Moga Periphery Pump Association v. Union Of India And ORS.
!"# !$%&%"'
( ( ) )** *(
) + ,)(*) *,
! "# !$ % & & & !
'()* +$ !
', !
'- ....
) *, -(./ 01 ( / & & 001!
&!$ ! 0231030) 45& *67 8"
! 13
% 0 /
!
/
8 !
% /
8"
&
! & 13
% / !
&8 & 9& ! 8& 5
&!! ! ) &8 5& 8 +
5
:& & !)-3;!
<= % 4! ><=%?7/ (,(
% & !
@0 ; &
8 $!13
& % & ! " & &8 " &
& 8!"8$& &
/
5 "!5
/ & !
&8! & ! "! /
<= "
4! >+ /=?7!& &
8" & A 4! >A?7 %!! = & " &
&8"A 8 &
8 & !
& / +
03(6
"8 & !& & ! "
&8"
" & ! & & !+
5 & ! "
(63;
&8(33;/!
& ! (,(@4(74 7! &!
$ ,
& !
&8 8 !
+
8
!" 9 +
" " 8 "& 8 !
/ 89 & !
/
0231030)45& *67/
" 023@030) 5(6(3030)/
! 8! & & 8 !
"
! " & B !"
8" & & "!! ! "8
/+
!
& ;+$&
"! '+
! &(,, ! & & 0330% &"
8!
& '+ &
! !! & & A / !!C%$!% &"
!
! &
&8" B &
&'+ &"
&8 & $03(2
*A; 2 "0
&8 & 8& ! & & 8 !
'+! % &"
- I have heard arguments of both sides and scrutinized record with their able assistance.
1 / !
!! 8
9& !% / (,(
9& ! % /
13
/
&#&?
030)
" 023@030) 5 (6(3030)/ 8 !
+
! & !
! +
! "& 8 !
6 / " &
"!5
& & !! 8"/5
&!! ! 5
)-3; <= % /5 8 (33;+ & &
& !& & 8"
(,(@4(74 7! &!$ 2 / 8 ! *
&88" ! & !
+
"$ 8
!" 8! & "& 8 !
/ 8 ! &
& 6! & 8
@ D & !8:&& !
"& 8 ! ! !
& "
! (3
8 & "!
!
& " 8 & /
&8 & ! &
&8"A + /=/ & !+ /=
8
& '= "$ ! &
&8"
8/
!% &"
! & !& A + /=
& '+& &(,,! & & 0330/& 8& / & &!! +
&
"! '+
! &(,, ! & & 03309& % &"
& ! &
& 8" A + /= (( /
!5
"! 8
!
&
"8"8 !
& " "
8
8"& $ ! "
!&
/
" & 9&! & & !
#&
8& "
& ! !!" &
&8" ((( $
!""# #=?8& &
&!& !
!!
!
/ 5& !24)747!
$& " &(@-2 " & "!
" 88"85 "
8&
8&
! 5 "8&
8& !!& !
8 / & ! "!"
8" ! 8 (@! &"
"8&
!! 8&
"/ 5 !9& !"#$"$ %
& %
&
% % '
(
) * "+$
,
-
%
%
.
.
.
.
**
#/
01- 2(
,
%
,
3 4
5 "3 $) %* 6!
*7
8
((0 $$% % $&' ' ()'' $% *
+
!"" ,- #& A! 5& 8"5 &
&
/& & !
5 .+ )
&
(
) * "*$"
$ ' 5
(
9 (
: 4
;%
%
4
% %
& 5 % %
-
3
)
%
%
%
'
,
;
5
)
"- $ (0 / & ! & !
& &!8"!5
8&8" & / 8 !
*
& "& /
& 9& A!=?8& & !$$ ( /0'1 2 "%'*
-3 4!"",43 " :& !
** & " /&
" 5&8
"
! & " & "
/ 5 !9& .
&
& &
< ) 7 "*$%
<
& &
& ="*$
& 2 8 % "7$5 &
"#$
&
2 8 >
&
) 7 "*$
&
) 7 "*$ ,
8 =?
'
4 @)53* +A '7/#="* ++$# '3 * ="* +A$7 'B** C%4 4 @)53 * +! '*7*!="* +!$# '37*D="* +!$7 'B 7DC% 4 3 E@* +A42EB*/DC 4
8 G? @"* A#$* ''++!= )53* A# '**+DC
5 ) 7 "*$
& & <
%
& ) 7 "*$
<
%
<
%
<
& & 5
'
?
'
@)53* +A '7/#="* ++$# '3 * ="* +A$7 'B** C%4 @)53* +! '*7*!="* +!$# '3 7*D="* +!$7 'B 7DC%3 E@* +A42EB*/DC 8 G@"* A#$* ''++!=)53* A# '
**+DC%
5 F ) % * 7A F ' 3
8 & &
8
, ) 7 "*$% 2 ( -& ) %* *D% -& ) % %
& ,
5
& ) 7 "*$
%
?
'
@)53* +A '7/#="* ++$# '3 * ="* +A$7 'B** C%4 @)53* +! '*7*!="* +!$# '3 7*D="* +!$7 'B 7DC%3 E@* +A42EB*/DC 8 G@"* A#$* ''++!=)53* A# '
**+DC
& 5 % '
G -& & '
3#+"77$ -& ' &
F
'
3 #+"771)$ 8
% , )
%
) 7 "*$ '
+ 9
-& ) % , ) 7 "*$
5 )
G ?@"* A+$# ''+*=)53* A+ '*6##="* A+$# '3A!/C '
7! ?) ) %* +A
+/ 2 (-& ) %* *D
& , ) 7 "*$%
7! )
?0
' (
7!,
'
7!
5
,
7! ) % &
) 7 "*$ ' , )
(0
" 8"! 9&
& 5&85
+
& $ ! :& !
8"/& :& ! 8"
! &
8 !&!!5
8 $85 +
!
E "+
"! !/
%
:&
& &
$!+
&
& &8 & " !
" 8
& () / 8 ! *
&&8"
!8&
& 8" (@4(74 7! &!$ " " $! " 8&
!
& ! &8
8&
!
8& & & !8" (@4(74 7! &!$ & 8& :& &
& ! & & (, $ !8 &
!
! & 9& % &"
9&
& & (,, !
& & 0330!+
& ! & "
8 & .) *,1 3-3)030, )
C
B F B' 3 H