← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/14955/2018dismissed

Suresh Kumar v. Daryao Singh Kashyap And ANR

2019-01-24Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary8 pages



       

   !

    !"

 ! $% &! ''(( )!

!" *$  $! 

 "#  $%  %%% +!

!) ,$ $!"#-

 ...

%%%  &   ''(( / **!- 0 *& !  1 2'

3"$(!

 (,-( * !

- #  %!

(  4$!3"   (  3"  $  !   /  '(

!

'   '!

!&   !  *!&     ((      $  3

! 0 *& ! 1 '

3"$ (!

 ( '$( *$ & 5!  

!" !0  $ !$ '!

-!& #'(

/!" *$!  '! ''(  ( ! ' '!

!& *!&  $-3 6 34 $'! ''(( /  ! $% &!   $'(

! *!& 6  !

 ##7894 !$! $ 1##784 !- !

& "3"''(( 7 94 *!$ ( 4 (36  !* ! !' 3(  (

 $ ('!

!#$ '(

/! 4 (3 (*$ (!* !

$! *$, !  4 (3(3('" 3($& 

$!

& "

4((

$'!

8 ! 4 '(4$( 3& *$ 4  !" 4(( *'!

!+(

!& '!   3 !  $  

     3  * !!  ( *4$  $  3(   ( 

3    !

 ':*( 4

3"$'(

2; 13   $!6 $ (  !! !

 3($!

 & "9  !$!'($  ($'!'!"  '  - !   -  (      ! 

 (<$     &   4

 $3 (( - !   $3"$!  ( '

= #$'!          !   $    4$(  < *  -!

'!(& !"30

-!& 4! !-!94

$$ -!  *!& 4$ $'(

!!- 1(<$ !

& "94 !$!

'($*!& !*  3!  &  '!4! & 4 (3"  4$(

3& *$ $ 3 ' !$ '!'!" 

 ('$"

('

-!$  '!'!"94 '($ $ $ < 4(* "*!& 34

 

( 4 '!" ! '( ( >((4 *

4! !&3"$(!

!(, ! 3 $'(

 ?$$!  $  '(

    (    !  !  '  '!

!&  ! 30&!

$'! ( *4$

@  (!( '!&  ! ! *$ !&(  *$  '!'!" '!" !A++ ?$$! (  1 7  &  1 !((*(# (( -  3  $!*$

A++

 ?$$!$ 

&  3(A+ 1 ?$$!$'(

 '' !& ( *$'!  3"$ 4    A+  ?$$!$'(

(  ($'!

A+

 ?$$!$  '!'!("-(  !$' !'

 !  0 !  A+ ; (  B- 4 (3"3$$'! !(, ! 

! *$  #! &  - !! ( $$'(



(("'!-$ 6  $*!& B6+

 4((

$'!

6 $ !(

'!-9 4 !$! (  3"$(!

 !(, ! $     7!        4$&  $  '!'!"  $  3

@  (" (3"$'!  /''(( 4 3   ' !$ ! !

C$'!'!"4 &(" ( !$( & '

$! -! -"$((* @  ' !$ !94 $($  !  ''( 4 3 ' !$ $'!'!" '!0  (

 $! - !4 $3"$!  ( '

 

(3"$'(

#! *("#!! *''(( 7 6  !* !$ (4$ '! $!& $

!!' $3(  (

! *("# (3"$ '(

/!  4 !''( (3"$'! ''(( 4 

3"$(!

 ( -0 *&  1  **!-$! !&#'! ''($ 3 (

-$& ("!*  $3$ $(!

 ! 3(4$-*!

("!! ! *$ (3"$ '(

 /  !   B-     !!     '!-  $  $ *!&  34 $ /''(( $'(

B6+ $! 

' ! & !-!#

4$4 !" 4(( *'!

'! !

!(  ' $0 *& 

$($=*$, ! ' (()*+(,-, -./)0)12.)3).4

!%567  $0 *&  =*$, ! )(+.8+(2.9:

*+(,-,;(2,:).).81:+(, 7 5!  2*23! !*$ $! (" !  ($ 4$$0 *& 3!#$ &

$ ( 3$:!

3& $$ ''(( !" 4(( *! !

$& #4$$ ((*$- 3 *- $''(( 9 #$ #'!"$$ ''(3((4# &' * 0 *& ! 1 2'

3"$(!

 (,-( * !- #%!

( 0 *&  ! 1 '

3"$(!

 ! *#

%!

(3    (3"$'(

/! 3 

$! *$  9$-$!(!

$-'!

$ ( '$'" $!!#4$$4 !

$3"

(!

( , !" +(

/! '($*!& ((   3"$'! ''(( ! '$ '(7& ! *1&!( ( !  (<$ 1(<$ $4 !-3"$''(( / !

& "

4 *!$$ (4 (36  ; 1 +(

'' $4

36 +?  $  &% &!+?

$ *4

$*!& ((B6+ '!-$6  $*!& +?1!<$,$ $!"!"

+ 3(#4$ $*!& (( +? (&D '#&'

) ! &'''!

-!4$$B6+4 4! $- ("'!- $  $'(

' 1(<$ !

& "3"$ /''((  ("'!- !! /''(( $

$- * $*!& ((4$$'(

=4-!# $ !

6&  #$&$ *  ! $*!&  # B6+  9    &!    !!  $  $  '$*!'$  

''(( 7  

  

6 &'

''!(! * /''(( $  $ *  ! !* ! $!"' 3( &'- !3 $ ( "

-  $ ((* +!

* &!<$

  3* !! ! (  & " '(

$ +?

 ! !% &!#,(!< C$ (

#

;

%!

(

-B6+?

74 ( 6 3"$'(

!&!< $ '!  $

  3* !! '!!& $*!& 

((B6+ B6+14  (" !- ' $ /''((  + (!'B6+  !!C$ *$ $!'("$(*(

4 *-  $!'(" -(3( !!

 4((

$'!

'!

!

 ("'!- !! B6  $*!& 3

&3"$ /''(( & "4! C$! - !! $B6+ !  (  & ! ! ( "<  !*!"!& !'!    ! 3(4$-!*$("$($  / "       3     ' !$ !     $  '!'!"    @   !



$ 0  !# !(- $ ''($ 3

( 3" "/       3 !$   !9 4  '( 3"

 $ $ 3  ' !$ $ ' '!'!"

!

$$ < 4(* $*!& (( 34

 ' (! 3

#$ *# $'!'!" @   $-3 ( "8  3"$'! ''(( / - (   ! *$' " ! 

(<$ - (

$ $( $*!& '!*!& ((   34

/    1 4  $3 (+

*

$



(<$ '!- !!?

$!!

6&  &$ $ &< " @ !"!*! *$ ( $'!'!"$ 

'$!- !!?

3(*- "( 3 $'

*

& 9 '! $? $ !

6&  $$ ($ '!'!"    @      "  4     % ('  -  (    

! 

(<$ = !$! $$'

$'!'!"4 -!$& $6  ( =4-!# 3 $(!

 ' @ !" 3& #

! 

!&$ ( $'

'!'!" @   ((4$$&9 #$ #''! $3 !-

$(!

  ($

$$ ''(( $( && *$'!'!"!

!! & "

!  *$ ! 

! :< 3 

$'! $''(( ( ''! !&$

$''((  $ *! !

$& @   #4$$ ((*$-3

$ -!$''(( 9   "*! 4$ -!' $!* & ! 3"(!

$$!(

' '!

!& $ *!& ((   $ ( 3 ((4C$0 *& !( ' 3"(!

!

''(3($  ! &  3$ $& !(6  & "! @ $0 *& 3!

+!

! ' '!

!& *!& (( 5$  $  (!

   !  3(4  $-  ! !    !!

     *

  $  ''((       4$( &     '!'!

''! - !!4$$4!!  !

! 9 &"



!' @   (4& $(

(@  

 (4 -(- ''( $!!* & 4 !



3('   "

((*("#

!&"!'!-!

" &' * 0 *& !  1 2'

3"$(!

 (,-( * !- # %!

( 0 *& ! 1 '

3"$ (!

 (#4$$(( ! " !

! 3"$ , !  ''(  ''( 3 (3"$''( 7''(( !

!!11 (,+, ! ( *$ ''( * '!

4$(

3& *$$''(( 4 (! * '!

3"$(!

 (-!!;  $ &!$ 3   &! # $ ''( 3 ! ! &''( #! *("# ! *("#$ ''( 

4$ !!   %2,)233!

!"

-89+ !

?$$! '< *7! 

E 7 ?$$!!'!3(

E 7