← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/9930/2018dismissed

Sukhwinder Pal @ Surinder Pal @ Billa v. Krishna Rani And ORS

2020-03-05Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh5 pages

    

!"# $#%&'&()* 

+,-.&($#/ !01+/&($#/ !01 &00!

 22#00!("

3#/'+'

4/&'-(!!(&!($"-#/'

 #'2($#("'

) 5 6 6

/#'#(") / -&/&($#/-2/!7$3%!"#7

/"-#!22#00!("

 67 /!0

-&'&'"-#'#%($!22#!0 "-#$# #($!("&(!'+&" &0#$89"-# /#'2($#("'-#/#&('##,&(:'#2!/!"#2''#''&( "-#'+&"2/2#/"989.!9  !2!/"&"&("-#/# 7&"8#&(:!/#'&$#("&!0-+'#;#!'+/&(:*;!/0!'7 +009 $#'%/&8#$&("-#-#!$("# "-#&;2+:(#$<+$:;#(" "-#0#!/(#$"/&!0 %+/" $;&""#$097"-#!22#00!("&'"-#'( /#'2($#("( !($"-# 8/"-#/ /#'2($#("'( !($ 7&#!00"-#20!&("&

'

2("-#20#!$&(:' "-#2!/"&#'-!3&(:8##( &0#$7&(%0+$&(:!

/#20&%!"&(""-#./&""#('"!"#;#(" "-#!22#00!("7"-# 00.&(:&''+#'

.#/# /!;#$89"-#"/&!0%+/")= > ?-#"-#/"-#20!&("&

'!/##("&"0#$""-#/#0&# '#2!/!"# 2''#''&(!'2/!9#$@

?-#"-#/  "-#  20!&("&

'  !/#  #("&"0#$  "  "-#  /#0&#  

2#/;!(#("&(<+(%"&(!'2/!9#$ /@

?-#"-#/"-#'+&" "-#20!&("&

'&'(";!&("!&(!80#&(

"-#2/#'#(" /;@

A ?-#"-#/"-#20!&("&

'-!3#(%!+'# !%"&(!($  " &0#"-#2/#'#("'+&"!:!&('""-#$# #($!("@

* ?-#"-#/"-#'+&" "-#20!&("&

'&' !0'#7 /&30+'!($ 8!'#0#''!'"-#'!;#&'8!'#$("-#%(%%"#$ !%"'!($ "-#20!&("&

'-!3#(/&:-"!($"&"0#""-#-+'#&( $&'2+"#@

B ?-#"-#/"-#$# #($!("&'#C%0+'&3#.(#/&(2''#''&(  "-#$&'2+"#$-+'#@

D #0&# E -#/#'2($#("=20!&("&

'#C!;&(#$"-# &/'"/#'2($#("!'!

.&"(#''!($"#($#/#$$%+;#("'&("-# /;  !($5!20!&("589 .!9 #C-&8&"#$#3&$#(%#7.&"-%#/"!&($%+;#("'-!3&(:8##(/# #//#$" 89  "-#  "/&!0  %+/"  !'  ;!/,#$  $%+;#("'7  &(%0+$&(:  !(  !

&$!3&"  !($ %;20!&("';3#$""-#20&%#!($"-#+8 &3&'&(!0!:&'"/!"# -#!22#00!("=$# #($!("#C!;&(#$-&;'#0 !($(09"#($#/#$ -&'!

&$!3&"89.!9 !$%+;#(" A 2(!22/!&'&(:"-##3&$#(%#0#$7"-#0#!/(#$"/&!0%+/" +($ "-!""-+:-&(-&'#C!;&(!"&(=&(=%-&# "-#!22#00!("=$# #($!("-!$'"!"#$ "-!""-#20!&("&

'-!$(/&:-"""-#'+&"2/2#/"9!($"-!"&"-!$8##(:&3#( 89-&' !"-#/"-&;!($-&'.& #7!($&( !%""-#'+&"-!$8##( &0#$8#%!+'# "-# !"-#/=&(=0!. -&''&'"#/7;!($##24!+/7/#'2($#("( -#/#&(7 .!("#$"$&'2''#''"-#!22#00!("7-.#3#/7&(-&'%/''=#C!;&(!"&(7-# !$;&""#$"-!"!

"#/"-#$#!"- -&' !"-#/7-#!0(:.&"-"-#20!&("&

'!/# 0#:!0-#&/' -&' !"-#/7.--!$&(-#/&"#$-&'#'"!"#&(#F+!0'-!/#'

".!'!0' +($89"-!"%+/""-!"!;+"!"&(#("/9C

7 '-.#$  "-!"  "-#  2/2#/"9  '"&00  '"$  &(  <&("  (!;#'  "-!"  .!'  (#3#/ 2!/"&"&(#$#(%#7#''#("&!009("-#!

/#'!&$#3&$#(%#7"-#'+&" "-# /#'2($#("=20!&("&

'.!'$#%/##$&("-#&/ !3+/ * ("-# &/'"!22#!0 &0#$89"-#!22#00!("7"-#0#!/(#$$$&"&(!0 &'"/&%" +$:#7:!7!0'+2(("&%&(:"-#!

/#'!&$ !%"'7 +/"-#/("&%#$ "-!"!$;&""#$09"-#'+&"2/2#/"9-!$8##(2+/%-!'#$89"-# !"-#/ "-# !22#00!("7&#89-!($!;7$+/&(:-&'0& #"&;#73&$#!/#:&'"#/#$'!0# $##$$!"#$   !($"-!""-#!22#00!("-!$!0'!$;&""#$"-!" !%"7 .-&%-.!'!0'3#/& &!80# /;"-#   0#$89.!9 #3&$#(%# C

 /"-#9#!/

= ".!' +/"-#/("&%#$89"-!" %+/""-!""-#!22#00!("-!$ !$;&""#$&(-&'%/''=#C!;&(!"&("-!"-&' !"-#/-!$("#C#%+"#$!(9?&00 &(-&' !3+/!($-!$"-#/# /#$&#$&("#'"!"#7.&"--&; +/"-#/!$;&""&(:

"-!""-#/"-!("-#2!/"&#'""-# 7"-#/#.!'("-#/0#:!0-#&/ "-#0!"# -!($!; -# !%""-!"(# "-#'&'"#/' "-#!22#00!("7&#.!/(!

!(&/#'2($#("( -#/#&(7.!'("/#'&$&(:("-#'+&"2/2#/"97.!' -#0$"8#("'+

&%&#(""$#(9-#/-#/0#:!0'-!/#"-#/#&(7.&"-&"!0'

+($"-!""-#!22#00!("'5;"-#/7&#/#'2($#("=20!&("&

( 74/&'-(!

!(&7-!$ &0#$%;20!&("'!:!&('""-#!22#00!("8# /#"-#20&%#!($"-# +8 &3&'&(!0!:&'"/!"#7""-##

#%""-!""-#!22#00!("!($-&'.& #-!$ 8#!"#(-#/+2 ("-#/&;2/"!(" !%""-!".!'("&%#$89"-#0#!/(#$ &/'"

!22#00!"#%+/".!'"-!""-#!22#00!("-!$!$;&""#$"-!"-#-!$ &0#$!%&3&0

'+&"!:!&('"-&';"-#/!($'&'"#/'.-&%--#+0"&;!"#09.&"-$/#.7.&"-! %29 "-!"'+&"-!3&(:8##(;!/,#$!'!/,("-#%!'# &0# #(%#7-0$&(:"-!".&"-"-#!22#00!("%('"!("09F+!//#00&(: .&"--&';"-#//!"-#/"-!("!,&(:%!/# -#/7"-#20!&("&

'-!$!/&:-"" '##,'#2!/!"#'-!/#'&("-#'+&"2/2#/"989!2!/"&"&("-#/# 89;#"#'!($ 8+($' ('#F+#("097  "-#  &/'"  !22#!0  &0#$  89  "-#  !22#00!("  .!'

$&';&''#$

# /#"-&'%+/"7+2(!F+#'"&(2+""0#!/(#$%+('#0 /"-# !22#00!("7!'".-!"2!/" "-#<+$:;#("' "-#0#!/(#$%+/"'8#0..!'

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

 .&"-%'"'

"-/+:-+" * 

 

 2,   ?-#"-#/'2#!,&(:G/#!'(#$ #'G

* ?-#"-#/#2/"!80# #'G