← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRWP/1393/2019dismissed

Parmod v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-02-22Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl15 pages





     

  

    



 !

  

 "   #

$  %

  



 !

  

 "  

  

  & "

''()*



"   &+

*,'

()*



"  #

 &&  

 ())+( !

  

   !

"

   

 "  -'' "  .*   -  ' - "  '  ) ' /0 # 

 

  1



,

 " *  * -

   

  " 

' 

.3 

#

  " (  

 . ' .!

  -

 

'',  

  

    4)5  6 

  " (   #

 . ' .! $ %  -

 

'',  

  

   4)5  6 7   ' 

  .

  -''

  '

   

 

   ,*  3   .

 "

,  

 

,   .

  '

(

( .

 

 - ' . 

,

 7   '  " * "



* 

  .



     (    . 



 '    

 .

%

 

 7   ' 



  .





" (



""'  "

 '   *

"

, (

   

  "

 '  -   "

 "'! 

  8



 -  3  

 .

  '

 4 6456 

 "'! 

8 

 

  .





 

"   '.

.



"'!

   9

4)5   6 -

 "



 .    ) ' / 

 

  1 (  



"'! 

  8

8( -

 .   .!

!



+*  5 

 "-  .!

.   46    9   -

  9 

    '  ( #

 

  .



'

 ,

 

 

 *  

"     

 

 

       : 

(



 

   .2 



 "'! 

  8

8( .

$ - ' .

 "'! 

   9

- - ' ,*

   

"  ;

(



 ' "

 3 , 

<.' "   1  

    !

" # $# %!&#" '()( *  ')+  " 

 .    "



 3 , 

 "

"  .'-                                       !

       " "         #    #   $  ! % ! &    # $              '    

      #  ! % ! &     " " (   (    (

  '    ! &       

!  '

      ! (   (       " "  ) ) ))   * 7   ' 

 .! "'

, '  "

 3 , (

, 

 "'!      9  -

  9  9) 

    *

 "'!

- 

.  ) '/



1  7 

  '( 

 



(

 *  '!

""

 " "  

  .





 " (

  *  .,  .2 



 

 

 "'! 

  8

8(



 "'!   8

8 - - ' ,*

 "  

 "

, 

 . ,

'! "

( ,

 "'! 

8 

 

  .



" ' 

 "'!

- '  -

 . 





 "'!

 .

%     "  ''

  ' "' '

, ,*  

   9

 

 

  .



 " '

 4 6 456 

 "'!( -  ""' .' 

 " (

 " 

'   , .!

   

  

  2  .!

 "'!



 '

(   .   " 

 '  1  ' , 

 "'! 

   9

  .    ) ' / 

 

  1  ' 

. "'

 "

 3 , "

 .!

 

 ' = 

<.' "      4'6 98  9 '  > &

 !& $#  &"  , - -% .  #/

 '*  "  

3 , "  .'- &        #    

 !  ! % 

'   '

    +                 , '  %       '   +               ! '  !  (           #      '   '   +           !            

   '))') ))+  *

 

 '   ' 

 "

 

" 

"

".%    "

 4"   

6  $   % 4"    #

6( ', -





 ( - *  .!

 )  '  $ ,( ;

 .

 * ,

   

       -

  9 1

 9:  -

 91 -   

&  ! 0&  1('21*)

   ! -    %( ./  0 %/     



  



1 2-$) ) ) )) )

) '

     #    3 % ! 3     /    

(  

       ) )  ) *3'21*

  -    %( ./ ( 0 %/

 

         

  1 2-$ 

   ! 

  '

   2   #    3 % ! 3     /    

( 

          4 (



   *

"" ' ' .!

  .

 , 

 ,  * 

' .  .!

* = 

  *

   

 "

, 

* . "

 .! "'

, '   '

 4 6 456 

 "'! 

  8

8( -

 .

%  .

""' .' 

 .! %",  *-

 

   *  '

4 6456

 "'!"  .'- 56 ! 

 

&    $     '    '     

           2

 '     



      ) )7$

'

56 ! 

 

&    $     '    '     

           2

 '     



      ) )7$ 6  

       '    

    '

     ) " ' 

 "

,  - '  -

.

"  ', -

 

   

 . *  

     ' , ( # !  '  ( -  - -  , 

" <    4=

3

 = , 6( - 

   * " 1 -  .* 

 "

, 

- ""





  "  '

-  - , 

  !



    -  - 

% 

  ' 3  !   '

,   ',

'!  '

*  '?,  

 !

 

(

 .*

   

 - ' .   "

 '    - '

* , !  

'    : !   

'    " '

 4 6 456 

"

 '  "'! 

  8

8 1 -  

 .*

" ( 

 

  "

, 

 "

, (

, / !   

   ! 

'    

'    !  - -  '



 2 

  "

'

  '

 4 6456 @*   "

(

   , .!

  '



 "    -

  2  

* ,  .   " '

 4 6 456 

 "'! 

  8

8 1 -

 .* 

 "

, 

 *

 

'

( ,

    

 +* -

 5  5

* 0   ! "-  ( %",  *- ''

'*    

   *

'   

(

 

  "

 '  -  3 

 "

,  4 .

 " " 6

* . "

 

%,   

 ''

 '*  

 "'! 

  8

  . 

'', .! 

 

  

  -   @* '

 4 6 456 

 "'!

  . 

'',(  !

, 

.   

 

 '

  '', '  , 

 '

- 

! - !

 ' ,    .

' 

  





 "'! 

   9

( -  ' .  

""' .' 

    

 "'!   8

8



, 

  

 *  . 3 

 <.' "   1  '

 ,  4" 

   .  # $# 5 -6 , &-/ "   '(')7  '7'  ,

, 

 <.' "   1  

   $# %!&#"'()(*')+

 '    &        !   !))) 7) )))))) #&-& 

 !&  )  8 %   +      (   (        $ &  +    # 

       (  (    

    (             

        

     ) ) )#)  ) !

 &6& 89

0!- )7:1

)  %       $ 56

    '      

(    +  (   (

      

   (      

    

      ))

 ) ) )') ) 56)

)

) 526 &   +  ( '      (         

     

     '))) )  7) %           5      

6       '       (    '      '       '

' () ) )))))9 ():) 56

     '    (       

      9 ;

) 5'6

     '    (              9 ) 5 6)

)

) 5,6)3) ))))#)() )  )+ *):) 56  

       

 (         '$ 5 6   (       

       <  (   ! + ;) 5'6    (   +    #  

  

        

*  )  %     $ &   +  (         ():) 56     (        )') )3)% )!)52) )" 6;) 5'6       (  

)))) ) ))) ) ;) 56     (       

   

)')()) ) ;) 56))) ) )() )  ) $ 1   

      $ =       # (

   

             

 

         ' ( 

   

      '   #        ( 

 

 '         )) ) )) )) *)  &             '                " "        2   &  !  #) )4)>)? ) )0 $   5 26                           !

       " "           #  

 #   $   ! &          (  ( '   ! &            

+    !(   (       " "            3     

  @  '    )) ()  )) ) ) ) )   ))   2 3 0 (   !       9 

 !  # ) # ) >) ? ) ) #)  ) %9'

5"6)#!!)

               3(   !    9   !   #) )4

). )# )>)? 5,6  #!! 

 

                    # 2526  % ( "(         

/       *   (       #      !

       +            





      '     &  #    

 !      #      ! ' '$ 526  #      +        &  (      

 !    ,(           

   '

  #    ! 4(           (  '   

      + ))#)) ) )! ) )* &88 - "  & &# " 0 #&#  $&;

"&#  - " " < 8&0 < $8   " &6

$&0& #"88 = > & 

#&! &

#&! & % "

 < 6-  8#

 < &#    %!&#" ;"&8 ! 6& & % " < 8&0 ;"&0" ;

-8! = <<8&0=8

" 6&##& 

#  0"&# - "8!#- !  4':  " ! & %" "&#  -  #  

!

" & = $ "8! " " < 8&0 !0&#&

<<8&0=8 & #-0" 0## ;

-8! = ;"&0" ;# < $&8& %  " &6

"&# 0 $&0&  "&# 08-#& ;# 

&$!

"

;& % %

- ! <+)7< 1? 1?  &%"  = 0 #&! !

6&##&  ><& % & $&; " 0 #&-& 8 # %- !#

 $&0 - !

&08# '(  !

') " #&-&

 !& 6-# = "8!  =  8%8

 -0"  8%8 &%" 6 #

" 9 &# # 0 =- 8#

6 " -8#

6!

" - ! / )3 " < 8&0

< 6-  8# !! )1?'((?

;# &##-! & " 6

" @ $

 ! ;# <-=8&#"! & "

&0&8 @A -0"

& &0& &# #&!  "$ = &##-! & B 0&#

" < ; #



! - ! #-=C#0& )

0& # *1'  !

*11

"  ! <& % & $&; " < & 0&<8#

8;

 - 0&! = $ #-0" < 8&0 &# & B 0&#

" < ; # 0



!

" <<

< & @ $ 6  &  6#

"<

$&#& #

" ! !&#"-##-

& -  " " < 8&0 !! )'*'((' &# & 0  66 &##-! = " D&  0&8  66&##&   !

0  @ $ 6     &8# E< 6  " !&% "

" E& 0

@  8 &# #    " !&% " -0"

< 8&0 < 6- 

8# ;

-8! %& =  0=8  " <

$&#& #

" ! )+   &>"&8 @ 8 8 ! !!&& 8 !$ 0 @  8

" 

   #-=6&! " !&

   < 8&0&# "$ = &##-!

6 &6  &6

#  ! " 8 < 8&0 "# #-< #!! "  8&

 #

"  ;# "&-# ;"  < 8&0

< 6-  8# ;#  & < &

   %&$ < & 

&6 " ;

< 8&0# ;  < & 8 "  %-6 

 @ 8 6 & 00< 0 & #6-0" # " < 8&0 !!

)'*'((' &# & #-< ###&

 8& < 8&0 0& 0-8!

??'((( #-=#&-! 8

'1''(() " < 8&0 !! )1?'((? "# #-=#&-! "  8& < 8&0 !!

)'*'(('  ! #-0" < 8&0 "# = <-=8&#"!

="8

" @ $

"  " < 8&0 !!

)1?'((? "# = &##-! & B 0&#

< ; #



! = #-=C#0& )

0& *1'

! ;&"

0& *11

"  !  ! & #-< ###&

@ $ 6  6

 !-6 !! )'*'(('  ! 88

" < 8&0&# " < 8&0 !! )1?'((? &#  #-

< 8&0 " #&! < 8&0 0   ! "#   &!  >

$ " !&#0 & $#! & "  F=8 @ $

%   < !

# 6&##& #

66- #  0 & B 0&#

< ; # 0



! - ! &08 )+)

" #&-& =- & &# " < 8&0 &##-! - !  -  ! " 

 #-0" < 8&0 "#  #-

0 " < 8&0 !! )'*'((' &# %&  #-

 < 8&0  !

0  = <-   "&%" <!#8 " " < 8&0 !!

)1?'((?

" # " & #># <<

$8

6 "  F=8 @ $

 -0" < 8&0 "# = #<0& &088 #-< #!!

)1?'((? 0##  = < &$

" $&0#;"

 0 $&0!  )1?'((?  &    56       " " 

   

 '   

   

       3 % !( "  53%!6   '



  '     &   

   '               

$                    &      

(   /  

(     '       

  #  3%!(  

  '

  (  ' 

    3      '          

    

  3%!(   '  # $   !      & 9  0

  '       



   '       '   4A'

 +        ' )') )#)+  )  !@ (     '   #  B   '

   '   )  &          2    ,          '   # &       

          # +    " "(    



  '

     

  (  '              4 (   # +        @               )) ) ) ) )! * ) " ' 

.* 3 , - '  -

 "'(  "' 

   9

  8

8(   ,

 . ' " .!

   , "

 

 "  -  

 

.* 3 , "

 .!

 <.' " 

%  1  )  ,

   '

-  3 ,  

 " (

 <.' "   1  

 '



 "'!

-   .     ""' .'  * <    "

 ' ( 

 "'! - -  "* '

   *  1 -  

 .*

*

 "'! 

   9

-   

   .!

 ;  '   

!

 +* ( !

 ( $ ' "

 ( 

,



  + '  ( !

 (

,

  "'!  "

 '  - ' ,  .  .' 

 "* 

   #  

(

! "'! 1 - ' '

 "'! 

  8

  .



  ' "'! 

   9

"

.'   .

' 

 +* 

( 

 "'! 

  8

 .    5 

 "-  .!

.   46    9   -

  9 

     "  +* & 

   9

 '' 

  ' "'( 

 "'!   8

8 -

! "'!



 

!  

 "'!

   9

 . "

,  "

'



 "'! 

  8

8 

  

% ""* ' 

 <.' +*



 "'!

*, . " ''!  " .!

 "'! 

  8

8( - '    "

 

 *  - 

* . *   8

8

(  *- 

 .*

   .!

 <.'

"   1 ( 

 3 , "   .*(  

""





 "'! 

  8

8 - - ' . '* 



""' .'

"   

"'!

  9

( ,

 . ' " .!

 '   ' 

  .

( - '

&  . ""' .'

 

  "(   

 "'!   8

8 - -  "* '

 

 "

,  3 ,  *  

   

  "

, 

     

 : 

 A",  *-

.*      

(

   

 "

 "

,   .

  

* . ,

'! "

 

(

 *  . "

'  .

 " "  *  .  ),'!( .

   

 "

,  

     

  #

  "

' ,-."

 

/01##2#+## C )D 

" %,0  B0C 

"

.' B0C