Dinesh v. Rajesh And ANR.

   
      


 ! "#$%$ & ' ()(* $&%+ ((((((((  $ &, -,%.% /%+ +, (((((( %0 &"& '

12 ( 3
 3  ,%& ' ,( , %+ 3$&4+
+ .+ &5 "6 #

! , $ &,( ,( 7,$8  ,9 :5   ,;

! , ,%0 &"&  ( 3

3 5 (  $ &, $&%+ % !$:"

+$% 0 $ & <=
,((
( %8$&4 >.

%+$&4 !

+ ,", "

" (( &&?., * %%" @;

,&" ""$ : 3%%$ &% ."45 9 ,$5 9+,@;

$ & .&", 3# $ & *=
,((
(5 !$:" @;

$ &,5 ! , ,7 &"$&4 % @ #8

:
., 5 + % @& "$%7$%%"( ( ,$!:;5 + 0 $ &, 9 ##.%" $& # 70:

$& !$:"

.&", 3# $ &% *= < !

+ 4 @: &% ,.7& % # 5 ==

+,$& , ,!,,"

% 1 + (( # ( !

:5 $ &, 9 # &6$# " ! , + !!&# 0.&$%+ @: .&", 3# $ & *= !

+ (( # 6$" /."47& ! # &6$# $ & "

" (( 0 %%" @; ."$#$ :  4$%

 %

:

%%5 9 &" 6$" %0

 ,", ! %& &# "

" ((5

+ 0 $ &, 9 % %& &#"

.&",4 %$70: $70,$% &7& ! ,

0,$ " ! %$? 7 & +% ! , # 77$%%$ & ! !!&# 0.&$%+ @: .&",

 3# $ & *= !

+ (( #

&" @; $70 %$&4 !$& ! %( )5 ( *( $&4 44,$6"

! ,% $" /."47& ! # &6$# ,", ! %& &#5 $ &, +,$& !$:"

: @! , +
., ,&" ""$ : 3%%$ &% ."45 9 ,$( .,$&4 + 0&"&#; !

$"

:5 $ &, +,$& !$:"

$ & *=
,((
( %8$&4 ,7 &" !

% @ #8

:
., @; # & &"$&4

".,$&4 # .,% !

:5 & (( 9+& + 7

, 9 % :$% " @! ,
.,

4 ! ?

7$&

$ & ! "!&"

9$ &%%%5 & $" "

;5 # 70:

$& 7 6"

$ & *
,((
( ! , ?

7$&$&4

""$ : 9$ &%%% $"

$ & 9 :: 9" & =(( 9$ &%%% & 7:; 3 &/ ;5
:,8 $& + 3 :% &"  ?

!!$#5 9 ,$ 9 ?

7$&"

% A 9+ 0, ".#" " #.7& % - * +, 9$ &%% A 6".

5
:,8 ! 3 :%  ?

!!$#5 9 ,$ 9 :% ?

7$&" 9+ &","

" #.7& % ?(A  ?(A (  + # & $ & !

$ &,

+ ?

7$&

$ & !

""$ : 9$ &%%%5 + %

##.%"

$ &, +,$& .&", 3# $ & **
,((
( 9 % & ,# ,""

&" # 70:

 $&#,$7$&

$&4 #$,#.7%

&#% 9, & 0.

+$7 &" + 9 % # &6$# "( <( + ! ,% $"

$ & *=
,((
( 9 % # & "

@; ,%0 &"&  (  +,$& /%+ 9+,$& $ % %.@7$

"

%$&# A

&" A 9, !!$#$ : 9$ &%%% &" " #.7& % 9, !!$#$ :5 +,! ,5 +, % & 7$?$&4 $& +$, $7 &$% +, 9 % & ## %$ & ! ,

70,$&4 9$

+ " #.7& %(  % %

"

+, $% & ,>.$,7&

6$"&# !

#+ 9$ &%% 7.% @ 0.

##.%"(  % !., +, %

"

7, 7$%%$ & 0.

>.%

##.%" 9 .:" & $0% !

#

7 .&

,/# $ & !

+ 6$"&#5

* .&:%% ##.%" %+ 9%

+ 9 % 0,/."$#"

+ &.% %+ 9 %.#+ 0,/."$# :

;% & ##.%"(  :% %.@7$

"

+ @ %$# $&4,"$& % !

+ !!&#% 9, 0.

##.%" $& +$% %

.&", 3# $ & **
,((
( ## ,"$&4:;5 $ % 0, ;"

$ & @ "$%7$%%"( )( +
., ! :

,&" ""$ : 3%%$ &% ."45 9 ,$5 6$"

$70.4&" ,", "

" (( &&?., * 5 "$%7$%%"

.&", 3# $ & *=
,((
(5 !$:" @;

$ &, +,$&( ## ,"$&4:;5

$ & + % @& !$:"( (  + 6 + ," :

,&" # .&%: ! , $% &" + 6 0,.%"

0, @ 8 % 9::

+ $70.4&" ,",( ( ! , # &%$",$&4 + # & $ &% !

$ &,5 $ 9 .:" @

00 %$

,!,

!9 /."47& % ,&"," @;

+  &1@: 0?
., =( &
 

    
 

 



+,."4 &#+ !  &1@: 3.0,7
., +:"

6,; ,, , , 7$%%$ & $& # 70:$ &# !

+ 0, 6$%$ &% ! 3# $ & *< !

+ :"
,$7$& , #".,
" " % & &#%% ,$:; 6$

:( + ##.%" 7.% %+ 9

% 7 0,/."$# + % @& # .%" , 9 % :$8:;

6 @& # .%"

+$7( & 

 

  
   
 &1@: 3.0,7 , # &%$",$&4 :

,4 &.7@, ! # %% + $%%.5 +:"

% .&", '

 !"

#
#$%& "'$""

$##&

( )  *'

+ ,& "(

- #" (( #%"$%(%( #(#+#"## && "(( #%

,.

"# / 
0

 ' +"& " (( #% #"0 " " "# ' - #% .% (

( #(#
#%"  ##"0"# ("1."#(

,%

%(%"%"# #

%"&

&2 #( " 0 %#
"$&%$ ##" &"

< (

- #"(( #%,( +( #( ( #&($"  ####"0"# 

%(0#( #%"(( #%',"##&" 

 3 B( % ,4 ,"% + 0 9, ! # .,

,", , :5 $&    

 

   4
 &1@: 3.0,7
., +:"

00::

 # ., ,$&4 #,$7$& : !, 7 /."47& ! # &6$# % 0 9, ,", + , : !

##.%" .&", 3# $ & *= !

+
"5 + 96, %.#+ 0 9, %+ .:" & @ ?,#$%" $& , .

$& 7 &&,(  % !., +, +:"

" & 6 : , , : !

##.%" %+ .:" @ ,"," @;

00::

 # ., $& ?#0 &" , , # %% &" &:; 9+& $& + 0$&$ & !

00::

 # ., %.#+ # .,% @# 7%$&"$%0&% @:

6, $:., ! /.% $#( (
7$&4

% $& + &"5

! 0 $ &, ,# ,""

.&", 3# $ & **
,((
( &&?., < "% % .&", '

 56 786 :;6 < #; "#($%(+#,

", ## %0("- #' +   44  &   # 

=1  % ;  44    &  # 

=1   &$

&(

%#(" +& ,

' , 0 %# " (


0"(" 6. )%)  ( %   >"  ,  "$    #, ' ?

#0 #(

( < #; !"  0"  "- #  6. )  %  ) 0 

#%& (#"
# 0   %#" %  0"   *#

# &&(  & %#  %  % 0 @# #+

%&& 3?>", "$

) #,' ? #0 #(

( < #; !"  " &
 (

 # 

(%%  "

+"

"#( #
"0$ %#  ( &(


,0#+$  >" , "$#,' ?

#0 #(

( < #; !"
"

#, "$(%&&(

#"'

 ( &; (?>", "$#,' ?

#0 #(

( < #; >",  "  0###  "$  % #% +#, ?

#0 >### & # ,  < #; >" #, "$#,,

%&(?

#0 "$## %,("-   ; #+

,"%#

%("- # < #; :  ,

% (  ,  $%(   %&($%(?

#0 A# B*#"A%$ 55:1( 15B 0    CD

%=1 :#"3 ( C0$&4 $& 6$9 ! ,%

" :4 : 0 %$ $ &5 9+&

$ &, ,# ,"" .&", 3# $ & **
,((
( $% , "

9+ :5 $ #:

,:;

%+ 9%

$ &, 8&9 9+

##.%

+$7 9 &" + !!,"

& ?0:

$ & ! , 7(  $ &, 9 % 6,; 9::

, !



+$7 :% + !!&# ! , 9+$#+ + 9 % @$&4 ,$"( ( ,&" # .&%: ! , $ &, 9 % %0#$!$# ::;

%8"

9+

0,/."$# + % @& # .%"

+$7 9+

: #$,#.7%

&# + % &

@& 0.

+$7 9+$#+ %+ :: 6$

:5 + 96, & &%9, $% ! , +# 7$&4( +, $% & /.% $!$#

$ & ! , %.00 %$&4

+, + " @& &; 0,/."$# # .%"

$ &, & ## .& ! $70, 0, , $&%.!!$#$& ,# ,"" ! +$% %

.&", 3# $ & **
,((
( *(  0,.% : !

+ $70.4&" ,", 0 %%" @;

+ :

,&" ""$ 3%%$ &% ."45 9 ,$ 9 .:" ,6

$ & *=
,((
( !$:" @;

$ &, +,$&5 + % @& "$%7$%%" @; + :"$&4 % .&", ' & +$+" +"&

(#% " $ (# &'"#%#%

#+ ( %&(#
"#

#&" (#% % "

#

(# '

'%###% & " ##+$" &  /,0,&$+"

#

(
 "  

  "#  

+%  "  &  

0+

( ( )  %& .+)>

2,%)>4:$% %% +& $%( #
" (#  0#  &.%  &  %&(  $%(  '

  "  #  &  "

"#' ( %% ( )  +  )

# &" (

 ( % $ ""##& '""#%0###"$' ( %%"

#(& (( #%="#( # %'""#%0###"$'%

##1.%'," !"##" &"  %  (

  & 

+  # (&(  - ##    # 

( )  # %#'""#%0####+ % ((

%""

0#

,.%

( )  ;

%("#'( #%

% '$1#%  

   ##  %#    $  "     !"

#'+&

,0  %+"&&(& 0"("
" 0#'+

#( % B,$0#&%#

& (# %#

    !   " #$%&'#()*) '*  (%'+( 0" 
"#'" %',7@'

) 2'

D7 ,7+"

# E1

!"  (( #%1

  0#  &

,  0   &  "  (" +# '+&(%'," !" $%(&"

#(  "#' ( %%"#

#( 70# #0 &" 

&"$%('

+" ( %',"

#(  +#"  !" +"
"## (  ) 
"- # %+"(#( # ####"# '# (&(

,

"
'

"###&

+ # (&(- #"(( #%1

"##

( )  0" # ( "(#( #

#####+ %((

%""0#

.% ( )  %""# #

% ,

%("

  !#

"#$0

& (('%(#      , )!  - #$%.'#()*)'*  (/0$ '12(  !"7@'

 .

 #(# 3 *        !

     -   #$%.  '.(  )*) '*  (4%&"# %%0"$ ,

 ## "#&"(( #%%#(##  ,$ "  ##"(( #%#'

#"0""#"#

#

%

%(" "#(##

%, %""(( #%1

0#&

,0 &  "$ ,'++""#'+

#( %& "$+ & %(#( # ####&"( '% F % ( # & "

"#''

#"0# 0"

%("#'( #%"

% " ##  &  "  - #  0"  # (    "  (#( #

####"#&"(( #% (  )  $0&""# #2 %+#&":$# /("&"#

%"&"7@'

 .

(##

%

',  %( # & "

"# # (&"(# &"

" 

"  
"   % ,' ##%(## .(   (##  %  0"   "  ##    

+

,  "# ((#%&

&2 #( G

"
"   % ('

##%    "  (##
 0"   "   +    "#    ' ##&( ,& # (

### ("#0 +%## 0 + 2(&$%( "(

 & #%" (  0###
0"0 #

#%'" %  "# %
, $0#&%#

& (# 0 %#- 3  5

!  2   #$%6'%()*)'*  (%$&%'*(

= 0" "#'" %# E1

!" +""0 %

 3# #% ( '  ) 
 "  0 #  (&

%  ',  "#  ( #  #    ' . (#%   ,    .(   (##
 0"   "  

 (

  #  ##&%  "  "  ##    

+

,  "# ((#%  &

 &  2 #(   !"  ( #(# " #"

%.#& 0

+   #'# (""0" " 0# *',"

"$+2

#%(
 0#$%',#  #

, 

+

, (( &"#(( &

&

(%+#  % &  ,' ##%(##0" " +

"#'##&( ,& # (

## # ("#0 +%## 0 + 2(&$%( "  

  & #%    "  (   0###
 0"  0 #

#%'" % 3 H +$0"'$%#( ##%&(#%( #(# (

%0"'$1(%

#
"#

#&" (#% %  $0  "  " 

#  

(  #  '

    ' %###% 3 <(  + 6 4 & +, .4+ + ,", 0 %%" @;

+ :

,&" ""$ 3%%$ &% ."45 9 ,$ &

$ & *=
,((
( &"  !$&"

7 $% $& ## ,"

&# 9$ + :

&" & $& ,!,&# $% # ::" ! , $& $" ,",5 7 ,% 9+& & 0,/."$# + % @& %+ 9& @ # .%"

$ &, +,$&( )( & 6$9 !

@ 65 !$&"$&4 & 7,$ $& + $&%

$ &5 % "%,6% @ "$%7$%%"( &#5 + $&%

$ & $% "$%7$%%"( ( :: 0&"$&4

$ &% %

&" "$%0 %" !(

3   ()(*( %/8% A+ +, %0 8$&4 ,", '

 A+ +, ,!,,"

+ 0 , '