← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/482/2023allowed

Satwant Kaur And ORS v. M/S Robin Transport Service And ORS

2025-07-23Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma10 pages

           



!"

 #$%$!&'

()*  +   

 

        

    '

 ,-

./ .  .

.     



   





!

     " #

$$$$ .

.

/

#

     

         %      

#& '( )'))   *    #++  ,   #-../      0*  1  2   3  45  ** %   *   )# .# ++67%  8(9  * 

 1 %  ,       )( #'

)'#-

)

   * 

  :**  /            :        ; / .

..

 .

 -   .-    .

&

     *7

   * /           

      /          

      

*     

<

                   "  # 

 */ %    % /   *

 *      /        % /% 

    /  * 



( =               

.

     

  6)/  % *  %     

      % / *    ) 6'

'''7  * > *   ?

      *       

      :  % 0 

.- -0 

  . 

-

>4   *  0           Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 12

.(45 6 !(5  % %  

 **      *    7 @30     

            

    

       

              

   

     

 

       

 

     

           

   

         !"#$            

  %#  !"&$

   

  &'   !"($       

 

 31)

        

        *  

         (+,                  







   

  

-  

    

 

      

      

 $          .  /

 

         

                *  

 

                     

  

         

      32 

                   (+,          

    (+,          

         

  

           

             



 

        

   * * * * * * 42. )     

 

    &$          0

 1   $        !2    !(%+ %!

%(

$ 

    

 3!4 %'#+

3!'#!#(

3!(#'&+

3

!&&!&(

 3!#&'(+

  



   

 3!!(!((

35 (''+

34'!'(

 3(''4+

#'

>4 *0  National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 1

. 37    #++ #+&7  #+.  ,   #-..

 % 7          %  ?

     * *  2B5 *    %% 

%   

/%*  A 2 5   %       */       *  ?

  A 2C5 D    %        %  *EA7* /  ?  /      E %*     7 @52. 6  conventional heads

    

   

 7/

8*

    7 %(+++       

  7  !+++++  

  7 !+++++ 



 

         

      

   7/

  0  9 

 





       



   

 

  

 

   :    

        6     

+              

     



 



    

   

  

  

   

  ; 

       

          

     

        

   

     



   



                

  

*

     

            

  

 

  

     

 

!(+++  7 &++++     7 !(+++  

    

                    



    <              

  

 

 )     

               

  

    

  

   !+,   

) 

 

 

  





  = = = = = 59.3)    

  (+,    

 





 / 

   &+

    

 #+, 

  

&+

(+

* 

  

 (+'+

    !(, 6   

   

 59.4* 







 $ 

   &+,

  



  

    &+

6  %(,

  

  &+(+

 !+,

  

 (+'+

   

  

  

     59.5.              

           #+#%0> ?  



    59.6. 

         

  0> @ &%/

 59.7 

         59.87   

        





 

    

 7

!(+++7 &++++ 7 !(+++

  

    

  !+,  

A ## >4   *  0           

 & 5 )

&%(5 &# !64 &* -$6$ :

;%/

&(

)$ % <(<5(  < 5% 1 

. 7    % .

5)

; 56 %(45



5 & * . <$ .(45

  % % * 

  *      7 B216  <

  C  0 8         

  

         

  ;

   

      

 

*  

D D  

   



 D    D  D 

D D D 

      





 

 

  



    )  

      

       

  

 

%!! Spousal consortium   

        

         

    



D  

   

     

 /  D %!% Parental consortium      



              

   D    

   

     

   

     D %!# Filial consortium             

  

 

   6

     

          

  

   

    

     

              22  



 

     

       3 /     

 

  

E    

 

       

   

 3 /                

   

           

 

  

      

 23 3> 

6  

    

      

  

 

   

* 

       

               

               

C       

    

    6 6      

    

      

  

   

           

   

24  

   

    

 

   D

 D   C  0 8*  





  

  

   7 &++++  

  -.



#)

=  / >4 *0     E %* 



  

#& '( )'))   *    %/     

7*          **    *  7  7 Sr.

No.

Heads Compensation Awarded #  /=*  )'.&&72)6''''#)5 ) D   8#'9  )'.&72#'9)'.&&5 &        ?

  #&

 (+&-72))-#+F#& <

=*  #6))(72))-#+7(+&-5 <    ##

   /  )'

#+ 6+<72#6))(F#)F##5 + GC  #.

'''7 ( D C?

  #.

'''7 .

G0 *  # << '''7  <.

'''7?#   <.

'''7?) !

) !64 &% $!& %/ =23=+3>  :(#$!&

*  /   %/ = =33+> &< &# :

6!(& %/ =22>  23+3 33+

#&

      

  />4 * 0 Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma  

 R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation 

+ .(45 6 !(5  % % 8=  

7* %    8-9  *   * * %*    H

#<

  " #       * * %        *  *    / E %*           ** %    *

     #& '( )'))  *

 

     ;   

#6

 %

 /    

.

.



 !/)&7)')6 1     I    ;%7 ;% J" I        J