← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/26035/2023dismissed

Sheela Devi v. District Collector Cum Presiding Officer Under Maintenance Tribunal, Gurugram And ORS.

2023-11-29Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl9 pages



    

   

 !

"# $!%&'&"(

)*

* +,!!- !.&

****! & &"(!/ 0!/'1'

&' /&% "--!% "/ %12 /!'&$&(3 ##&%!/ 1($!/ 4&( !((%!

/&51(-6 1/13/2 ($ " ,!/'

*****!'7"($!( '

4

89 4* + 0:+  

  

      

 

 

  



;;;;

0:+  *

9

!

" #   $$%&$$' ( ) 

   " 

 



* + !   #   

   ,(-

$../ 

     0           ,  (-    $..'

1  2$..'23*+ $

$

4$.

!!

$.$5( "

  

"*  

  

          



 !  " #   "   #   "$ 



$  

 

&  #  %'  "((     

"        #    

           "       )       "   *+, - .

 !  / 

 1 #2 34   +   *12+.  !      

   !   "      " 

      

 "



4  

2-6766- (8 

#$ %  5  9%'



   

    )    

 %'  

 :  

%%;$ %< !  

4"

=!  3> %  

(*(?.7@  $<     +  7$  $          

    ,    

              $    #   #

                 " 

    % $ A ?  "   #B- ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

?%  < 

     

-     * .        @  

 <   < 5    

  "$   

  #       "- #%  + "    



 # $      "

""  $ 

  9    "%'

 "



 $ $##  ) $ "

  "<  $      $      #     "     % <<  +  7$  $    

,



       %  1$        #   #

               "     %9 '  

 

    $ $ %!  

- -+

< 055

 9 

@*6. $ 8(  $ 

      5 "  :  

*%%;.+-(@87-

@ " 

 

  

 ( %(%

@%    

        "    

#"

   B- . 2

" "  :  

%%;:

  *

. 



$C :

  *

.#     : !$ 4  

+-(@87-

@  





"   # $    



  % . 2      *+,   - .  

     !  / 

 1 #2 34 + *12+.!  "  % . 2  $ 

 #  

    + 

  

 ) )"$  " #     

   D +5

 %((%

@% < )  " 



 

6 ,    

 #        &  $/ !!

$.$5 #  7 

,

8 9 " 0  ,(:;(

   

 1,903  7      ( *  " 



<  #

< 2

<2 =         E  !  / 

 1 #2  34  + *12+.! " <  +$ /  < F  5"

 " (7?6>+G12+G

@! -((-

@   ! "#$%&'( ) *+,- %.*,)- )- )  "** / /$-)+)01  2(()  0+ 3,)0 0,04) 0,*  1,,0+-% 2  

!%>%A %@H7  @%6%

@

5    $

  F "

 

"  %((%

@

5   #   

&  

#"  .

2

" "  F  

%%;F   *

. 

 $ F   *

.#     F !$ 4  

+-(@87-

@ 

 



"   # $   



  % .

2      *+,   - .  

      !  / 

 1 #2 34 + *12+.!  "   % .

2  $ 

 #    

  + 

  

 ) )"$  "

#    

  

D 2"  

/ $ '   2   +  7% <  #     0

  31 # !#     

 

    + %  <   #     0

   3  1 # !%"     2            

   %  <   / $

" # 

 31 # ! +    (?$# !   "  # #

 $        G </ $$   (%(%

@" 2  

  4 )#

!#  # 

 31 #!  # 

 31 #! 

    #      0

   1 #  2    

       4 )#  

   +   *12+.

!%E  -#    &    B- .

'  

               7      2 +  7     / $     #          <

   "    %

  <

+

 <



@  2 

           #    

        % + "

      <

 $     "G-

 "  # 

"

"    %  @ +   #  

     $  

        

    # "  # #



  G   G   

 %  @ 

+   % 54,0-((66 7 )+)0 ,)0) - ,0- (% 2   #   

+  # "  #   

5  

   

 $            

 



 $

       



  

 $    

  

  

      $ <

% 2    "  $ 



 

     "

 $   "       "   " 

I  "     #

   "% @% '         "" 

-   *(.* .  )      "          1,    

-     *(. 

  ?%J 1$%;;

!  

4"

=!  >  F +,

 

 $  #  $       2 +  7%% "  $ 

  % < $  "  BJ%%% ?%  < 

     

-     * .        @  

 <   < 5    

  "$   

#   "-- #%+ " 



  # $      "

" "  $ 

  J   "%'

 "



$ $# #  ) $ "

  " <  $      $       #   

 "       %< <   +  7$  $          

    ,    

              %1$   # 

#

     "      %%%J 2  # $    / $ 

!  "  

<

"+    (?$    H%?% (?      #  )        ,    

 (   @ %  *(.

   $    G   " ""



       G   * .  1$         G    "       G    *@.

1   

   F "



"5 " @%(%

2A %6766

(8  #;

  53>     5 " @%(%

+A  

(               >  ;

 

#  % '     !  "  $  !  "  

$   +    (?  # #  # $     ) 

  $%   <

 

$ 

$#    @ +      !  "   

$ 



 5 " @%(%

 #F   * .% . '

   $ # $  # 

" !  "   $  +    (?/ $   #  )  , 

( @ F 4 

  5$A $5 " @%(%

 2A %6766 (8  #;

  53> %< 5 "  

"

#  "+A %7

(  > ;

 # !$ 4   F "

   %!   $  #"

!  "    +   %<  "

      2 +  7 

    ( %(%

@    

   !    "           "

$  +   

=

(? , 

( @ " "

@%(%

 #F   * .  $    "

"  5 "%A, " , F "

+A %(

( H%

6%'  $

   <

    # $    @ + % .

'

!  "  # #

$  +    (? / $$A   

H%?% (?# 

 

 $ $  #   +    ,

( @ ,   

" 5 "

@%(%

 #F   * .%1$ 

 "+A %7

(.  5 " 

%<

!  "      )"$  ,  " # 

  +    

 "    #F   * .% < 

&  )   F "

   

  

G- !  

 1 # 2  34 + *12+.! "9 

 # "

"    , 

 =#

 "   ",$5$..' 

 "

"

"# 2# ,  (  % ,0) ., - 4.6 7")--)001,*  ,0)- ) 8 2-% 6 +  ,-  99'

 ""  :    $>    "     #     = ,    

$.!> # # (  ;( 

)

   * 6 # ,      7

* ,  " " "   

   *   * )    "

"

"%,0) .,;-,-- 6,   " #   1

< 223  , 

 =#

   ",$5$..'   #   *   <*       "

"

?

6     #   1@  A3 # # #7

* "  # , 

  # #      

     

  #   #   

  =#

 # " "" " #    ,$5$..'

#

 =#



<*

    

*  ?

)" #"  " ""   # >

)

       #

 =#



"

# @

#    "

"

0:+ 

".!25!/ )6

  < 0 & <*B &+ 0 # B &+