High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/6299/2018dismissed

Balbir Singh Deceased Through Lr Nishan Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2019-11-13Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia6 pages

!"#$%&'()&'*)+""*+&*, - &&*).

&**+%.%"/0 !1%)2%"#'

.%"+*,*+* .*,&')(#'3

45. 2& &* ("6 1&')(#'!!*+&)7-)%&. ) ",&'*).

8 *.9",*"&.

/ :3

222;3

)*.*"&/<

. )-%",*)= ()' " 7,>+ &*)

)= 2%"#'7,>+ &* )&'* 99*!! "& . <

'*9)*.*"&6(,#-*"&.' !!,%.9.*%>* 99* !.%*

707070 ",0?0< .&'*+--"@(*.&%" ! $ ",&'* +&. )*%">!>*,%"&'* )*-*"&%"*,%>*+ .*. )1)*>%&A7 &'* +&. )*1*%"#*B&) +&*,)-

!1%)2%"#'

*+* .*,&')(#'!*# !)*9)*.*"& &%>*%.' "2%"#'>.2& &* ("6 1 ",&'*). '*9)*.*"&.*& 99* !.%!*,(",*)2*+&%"CD&'*3 ", +@(%.%&%" +&7 D ) .')& &'* :+&: # %".& &'* $ ), &'*

**)*"+*()&7-)%&. ), &*,0?? &%."&,%.9(&*,&' &&'*- &&*)$ .%" !%E*,1A&'%.()&%" ?C"C ",&'*- )F*&> !(*$ .*"' "+*, )- .7C5<&D75<9*) +)*1A&'*%>%.%"*"+'&'%.()& '*! ",$"*).' >*"$+-* &*)&'**B9%)A0A* ). ",' >* .(#'&+"," &%",*! A ..(+'"&'*#)(",&' &&'* 6(,#-*"&9 ..*,1A&'*%>%.%"*"+'&'%.()&$(!,1* 99!%+ 1!*& &'*-

<< >*" % &'* , &* &'* . %, 6(,#-*"& %. & F*" %"& +".%,*) &%"7&'*9*)%,0A* ).' . !.#"*1A'* 99* !. )*%!*, !"#$%&' &'* 99!%+ &%". & %-9!* , &'* !*# ! '*%). &'* )%#%" ! ! ",$"*)."

0?0&'*)%#%" !! ",$"*)' ,,%*," ",&'*+ (.* +&%"' , !.,%*, !"#$%&'. %,$"*) *)&$ .- ,*&'*)* &*)&%!* 99* !. "&'*.*+%)+(-.& "+*.7&'%.()&%.&'*9%"%"&' &&'*)*%. ".(%+%*"&+ (.*%.- ,*(&&+","*&'*%"),%" &*,*! A%"%!%"#&'* 9)*.*"& 99* !. '*! $!%-%& &%"+ ""&1*&')$"(&)-&'* $%,$" ++("&9 )%&A ..(+''(#'&'*9*B()&' .+","*, &'*,*! A%"

!""" # $%&'$##"(")*+ ",","

- !- . $%&'$##"("'%+ (9&A* ). 1(& +(".*!)&'* 99!%+ "&+(!,"&.'$ "A6(,#-*"&$'*)*%",*! A0 A* ).' ,1**"+","*, "

!"#$'*)*%"&'*)*$ . ,*! A-)*&' "0A* ).7 $'%+'$ ."&+","*, ",&'*! ",$"*).' ,*!&. &%.%*,$%&'&'* +-9*". &%" . $ ),*, 1A %#' ()& %" &' & + .*"&'*) .*& ! ",$"*).' ,.(++*..(!!A 99) +'*,&'*9*B()& ",#&*"' "+*, +-9*". &%""&'*1 .%.$'%+'+"," &%",*! A$'%+'$ ..(#'& $ .,*+!%"*, 2%-%! )!A7 %" $ % & '( )*'

''+'

,- . "!! 7%&$ .'*!,&' &"+*".(%+%*"&

<0< + (.*$ ..'$" ",&'*!%&%# "&.' ,"& 99) +'*,&'*()&7&'*,*! A $ ."&!% 1!*&1*+","*, "$'% /*

,- "! ,1 A* ).-"&'. ",, A.,*! A' ,"&1**" +","*,1A&'%.()& ",&'*9*B()&)*(.*,&+","*&'*,*! A1A '!,%"# &' & &'* ! $ !%-%& &%" - A 9*) &* ' ).'!A ", ' . & 1* !!$*,$%&' !!%&.)%#()$'*)*&'*.& &(&*.9)>%,*. *!% "+*$ .

9! +*,(9"> )%(.6(,#-*"&. *!*> "&9)&%"&'*6(,#-*"&)* , .

(",*)/ G?'*%..(*.!%-%& &%"7,*! A ",! +'*. .$*!! .+"," &%".(+',*! A )*1*%"#*B -%"*, ", *B9! %"*, *>*)A , A 1A &'* ()&. '* ! $ !%-%& &%"%.*".')%"*,%"&'*!*# !- B%-G"&*)*.&

*%9(1!%+ * &2%& %"%.3%&%(-H %&%.)&'*#*"*) !

$*! )*&' & 9*)%,1*9(&&!%&%# &%" (!*. 3%-%& &%" )*"&-* "&&,*.&)A&'*)%#'&.&'* 9 )&%*.7) &'*)&'*%,* %.&' &*>*)A!*# !)*-*,A-(.& 1*F*9& !%>*) !*#%.! &%>*!A%B*,9*)%,&%-* '* )%>A ("+%! %" *"*) ! %)* ", 3%* ..() "+*)9) &%"3&,> "- '-*,1,(!

'%-7 D 7)*!%*,(9"&'*$)%&%"#.

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

<D< ;'%!*+".%,*)%"# .%-%! )%..(*7&'%.+()&%" .' ' && +' )6**> #'(" &'9() )+ ,*-A

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

%"*,7 &'* +()& + ""& +","* &'* ,*! A" .A-9 &'*&%+#)(",. !"* &%. !. $*!!.*&&!*,9)%"+%9!*! $&' &% .-*9*)."' .& F*" )*!%* 99) +'%"#&'*()& 6(.& ) %--*,% &*!A &*) &'* + (.* +&%" ' , )%.*"7 &'*) 9*).". + ""& & F* 1*"*%& &'*)* 99) +'%"#&'*+()& & 1*! &*,.& #*)&'*)* .

<C< &' &&'*A+ ""&1*9*)-%&&*,&& F*&'*%-9*&(. &'*),*)9 ..*, &&'*1*'*.&.-*,%!%#*"&9*)." 0"2& &*= )" & F ).>2 =&) AA

).7 2 ?7 &'%. ()& )*6*+&*, &'* +"&*"&%" &' & 9*&%&%" .'(!, 1* +".%,*)*, %#")%"#&'*,*! A ",! +'*."&'*#)(",&' &'* %!*,&'*9*&%&%"6(.& &*)+-%"#&F"$&'* )*!%*#) "&*,1A&'*()&%" .%-%! )+ .* .&'* . -*+ ""&()"%.' 9)9*)*B9! " &%"),*! A ",! +'*.'*()&1.*)>*,&' &.(+' 9!* %. $'!!A("6(.&%%*, ",+ ""&()"%.' "A#)(",) %#")%"#,*! A ",! +'*. D2 -*>%*$' .1**")*%&*) &*,1A&'%.()&%" #,%.'3 ! ).>2& &* )A " ).7

?2071.*)>%"# .(",*)/IG2(%+*%&& .& &*&' & 99*!! "&.F*9&.!**9%"#>*)&'*%))%#'&.) !"# ", *!*+&*, & $ F*<(9 $'*" &'*A ' , &'* %-9*&(. )- 4%) ! ' (' " ", 6%& 2%"#'J.

) &%.8'*)*)*,*.9*) &* &&*-9&.&'* 99*!! "&. &)*<,&'*.*"%)%&A7'*!,1A&'*-%"> )%(.+ ,)* )*"& -*" 1!*&&'*6(,%+% !)*>%*$ &&'%.1*! &*, .& #* '* %#' ()&7 &'*)*)*7 ' . )%#'&!A ,%.-%..*,&'*$)%&9*&%&%""&'*#)(",,*! A . $*!!H C" 5. (9% -",. ).>. "%"",%

).7 2?D7&'%.()&+".%,*)*, + .*$'*)*9*&%&%"*)$ "&*,&#*&&'*)*!%*"&'* 1 .%. &'* 6(,#-*"& &'%. ()& $'*)*%" 9 )&%+(! ) ! $ ' , 1**" ,*+! )*, (!&) >%)*. '* ()&)*6*+&*,&'*9*&%&%""&'*#)(",,*! A ", ! +'*. 1.*)>%"# . (",*)/< G'*)* %. "* -)* #)(",$'%+'1 .%+ !!A.*&.&'*9)*.*"&+ .* 9 )&

*&%&%"*). )*)*< #%& &%"#+! %-.$'%+'&'*A' >* "&9().(*,).*>*) !A* ). *&%&%"*).$*)*"& >%#%! "&1(&$*)*+"&*"&&1*,)- "& ",+'.*& .%&"&'**"+*&%!!.-*1,A*!.*:.+ .*+ -*&1* ,*+%,*,H "&'*%".& "&+ .*7 &*)+".%,*)%"#&'* +&. ", +%)+(-.& "+*. ",&'*)* .".)%"),%" &*,*! A A* ).-"&'. ",, A.7&'*%#'()&,%, "&%",.(%+%*"&#)(",.&+","*&'*,*! AH ">%*$&'* )*. %,7"#)(",%.- ,*(&&+","*&'* %"),%" &*,*! A%"%!%"#&'* 99* !. ",&'* 99!%+ &%".&%-9!* ,&'* !*# !)*9)*.*"& &%>*. )*,%.-%..*,

<< ++),%"#!A7&'* 99* !. )* !.,%.-%..*,1*%"#&%-*1 ))*,

22;3 >*-1*)07 ,%"*.'

;'*&'*).9* F%"#5)* ."*,/*.5 ;'*&'*) *9)& 1!*/*.5