Hardeep Kaur And Others v. Narinder Kumar And Others
!" #$%&#&!' () ) *+&##,-*.+*'&!/0#+1 ))) ,,#22*'/1 3#+1.1 *+%'&#+-.4*+*'&!/0#+1 )))#1,!'&#'/1 5 6) 77
3 77
!
"
####
3 778 )+*2 $ %
& &'
(
( )
*
(+$(+,$- +- ,$ +,$-
,.
,- +,$- &' / % ! )
0/ % 1*&'' 2
!
0
1
+
(+$(+,$- 3 )
* 2
)
* )
* "
4 '
$+ $, +,$5
)*
!
)6 '* !
' &
! !
47$-37,$,8 % '
9
2
! 2&
:
! '
7 9
& ;,' & ,8+, '
! & &
! !
47$"<7-"=$ &
! &'
$ &
'
2 !
' &2
)*
!
2
3
! &
! 2 2 & !
> >?
5" $"
$, +,$5 !
+=-""=8+= ",87 ? !
$..
$-55 2
!
0
;
!
!
@
!
! ! & / % )* :
!
@ '8,'
'?
$;,,,(7 > )
8;,,,(7 +;A
$5,,,,(7* :
7 )$(8*
@
$; > 6@ $;,,,(7 /
8,,,,(7 / $;,,,(7 .
!' / %
+.,$+;,(7 '& &'
'
'
C.A
'
"
&
C -A
!
D
=
(
(
2
!
&' / %
! !
&
/ %
1
/
& / %
F
>
F ! > @ F !
!
&' 3
1&
G ' ' !
'! &' / % - /
!
$.
&
!" !# !
" $%& '
(
! )
! %)
!
*
+ ! $%&
*
*
" ! ! ) $% , - "
!
! *
.
/0+/0+012,! .
/0+0/+&/03
+ * ! " * $%&!*
! *
! .
* ! .
*
! ! $%, "
* - +04!40,% " * 5)+045)+06
+++7*
! ! * * * 5)+1/+5"*!$,
.
!.
*
"
! !
* 5)+1/
* ! ! *
* /8+0/+&/02
- +0,!/4/%! * ! #
*
* - +0,!//% * + . -
9 +
&/0, & -0&4! +: $, /
&
!
''
'
6@ 7$. 7$= & &' ' 7 E7;
2
! !
' ' $$
& 7
2
! /%
( H &
' / ) H * !2&
E7;
4 ' $..$;(7
2
!
' 6@ 7$. 7$=
$;,,,(7&' % $+
&
2
!
' &
/ % )/%* ' 2
!
&
&&' % /
&
/%
'
%
'&
'
& &' 2
! ! '
H
& !
' $..$;(7 .$;(7 & !
' & &' $.$;(7
' '
' $;,,,(7 $"
'
" ! ' '
$;,,,(7
$8 /
" & !
' ' '
&'
&
/%2
!
& (
'
$;
%
! ! &'
' ' & $.,,,(7
$;,,,(7 $.
%
' !
! "" #$% "&"& "
'() % # *+%,
&"-
&' @
0
+ *.
/0( %12 0 3 "&-45.5.
4""6 % 1 # 7 /
.
/
% ""6 4 5.5 .
4 &&' () % # * +% , 8 % 1 ( 9% 5 % % "
4 5.5 .
4
'() % # *+%, " "-
$= %
&' 3
1& @
> 2
&
&'/ %
&
& #*& !4,#'1*/%!' *9*+&#&:;6&) +%:.'*2 !4,#'1*/%!'
9*+&#& :;%<0 !.+/ ?
$;,,,(7
$.,,,(7
> "=;,(7
)+;A
* 5,,,(7);,A
* :
@ 8.55(7I
$(8 ) * $5=;, (7J Rs. 6,000/- ([i.e.1/4(half) of (Rs16,000/- + Rs.
8,000/-] Rs. 2,16,000/- (Rs.18,000 /- x12) Total Annual Income Rs.2,25,000 /- (Rs.14,062/- x12) Multiplier Loss of Dependency Rs.25,31,250 /- (i.e.,1,68,750 /- x 15) Rs. 32,40,000/- (i.e. Rs.2,16,000 x 15) Funeral Expenses Rs. 15,000/- Rs. 25,000/- Loss of Estate Rs. 15,000/- Rs. 20,000/- Loss of Consortium 40,000/- Rs.48000/- Loss of Parental Consortium NIL Rs.96,000/-( 48,000 each x2) Filial Consortium NIL Rs.48,000/- Total Compensation to be Paid Rs. 26,01,250/- Rs.34,77,000/-
= $5
&
&' / %
.A
'
-A
!
D
&
& &' @
&'
$-
!
&
&
&' % !
&
'.A
' +, ? !
!
! &'
) * ?
&' / %
! ' &'
0
+ *.
/0( %1 : / 3;
;
"
'() % # *+#, &"
"
+$ % 2
!
&
& !
!
'&
) * "8==,,,(7
!
.A
'
-A
!
'
)
( * ++
'&
' ) '*
!
&
&
( &
&' / % +"
% &' ' '
7&
!
'
7
3 77
$- $+ +,+" $ ; < = $ -
; < =