High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2102/2024disposed of

M/S Scbl Commodity And Forex (Through Directors And ) Others v. Sh. Satpaul Mehra

2025-02-15Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu6 pages

!"#$%&#'()($*+ ,,

!"#$ %&

%

'(

)* "+ ) ") %%%#"

") ,' "- , " %%%%"),

+ -. , / //

#")" .

)%

"/'01 $+ "2,, + ,"

")%

)%1 "/'01 $+ "2 ""), % 333333 // , 454 1,,

' ""+

2 " "2 #+"

'"0 542) 6%#%7 2,+ ("+ +"

+, ")28'

)2 ,," "' " (9:%1440 ;%%<(' )2 ,," & :% = %%4 ' :% 14= 4%%4 ) 1">'" 10 1 10 "),"+

$"% ? ""))"

"

",,

0)" )"

,"

2)'8"+ 8') ">+",

)%1 1" !""+ "( ( ")" ",+"% ;5; 1,,

' ""+

2%#%%2,+ ("+ @"

+, ")2(""" ""

< ") "" 2 "+, ," "+"

, ))1">'"101 10"),"+

$"%

? ""))"

"

",,

0)" )"

,"

2)'8"+ 8') ">+",

)%1 1" !""+ "( ( ")" ",+"%

+)"

#")" "$ ,"

) "" 2 "

2 )"

( )

"

2+$

"2)" "+" 4%%4 ,))"

""

A'

( "?

) ))0 +, +)"

" ( :% %%= ' " "+

2 " :"(

"

9) '" )1+ 0

2) 6:91+ 0"","

")"")" "+"

' "( (') , )" 2 ," 2 ") , +,")

8 )"$" " '" 2 +"B'" ' %"% )%00(

"") -5C,"'2 "2 ))'+"2 +"B'" B'")

< 8'

;%% ,))"

""

")) )A'

("0 "",,"2 "

( ) "2")

8'

2+$

")" "+" 4%%40)

) ))"

% D"2+ )2 "+)")"+ 2 +$

"2)" "+" 4%%4,))"

""

A'

( "?

) ))0 0""+,

' )' ".

!"#

$

% &'((((( )

"

$ % &'((((( )

* %

+

, '( - . (/ (0 &'((((( )

(-/'(((((('' 1" 2# "

,

$

$

%

,"

%

% ,

$ 21 " 2 "

(/ (0 $ 2

, $ 21 " 2#"

$ , % ,

(/ (0 2 34

"

23 "

,

,

%$

2

$ ,

,

% $

,

%

% %

$ !

/ * 4 !

'

( *5

$

$

$ $$ $ ,

(6 (0

47 $ ! " 8 !

7

4% "

$ , ,

2 ,

.

$

$ $

%

0(6 (0$

2

,

,

9

:

% ) ,"

") "" $$"

+"+

)+

)

$ ') ,"))

),'

" )" ++' 2

)'2

22"" +"B'") ))'"

","

")%?' "+ )

,

")$" $"

)"

"" "2"

+

" "2 )' ", 2

)"""+"

$"

)"( 1)+ ) ," )) "( +,' "22"+") + ", ' ""+

42 ":91+ %1( + ) ,"

") $"" ' "(")" "+"2" ") ")"

22"" +)")< 2+ (

(

2 ") '

")< ""," ")) ,)

,+) )% % &""

+')"2 ""), +!"

("

"2+ '2 )"

"" ")8"+

0 2 "22"+" )+,' % ;% E" )

") ,"')"

",,"!% =% ), ") ,

")" '($ ')) (")2

(

"2" "

")"+"

)' 2,")" "$ ,"

% :0,"

")$"" ""

)"

""

""), )""!

(

)"

" +$

"+ "' )" ") )2

")(""

"

"" ",

")"2"

%

2' "0"),

) ,,)"

","2 ","

")< "+!"

("

"2+ ' 2)"

"" 4% E7" "',""' ;7 !5$! "$ 9 7 ;

==0 " " (

"

" "(

( +,'

(222"+",' )"' ""+

2:91+ 0 ))'"

+" ('

" ") ""$ , 2#:%" ))' ". F GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG

< *

=)

;

><?????????????????? >$<?????????????????? > <!

$ !

9

%

$

.@ , $

??????????????????????????:

)2' ")"$"

E7" "',""' #:% ; +,"

' +"

'+" "+) )

"( ),"+ +2+ )

+') +")2 "+)" ""$ )"$

) )"( " )) ' ". A%

$

$

%

:

9 ",")" +)"0 """+"

(

(+ +') +")2 "

'+

2 "+) ) +' ")' ". > <5

%

(

B >

<

B4 >

<5

% 5% 9$ "2 "$"0 )' "")

" +,'

(222"+" )"

" "+$

2,"

":)%

,)"

) 4%%4 ;%% > $

"

'+" "+) ) )%;0%

=

% )"B'" 0 ,"

) "

< )

4%%4 ;%% > $ < ,))"

"' )"")"

)

"0)'8"+ +) )2)%;0 ,"

":)% ) )+B'

% ) ) ) " ",)

#'8 " &"( "$ +") 1'

," 2 ""!)2 % % ) )'"

) 2 ,"

" :)% )

)+("

"""")"

2+') 0 2 "B'

"

"+)"% #"

(,,

) 0 20)))

),)"

22%

,, // 9 C D2

1 D& $ 1