(8?*-21(+K O29 ,- 8(P4<28 (9126<*97?(-1K 2 32)1 O7*)7 72+ 6((- +(-*(+ *- 17( O8*11(- 9121(?(-1 1721 7( O29 2;;,*-1(+ 1, 17( ;,91 ,3 ;(,- ;48(<J ,- 1(?;,828J 629*9 2-+ 29 ;(8 1(8?9 2-+ ),-+*1*,-9 17(8(,3 7*9 9(8I*)(9 ),4<+ 6( 1(8?*-21(+ 21 2-J 1*?( O*17,41 2-J -,1*)( ,8 8(29,-/ T1 +*+ -,1 (-12*< 2-J 91*P?2/ &,8(,I(8 17( ;8*-)*;<( ,3 -, O,8@K -, ;2J 6(*-P 2;;<*)26<(K 17( ),-9(U4(-1*2< 8(<*(3),4<+-,172I(6((-P82-1(+1,17(8(9;,-+(-1/

!" # $%&# '& ( &%& !" ) !)%!% *%+ !" ! &&%* $!! % %!%&

!"! " ( &# )# ,- )% ("%+" !" # $%&# '& ## ( "% !%!% !" !)! ( .!%% ! "* !" &%! "%)-

%! ! + "% %!)!- %!

%& ++ %& ! !" !) + %!% "%#!! %!)! /

%%& !" + !!% - ("%+" "

! #, &

, !" + # !" ##!- %! % ! %! %)!%* ! !)% !" ! !" %!)! !" ! 0 *%& " (%!" !" .%+!% !" )!!- !%! + % ) !%# ! !" ++ %& +!% % !" 1 * . - ! /- + !%!% !" !) , ! %+#%& !"! - !" !)! 2 $#%- +! % !" %!%+!

) %! 3# 2 )- . - !" 4%! ("%+" ( !

)! ) !" ). " ++ ! / %*%# $#% !" 64%! 6 +)! 0+"%, %)#)!!% !"

) !+!% +!- 7- %!! 2 ) 89 #:;- % 4 ! !" ! # %<(%- ) # *% 1 * . ! /- + %

! % !) !" !

, !"%

!- ! !" %+!% !" "%&- %! %

! !"! 9 # ! %+#%&

( +!% !) ,

% !" %!%+! 2 ) ! #%"%& !"! ( *% #, +!% =" * ( !" &% %+ !" !%+- 4 -

, !" %!- %!%+!

) %! 3# 2 )-

/- +##%& #%+!% (%!" + )#!

% ! ! 7/ %##%& !( ! $! &"- =,%! 86&#%":-

#< 8 :- !(

! "#" " # !

$% "% & "# #! $

' ( % " ) # ''*

" $

! " ) $ ! "' ,' #!& " "

##! "

" + -

! "# + ."',* * /

# " + ."',, 0 %

''*' 1 " % $ #

"# "" " & " ,'

' " + " % $ )

"" )! !

$ # " + ## # $ )#

"& )! #!

$ % "

"+ #" + "

' -' "

" % )# + # & 2 % )! " &

& " # ! "# + ."',* * /

# " + ."',, 30 $ " ! " 4 " ! " ) + 2 " " .#" + 5) 6%

# " "" # ) $ 5 $% "% & + $

$ " + "" )

"" )! 783 78 # " ) + " + *

!" + " 5 $& + # $ " " ) ## ' 9% # ! )5 " )

" + #

)! ## "%

" + " $% )! 1 5) "

" . ""# :"

#""(((

#"" (; .$# & & " " ! # ! + + # $ # " % #)# " % # $

" # )# )

" "" "# ' 1 ") ""

""$ ) % " )%' ' 1

+ 2# !

# & ##!

+ )

+ "% )

" !

#$!#% &"! ! # ' !

( #

) *+,-)) ./0)) 123)) 45/56)) +7)) 8/9:/;/) < = >

? @ AA=<

'# #

# < B C

$ <

" # #'

! D

" $

# $

' !!$#

$ ! !

!'#% $ #

' !

" < !

" $

" ! % F! ' #

'G$ % $ H

' # !

" $ % $ #!

'% C" H $

# !

" $ G #

# !

< $$

! "

$$ G % "

< !!$!

" !

# !

$ #

" $$ G

! #

# #

" $ $ #

' !# $$

$$' !

" $ % I > # $ < $ #$

$ !!$

# %

" $$ #

$$' !

$ $$ # ! #

# # !<

# ) ./J;K)) L/,/)) 123)) 45/56)) +7) ) 8/9:/;/M) N >

? @ A=A% $ " " $ #

" < '

" $!$

" ( ! !

" C# #

# $#

$ O PQRSOO TUOO RVRWRQO % X>) Y9K2Z/;) ) [/,)123)45/56)+7)\)])YM) ^_>

! "

#$ ## "

# !

' # #

(

& !! & "

# & )

$ " !! (&

) " ''# !

! #

) $ ( !! &# ) &

) '

' "# !

#$##$# * &

! '

!! ) & ) "

# # !#!# !# # & '& + ,

' ## #(#(

!! )

&# - # & )!# $

!# )

" !# ( ) # $ &

/ 012324// 56781// 9// :3;// <;=// 5424>// ?@// A23B272// 9// :3;/ C/ %D EE , E " #'##

& # &

, !#)

" & !( #

$ # # &# ! # #''$ * !(

! # &#

)

$ # #G #

" ! &# ! #

#''$

$ !#' '

" ! .

+ ,

" !#)

)"#

)

# ' ' !

( ##

# &

)

# '

" #( #

# &

"#H '# & "

" " & '

! (! ##() # #( # %/ 5424>// ?@// A23B272// <;=// I6232// 56781C/ JK ,

, !#)

# "

)! & '# '# (

& #

# # !# )!

) #

# #( # '#

#$ +

# (

! $ !!#

! !" # $! ! "

! !

%&"'"('# # ) !

$ % *% " !% !

+' ) $!

! , -./,, 01213/45,, 678/429/2:,, ;412<.,, =4/>>,, 12?, , 127:./4,, 8>@,, A@;@;/BBC1DD1, EFG $

FFH ! % !

"!&"

! %&!

"!&

!% " '

" & '

& ! ! !

"!& !

" ! H " ' ' !

! ! "

" %

% " %

%! !

"# J " !

!'!

%! " '!

!! " # # J " !

' ! $ &

""JK & % ' ! !

' " % !H! " !'!

! "" " !# L# M!

N ' "'

"" !" " ' %!

! !

!IH

! ! , O:1:/,, 7P,, Q/41B1,, R,, S4>@,, 8>@,, T@Q@, , ;.1>U1412,, =CBB1C5, E FG $

LH '

H !

+' $!

! '"!& ! V !I

! '

! & ' "!

" " '

" H W###X & "! " " ' ' ""# $

" " !% !

! ' " !!"& ! " !

H " " "# )!

! & !"

" & ' "!# $ "

" ! Y! ! !

" "

!" %!

I %" ! L ! '

I %" I %

! Y &&

! ! !

"" ! ' " '

Y ' %& % ' ' !

Y # $ "

! "#

$ # #

! & '

!( ! ! #

"# & $ ## ! ! !( ) ( &

& (

" $ #

! ( "# "%

" (

& ! $ # )

&$' $( ## & (

# ) * + &, (+

!") * - & $ ! ("# ). ) /

! '

( $ (

%! "(

0 1' &

# ( $ )

&$' " 2 '

3 4 #

& #

! # $ '

- ' %! # 0 % !#) ) /

() 5) 0

" '

6 #) 89:;<7=>?9:@7777777777777777777777777777777777777778>A>B7C?><D?>9E@7 >C;:BF7C?:GH7I<J;:CG7 I<DFG7 5)) $K!,, L ,K MN0KO/ L P "

MN0KO/