High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/5812/2018dismissed

Satpal v. Ramphal And ORS

2022-03-14Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj20 pages

!"#"

$ % &

& ' (((((

! "

#

$ ##

((((( & '&& %

#

& #

## ' ( ) ( * # + ,# !

, - ,./0(10 "

"" 2

(3!3!

)!1! !3!3 )

/,

* # + ,# !

4

"

" ' '

$ "

" "

# "# "

#

' % '#

# '

#

"#

' )3&

#1'

# "##

!% #

5 !6

% '#

# '

# '#

!

0

"

# # "# " '#

7# '

"

' 8802 2$ + 2 4 ' " ''

0 !

# " 30 " '#

7" '

" "

'

!

# " ! "

#

""%

" "#

9 "

'

#!

# 2

:$3,,7 # ##

;

"# " '#

# '

# / ! "

##

"

,

##! ' # ;

% # " ' #

)"*+,-)*. "" "$ 2- 9- - ' " 6 # " 90

# + '

# 90 90 90 7, 5'

."" # 3 903 -

."" # ) 90) # '#

)"*+,/+0#1 .*"23)4)* /$ 2- <;

- ' " ' - ' "

" ' <; 9$

9$*

# <;9$ , " #

7, 5'

<;9$ , "66- ( 7, 5'

<;9$, , ", #

7, 5'

<;9$6 , " ''

" * '

# 7, 5'

) <;9$< , "

0# 7, 5'

:

<;93$ , " #

-

( <;93$ , "#

"5

# -

<;93$, , "

$

-

<;93$6 , "

$

-

<;93$< , "

$

-

5 <;93$+ , "

$

-

<;93$= , "

-

<;9)$ <; 9)$)

# 3 &0 6

# ) &0< , " #

# %

0 '

'% !

!

#

" "

##

'

2- <;

- ' " ' <;6 & 0

<;6 , " '

"

)0:

<;6 3 , "&

0

&06 , " '

"

)0:

>

" #'

" ! # , '

#

'#

$ #

"

#

"

#

# 4

"

" ' ' % # ,

'

'

"

!

"

#

$%$&!$!' ( ) !

$%$&!$!

6

"*

+ ,-, *

"

# -

.

*

$ # ' # , ! 2

! ' #

' # , """ '

" '

# 7 # '

"90$2

# '

'

"

'## #, 7 #

##

#, "

## "90 '#

$2 #/

0

" "

"

# " /

# #"

#

$ ##

" #

$ 3 % "

##

"

'

" 3 / "

#

90$2

!

'

" ' " ' " "#% '

" ' ; " '

" ; "

" #

/0((((((

/0((((( - "

- "

)!

( /0((((((("

/0((((((((( " / 0(((((((((( -

"

- 3 <; " ;

'

0 0 "

# # ' "# "2 # "

'#!

!

&

' "

" '' " "

'#

&

; " 0 ;

"#

" 3 <

!

" '#

"

5" ' "# !

!

# ;#

# & #

$ ##

' & "

!

"

#

$ ##

# '

' 3 2 #!

'#

' "

!

'' " "

'# " '#

"90!

&

"# ! '

' ;

# 33 % #

"

' '

7 '#

#" "# 3) !

#

# "

'

## "# " #

$ ##

"

/

# #' #

# "

'#

3:

/ # "

'#

$ #

2 #

"# !

"

# "# % '

' '

90$2 3( %

" '#

'#

'

& '# ' 6 ' "# ## 6 ' "

/

! ##

"

"

"

"" #

-

"

'

& #

$ ##

()

'#

"" # "

0 % ! ! # " '# '

31 %

"

#

" #

!

' #

# ' " / # ' #

#

&

' "

#

&

'

#

"

' #'

#!

# &

8

#

' 3 % '

"

" '

##

" '

3 %

"

'

&

' ;

" & "

!

#

'

#

! '

# #

9

) % '

# " " ,

#

# 4 #% 7

8#2',

# '

"

#

;

?/0"

1!%/0

/0/0 #

*

/0

#

/0

2

3

#

# #

* # *

#

2

# 2

4

#

2

2

*

2

#

)

"

)

5

#

(

6

2

#

"

"

* 7 8

9

.

8

+:1& & /;0"

5

#

# <

<= " >" ,* " " >

" ," >

2

#

>

<

:

30

#

<

<

<

<

(

2

#*

)

/0 "

1!% /0

)

2

#

?

+

"

"

<

-

# < *

(

<

<

*

" " " +> 2 " * " >4

> # 2

*

#

-

2

>

)

-

#

2

6

%

2

: + ! 7

8# 2' ,

# '

"

! "#

$%

?& 6

# "

%;@

2

#

#

& 6 " 7

/!$$0:"

@:

#

"

%;@

! :

= ! *

2

>

# *

> #

> #

*

-

A

-

"

> )

/,

6-+ " B/:;&0%"

!:"

. " 6 /::$01"

;"

" B/!$$%0"

;9

" " ./!$$10$"

::6 " " B/!$$0:"

;%" B + ,

" /!$$;0%"

$!"+ "++

/!$$@0&"

&%&

" /!$$:0$"

!$

"

- + " /!$$:0"

:@+" " 2/!$$0!"

11&0 %"

"

7 8

+:%1 !!;

=/1$10CD

2

/0

E

4/!0

-

# 4 /%0

4/10

E

F 1*

/"

* 7 " + :&1"

6 " " >+:&;"

!.G

" . +:%"

!$$7 .

" 6 /:;$0!"

1&$ " " 7

/::@0 & "

1! 6

" " ./!$$!01"

@& " G ">* - /!$$;0%"

;&&0 & " 7 -/!$$;01"

1&

= /"

1%! 1!0C/0

# /!0 *

:;%

(

# /%0 , (

H

I H

I

I H

I - I

(

#"

H

I

#

/10

#

J

>

"

#

/&0

#

F G

? " B/!$$@0$"

1&$

# I #

*

;" +> 9

/!$$:0:"

%@

(

>

5

=/"

%;1 !$0C!$D

#

F @ " B 6 /!$$:01"

!;

>

> # 2

*

=/"

!@ !@0C/0*

2

I

4 /0 * 2

I

4 /0*

2

> / 0* 2

I> >

/ 0 *

2

4 / 0 *

(

"

2

#F

' " /!$$:0$"

1$ :*

(

>

#*

I #

6

F/ 0 &

!$

= ?!$*

(

-

A

*

C

F

/, +>

7 7 '

/:@101 "

%& 8( *(

))

G 9 K"

::!"/!0"

%! *

+

K

8::1"/%0"

&G' 2 /!$$0"

&$

" /!$$:0$"

!$G6 + " /!$$:0$"

%0F / 0 &

7

"

/:::0!"

$

6

& ,>.

" " 7 - /!$:0 & "

1%

"

%;@

2

#*

:&!

%

=

?% #

B E /:;@0"

!!@

2

#

)

2

2

#

#

> 2

$

=/"

!%%0 C$

# 2

2

"

E

*

"

E

F %" " 7 /::@0&"

1! 2

#

)

2

#

2

#

#

7 2

2

@

=/"

10C @

>

2

2

+ 6'

" G> /::0:"

!!& 5

#

>

# 2

)

>

6 )

> >

L

-

>

#

>

4 >

I> 6

>

# > 4

>

8 # 2

( > F %!7+- B " 7 /:::0% "

%$:

2

E

#

2

"

E

#

"

E

*

"

E

>

A

# 2

*

*

2

# "

E

%% " B+:&&"

@$; &

=/+@$:)$0 ?&

>

# 2

> E

"

1;

> #

2

#

-

)

-

> #

#

>

#

-

>

/"

6 " >" " +:&!"

&!4 7 " B+:&%"

!!0

2

>

%17G + " /:;:0"

%&&

>

-

2

:

> >

F/ 0 ( % !

'" ' # " #

# 7

8# 2' ,

" ' '

# 4 #

''

@

"7 , # '

# # 4 ##

#

4 # A / # # 4 #! 7 , '

'

"

A

## , ! 7 , ###

" ""

#, ! # #

"

" # # ,

"

'

"

%

" " 7 ,

#

" 4 #

# "

#" B

#

'##

C A % ##

#

# ' "

4 #

#!

" ## '

'

#

"A ;

! !E

#

'##

F!

E

"" F!E

'

F!E

#

F!E# ' &F!

# ;

"

##

# 4 # 2 # '

"E"# "#

F '

#

"

## "

4 #!

#

"

'

#

A % " ""

# "

"

;# #

'

# &

#

$

'# '

#% " '

# "?

" C! " " # "#

""" ' "

#

$ 1 / " "

#

' " # #

#

7

8#2' , !/

"

#,

''

## #! "'

" /

#

#,

#

"

"

/ # ###

## ,

0

!

!

' " #,

# ' "

"#

#

# ,

#

'

"#

" / # ###

#,

## ,

#"

# # % #

"

& # #

'% ' " # & ' ;!036< "" /

-

= M A9

= M A9