Iffco-Tokio General Insurance Company Ltd. v. Promila And ORS

  

       
   !" #"$%&%'() *   + "'", -'&., '$" /0 '12!#  3300"-- '! 4",&.& ,/%-  '#!5",& 3"&0'#"'!& 
 
  
   ,"&"'!( ,4%&5 -66 ,7 -8#9$ !" !5" 00"-- '! :::
     ;<

5 --"'6" =1 !5" '&., '$" /0 '1 %& ! 7 ,# # !"# *  6, '!%'6 $/0"'& !%'
 >?88))@A ! !5" ,"&0'#"'!&@$- %/ '!& ' $$.'!   #" !5    &=%, B%'65 %'  /!, 9"5%$.- , $$%#"'!' ) ) 5 --"'6"%&'!5"6,.'#!5 !& - ,1 
 8>8@A0", ''./$.-#'!="0,9"# ,/!5"%'$/"A! C,"!.,'8 ="&%#"&8 %! 7 &  $ &"   $'!,%=.!,1 '"6-%6"'$" & !5" $$%#"'! 5 # $$.,,"#' $$.'!  5" #'$--%&%' ;

<  5 9" $'&%#","# !5" &.=/%&&%'&   -" ,'"# $.'&"- , !5" 00"-- '!=.! /.' =-"! 6,""7%!5!5"& /" ;?< 0",.& - !5" 7 ,#,"9" -&!5 !!5","&0'#"'!&@$- %/ '!& &! !"#!5 !!5"#"$" &"#7 &7,D%'6 & E.'%/F
%"$$.'! '!7%!5 @& G /%# ,  , #%'6 /0 '18 //%&&%' 6"'! B50 >>8 "7

, %' ,D"!8&/ %- = # '#7 &" ,'%'6
8>8@A0", ''./8="&%#"&8 7 & #%'6 6,%$.-!., - 7,D8 /%-D #% ,1 '# 7 & " ,'%'6
 ?8@A 0", /'!5 ,/ ,"& %#&.,$"&857"9",8!5"-" ,'"#!,$$%#"'!& - %/&

 ,%=.' -8+.,.D&5"!, 
5","%'

!",,"

",,"#! &E!5" ,%=.' -F%6',"#!5" $- %/'!5"= &%& & - ,1 '#,"-%"#"C$-.&%9"-1'!5"%'$/"A! C,"!.,'&  !5" #"$" &"# 0,#.$"# ' ,"$,# =1 HA> B '#""0 +./ ,8 .-!% &D%'6B!

8+.,.D&5"!, 75=,.65!!5",%6%' -,"$,# %'$/"! C ,"!.,'&,"- !%'6!!5"#"$" &"#0",! %'%'6! &&"&&/"'!1" ,& >A '#

A
%" C '# C  -'6 7%!5 $D'7-"#6"/"'! C? '#

C> ,&& ''. - %'$/"   !5" #"$" &"# ,/ =.&%'"&& , !5" &&"&&/"'!1" , A7 &
 88@A 5"$- %/I. & - ,1%'$/" !5"#"$" &"# ,/"/0-1/"'!7%!5@&G /%# ,  , #%'6 /0 '17 & '!&57'%'!5"%'$/"! C,"!.,'&
%" C! C> 5"," ,"' &%6' !.,"& ' !5" -"#6",& ', !5" -"#6",& 5 9" =""' 0,"0 ,"# =1 HA?

5 , 'B%'65&&.$5$0%"& -"#6",&
C! C)7","%'&.

%$%"'! !0,9"& - ,1%'$/" !5"#"$" &"# ;>< 5" -" ,'"# ,%=.' - 5 & '! ! D"' !5" & - ,1 %'$/"   !5" #"$" &"#%'! $$.'!75%-" 7 ,#%'6$/0"'& !%' 5"0-" !5 !%'$/"

,/=.&%'"&& &&57'5 &'!=""'0,9"#8$'&"I."'!-18!5"& %#%'$/" #"0%$!"#%'!5"%'$/"! C,"!.,'$.-#'!5 9"=""'! D"'%'! $$.'! , $/0"'& !%'8#"&'!/",%! $$"0! '$"&%'$" 0 ,! ,/$- %/%'6& - ,1 75%$5 !5" #"$" &"# 7 & " ,'%'6 & E.'%/F
%" $$.'! '!8 %! 7 & $- %/"#!5 !!5"#"$" &"#7 &#%'6 6,%$.-!., -7,D &7"-- &7,D /%-D #% ,1 '# 7 & !5","=1 " ,'%'6
 ?8@A 0", /'!5 ,/ ,"& %# &.,$"& 5"#"$" &"#5 # %-"#%'$/"! C,"!.,'& ,!5" &&"&&/"'!1" ,&

>A '# A
%" C '# C  -'67%!5'#% ''$/" C "!.,' 4",% %$ !%' ,/ C? '# C>  5" & /" 7 & 0,#.$"# ' ,"$,# =1 HA> B '#""0 +./ ,8 .-!% &D%'6 B!

8 +.,.D&5"!,  75 =,.65!!5",%6%' -,"$,# !5"%'$/"! C,"!.,'&,"- !%'6!!5"#"$" &"#

  75%$5"&! =-%&5"&!5 ! &0",%'$/"! C,"$,# C @ C>86,&& ''. - %'$/" !5"#"$" &"# ,!5" &&"&&/"'!1" , A7 &
 88@A! %&'!!5"$ &" !5" 00"-- '!!5 !!5","!.,'&7"," %-"# !",!5"#" !5  &=%,B%'65#"$" &"#,!5 !!5"& /"7","'! $$"0!"#2" ,'"#$.'&"- 5 & %-"# ! 0%'! .! '1 6,.'# ' !5" = &%&   75%$5 !5" %'$/"A! C ,"!.,'& %-"# =1 !5" #"$" &"# 7"," ! =" %6',"# 75%-" &&"&&%'6 !5" $/0"'& !%' 0 1 =-" ! !5" ,"&0'#"'!&@$- %/ '!&  '$/" ! C ,"!.,'&

%-"#=1!5"#"$" &"#%'!5"',/ -$.,&" ,"!5"="&!"9%#"'$"75%$5$.-# 5 9"=""',"-%"#.0'=1!5","&0'#"'!&@$- %/ '!& '#7","8 $$,#%'6-18 ,%65!-1 ! D"' %'! $$.'! =1 !5" -" ,'"# ,%=.' - , &&"&&%'6 !5" $/0"'& !%' 0 1 =-" 75%-" ,"J"$!%'6 !5" $- %/ ' !5" = &%&   & - ,1  &8>8@A0", ''./75%$57 &$- %/"# &="%'60 %#!!5"#"$" &"# =1 @& G /%# ,  , #%'6 /0 '18 //%&&%' 6"'!8 B50 >>8 "7 , %'  ,D"!8 &/ %- = #8 %&!,%$! +.,.D&5"!,  ' !5" -%65!   !5"

,"/"'!%'"#0&%!%'86,&&!! -%'$/"&57'%' C @ C>
%"!5" - &! ,"!.,' %-"# =1 #"$" &"# %" & 88@A 7 & ,%65!-1 ! D"' & !5" ''. -%'$/" !5"#"$" &"# ;< ' &.00,!   !5" 0-"  !5 ! %! 7 &  $ &"   $'!,%=.!,1 '"6-%6"'$"8 -" ,'"# $.'&"- 5 & 0,#.$"# $01   !5" &%!" 0- ' %' $.,! !# 1$01!5"," #.-1&%6'"#=15%/%&! D"'',"$,# & ,DKEF 1,"

",,%'6!!5"&%!"0- '8-" ,'"#$.'&"-$'!"'#"#!5 !/ ,DEF%&!5" 0%'!75","!5" $$%#"'!!D0- $"0",.& -!5"," ,"9" -&!5 !=!5!5" 9"5%$-"&7","6%'6 ,/&/ %- = #75%$5%&'!5"-7",&%#" !5"0 6" !7 ,#&0%'!EF'$"!5 !="&!5"'%!%&I.%!" 00 ,"'!!5 !%!7 &'!  $ &" 5" #'$--%&%' 5"#"$" &"#7 &6%'6' /!,$1$-"'!5" $,,"$!&%#"!7 ,#&/= - 75%-"!5"

"'#%'69"5%$-"75%$57 &$/%'6

 

,/ &/ %- = # 7 & -& 6%'6 !7 ,#& /= -   0",.& -   0 , 6, 05 > !5" 7 ,#,"9" -&!5 !!5"#,%9", !5"$ ,5%!!5"&%#" !5"$ , 7%!5 !5" /!,$1$-" ! !5" !%/"   $,&&%'6%! '# &  ,"&.-! !5"," 8!5" /!,$1$-" "--'!5", #!%&8!5","

,"8 00 ,"'!!5 !%!7 &'! $ &" 5" #'$--%&%'=.!!5"#,%9", !5"

"'#%'6$ ,&!,.$D!5"&%#" !5"$ , %'!5"/!,$1$-"75%$57 &6%'6'!5"$,,"$!&%#" !5", # & ,"&.-! 75%$58!5"/!,$1$-" "--#7' '#!5"#"$" &"#&.&! %'"#%'J.,%"& '# "9"'!. --1&.$$./="#!!5"& /""&%#"&8!5"#,%9", !5"

"'#%'6$ , #%# '! &!"0 %'! !5" 7%!'"&&A=C ! $'!,9",! !5" !"&!%/'1   HA8 + , / B%'65 & 0", 75/ !5" $$%#"'! 5 # =""' $ .&"# #." ! !5" '"6-%6"'$"   !5" #,%9",   !5" 

"'#%'6 -! $ , 5.&8 !5" 0-"   $'!,%=.!,1'"6-%6"'$"%& -&=","

! /",%! ;< !5",0%'!5 &=""' ,6."# ;)< '!5"$%,$./&! '$"&8#'! %'# '16,.'#75 !&"9",! %'!", ","7%!5!5" 7 ,#0 &&"#=1!5"-" ,'"# ,%=.' - ;< %&/%&&"#%'-%/%'" 
BH -%  .#6" ) * /%! 
H5"!5",&0" D%'6@," &'"# ( "&@


H5"!5",,"0,! =-" ( "&@