Vinod Goyal And Another v. State Of Haryana And Others

 


    

     

































  


 

  
! " !#$%& " '() 
& )(&)  

*(

!#$%& " '() 
& % % $



  
!
"#
$%"
"&
'(" )
*
 !
+
!"%&

%
&
"""
,* !
-*"*"&

 &
"""
"

!
""

*
!"

&
 &
"""
!
+
!"%&
'("
,*
!
.*"% 
.
!"(*" "&
'("
" !
*'"#
" &
'("
)
 /  )(&)  

*( + ' 1

*
(%"#
#"



*
"
,


)
" #" "#

#"



*
 
(( &
&

#
) *
%(
"
12345316
7 8
/19:
)
*
"""

'#
*
#"+
*

%" 

%"
)# "(;&
"*

*
(#
/"%

'"

%
)



)
*
;
 %(

5

*
%"
(%
""
)
*

*" )()%%
( &

%"+
 #&

*
#" "
) (
131

)
*
 *

"
-#"
" ""(




"
(;&
*"

%"
"
%#
(&
531< 7*")
)
*
)

"
*
= (
)
531<=:
"
("# ("

*
> (
)
531<=&
* *
"""
(

51
)
5316& '
,*)
"
8"(
*")&
*"
*

%" 
" /"%

'"

%
)
*
%'"
 %(

*)&
* *"
" 
*"
*

%" &
('
)
*
"%
%"(*

"(;
(  
 
*
"
(;
(&
1642 7*")
)
*
("%%
"
*
= (
)
1642=:
*
(#
)%% #" &
"*
"
/"%

"
'"

%
)


)
* %'"
 %(
&
* 
*
"

"'"%"

%
)
(#

%"
)#
"(;

  

     
     



                    

  

! "

#

 $%#"

                    "   &  $%#"

'

  ""

 "'        ( )#   

  *  "

# 

"  "

  #' #

 '  ""' "

$%#"
+ < *&
"
"
*"

#"



*
,

) "(
)
(

*
 

( 
" ( 
* "
"
15345355
7 8
/1?:
)
%"
)
%"
 ',
)
(
131/
)
*
= (
)
531<=
2

*)&
*
%"
(%
""
)
*
 *"

%"+
*
 #&

"'%
)
(
131

7":
"
,%%

, "&

"(*
)
(%"
@
)
*
%(
"
12345316
)
*
"""

'#&


*
"
 #
(#
(#%% * &

*
)"(
)
"
()(
(
8

""

"*
 12
)
*

%&

")) "'&
"
)*

*


*  
(( &
(
,*)
"
8"(
*") ,



- # # 

' "."
 $./0 1 
+ 9
"


)
*
"
(&

#"+
"*( # (7:&
*"
*

%" 
"
"#"+
)
*
"  %(

"
* 
"
%A &

"
%A"

%&
"
&
" '"

%
)
)"(%"
*
"
 %(

-;%&
* (%
)
*

("
" &
*"
*

%" 
" *
/"%

'"

%
)
)"(%"
*
"
 %( 

*
("
,%%

"
" #
# &

*
' )
(
131

)
*
= (
)
531<=


',
)
*
%(
"

12345316
-"%&

'"%
#"
)
"%
%"(*

"(;
(  
 
*
= (
)
1642=&
*

* &
)
"&
)
*

%" &

*
&
("%% ,*
*
' %
 /'
*
 %(
&
*

"* (#%%
%",)%
*
"

*"
*
"

'

#


"'%
)
(
131

)
*
= (
)
531<=

&
%(
"

12345316&

(#%%
("(
"
"%

" "
*
"


*"
*
"
  
*&
""

/ "%

'"

%
)
*

%" &
*
)
)"(%"
* "
 %(
&
"*
"


 &

"'%
)
 B(' (#%"&
"
#"



*
"*
(( &
"
(
*

"

'
 B('
*
(#%"&


#")"'&
*"
* 
%" 
"
"
 "%
(#
)
*
%"
%"
%"
 *
(#%
)
*
%'"
 %(

*)&
*
%"

(%
)
*

*"
"

%
%"+
*
"

'
" #& *
#

*
'
)
(
131

)
*
= (
)
531<= " C&
&
%(
"
12345316 ?
*#&
*
% "%
( #
%"

* #" 
)
 )("

*
"
"
("  ='"

%=

=/"%=
)
*
"(;
%" 
*"

%


"
B

#
#"



*
-

("

%

"
=       

 

        

!

,*&

*
%'"
""

"*
*)&
""
,*)
" 8"(
*")&
*
-
*"
8 &
*"
#
/ %A"
)
*
"(;
%" 
"*


%'"


*
%"
% (( &

(%"#
*"
* 
*
"
"(;
%" 
"
* '"

%
" C
"
/"%
)
)*
*
;
 %( 
-"%&
*
-
*"

*
*")
8"(
%'" ""

"*&
"
("

*
' (
7":&
*"
"+
*
',&
*"
* "(
)
*
"

'
"
("

&

*"&


"%("

%
%

"

"
)' #"2"


"
"
,*

"(( )
"
8 "
#
)
(#"
(# # 
* -%%(
(( &
* &
*
"
8(*;
(#

(# 
,*
"

)"("%
 &
,* &

""%% *
"
)"(
)
'"

%

/"%&
;"
*

)
* "(;
%" 
"*
)
)*
*
;
 %(
&
* ,+
"
"
,%%
("&

*
"(;
"*

((% & *"
"
(*
*
"(;
%" &
"
"#"

%
)
(#
%"


8#
)#
"(;&
'
*


(#

)"("%%
'"

%
D@5 !'&
*
-

"#$"!
%
"

%



&'(

 )  

"(



* ( + ,

-

 ./ 

  

0! ,

 1$!#"


*
*")
8"(
 '" / ,.

 $  /           $

'            $ %#"3 '  "#' $4

5  # 

  " 

 ", #

+, +  



 
6/
-"

$  ./6$4

5 "  

   $/
-#' '$4

5

 

     &     $  /
-    #  $  /        #7         '




-     

      

     "       #

 "

      $  %#"    "   

2#  7'

'


+ 56
8# # 

  '                      

'    

 "        #$/./6         

'          $ %#"3 '     

  ", #

+, +  



     #  '   

'#     



 

 

'7    "   '' '"  
-    # $/       #7           '   

      "'  , #

+  , +     

 

        




 -           

  # 

" #         "        $ %#"" 2#  7'  '


59
   " 2#  & # '#7 "       2#          !

        "    "7'      2# !  ## & # 7'#    ' "

 '    !  
 -    '    

 !#   7'  &"

              & #"7' 2#"

  "'   ! "'   !             '    "    ' 

 
-"!"7' 2# "

##"''"      ! "

#"  



         

  
 8      

     

    

" 7'





 3 

 

"''

"

"

#



 
-#    &2 # &"    "

       

      

- ''  

      '     
:

   #        "         

     

      

  
 8   !   

 #    "     " 

 !
54
8"7' #  

 " 

 #     '

 

  '



 !  # 1 ;# ")  
 -             ''

"

"'



   

 # " #   

 2 

 #



 
- ' #



  "

  " '

 #  


 55
<  "'

 *   #



  "  "   *  

 '   

  * 



   

 

      # ' 

 
%

' 



   


2

 34 5 0!67 11$$!=>

$

"     ( ,


6
8#"       

  4        #      $    "  

 "


 -     "'(     %#"    '           ?8      

 

      

 

    # 

  

 



 
8



           

 



 "   

          



 #';#)

   
8  & #

## 
@  ";#0

2   '& ## 
# '""

 



 
A %#"

     '

 

  '  '''#






+   #$/#         $  %#"      "   * '

   "

'  , #   +,  +  

'

  



 
- 

   #      *!           '   "   " , #

+, +  



 
- '



  !



   "7' !  !  



 



" #
8  # #



   #  ' #*
 -   #  

  

                     !   &"

! '"  !

  #            

    "

  *  '

"

/
8    

# '    

"  ##  

 !  ' #        , #   +    ,  +

  

   

&  & # 

# !#"2

& &# ""

"

"'  "            

"7'     #  2      

 #


-"   " "     #    "#"'! #  "2   

  &     &#   "   "

" "'"      "7' # 2 

#





-   #      '     "

    2'      '

"         ! !'"$ /          ./6    

       
/
./
+ @ !'&

"
' (
  
*
= %
8
- 
("

../ 001/ - , 2 , %
" #13.4 $15 /1/

6171/ 8 4 )919 2 "1411491 1 !#&

*"
 8%" 
*
= %
8
-&
*

*
%'"
""

"* *)&
""
,*)

8"(
*")&
*"
*
("

"

#
%#
,*
,*(*
*
"*
"
8(

%A
* "(;
%" 
,
8 #='  

 &"  "  ""

& & 2   ..4  '  

     "     * 



  
%



+ +

,







 



  

!

8(9,( (

:

,;  ,9

, +

 

+ 



;



,



 9  <

 (9,( (

6, !



, 9  '

'  

 ,



  

=( ,

   <

 ,;

    %

3,( 

 , 

+ ,



=( ,



+"

'( 

+

('

  9

 

( (

!,

(,5

 

;

9 5 ( , 

( ,





 6

* &
"%
'
)
*
"(;
%" 
#"
/ %A
)
"
% "
)
#&


#"
/%A & * 
"%

*"
"%

(%"

*
' (
#"



*
- 
./ ) .# 1 : 01;&
*"
*
"#(
)
*
 %(

" '
(*" 
"
*
("


"
(*" 
)#
*
 %(
&
" *

*
)("
)
"(;&
"*

#
*
 %( 
%"%
"
(*
*
)"(#
)
*
%" 

/ %A
("
'
"
%'"



*
(%
)
*

 (
*"
*
"
'"

%

/"%
)
)*
* ;
 %(


*
("
" 
*"
* 
*

%"

)#
"(; 4
!'&

"


)
""

2
"
9
)
*
% )*

*
,

&


'"%
*"

)
*
%"


;
,"
"+
' 
""
A"#(*"

9?6
"
543?1446 13
*&


 ("

*
%

")) "'&
*"
* 
*"

"%
)%
-E/53119
)
5312&
,* 
*
(%"#

%)
*"
*
%"(*
"(;
)("7:

(%"


(#
%"

#
)
(
5275:
)
*
= (
)
531<=
,'& *
"
,

,"

)

*
-


' 
 
"

39365319
,*
% 

*


)%
"
"%
"

(#*'
"

(#%"(

*
"
 
*


 #
"
)
*
 
(( 

,'&
*
"
"
("#
B(
' 
 
"

1632531@
7 8
/1<:
11

*")&
*

)%
-E/1@63@/531@ (*"%% 
*
")"
B(
 
"
1632531@
,'& *
"
,

("#
# 
*
-
' 
 
"

31155353
7 8
/12:
*
"'
"
)
*
"
 
 8"(
*") ,




8#"   ,+ 

   

(  

 ,,

 ,;   ( ,

+  9,5

 11>

+ 

,

 9 

(

 



'



  ,   

  ,       

 

(

 

 , 

     9?

,  

'

 -    #             #  " '

  # =B

$

" 8;# "  

! 

 <
64695!
+ 15

* 
"%
*

*
"
" 
* (%
)
%
(" 
 
5
%
5
)
*
--
*
"


*"
* *
*
"
,

("#
)%

*
"
531@&


,*

("#
(

31155353
%"%
,*


*
 (
)
*
"
,
&
(
131/
7":
("#  
*
"""
(

51
)
5316

;%&
,*
* 
*
(%
,%%
,*
*
%"'
)
*
-&
*
"#

*
,


*
8
7":
,'&
,*
*
*
"

%"'
("#
"+
)


("#
" 
*)&
)
# 
*
"
)
*


("'"
*
"
%"

*
*" ,*
*
"%
,

,"
 B (
%

"
)(
*"

 * 
*
(#
 
*
(%
*

 
5 %
5
--

"
*
"
#
%"

*
"
,


1<
!'&
*
"'#
"

*
 
"((

' 
(#"7:&
'/"/'
*
7:
*&
* * "%
#"+
"%%

()(
"(
)
(#"7:
"

)#
%"

#"



*
#%"%
"
%"
% (( 
,'&
(
*
-
)
"
7":
*"
#" 
"

)#
((%
*"
*
"(;
%" 
"
"
 "%
(#
)
* %"
%"
*&
*
"
((%
"%

*
%" /% ((

(%"#
"
,*
*
 %
#%"%
"

"
*% 
((
;"
,*#
%"7:
,
#"

&


* #
*"
*
%"
%" 
,

"
 "%
(#
)
* %"
%"

*&
*
" #
7":

#/%&
" &

B( 

12 *#&
*
%"
)
*

;"
*
%",)%% "

'
*
 B(
%" &

"
#/)
%"&
"& *
(("
)
*
&
'
*
 B(
%" 
"*

" "
*'
"
*

"
;


%",)%% '(
*)#
*
"

'
(#
"+
)#
*
)"(#
*" 
"(
)
"
)("
 
(
2
)
*
= (
)
1642=&
* %"
,7:
("#
'
)
"
 *&
%


'
* "(;
%" &
,*"&
(#%
'#
)
 *&
%
"
 '
*
"(;
%" &
"*
("#
*
() &
&
* "(;
"* <.1/ ! 2 94.
 9 19

")#"*&
*
-
) 

#

*
,
& " &
,*
*
"

'
 '"&
*
"#

# 
*
# 

, )("7:&
"
(;
*
","
"
#""
"

"))# 

1? 
 
"

(

1@
(
*
#"
("
%)
*"

( &
*&
"%%
*  
"%("7:&
)
"&
"%
" 7:

) :)(&)  

*(;

'(&

:% % $

 ;

  

'(& +"'
 *


494 013.6=1 >= 494 0915/ >=