High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/53310/2024allowed

Sukhwinder Singh v. State Of Haryana

2025-10-28Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel8 pages

* +, ''+ .

* +, ''+ . *+2( @ *+2( @ *+2( @ *+2( @0 "#$%&'

( "'

)% A6 *'*'+ ( ( 7(# - "** +, (- A63+

( *.

( *. 5/ 6 " " 5/ 6 " " 5/ 6 " " 5/ 6 " " / / / / (6 :#%)( +-10

7+* ,+( *% 3*'*'+ (6 (6 ;'%1 "'

)%0

6 <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< / / / /0 / / / / " " " "

( * 3*'*'+ % 2 ,'1

( "*'+ 9@ +, *% %(*'- )('$ "#($% " %'*0

,+( %+(* 4""5 ,+( )( * +, , ()#1( 2'1 *+ *% 3*'*'+ ( '

2('

) +6B9 >66 ()'*( ,+ ( *% +,, 3# '%21 #

( ( "*'+ C DC BC >C @ +, *% (+ +*' (#)

-%+*(+3' "# #2* *0 B@ ,+( %+(* 4 *5 0 * +1' "**'+ 11 2 0 "'( (0 (- 6

% )(78 +, *% '

=# *'+ ' *%* *% 3*'*'+ ( '

+, 2 2'

) '

3(* '

) *+ * '

7+17'

11) (+7 7(- +, > $'1+)(8 + 3+* *

$'1+ @ )(8 +, +3'#8 ,(+8 +# # +, *% 3*'*'+ (6 % 3*'*'

( % 2

+8'

*%' + *% 2 2' +, '1+#( +, +# 81-0 ('1+$ "'

)% ? +*'6

6 /( +# 1 ,+( *% 3*'*'+ ( % '*(* *%* *% 3*'*'+ ( ' '

#*+ - '

6D6 96 /( +# 1 % ,#(*%( #28'** *%* 8

*+(- 3(+7''+ +, *% * %7 +* (#3#1+#1- 2

+831' &'*%0

*%#0 *% 3(+#*'+ #,,( ,(+8 '

%( ,*6 /( +# 1 % '*(* *%* *% *('1 ' 1-

*% 1'2'1'*- *%(+,

+* 2 ,* *% 3*'*'+ (6 /( +# 1 % ,#(*%( '*(*

*%* +1 2' *+ ((- *% 3*'*'+ ( ' *% '1+#( **8 * +, +# 81- ('1+$ "'

)% ? +*'6 /( +# 1 % ,#(*%( '*(* *%* *% 3*'*'+ ( % #,,( ,+( 8+( *% -(6 %#0 ()#1( 2'1 ' 3(- ,+(6 /( "** +# 1 % +33+ *% 3( * 3*'*'+ 2- ()#'

) *%* *% 11)*'+ (' )'

* *% 3*'*'+ ( ( ('+# '

*#(

0 *%#0 % +* (7 *% + '+ +, *% ()#1( 2'16 /(

"** +# 1 % ,#(*%( #28'** *%* *% '

* * 2'1 31 ' 2(( 2- *% (')+( +, "*'+ D +, *% *0

*%#0 *% 8 +#)%* *+ 2

'8' 6 /( "** +# 1 $ *+ 31 + (+( #*+ - (*','*

@66 '

+#(*0 &%'% ' *$ (+( 6 %7 %( +# 1 ,+( *% ('71 3(*'

%7 )+ *%(+#)% *% 7'121 (+( +, *% 6 >6 % 3*'*'+ ( & ((*

6D6 9 &%('

,*( & ((' +#*

%11 % 2 3(

6@6 +*1 3(+#*'+ &'* %7 2 '* 0 +#* +, &%'%0 + 1- % 2 E8'

*'11 *6

#2'*21-0 + 1#'+ +, *% *('1 &'11 *$ 1+ *'86 % 3*'*'+ ( % 2 '831'* *% '

=#*'+

+11- + *% 2' +, '1+#( **8 * +, ('1+$ "'

)% ? +*'6 3(

3(+#*'+ 7('+ 0 *%( ' + +*%( 8*('1 7'121 *+ +

* *% ( &'*% *% + *(2

E3* ,+( *% '

'1+#( **8 *6 * ' 3(*'

* *+ +* *%* #% '1+#( **8 *0 '

*% 2 +, +((+2+(*'7 7'

%+1 1'8'* 7'

*'(- 71#

+* 2 +1 2' ,+( '831'*'

) *% 3*'*'+ (6 % (1' + *%' # #2* *'*

**8 * (' ('+# +#2* 2+#* *% ,'(

+2F*'7'*- +, *% 6 * ' +* '

'3#* *%* *% 3*'*'+ ( & +* 3( * * *% 3+*6 % 7('*-

&')%*) (=#'( *+ 2 **% *+ *% '1+#( **8 * 8 2- *% +# &'11 2 ,#11- ** * *% *'8 +, *('16 % ('71 + (' * ( )'7 (' *+ 2*21 '#0 &%'% %11 2 (*'+'

#('

) *% +#( +, *('16 %' +#(* +* 8 '* 33(+3('* *+ 17 3 '

*+ *% ('71 + 0 * *%' *)0 1* '* 8- 3(F# ' *% *('16 +*%'

) * )'21 % 2 2(+#)%* ,+(&( *+

'* *% 1'$1'%++ +, *% 3*'*'+ ( 2+

) ,(+8 *% 3(+ +, F#*' +( '

*(,('

) &'*% *% 3(+#*'+ 7'

6 >66

* *%' F# *#(0 '* &+#1 2 33+'* *+ (,( *+ F# 3 2- *%' +#(* '

%#1 "( 7(# "** +, F2

%#1 "( 7(# "** +, F20 3

>B9 >B9 >B9 >B9

.9B@0 &%('

0 ,*( (1-'

) #3+

*% (*'+

' +, *% F# * +, *% + 521 "#3(8 +#(* '

)% 7(# "** +, 8'1 #0 "#3(8 +#(* B G "8*6 F8# '%0 #1 8'

8'- ? / ++ 3# 7(# "** +, #F(*0 (+*' + *(+1 #(#0 9 " BG "** 2- )1#(# 76 11#12'

('8#** H

(650

('8'

1 D> G

;'F- "'

)% 76 % "** +, (- 0 2('

) "3'1

/7 *+ 331 (16 +6 >>C 0 D66 0 % %1

*%#.

I>6 * ' &11 *21'% 3('

'31 +, 1& *%* + ,'+

8 2- +#

( "*'+ >D +, *% * ' '

%( *1- 7(- &$ 3' +, 7'

6 "#% **8 0 2- *%8170

+* ,+(8 *% +1 2' ,+( *% + 7'*'+ +,

'7'

8#* 2 (#*'

'J &'*% #*8+* #*'+ F# *'+ &'*% +*%( #2* *'7 7'

6 +(+7(0 + (+7(- % 2 ,,* ,(+8 *% 3+'+ +, *% 3*'*'+ (0 &%+ % 2 #2=# *1- '831'* +11- *% 2' +, '1+#( **8 * +, *% +# 6 +&7(0 ()#1( 2'1 3(*'

*+ 1',

1'2(*- +, '

'7'

#10 +#(* ( +21')*

*+ *('$ 21 2*& ,)#( ) 3(+ 1 1'2(*-

#('

) *% ,,*'7 8'

'*(*'+ +, F#*' 1+ '

6 % ,'

1 7'

*'(- 71#

8''2'1'*- +, *% '1+#( **8 * 8 2- +# ,11 &'*%'

+8'

+, *% *('1 +#(*

( *+ 2 F# '*

#('

) *% +#( +, *% *('1 '

+( &'*% *21'%

3('

'31 +, 1&6 +&7(0 &%'1 F# '*'

) 31 ,+( ()#1( 2'10 *%' +#(*

+* (8'

+21'7'+# *+ *% '(#8* #

( &%'% *% ( % 2 ((') +( '831'* 0 '

1# ) *% *#( +, *% 11)*'+ 0 *% 7'

) *% 3*'*'+ ( *+ *% +,, &11 *% 3',' (+1 **('2#* *+ *% 3*'*'+ ( '

*% +88''+ +, *% 11)

+,, 6 3('8 ,' E8'

*'+ +, *% ,*+( ' *'1 *+ #( *%* *% 3(+ +, 1& ' +* 8'# 0 2# +( 8' '(* 6K >6

3(#1 +, *% J'8 ' +( ( 3 2- *% *('1 +#(*0 2(+#)%* ,+(*% 2- *% 3*'*'+ (0 '

'* *%* *% *('1 ' '

3(+(*'

)

,+11- *%(+,

+* 2

1 *% 3*'*'+ (6 3( #*+ (*','*

@66 ,'1 2- *% 1( "** +# 10 *% 3*'*'+ ( % 1( - #,,( ,+( 3('+ +, -(0 8+ *%

-6 *%' 7'& +, *% 8**(0 *% (')+( '83+

( "*'+ D +, *% * *

'1#* 1')%* +, *% (*'1 +, *% + *'*#*'+ +,

'6 >66 %' +#(* '

F# * *'*1 :#1&'

( 7(# "** +, :#1&'

( 7(# "** +,

F2 3 >9D9 >9D9 >9D9 >9D9

. >BG ,*( (1-'

*% (*'+

' +, *% F# * +, *% + 521 "#3(8 +#(* '

( :%*++ 76 +8 "-60 "** +, '%( B@ " @G #1 %8

*#1- 7 6"6 -$ BB "

G 7 #18 2'

"%'$% 76 "** +, %(%*(

+*%(0 ('8'

1 9B9G +% #1'8 ? #'

76 "** +, 1%' (3+(* " G ('8'

1 331 +6 9C D6 *'*1 I%'** '& 1' "#2% 76 % "** +, L* )1KG I'*'%

%'$(- ?

3 76 % "** +, L* )1K0 "3'1 /7 *+ 331 (16 +6

6@6

*'*1 I+%88 "18 ', "%'$% 76 % "** +, #F(*KG ('8'

1 331 +6>B +,

6@6

*'*1 +31 :('% *( ? +31(#8 76 '+ +,

$#( %# %(- 76 "** +, %- ( %0 9

('8'

1 D G % %1 0 *%#.

ID6@6 % (')%* *+ 3 -

E3 '*'+# *('1 ' +* + 1- 7'*1 ,)#( *+ 3(7 * #

+33('7 '

G *+ 8'*')* E'*-

( +83 -'

) *% #*'+ &11 *+ #(*'1 '83'(8 * '

*% 2'1'*- +, *+ ,

%'81,0 2#* *%( '

+7((%'

) +'*1 '

*(* 37'

) &- ,+( 3 - *('16 %' (')%* % 2 (3* 1- *#* *% ( * 3*

*% (*'+

' +, *% 2+7(,(( *+ "#3(8 +#(*5 F# * %7 1'

+& (' +,

''+ +3 ) #3 & 7'* +, ,#

8 *1 (')%*6 % + 3* +, 3 - *('1 ' 81)8* *+ *% (*'1 *'1 3(* +, *% ,#

8 *1 (')%* *+ 1',

1'2(*-0 )#( *

3((7

( +#( + *'*#*'+ 6 % (')%* *+ 3 - *('1 2)'

&'*% *% *#1 (*('

'83+ * *% *'8 +, *% ((* +, *% #

=# &%'% + *'

# * 11 *)0 81-0 *% *) +, 0 '

=#'(-0 *('10 331

(7''+ + *%* - 3+'21 3(F# ' *%* 8- (#1* # *+ '83(8''21

7+'

21 1- '

*% *'8 +, *% +88''+ +, *% +,, *'11 *% ('8'

1 3(+ ) #88* '

*+ ,'

1'*-0 +#1 2 7(* 6 % 3 - *('10 (1- %('

)

=#'$ '3+1 ( '

=# +, ('8'

1 F#('3(# 6 % +7((+& +#(* +$*0 *% %7- 7+1#8 +, &+($

*% (#1* 3(#( + *% 3(+#*'+

+1'0 '

#2'*21- $3 *% *'( ('8'

1 F#('3(# *'1 8% '8 #

( *(

*('

6 +&7(0 *%'

+* 2 E# ,+( $3'

) *% &+( +, 8+1 % )'

) + ,+(

'* 3('+ +, *'86 * +* (7 - ( '* *+ *% ('8'

1 F#*' -*80 (*%( '* 8$ ,+( ** +, ,,'(6 % )#( * +, 3 - *('1 ' '

*+ 7+'

+33('+

3(7

1- 2- '83+'

) + *% +#(*

*% 3(+#*'+ +21')*'+ *+ 3(+ &'*% *% *('1 &'*% (+ 21 '3*%6 % )#( * (7 *%(,+1 3#(3+6 '(*1-0 '* 3(+** *% # )'

* +33('7 3( *('1 '83('+ 8 *G +

1-0 '* (1'7 *% # +, *% E'*-

3#21' #3''+

# *+ # (+17 ('8'

1 %()

1*1-0 '* 3(+** )'

* *% ('$ *%* 7'

&'11 2 1+* +( 88+(' '88 2- *% 3) +, *'80 *%#0 '83'('

) *% 2'1'*- +, *% # *+ ,

%'81,6 * )+ &'*%+#* -'

) *%* *% + =# +, 3(*('1 *

( )(76 # 0 3(#8

+ *0 *'11 3(+7 +*%(&'0 (

#2F* *+ 3-%+1+)'1

3%-'1 3('7*'+ +, F'11',0 ##11-

( + (+# +

'*'+ 6 =#11- '83+(* *0 *% 2#( +, * +, #% ,(=# *1- ,11 %7'1- + *% '

+ * 882( +, %' ,8'1-6 %( ' -* +*%( 3* +, *% 8**( &%'% (7 '

(*'+ * *%' *)6 % 11)*'+ '

*% 3( * (1* *+ 2'

) '

(1*'

) *+ +88('1 =# *'*- +, *(2

( *% *0 B@6 L%'1 + '

) 2'1 3*'*'+

7+17'

) +88('1 =# *'*-0 *% +#(* % *+ $3 '

(')+#( #8(*

( "*'+ D +, *0 B@ &%'% 8

* *%* +#(* )( * 2'1 *+ 1- ,*( %('

) *% 3#21' 3(+#*+(

,*( %7'

) *',' '*1, +, *&'

'*'+ &%'% ( (+ 21 )(+#

,+( 21'7'

) *%* *% # ' +* )#'1*- +, *% +,, %() C11)

*%*0 % ' +* 1'$1- *+ +88'* - +,, &%'1 + 2'16 % *('

) * (')+#( +, "*'+ D +, *% *0 B@ 8#* 2 8*'#1+#1- (#*'

'J )'

* *% 2$ (+3 +, # 5 ,#

8 *1 (')%* *+ 3 - *('16 % (')%* *+ 1',

3(+ 1 1'2(*-

+* 2 (

(

#)*+(- 2- # &((

1- '

*% F# ''1 3(+0 3(*'#1(1- &%( #% 1- ' '*%( **('2#*21 *+ *% #

+( F#*',' * *%

+, *% 3(+#*'+ 2- +) * (+ 6

'7'

+* 2 $3* 2%'

2( ,+( +( * 3('+ +, *'8 2- *$'

(,#) '

(')+#( 1'

+& "*'+ D +, *% *0 B@6 % 1)'1*#( '

'* &' +80 '

+( ( *+ #( 3 -

*'81- '3+1 +, *% #

( *% *0 % 3(+7'

,+( *% + *'*#*'+ +, 3'1 +#(*

( "*'+ > +, *% *6 +&7(0 *%' +#(*

+* *#( 1+ 5 - *+ *% 3(+*(*

-*8*' '

,,'' - *%* ,(#*(* *%' 1)'1*'7 3#(3+6 +#(* +, 1& ' #*-2+#

*+ #( *%* '*

+* 2+8 +831''* '

7'+1*'+ +,

'7'

#15 ,#

8 *1 (')%*0

+*&'*%*

) -*%'

) + *'

**#*6 L%'1 1'

) &'*% 2'1 )+7( 2- *% (')+#( +, "*'+ D +, *% *0 B@0 *% +#(* 8#* *('$ F# ''+# 21 2*& *% 1)'1*'7 * *+ #(2 *% 8 +, (#)

*% (+ * (')%* +, *% #

*+ ,'(

E3 '*'+# *('16 (+1+ ) 0 &'*%+#* F#*','21 #0 ('$ *( ,+(8'

) 3(*('1 * *+ 3# '*'7 '83('+ 8 *0 +#*+8 *'*%*'1 *+ *% 3('

'31 +, F#*'

=#'*-6 ()+0 *% # =#'7+1 '

,( ' *%* &%( *% *('1 % ,'1 *+ + 1# &'*%'

(+ 21 *'80 (#1*'

) '

3(+1+ )

0 '* 8'1'** )'

* *% 3('+# ,#

8 *1 (')%* +, 1',

1'2(*- )(

( *% 1&

0 #%0 +

'*'+ 1 1'2(*- +7(('

) *% **#*+(- 82()+ (*

( "*'+ D +, *%

*0 B@ +#)%* *+ 2 + '

( 3( ,* +, )'7 6 +*%( &+( 0 )( * +, 2'1 '

3(*'

) *+ +88('1 =# *'*-0 + )(+#

+, #

# 1- '

*('10

+* 2 '

*+ 2 ,**( 2- "*'+ D +, *% *0 B@6K >696 #(*%(0 3( *% '

#*+ - (*','* *% 3*'*'+ ( ' ** *+ 2 '

+*%( 6 +&7(0 *%' ,*#8

+* 2 )(+#

#,,'' * 2- '*1,0 *+ 1'

*% + '+ +, ()#1( 2'1 *+ *% ( '

*% '

=#*'+ &% ' 8 +#* ,+( )( * +, ()#1( 2'1 =# *% '

=#*'+ 2- (*'+'

) #3+ *% ,*C'(#8* +,

*% '

6 1' '

*%' ()( 2 31 *% F# * +, *% + 521 "#3(8 +#(* '

#1 +% 8'( % ' 76 "** +, 6 #1 +% 8'( % ' 76 "** +, 6 #1 +% 8'( % ' 76 "** +, 6 #1 +% 8'( % ' 76 "** +, 6

+*%(0

('8'

1 @>

+*%(0

('8'

1 @>

+*%(0

('8'

1 @>

+*%(0

('8'

1 @>G '7''+ % F# * +, *% + 521 1#** ')% +#(* '

+, "('

%( 76 "**0 BB@

"('

%( 76 "**0 BB@

"('

%( 76 "**0 BB@

"('

%( 76 "**0 BB@

('8'

1 9DD ('8'

1 9DD H F# * +, *%' +#(* '

+6@@

*'*1 $%'1% "'

)% 76 "** +, (-

$%'1% "'

)% 76 "** +, (-

$%'1% "'

)% 76 "** +, (-

$%'1% "'

)% 76 "** +, (- 0

B66 0

1(F 76 "** +, (- 0 BB@ ('8'

1 B6 1(F 76 "** +, (- 0 BB@ ('8'

1 B6 "#,,' *+ -0 ,#(*%( * +, *% 3*'*'+ (

(*('1 ' +* &(( *% ,*

'(#8* +, *% 6 D6 7'& +, 2+70 *% 3( * 3*'*'+ ' 11+& *'*'+ ( ' +( ( *+ 2 (1 ()#1( 2'1 + %' ,#( '%'

) 2'1C#(*- 2+

*+ *% *',*'+ +, *% / 6 + ( *('1 +#(*C #*- )'*(*6 +&7(0

'*'+ *+ +

'*'+ *%* 8- 2 '83+ 2- *% + ( *('1 +#(*C #*- )'*(*0 *% 3*'*'+ ( %11 (8'

2+#

2- *% ,+11+&'

'*'+ .

' % 3*'*'+ ( %11 +* 8'# *% 1'2(*- )(

'' % 3*'*'+ ( %11 +* *83( &'*% - 7'

0 +(1 +(

+#8 *(-0 #('

) *% *('16

''' % 3*'*'+ ( %11 +* 2 * %'81, + * 2,+( *% *('16

'7 % 3*'*'+ ( %11 +* +88'* - +,, &%'1 +

2'16

7 % 3*'*'+ ( %11 3+'* %' 33+(*0 ', -0 &'*% *% *('1 +#(*6

7' % 3*'*'+ ( %11 )'7 %' 113%+ #82( *+ *% 7*')*'

) ,,'(C" +, + (

+1' "**'+

%11 +* % ) %' 113%+ #82( &'*%+#* 3('+( 3(8''+ +, *% *('1 +#(*C11= )'*(*6

7'' % 3*'*'+ ( %11 +* '

- 8

( *(- *+ 1- *% *('16

7''' % 3*'*'+ ( %11 #28'*0 + *% ,'(* &+($'

- +, 7(- 8+ *%0 ,,'

7'*0 2,+( *% + ( *('1 +#(*0 *+ *% ,,* *%* % % +* 2

+88''+ +, - +,, ,*( 2'

) (1 2'16

*% 3*'*'+ ( ' ,+#

*+ 2 '

+,, ,*( %' 2'

) 1() 2'1 '

*% 3( 0 + *% 2' +, %' ,,'

7'* +( +*%(&'0 *% "** ' 8

*+ 8+70 ,+(*%&'*%0 ,+( 11*'+ +, %' 2'1 &%'% 310 2#* +, +#(0 %11 2 (*'+'

8('* *%(+,6 @6 +, 2(% +, - +, *% ,+('

'*'+

*%+ &%'% 8- 2 '83+ 2- + ( *('1 +#(*C #*- )'*(* '(*

%('

2+7 +(

%+&'

+*%( #,,'' #0 "**C+831'

* %11 2 * 1'2(*- *+ 8+7 11*'+ +, 2'1 +, *% (6 B6 ( ( +( )1-6 6 +*%'

) '

%('

2+7 %11 2 + *(# E3('+ +, +3'

'+ *% 8('* +, *% 6 6 "'

*% 8'

% 2

0 3

) 8'11 +# 331'*'+ 0 ', -0 %11 1+ *

'3+ +,,6

" / " / " / " /

*+2( @ *+2( @ *+2( @ *+2( @0 8%7'( L%*%( 3$'

)C(+ .

!C+ L%*%( (3+(*21.

!C+