← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/59430/2022disposed of

Suraj Sain Sharma v. State Of Punjab

2024-08-28Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi25 pages



      

 

 !"#$% &' ('

)*$+!$%$,%-.%* (' ('

   

     



   

 /0'1 1 1



     

 ! 

   "#

  $%   & '     (

    !     )

***** 1 1

 ' !)3



    

,-)%

%   . /   01 (0 )0(2"  3 4)#   5 6/ 7%6++

/   

  

  6 85

9$ !

/6          /   %:74;14)0(;  6     (( 0< )0(;    

  1)1  1),  1);  ,<)  (,-    (,=  7 %          (= (( )0))"  3 4,#    6 5/ +

+      6     8        !

 59  $ >  /  %4=4)0)0  6     (= (( )0)0  !  9      !           / 

/  

 

)

        64   6   69  66 /       / ?   9  

+ 

  

        6 

   9 ! 9/             "

 6#   

     9 9   

   /!

          )( 0) )0);

         6  (( 0< )0(;

  3 4(  

@   6  !

6  

   6/   

 

 

+6 

 1);1)11),,<)(,-(,=7 %!   01 (0 )0)2   

 

/  01 (0 )0(2

    3 4)

,  ! 9       4      % 5/ & ++ +   ! 

   !   (= (( )0))    6 5/ ++       (= (( )0))

  3 4,



<  

   

/        01 (0 )0(2 "  3 4)#        (= (( )0))       ! "  3 4,#   66 /    

;

 6     6                

 6"  3 4(# 

6 ++   

 ( <

/6 A+"  #   6    &  "?

# %/  !

  .  

)0)%

%  / 

/  "  3 4)# +      6

 

 



/ "  3 4)#   !  "  3 4,#9  66   

 6

6

 /

                       !"!#    $"%$      "&%$$"%$ '  ( ) *)       (    )   +%+$ $"%& "!"%$"%& '),

*    -  .)      /  '  $"%0%  11  2"3'4 5) ( ) )$"$&% 11 +3!' 67,8

)$"$&& 967 +2)6 5). 

/ $"$2$ 11 0+:

6    6   (4      6       6 

 .  6   6 

-

6    6   )4  6       6 

/ "  3 4)# 96 !

6 6 9 

  6

  

! 9  9  

  



 

 3    

 66 9  9  

     !  

    

  3           6   6

     !    

  )0)  %

%     6 6 9   /     966     6

6

 /

 ;,84) < ,.,< $"%2%2 +&#: = 7 !

 6    6 

(0 @  

/ 96  ! 3   !

)00)0))01)0,%

%  

  

   694 $""<9   =      

 

  

   



  

    

     

  

    

     

              

 

    

       



 !       

                    

                  "       

# 



!   



  $        

%&'

      



        

 %&'      

 

    

 



( >$"$    ?= %!   

            

           

 

  

 

  

%&' 

  



     

   

     )    

         

   $ 

  



    

     

    

         

   

        

 #

   

 

  

* ! 

                  

  

 " +  # !

 

 "     

 

  !





  

',,( '!- $  ++

 %!     







 #

       

  

 " +  

    

 



 ( .!-

  ++

 %!                   

   

        

     "    

           /(

$"&=4    ?= -    

   !

  

   $   

   ! 

','      

 

    

 

  

      

     /( $"2@  ?= %! -        







    

 

   !                      





  !         

     

                             )   !     )  ( '!0       

 

 %!   

 

 

 ( .! -     

               

  

      

 %!



    ( 1!2

          

  

          

             

        

       ( 3! 0       

     

     

  

   

45(/ (( !/

 6      4

B>6 

%     

       !"!#

$"%$ "&%$$"%$ :  6 4 1(6 7 

 

    "     0(.%189',%'  :" ;   <  <

      (  -   

    

        

   

   

    

1%4 1', - 

" (=     7 



 

> 

?

 + ?   "(;((                      

$ 

 

$  

 



    

    



           

        

  

     +

 ','      "    "  

 (6 :"   

       

  

 

    +

1%41',

- 

" (=    "(;((        +

',' "

  "     (  6  :  "        

   

   

     

$         

  

       

  

    

  





    

   

        

    )  (  6  : "     

 

>  >  ?

? 



 ";

      

','" "    (6 : " 

      '3('(',%% 

   +

1%4 1', - 

"

 "(;((  ( 

  

<

  



 ( 3(2      

 :" 

"(;((       

$   

    +

',' "  "            

       7 

      

    >    > 

?

    ) 

"(;((  (-

 



 

 

$   

    +

',' " "     

    ( 8(6  

  

',' " "   



     

 

   

     (6   

$  +

                

   

                  ( -

    +

 ','      "    "  

 

 

  

%38      



   



    

  (6   

$  +

',' "  "    

     

       

!      "  !         

    

  #  !

  $         



   





( 5(+

',' " "    

 " "     



 ',,3!   

@   

        

 )  (@ 4(6      









@=             (-   



          



+

 %!

','

   

   

     )   

$    



           

   

  



    

  

(@ &(6 



   ( (('.(8(',,8 

  0(+(A(&'. B! '%(8(',,8( %,(2  :" 

   







   

"(;((  (6 "(;((    



$   



   



+

',' " "    (+

   

  

)  "(;((       



 :" (   :"   $  



             

',' " "    (:



           

  

   : "         



 

 

   +

1%4 1', - 

" (6 "(;((           

','" "       

 

  ( B>6 

%8() *)  ( )  +%+$ $"%&  "!"%$"%& :'  6 4 '8(6     

 

    $ 

    +

 ','  "    

"           

        )  (6    +

','"   

"  

 

    



    ',,3        

   

      ) 

 

(6   

   

   

  

                                     



    

$              

       

  

       





    

  

            ((  +



+ )

 +   (  0

   6   C  A (  ',%, .!  7"7 "  !188# 0 <

A (<    C (;6',%' %'!+"1.'!( B>6 

% ;,84) <  ,.,< $"%2%2 +&#:'  6  %,(  +

 ','      "        



    @  

       

 )  @

   $    



           

(-

 

    



     

      

     )     $        (6  @   

       

 )  @ +

%&"  "     



!  "

  '3',,3!

( (('. ;

',,8(6  





     

 

              (6    



 

@=             (-   



                



   





 %!

','

   

   

     )    

$        



           

   

  



    

  

(@ %%(6    DE  



$       

              

     (  6     @@              

  

    

 (6    @@  

 



(<    

    

   

         

   

     



      

              

(:

        

@@ 

       







   

      $       

                                

     )    (-

 

 "  F+

 (+ F    ',%.!'+""1.3

        "             (-        )



@1,(  6              

         $ 

    +

','

" ( ("(   

    )  (6    +

','" ( ("(



      



     ',,3          

$ 

  



   



      

 

                 

  

         

        

       (@    !

%'(-      $  

 $                    



                   

$    +

',' " (6   @ $ @

 

 +

' ! " 

 

@'(@ !@ $ @ 

 $    

  "    " # @ %.(-



      

 $           " 

$ (0

   

 $     +

',' " (- $ 

 

',' "  

  



 +

',, "    

      



 (6

       

  

         

   

        

        

            $ 

  +

',' " (-

   

        

     

  

  

 

  ( %1(-  





    

    

(



-        

  

  ( B>6 

%8), *- .)  /'$"%0% 11 2"3:'  6  4 ''(    

       

 

 )    

      

$  



         (  +

 ','    " ( ("(   

             "    "    





! ',,3 

 ''

;

',,8    E   



      

  )  E(6

    )



   



               

  

  

(6 

   

             

$     

                  

 

  )

(6     

   

       

      <    



(6 

   





 "  G)> 

(  0)  )  ',%1 .!  7"7 "  ! 5&.  ',%1 1!

 ;

 7((;(!13&  ',%1!%1+""8.4

  

@%%(+

','  "    



    @  



     

 

   )  @   

 

   $              

  

           

(-  

       

          

     )     $        ( %'(6  @   



      

 )  @



%& "

"     



!  "

  '3 ',,3!( (('.8',,8(6  





              

    

                       (  6     





 

@=             (-   



                    





 %!

',' 

   

   

     )   

$    



           

   

  



    

  

(@ 6    @@  



$  

   

     ( 6   @@           

    

    

 (6    @@  

 



( <       

 

  

     

  

          

        (:

 

       @@





        





   

    $       

                               

     ) 

  (@ HHHHH HHHHH HHHHH '1(  6 $ 

       

$     

 

      

     (2 E

$ E

   





 G)>  4  

  



@%1(-      $  

  $                  

        $    +

',' " (6  @ $ @

 



' ! "   

@'( !D $ E 

 $    

  "      #@ -



      

 $           

        $ (  0  

      

  $     +

',' " (-

$ 

  +

','  " 



  



 +

',,

"     

       

 

 ( 6 

                 

    



    

  

   $ 

  +

',' " (@ '3(2

      

 

   $ (0   



 

       

   

  

    

 

 ( (=-7                       =-7 B  (  

   

@A       

         

    

  

   +

3,, 3,%3, .1 - 

" (:

    

  



   '.(%'(',,&(  

+  " (@ HHHH   '4(0  

    +

','

" ( ("(      %  : " (  0                

        

  :"  



 

  ( -       

    

  

 

)    +

0 6  "  (I( ( 0   <   ;',%% '!7"7 7

!'&.

',%%!%'+""8&3( '&(2 



  (< 

 

  +

',' " ( ("(

     "    

$ 

    +

','            

        "  





  ( (<    



)

 0 <

A (  B>6  

 %  84  5  )  ( ))$"$&% 11 +3!:'  6 4 ''(  2       

         

)        +

',' "  0('3',,3 

      $            

        

      



    

  

(J%4KL-

 



  

 

( J%4KG)>   (0)) ',%1!%1+""

8.4#  )    (  :

      0   ',%5!  .  +""  3'4#     <   "    I + !(L B>6 

%8 67,8

)$"$&& 967 +2:'   6  4 1(6

      @@ 

%+

',' "7 "

)





   0('3',,3

   

      

    ) 



    (  -           0(%'    



   

          

         

"   





 

 

)  

      

 

%+

',' "7 "  (-

G)>   ',%1!%1+""8.4"               

     



  

  

          "           





%+

',' "7 "  ( 3(-  

  

 



 

  (-  





        )

  



("       

% +

',' "7 "   



   ) (:



     

     

:  " (  

      +

  I

    ( B>6 

%)65) . 

/ $"$2$ 11 0+:'  6 4 4(-  

  



 

  

 

 )  "  

 

     % 

(+

 %!+

',' " ( " 

 

 '. ;

',,8  0('3

',,3(+

 %!+

',' " ( "





A$"$    = %!       

     



    

 

  

 

 

%&'  

   



      

 )  

    

   $    

           

    

     



    

 

   

 

 

  !

      

        

      "     # !

 

 "      

 

  !







  

',,(@

 !

6            @ @    

     @ )  @  

 '. ;

',,8(6

$ 

                       '. ;

',,8    

 )   ( 6  $ 

    (6   

$ 

     



     



 

 )    



  ',,1(6      

 '. ;

',,8    

  (2   





       '.  ;

',,8        

  '. ;

',,8( &(2   



   %3>



',%%      

  +

  +

 ','      " ( "         

       

    



     %



 

 +("( "2%!

  7)  ?  "2.!(  6

   

    





  

                

      

    



 

     (6 

 

      +

',' " ( "( %,(-   

      %5>

 ',%'  

  

    

(6

      

  (6

 



  

    %5>

 ',%'    

  

 (  -             

     

      +

',' " ( " 

(-  + ?  

? - ++

 +

  F  6   "                '1  A   ','.

         

 ','      " ( "    %8  ;  ',%.  

 

     

  ( %%(

  





        

  

     

   



        +

','

" ( "(:



   (6 

  

    

( :

      $    

 %!+

',' " ( "  

       (<

  

      (  =             

   

 

      %3>



',%%

        

',' " ( "(6    

              

      

   (-  % 





    

 %8;',%.

   

 (    

     (6     

      %3>

 ',%%      

%!+

',' " ( "(6         $

(+    $     (+   

   (6

  

 

   )   

    ( ()

 6 !

)00)0))01)0, %

% 96 9   3   6  9  9  

6

 

)00%

%  /    66  9   

 /

  9      4   

 6



 . 

     6



     

    

  C    6    .   3  9  : 9 + 6  9    9   3   

)00%

% 7          6 

)01%

%    

    

 

(1  6 9  

 /

  6   %  9    6 

6 

  % 

  6 .  



/ 

B9 !

 99    %    .  





(,   !  /

      B>6  

 %  

 !

 !

6  .     



 % 6



  9   

  /

   % 

    

 + /   ;,84) <   B>6 

%  6 

/

9  96 6  6

 

)0)%

%  !             '() *) ( )'),

*-.)  /'4 5 ) ( ))' 67

,8 ))65). 

/

  !

     !

(<

 6    3       6      9    

  6

    

  )00  %

%         

. !

/ 

)0)%

%  

 /    

/ 

  6 9   

)00%

%  3 /

   9 

7 

/

  69  

3 /

   9      6/

.    9

  /6  !

   

)0)%

% 9  / 

 3 

 6 9   7 

)0)%

% 96    /

(;

% /

     9 6      9   

 3  !

 3   

9   /  ?





  6   % 9   % !

6 .     /  7     . 9 6   !6/

)0)%

%

(2

7! 9 !

76

       

/  01 (0 )0(2"  3 )#    !  (= (( )0))"  3 4,# . +    

  6/





    6 /9   .



)0) %

%

(-



6   %  3  

   / 

 



 



9 69

(=     !

 

1 1



,4, * (2

     

 /  D   6 D