Kanwar Singh Alias Kanwar Chand And ORS. v. Rakesh Kumar


 

       






!










  ! 

"#$ %  !  $ 



&

""##$% &'

'&$ ( 

"%   )*+,- 

./ 01-  .0 +001 %
(&$')*$+$,-$% .%*$""##$% (&/0$12'+$/$#,)/-$%3/%* (4*$1/$#,(/%1$$/$ ($4$0 $'%$+,-$% .%* $$%5"% 66666  .0 +0012 .

*$""##$%
2$3$)/7*8 2$3$ *$$  *$./#7'#$-$""$#$7$/%/+"'70'7+%$- $%9

"$:1/%/$#/%/-%'7, 3$//3*/-* $""$#".$7$/%0'7+%$-$% 9 ;"$:1 #$ //#'7<'////=, 3$/,3$/+/ "%*.$-%.%*-$,%*"%5"#$/%/..
$4* )*$+$./#'/%.-1. >?,?, !5
.+%*.$%/

 ,, 5
$-*.+.$%$ /2$3$)/7*8 2$3$ *$$+/@$#8+/ $+$  ,?

,?A5
$-*.+ .$%!%>/$/$+,$%$+$ $0"$#%3$$##7%*$%

%*.$%33/"/.#$+$'/7!A2$$#

($#$/%'$%$%&/##$7@$*'3$ '0$,*/#$/%/-% 3$/ :$/74*$$'+:$%$/#/$+$:$/.%*1$ !


*  $/  .$%  %  /%  $  $7+%  %  ##  7$/7  %* $7/-'#%'$##$$"%*/*$; .$$#-/$%/ . , , , 5
"$-*1*$-/ >?,?, !5
$$% +1.+%*"#$/%/..*$%./B.%*B-'%/$7/%$%/ .$#3$:.!   *"#$/%/..3$$1$ 3/##/7%".+*/"$%.$7+%%##+$/"%/ %*../-.)': 7/%$, 3$/!  .+9 (%>

(:'%%*.$%%*/$'%*/C"/%-+"%% ".+%*/"$%.$7+%%##*$.%,%*"#$/%/..*$+% %*.$%"$##1$#%/+%".+%*/"$%.$7+% %##:'%%*1"'%..%*+$%%"%B%%*%*3, 3%*'/%""%1*$-+'%*%3"#$/7$$$+$% "#$ */$:$-*.$7+%%##%*"$%..$% *.,*/%/%#%-*/$%+1 %*/.'$#% %'%*$%+1,%*"%'/%3$./#!  >.$-% %*"#$/%/..*$'..*$%$%%$-4$*3$$+/%%/%**"/%$# %/## >

>$'#%/+$%#1,%*'/%3$./#3/%*$#$1.$:'%A $17$/73*/-***$./#"$$%$""#/-$%/ !

%/-.%*'/%3$7/%%*.$%*1$""$ $./#%*/3/%%%$%+%$//7"#/+/$1:0-%/7$/7 +$/%$/$:/#/%1,--$#+%..$-%,#-'
%$/$-$'.$-%/% ./#%*"%'/%*1$#$/:0-%/7$/7%*'/%:$

!
:1#/+/%$%/ +/%,"-/./-"#13$7/%"$$$

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

>
 E*%*  %*  "#$/%/..  /  %/%#  %  $  -  .  -1  .

>?,?, !5
3/%*/%%$"$1.F 

 E*%*%*'/%.%*"#$/%/../%+$/%$/$:#/%*"% .+F  !

E*%*%*"#$/%/..*$-$'.$-%/$#-'%$/% ./#%*"%'/%F  E*%*%*"#$/%/../%"":1*/3$-%$-'-%.+ ./#/7%*"%'/%F  > E*%*%*'/%.%*"#$/%/../:$:1#$3.#/+/%$%/F  ?

#/.

> %"%*'/%,%*"#$/%/..B$+/*/+#.$ E $#B$+/&/4$E
, +$4$*$$$E
!,

$%%$@$#*$7$,)%$+"&$E
,2'#", 7/%$%/ #4, )': 7/%$ ../-, 3$/$E
>, /*$/@$#)*$+$,$/%$#$4 @/+/%,3#*/$E
?,&/4$$$$E
A,*$0,/%$% $.%+$, ../-.3#$, 3$/$E
;*$.%,#$ -'#.%*"#$/%/..%//-B*/:/%
%B*/:/%

$($4%($4
($-#%*/- ?

:'%%*/-.%*"#$/%/..,.$%B$+/ $/$+$E
,)'*$$,)%$+"&, 3$/$E
,) )'*2'+$, +"#$/% #4,) ../-, 3$/$E
!,)'* 2'+$, 7/%$%/ #4,)': 7/%$, 3$/$E
$)$%* 2'+$, #4$E
>$%*$.%,%*/-..$%3$ -#:1/$% ! !

A .%*$/7%*$7'+%$$-:1#$-'#. %*"$%/,%*'/%./#:1 $4*)*$+$3$-/0'7+% $  -  $%  9 ; "$  :1 %*  %*  //#  '7  <'/ ///=,  3$/  #/7  $77/  .  %*  $.$/  0'7+%  $ -, //#""$#3$./#$7$/%"%5.$%,3*/-*3$ $#  /+/ / 0'7+%  $  -  $% 9

  #/7 $77/.%*/0'7+%$-,%*$""##$%./#"%7'#$ -$""$# ;

@$-'#.%*$""##$%5.$%$7'%*$%%* /+"'7  0'7+%  $  -  $%  9

 "$  :1  #$ /%/$#/%/-%'7, 3$//+//7%*$""$#".:1%*+

>
$7$/%%*0'7+%$-$% 9 ;"$/.$'.%* "#$/%/..:1%*%*#$ //#'7<'////=, 3$/,/ 3/%*'%$10'%/./-$%/ */--$%*-'+% "./#3%/7*%#1-/*"#$/%/..
$4*)*$+$ *$ ./#  /+"#  '/% .  -1 .  $% +1  %* :$/  . $7+%%##$%; 3/%*'%4/7$1#/.."-/./- ".+$-.$/$7+%%##.$-%%*"%5"#$/%/..3$ $1$3/##/7%".+*/"$%.$7+%%##3$ %*$/7:$#$-$#-/$%/.%*B-'%/$7/%$%/. $#$""$/%*../-.)': 7/%$, 3$/%* %$7%$%%3$%*$""##$%5.$%3*7%%*/"-+$4 :13$1.$../$/%'#1$%%%:1%*B-'%/($7/%$%3*/-*/ B*/:/%E
5*$""##$%5.$%*$#7$#%/-$%

%%*"%5"#$/%/..:1-$##/7'"*/+%7%%*$# B-'%$7/% ;

/%*../-.)': 7/%$,

3$/*-"1.$/#7$#%/-/B*/:/%E
5 $%*"%$# -/"% /B*/:/%E
5  *.,/%/37#1-#$/+:1%* "%5"#$/%/..%*$%*3$$1$3/##/7%".+*/"$%. $7+% %  ##  *  '/% ./#  :1 %* "%5"#$/%/.. 4/7 -1.$%+1/$#:$:1#/+/%$%/"*//, *-#$/+%*$%*3$$+/%%/%**"/%$#.+ ;  >%/## >

>.$-%%*'/%3$D'/%:./#3/%*/%*1$ .+%*$%3*%*-$'.$-%/$%%*"#$/%/..$.%%*%$7% $%/!   *"%5"#$/%/..3$.'##1$3$.%* $%'.'/%""%1 *$37#1-#$/+%*$%%*""%1*$

?
-+' G, #%$$%/$#/7*3$1$.%*$%$ *3$%4/7%*"-/./-#/..$7+%%##*$/"#$ %$4:1%*"%5"#$/%/../%$$/#$:#%*/+$%*/73$ --$#.+*/+$43/7.'##13##**$$7%"'-*$%* 3$""%1/$7+%%##$%; B*/:/%E5* $.$/.$-%*$%:-/:1%* '%:#3$'/%. -1$#73/%*/%%*$:37#1-/.$'.%* "%5"#$/%/..%/':+/%%%*$%:1$--"%/7%*"%$""$#, %*'/%./#:1%*"%5"#$/%/..4/7-1+$14/#1: /+/

%*%**$,#$-'#.%*"%5"#$/%/.. $7'%*$%%*.//77/:1%* '%:#3$%*0'7+%$ -  "$  :1  %*  #$  %/$#  '%  $  -./+  :1  %*  /% ""##$%  '%    %  D'/  $1  /%.-   *  B-'%/  . $7+%%##$%; B*/:/%E
5$-/"%.$% +1. >?,?, !5
/%/"'%:1%*$""##$%5.$% E
$/$+'/7*/-B$+/$%/*$$+/%%%*$.$/ .$-%*+13$-/$"%*/*$/-$*$3##$:13$1 .-*D'3*/-*3'#1-$*:1%*+*#$-'#. %*  "%5"#$/%/..  .  %  %*  %$%+%  .  $0,  /%$% $.%+$../-.3#$, 3$/E
;3*-./+%*$%%* '/%#$/%'$%//##$7@$*'3$ '0$,*/#$/%/-% 3$/ *$-+'%*+$%"#$/-!

?*.,%*#$/ -' G, #%$$%/$#/7*3$1*.,%* $7+%%##$%; B*/:/%E
5-$%:B-'%:1

A
3$1  .  7/%$%/  .  $#     */  .$-%  3$  --$#  :1  %* $""##$%5.$%$.%*/$%*"%5"#$/%/..*$./# '/%  .  -1  .  $%  +1  *$    %  %* $""##$%5.$%    %*  :$/  .  $/  $7+%  %  ##  $% ; *$.$/.$-%3/7*%#1-/$$""-/$% :1%* '%:#3$*/'/%./#.-13$/7*%#1- *$-/%*$7'+%$$-:1#$-'# .:%*%*"$%/$*$$#7%*'7*%*/-- -$.'##1)+.%*.$-%$$+/%%:1:%*%*"$%/+/%%#1, %*$""##$%5.$%$3/"/.#$+$'/7!A 2$$# ($#$/%'$%/&/##$7@$*'3$ '0$,*/#$/%/-%

3$/  "1.0$+$:$/.%*1$ !
 /B*/:/%
 %/ .'%*%/"'%:1%*$""##$%5.$%%*$%%*1%/%$ $7+%  %  ##  $%  ;   B*/:/%  E5  7$/7 $#  .

$.$/#$/.$'.%*"%5"#$/%/..$/"''$-.%* $+%*1*$$7%##%*#$8 , , , 5
"$-*1 *$-/$%+1. >?,?, !5
:13$1.-$*$-*D' 3*/-*$'#1/-"$%/"$$.%*$/$7+%%## $%; %"%*B-'%/.$.$/$7+% %##,%*"%5"#$/%/.. $4*)*$+$*/+#.%""/%%* 3/%:B$E
%-./+%*$.$/.$-%$%%#%+$ -/%/$7:%3%*%3"$%/*"%5"#$/%/...'%* B$+/&/4E
%*+$7/$#3/%3*-./+%*-/::/7 .$.$/$7+%%## $%%$@$#*$7$,)%$+"&$# %""/%%*3/%:B$E
%-./+%*$#.%$+""$"

;
:1*/+3*/-*%*$/$7+%%##3$-/:$/$+. %*$""##$%
.$%3*%""/%%*3/%:B$E
$# -./+%*'B-'%/.$7+%%$%; $3##$ -/"%.$.$/$%+1$"%*/*$ %/.'%*% /"'%%*$%%*$%./B.%*B-'%/$7/%$%/.$# 3$:.!   *"%5"#$/%/..$3##$%* $""##$%5.$%:%*.%*+-#$/+%*$%%*13"%/%* ../-.)': 7/%$, 3$/%".+%*/"$%.$7+%%##, $"%%#%+$-/%/.$.$/$7+%%## * $../$/%7%""$:1%*"%5"#$/%/..%+$4*/"-/ B*/:/%E
53*/-*/-./+:1B$+//72'#", 7/%$%/

#4/%*../-..)': 7/%$, 3$/$E
>  %*%* *$,  %*  $""##$%5.$%  B$+/  )'*  2'+$,  7/%$%/

#4E
%"%*/$../$/%$%!  B*/:/%E
5 $%%%:1%*B-'%/($7/%$%, 3$/3,/%*$-+/%* -B$+/$%/.)'*2'+$, 7/%$%/ #4E
%*$%*3$ %"%$%%*$%"#$-3*%*$/$../$/%3$7%$%%% * "%5"#$/%/..-#$/+%*$%//%/$##1,%*13$1$3/##/7% ".+%*/"$%.$7+%%##:'%#$%%*1-$+%43%*$% %*'/%""%1*$-+'%*+$%"#$.3#$, 3$/ $.%*/$,%*1*$./#%*"%'/%.-1.$% +1$#73/%*/%%%/%*-$.$""##$%5.$%%*$% $.%%*%$7%$%,%*1%/-$%

-$##/7'"%* "%5"#$/%/..%".+*/"$%.$7+%%## ;

*-"1.$/%/-/B*/:/%E
5 $"%$#-/"%/B*/:/%

9
E
5"%*-$.$""##$%5.$%,%*3$:$-* %*"$%."%5"#$/%/..,%*.,*3$%%/%#%- %*$%+1 %*#/7*%.$.$/.$-%'$#"/%/,*$B$+/%* -'+%$1/-$%*$#/-#:1%*"$%/$. $:*B-'%/.$7+%%##$%; B*/:/%E
5,%*-/"%.$%+1. >?,?, !5
$3##$/%%+$ -/%/*/%*/$%/"'% *$7%*'7*%* -%%.$7+%%##$%; B*/:/%E
5 %* $.$/$7+%%##/%/"-/./-$##1+%/%*$%H%*#$ $7%%*##$*$:$/.

+$$4, +% 7-1/$%7-1*/#/%/7$%/7/73/%*7$% %*#$/D'%//%*$:$%%$-*$'-%/*#$/ D'%//%':0-%%$1$#,7/.%,#$%- %3$ "-/./-$##1+%/%*$%%*/%/-%/%*#$3%## %*""%1%3$.'%*-#$/./%*$%/%*%*#$*$:$-D'/ $1'-*%/-*$:-/:1%*+*.'%* -#$/./%*$%%*1*$%%/%$$7+%%##%*#$3/%* $1%*"*13##/7%*#$3/%*%*/.-%$ %*13/.+1.%*/.'%'"#$I  %$1%%* $.$/%+$-/%/"-/./-$##1+%//%*$7+%% ##,%*%$%+%.$0,/%$%$.%+$../-.

3$/  B$+/  $  E
;  3*  -$%7/-$##1  %$%  %*$%  %*  #$  / D'%/*$:-'+$%"#$/-!

?/#%%  < = ? . ?$%!

? *'%*#$/


-' G, #%$$%/$#/7*3$1%-$%: :#/%*$%%*$""##$%5.$%3%$3$.%*/.$-%.$-% %*1$7%##%*/#$:1--$#/7%*/+$%/$#.$-%,$$'#%. 3*/-*%*$.$/$7+%%##$%; B*/:/%E5*$ :-+'
B-'%$:#+/%%#1,%*1*$-/*'7$+'%. $%+1. >?,?, !5
$"%**$%$/#/%*$7+% % ##  $% ;    //7 %*/  -'-%, %*1 -$% : "+/%%%../%%*$.$/$+'%-/:1*/+*$7+% %##$%; *$:.'%$%:-$'.%*-'-%. $""##$%5.$%   *  "%5"#$/%/..  /7*%#1  ./#  %*  '/% 4/7-1.$%+13/%*/%%  *$""##$%5.

$%*$$#%$4%*:0-%/%*$% %*'/%./#:1%*"#$/%/..3$:$:1#/+/%$%/ +/%%#1,%* $7+%  %  ##  /  $%  ;   $  %*  %$7%  $%  ./B  . B-'%/$7/%$%/.$#3$'"%!   %*/$%, :%*%*"$%/-#$/+%*/"-/%*../-.

3$/*$.%,%*$""##$%5.$%$%*%/-$%

-$##/7'"%*"#$/%/...B-'%/$7/%$%/.$#  ;

*"%'/%*$:./#

>" %/-#> .%*@/+/%$%/-%,9?!%*"/.#/+/%$%//$'/%. "-/./-  ".+$-  .  -%$-%  3*  $  "-/./-  $%  /  ./B  . ".+$-/%*1$$/.'-*$%/./B3*%*"#$/%/.. *$%/-%*$%".+$-/.' %/-#>>$#3/%*'/%. -+"$%/.%*:$-*.$1-%$-%B"/+"#/,%*$%/ $7$/%*"/.#/+/%$%//%*1$3*%*-%$-%/:4


3*%*$'--/:$-*3*%*:$-*//"-%.3*/-* %*'/%//%/%'%--'3*/%-$ %*-$/*$, -//7%*%$7%$%/!  ,%*"#$/%/..3$D'/%./# '/%  3/%*/  %*  1$  .+  %*  %$7%  $%   3,  %* $""##$%5.$%7$%/-$%

$7$/-$##/7'"%* "#$/%/..%-+.3$ ;

%".+*/"$%.$7+% %##:'%%*.$-%+$/%*$%%*/--$#+%.+$%/$#.$-%%* "$%.$""##$%5.$%%*$%%*/#$3$$#$1'%*+$% "#$,  3$/  %*'  -  '   G,    #%  $  $%/$# /7*3$1 *1-$%-+"#%*"%5"#$/%/..%"'-*$%* #$3/%*$// %*-/-'+%$-,%*$""##$%5.$% -$%-#$/+%*$%%*'/%./#:1%*"#$/%/..3$:$:1#/+/%$%/,$ %*1  $  %*  37    :1  --$#/7  %*  $.$/  +$%/$#  .$-% 3,/%*"#$/%/%#./%/%"-/./-$##1+%/3*%* "%5"#$/%/..-$+%43$:'%%*/.$-%*.$-%.%*-$ //-$%%*$%%/##%*%$7%$%/!  ,%*"%5"#$/%/..3$ $1$3/##/7%".+*/"$%.$7+%$*7%*/"- +$4:13$1.$../$/%B*/:/%E
5*.,*-$+%43 $:'%%*/-/%/':D'%#1$"/.#/+/%$%/3/##%$%.+ %*$/-%/7-1 *'/%3$./#

>  %* -/-'+%$-,  /%  -$%  :  $/  %*$%  %*  '/%  ./#  :1  %* "%5"#$/%/../:$:1#/+/%$%/ /3.+1$:/-'/,%./$1$% /%./%*--'%.//7.%* '%:#3/3*/-*%*'/% ./#  :1  %*  "%5"#$/%/..  .  -1  *$  :  -  3/%*


/%%*.//77/:1%* '%:#3$.'##10'%/./.+ %*/-$%*-'+%"-E/%*%*/:$%/, %*0'7+%"$:1%* '%:#3$$--/7#1'"*#$%* $""$#".:1%*$""##$%5.$%/$--/7#1/+/ *--/.+%*%3 '%:#3:%:$-4 %%*--D'$% /7$""#/-$%/<=/.$1,$#%$/". ;

!

 .0 +001
 

./34E*%*"$4/75$

5 E*%*"%$:#

5