← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/29247/2022dismissed

Anil Kumar And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And Others

2023-10-19Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi19 pages

!"#

!$ "

%&'

& &#)& & &

& &#

*+ ( 

, (--   !

. /   &-0 123 



 - -  52  

, 7 



#8  *+  

9 -   

 - -  52  

, 7 



#8  *+   &: 12-:

 - -  52  

, 7 



#8  *+   &:- (-00   - -  52  

, 7 



#8  *;+     -.

-  - -  52  

, 7 



#8 

*+    6-9- -00  - -  52  

, 7 



#8  *+   <3  #-  - -  52  

, 7 



#8  *+   &-2  - -  52  

, 7 



#8  *+   #:-  63  - -  52  

, 7 



#8  * +   5-8- 123 



 - -  52  

, 7 



#8  *+    <- 



 - -  52  

, 7 



#8 

*+    9  - -  52  

, 7 



#8  *+     &2 12-:

 - -  52  

, 7 



#8  *+ ;  &3 6-= 



 - -  52  

, 7 



#8  *;+   2- 



 - -  52  

, 7 



#8  !#&< !

>'?

<#4 %"6

 &#6 <#&

 

   

 

!

  

#$

  

  %

&   ''( 

  $#

&   ) *

 

  &"

&  +  ,- 

  . &"$/ 

& ! &"&#/ &"&# &"&!"

  /

&



  01 

 2  01 

 

&  )( 

 + ) '  

  $$

&  0    

  $/

&  3 4  5 61  0

1  4( 01 

 )- 2   

) &#6 <#&

%4 *!#&?+  

 - (    (   - 

 '     

  8 (

  9  -  '

    . $:

 $$ $

-1 (     &/&  + 1 )' 

6 



-1 ;

6 1 6 

1 (  

         (

   -1 

  - 

8 &  

1    



 3  

     . $:

 $$ $

<=  $>  &/&  + 1 )'

6 



-1 ;

6 1 6 

1

  8 

 

    < >     7

;

' + 1 ) 



-1  ' ? @  1 

  <

> 8 4('



<

>    + 1   

1 + 1    1 + 1 

9  9  + 1  8  -1 9  + 1   $/

 (    (     ' '

+ 1 ) 

 0  7 ':

+ 1 01'1:

 1'1 

1 -



-1:+ 1 ) 

   

 

       

1 '

 

1 ' "$ "!

3  -

 (

  "% "$ &

4

( 

 

    (  - 1

8 ( 1 '  '

+ 1 ) 



-1 ( 1 '

  1 

1 + 1   1    '   <

>    % A ''  '           1  

( 

 $ 



  (  ( 8   ' '

+ 1 )  ' 1  1 

 ' ' 8    < >    -1  -

 1   =   '

+ 1 )  -   



9    1  

    (  -1  ' (  (

 -1 6 

 ( 

     B  (  ( 

1

(-1   ( (

 1 

   ( '

  (    -     B 

 1 -

':    -1    '

 '

!

3 1

 



 -  =   ( (    B  = (     - + 1 )'    =  / 3     

 -  -1 2C - )  

( 

  + 1 )'

 

 

 

    

-    ( 

   1   (  

  $"

,   -

   ( 

8   -1 

 -  -   + 1 )'  - 

2 '  

   -

 

         (   

8     1

 



2 '    (    



 

1 + 1   <0 7> )  2 $#   (       1    -     

$$ ,    -

     - 1

8 1   8  8   2 (  ( 

  

  

 -  -         '   1  ' 

   1  (  

8 -C -

 7 ' -      1   (

 

  :  - 1   -



,    -

  8 ' =  -1 6 

     B   (  

(  (  ( 

1



( 

 -  

  -1 -1

    (

 (    - -

 ( "% "$ & ( 1 ( -    1  (   8       

$& ,    -

     -1    '    -1 2C - ) 





8 + 1 )'

    (   

 (    

 ( 





 

   

   ( 8            -1 

- =   

1

 ,    -

  = ' -1 @)

 -

  6 

(  1  (      -  2      -

  8     -  (      1  

 6    =

   '   ( ( (   -  8  $%        ' '    -   $# 3

1

       $$ $

<=  $> 9  # (   -

  

     

   

        

 

  





  ! "

 $ % 

 

 & 

#    

 '



#  

 '

 

 

 '

  !  

 

 ()*+,$- $!

9

   (   -

 

      1

   2 '   $/ A

    (  

8       -

        

 

    ( "% "$ & 1    

 -  -  '  + 1 )'        $$ $

<=  $>

 8   (  (  

8  3     (  -1

D- )  9

     !"#

 !"$ !%&# '#(## # !") * #    ( # +++  ,-*!." ! * "* / "

# # !"0!"-# "#1!) * # 2

)

   : - 1



3   C'



D- )  9

$ !%&# '#(#3*4%"5  

 



*$    .

    

  .

.

     #(    /..

       .

  #  

 

  /

  

.

 

 

  0         

  

  1      

 

$ (    (#  

 

#  ..

 

(#   !     .

 

  

   

$

(#  .

 3 $)0

 # .



     .

    .

  .      3''  45  





# 

 ..

 .

 

    # 

.



  

 0   



 .   ( # 



    

 6  3''45

    ( 7       '

 

  ..

 ..

 .

  $)  0 

  #   .



    .

    '



 

 

  8+$8*$988:



   6 3''45

 $-

9

    (  

 1   -   : - 1

'   -



. 1  

 

 - -    8             

 

 -  

8

3

D- )  9

6" . #4572  0/  ### #  !") * #8 2    1  (   -

      '1 (  - 1     '1   -

     -  2 '  C'

  

;)$  (





 1 

 '<09899$       

   

      

    

   





    

 (

   #  

    

$  =

 $&$  &   



  $$ '  )**89''>>*(. :?

@ 

(#

 

 

.

   

  #  

        .

  (   

1 .

A  0..

# 

# .

  

 #   

..

$%

1 #  





( 

        =

 B    " .

? ;9$      

  

  %

 )C(      .

   (   );$8:$9899( 

 



   

.

 # 7@0# 1.

 .  

,)

 

    7@0

   ..

#

  

$ ;C$D . 

 

( #

  

# 

   $2 &'    

   <E  9*+   







  .



 $2 (



  .



 

  



 &'

 

  $   .           

.



#    

  #

.

 

 .

  

$ ;,$2 



 .

 %" FA



.

 

 .

$3  #



6 #  

 .

 (# # 

      ( !   G'





   0     #  

       

 



$H

( 6  .

(

#

   

     

  

,9 

     

 

.

    

 (

 .

  0   ;;$2 A %" FA

 .



    #  A  

 I

J  6"   G

 $' 

 6   

)**:,'')+#

. >(#

 

K0 L    

  G 

 )0*0)**; 

(#   .

 .  A

A  

7 $2$"$2  $ %#(JJ$

 #$2 .

.

    #

 ..

     

  

 .

    .      

  ..

 (



     

 

  A #

                

     #

    $    .

  #  !     .

   !   !   .

   ( 

 

    

$    

  

    /.    

  

 ..

       

.

   .  

    .

 $     $ G    .

.

  #

6 #    .

  #      !    

 

.

   

  

## 



 ..

 

 

#( 

 

.

  .

   

..

$J   

.

    ..

   #             !  .

  !   .

       



  .

 L$$- ;>$ . 



 ( 

  %" FA

 .

#

 

0J      "  B # 0J $.

 .  1 









 #    #

    

0A    6"   I .

  

 1.



 

     $  

(  #     

   

  

J   (

 # #





  %" FA

 .



      "     B  # 0J (    '

(

( 

 "  B ( .





   ..

#

..

  

.

 

   # .



  

  ..

$%" FA

.





  

;:$  (#    A  



0J    6"   .

#

# A  

  .

.

 # ,,

$ 

    

7

.6 B  .

(    A (  

  

  .

    



  



 .



( .

.

 "      .

    

  

 $  

    #     '

  

    

       ( 1 . #      . (

6 #   .



$

"  .

(

 6  .

     #  

1 $ .

 (





 .

 . 

 ( 

 



;+$F   I .

( '

 

 

K0    

  

     .

 

 .

  



    ! #   '



 .

 

   #     

 .      .

       ..

 (

 

 

    !  <E 

$ % .

 0E & 

#

#

#          '

    .

 



    .

 

  ..

 $ ..

 #

 . 

  .  9, .

98)*# 98 H 98)*             

      

..

 (         .

         ..

   .

   

   98)*09898(    #     '

  

 $  2



  . A 



    1.

  .

    

 

     

( #   6 .#      

       ..

     $  2  % .

   #  .



 3 $  9    ,(    #        

 #

 



(  



  

  

<E $  % .

 0E   & 

  #

!   



  '

   

 

      $  2

    % .

 0E & 

  6 



   

   (        

  .   

 

$ ..



.

.   

 (     

         $  7  

!     

   

 6 

   

  

  $    ..

 

  .



          #           

 $E 

 .

 



  (   

      $3 

(  ( 

    

  /

               



/

 

 $L$LL$   % .

 0E & 

3 $C(

       

 (  #     

  

!         

         

     .

 (  #  

  .       #        



 

 # .

 $2



  % .

 0E & 

3 $)#

 . 

#  . 

  

    $#A      

.

#  

  

 

    #   .      

     

   

  

$- <.   ;*$  2   .    H$  &

6  7#

       "$ &   # (

  



 .



  

F   I .



   7

.6 B .



  .

$7

.6B 

.

.

   ' 

 <1 

9898$ #  

 .

6. 9898$    (  



#K0 :$

( .  3     :



 .

      .

    .   ! 1   

    

 

;



  ..

  @

0    '  

  H <1 $  2

       #

    &'     

       .  (            

  

$2 .

  A      .  



 1.

   6,:"   MG $ $' 

 6  M  $()**:,'')+ !     '

 #  

   .

$ +$   ( (

(     9898  #   

             

 . (

6 #   $ &' 

.

.

 1  6 





 /  $        !   1        .



(   (     

 $  2   #  

      

 .



# #



 





  ..

  .

  1   !    

     1 (    #       ..

 $    (    .



       

! 

   



  1 #        &'  J (  989)  $ $(   #

8+$8)$989)):$8)$989)$LL$L$ )9$

 (#     &' .

  ; (.

  ( . . 

.

    /

#     .



  

   #    

!  $2    ;       

 .

   .  

.

  /

 .



  / 

$E       



     .

  $- >8$2  1 .      

$   ( .



H$7   ..

  M'

8)$8,$989)

9)$89$9899$(  

  

 <E  

  

   @$B$  98)*09898  8*$)8$9898 

M'

@$B$989)09899 ,+ )C$)9$9899      

 M'  98980989)    8)$8>$989C$ #.

  

 



@$B$98)*09898 8*$)8$9898#    #



   . (

  #     



M'

 @$B$989)09899

   #

8)$8,$989)9)$89$9899$E

        #   1.

        

.



$ 

  

 0 

   

 <E 

  $   '<09899%

N   '0  K >)$2  

   # .

     %

)C(9:C9+  1 .

   

 .

   <E

   

   ..

 

.

  1  

   

),       $2

     #  0  99$89$9899 #  .6         $  2   #       

   ..

 (

 (#

  .

  ,*0 $( #  #    '

      

  

 (  #

 

    

  .

 . (  

 



   

 ..

 $2 A

  

       

   ..

  

.

   0  %

# 





  

  

),$-

4

(     (   - 1   (     - 1     (  

 

9  

    -

 (  ( "% "$ & (  7 '

+ 1 ) 



-1  ' ? @  1:

  1 (  1 '

 + 1   

1 + 1 



-   8   



  

 - 1  

8  

  -

   ( 

 1   -  2    + 1 )'  



 

           

' 2 (   

 

  

9

   

 '  '    (  + 1 )'



6 



-1 ;

6 1 6 

1

3   (   -  -        1 '    -

 1  - - -  '  - 1  

    = 

 (   1    - + 1 )'    -1   1

 '1 C

& 3  ' 

 1   = '   

 1  - -

 ' -1

 ( 1   - 9   '   

     1   -      1     (   -



% . 1  

   

 (       -

  (   -  

8

 

 1  =   '

   - 1 

 (  

A  ' '  (   -   -1     

 ?

?

  B  (  - '  -

1



1    ( 

  

  

3  (   1  

   '



4

(  

 $

A-1

  ' = (

   B     - 1     (  -1  -1  ' =   - 1    . 1     ( 



 ' -1 (    B  (  - 7 

-  '

   1 8 

 $  

= 

 8    

!

9

1 

  6  (   1:C   '  = :=

-1 =  

1   - ( 

  1 -1   6  0 

1    ' 

 -   6  E1 6  

 (  -



 1       1 (           1 (  8     - 1

'  

1

1



 



 6  )

1  =  -

A-1

    ' 

 -

    

/

 ' =  -1 @ - )  

 2C - )  



1  

  1

 -    ' 

  1   1 -1   

 

    ' 

  1 -1

- -1    

- = 8 4

( - ( 1

 -  -

 1  8  -  

8   '

  1

 -1  

     '1

 &"

 1        !

. /   *&#6 <#&

+    %"(

  ':  5:.

 -



5:.