← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/59376/2022dismissed

Sarabjit Singh @ Saba v. State Of Punjab

2023-07-19Mr. Justice Deepak Gupta5 pages





 !" !#"

$%&% '%(% % % % '

% )' *'

+,$-./

0

123145612 7 ,, 1 *32 7 ,9:



145 7 ,, 1 *32:5 7 ,9:

 !% !

=&>$"1

'%; " %   %1, %:<+ *  1:5?/%:<+ *5  1;5/'% /32 ;'4/%:<+ *5 +@9 '%; " % /$   - 255 , :2< /* ::

1 +

/,4 42+, #  : :.

./ 4, :+ 1 5A/+ ',+ <?- + 5A/',+ :,9/:

1 +,

// ../

./.

&/ 

%,9 9, +< ,/+@95>4 ?55,?* 5: **A .

.2 9@!5 :-/5,?* 5:A5 ,8,5B,+ :C

-4 ,/@ -/35:,,

5 ,8,544 2 @+-+ 4 4, & %   ?512

6123145B9  

C?

/8,5 :: ,?

+,,4 9?,:4 :?55 9+ .

. 5 4*.

./+@9 < *@*@5 9+ 5@+-+ 4 4, &

%     5:  2

  *:    ?-  +A     <4   @9?

5 ::

* @+-+  ?,*@ 2-+54 + ,55 45*.

./ 3 :2- *:*@5 ?-+A/5:2

:@ :5 <,9/ :,9/  ?5  5:  : :  :4   @     2   @    5  < 4  45  *  .

.

.  @9   +5 :  5  :

:

* :2:-*5,,8,5@95 4 +:

5,, @ 5 9+ /,9 ?5+55 5:2

*@ :2-5,, 8,5.

.2D ?5;<

145B9 

C/ ,:

*@5?A:5,5

* :,/ ?55:+5, :5@A4 : 5 5:,: 4:4?5+5

1455:@:

+@95 9+ 5 ,@ :- ?, :2-5 +@95.

./5,,5:2

 A 2-1261231455 ?-+A/?5 5 4?5 5,,,+ ,5:+@@ :@:

*8,52-9,545@:

 @< ?,< 4 D /?5+55:A  .

 &55 ++, : 123145 6 12 :;<

145B9 ,5 C?

 , :

:.

,9 +< -  @ 4 :5 :,+, , @ 5:

:8,5 ?,A

942: - 5 ,, *;<

145/: ?5+5 .

./  8,5  ?5  ,@  9 ,,  5:  +A :  5  5,  *

  145/  ?5  ? :    A   4  *@  8,5  1:

 *94

+,9 :?51231456124< @ - 5@*+,@9*:4,*+@@45 @:

*8,5

!5 99+*@5 *5 /< ,4 ?,  +:+ :  2-  5  19  :

  *  + /  < ,4/  / 32/?5*:5 ?9 ,+ :

1 +

/ 5451 +,

/

:

. ?

::

:?

/5 ,:

9?,++ 9 :2-5 %' / /32/?5 , @ 5 '

/ /32 ?,*:5@2 5:2

,:2-++, :123145612B9 C+ ++, ;@1+ :5: *?51231456 12/,:123145612::*@5 *@-@ ,* 8,5 ?,*5 *:55 ?,?-+,,4?5 :2:-?,*: ?,,2, < :5+, /?-++:

 5:A /5 @2 *:

:8,5@,5<

:@4 :,5?+@ 9,, ,,*123145612/?5,:

;@%* 24 49*@5 ',+% - 9,2@ :2-5 '

/ /32/** ,:

1 +, 

// ../

/

./.

& ?

::

:E?5 ,** ,:

+,

:

?

 

,,2@ :2 5**9 123145612 55 5,2

*, -@9+ :E55 ?,*:+ :4 D-+:+ :2-5 19  :

*+ / < ,4/ / 32E5 +< -?, + :*@5@E53 ,5 ,*:

:?

+, :2-5 E5< ,4, ,+@9 :@-A @ ++:

:,/5 ?

2/2 4+,:-,+

!2 5**5

145/,+ :

*94

55 5,2

 , :-5 2,,*,,9+5 +5 5,,+,123145/8,55,2

@:

: , + :

:59 :+++, :1231455: @

+55 :55 -5<

*:+ :4D-  14-99,45 29 /  :1 +, 5, :? ?:,5 ++,:?5 D-+:+ 2-5 '

/ /32 >  :1 +, ,2@,5, 123145612?5?5@:

:?,,,

 , 123145612/?5?,*:5< ,:5 *:

:+++, ;@>  :1 +, ,2@, 55 ,,4++@, <:

4,9 123 1456122 +, +, /?,++:

/9 123 145612/?55:++@9 :/@,5< :5 *@-@ ,*5 ::5 -/@2 :,5:5< ,2

2A 5    4:4 *9

145/,+ :

5,:;<

? :A 4 *@:

:8,5 ++*D /?5+55:A .

.:5 *  :+++, :1231456122-@ -9+5, :4, :,?55,+,9+-58,5?,@:

5< +,:

,2@,,,*  :+, * 259 ,,?

,  :1 +, :5< , +: .

%,*,9 123145612,++  :/ ,,4++@, <:

4,5@ ,,:9 / ?5?5@:

:?,,,

 ,*:5< ,:5 *5 :+++, ;@  +, /:

5*8,5  *94

++ :: 5 3 ,,, :5 /5,@2 @, 5<

2A :5 -/5?5 95 :+@ 9,, ,,*,:9 123145612/ ?5*5 ,: ;@#5 /?5-5 ::*@5 *@-@ ,*:

:8,5/+, -++:

5:A  9+ .. <4 4:5 * ,:*+,:++@,+ : 5    :  4<- * 5  ** /  2 ?5 +@@ 4 -545 @ ,*5 +, /9 123145612, :2   :4* 42%,,+5/9 2 4

,5 2-:,@,, .

%,*,9

145,++  :/,5 ?55:@:

+@9 4:45 ++ *.

F+ 9*5 :,+, , @ *+++, :123145612 5 +55 5:+,9 :?5123145612/5 , 545,,4 4,5@/,9 9+ 9 ,5  4*5 9, +59

145?,*:

2 ++@9-45 :5 @ *+@ . <4 4:5 * ,:*+,:++@,+ ,/2 ?5  +@@ 4  -54    5  @ ,  *  5  +, /  9

145,:@ :2:,:

:2  :2 5,*,5422:,:, -2:,5 ,,*+*   G'-4, ++  :%,,+5/9 2 4

,5 2-?

$-./

   B'%; " %C ,  $"'  H5  , :G,9 A4 ( ,G  H5  92  ( ,G  *94